Expert report review

The other side relies on an internal investigation report: what does a forensic accountant check?

An internal investigation report is written for the company that commissioned it, often through its lawyers, and it reaches a lawsuit as the basis of the other side's expert or as a document the company chooses to produce. A forensic accountant reviewing it checks who set the scope, which records were tested, how interviews were recorded and whether the report concludes that fraud occurred, which SSFS No. 1 bars AICPA members from saying, as the Journal of Accountancy reported.

A reviewer from behind compares an internal folder with face-down bank statements

How does an internal investigation report end up in a lawsuit?

In one of two ways: the opposing expert relies on it as a basis for an opinion, or the company produces it to support its position. What the company withholds as privileged stays outside the evidence.

A board, an audit committee or the general counsel orders an investigation after a complaint, an audit finding or a regulator's inquiry. Forensic accountants test transactions, lawyers interview employees, and the team writes a report for the client. When litigation follows, the report and its findings can enter the case through the opposing party's expert.

Federal Rule of Evidence 703 sets the terms. "If experts in the particular field would reasonably rely on those kinds of facts or data," they "need not be admissible for the opinion to be admitted." An accountant who builds a damages or loss figure on the investigation's findings may therefore testify even if the report itself would not be admitted.

The same rule limits what the jury hears about the report: "But if the facts or data would otherwise be inadmissible, the proponent of the opinion may disclose them to the jury only if their probative value in helping the jury evaluate the opinion substantially outweighs their prejudicial effect." The 2000 committee note adds that "the underlying information is not admissible simply because the opinion or inference is admitted" and that the trial judge must give a limiting instruction on request, "informing the jury that the underlying information must not be used for substantive purposes."

For the reviewing accountant, the first question is therefore which of the report's findings the opposing expert actually used. A report cited in a footnote is a different problem from a report whose loss table the expert copied into his own schedule.

Can the other side keep the investigation file privileged?

Often yes. The D.C. Circuit held in 2014 that the attorney-client privilege covers an internal investigation if one of its significant purposes was obtaining or providing legal advice, even when a regulation required the investigation.

In In re Kellogg Brown & Root, Inc., No. 14-5055, decided on June 27, 2014, a former employee, Harry Barko, sued KBR and sought documents from the company's internal investigation. The district court ruled that the documents were not privileged and, by its March 6 order, required their production. The court of appeals, in an opinion by Judge Kavanaugh, granted KBR's petition for a writ of mandamus and vacated that order.

The court started from Upjohn Co. v. United States, 449 U.S. 383 (1981), which held that the privilege protects confidential employee communications made during a company's internal investigation led by its lawyers. The test it applied asks whether obtaining or providing legal advice was "one of the significant purposes of the internal investigation." The court rejected the argument that the privilege falls away because an investigation was required, and wrote that the privilege applies "even if the investigation was mandated by regulation rather than simply an exercise of company discretion." It also noted that "communications made by and to non-attorneys serving as agents of attorneys" are routinely protected; KBR's investigation "was conducted at the direction of the attorneys in KBR's Law Department."

Work product rules add a second layer. Under Rule 26(b)(3) a party ordinarily may not discover documents "prepared in anticipation of litigation" by or for another party or its representative unless it shows substantial need and that it cannot obtain their substantial equivalent without undue hardship. Even then, the court "must protect against disclosure of the mental impressions, conclusions, opinions, or legal theories" of the party's attorney or other representative.

The practical result is that the opposing side may produce the report's conclusions while the interview memoranda and working papers stay withheld. The review then lists what the report rests on and what has not been produced, so that counsel can decide what to ask for.

What can be obtained when the opposing expert relies on the investigation?

The facts and data the expert considered, the assumptions counsel supplied, and on cross-examination the underlying facts. Rule 26(a)(2)(B) requires the expert's report to state the basis and reasons for every opinion and the facts or data considered.

A retained expert's written report must contain "a complete statement of all opinions the witness will express and the basis and reasons for them," together with the facts or data the witness considered in forming them. If the opposing accountant used the investigation's transaction lists or loss schedules, they are facts or data considered.

Communications between the party's attorney and the expert are generally protected under Rule 26(b)(4)(C), but the protection does not cover communications that relate to the expert's compensation, that identify facts or data the attorney provided and the expert considered, or that identify assumptions the attorney provided and the expert relied on. An instruction by counsel to treat the investigation's findings as established is such an assumption.

Rule 705 lets an expert state an opinion and give the reasons for it without first testifying to the underlying facts or data, unless the court orders otherwise. The second sentence gives the opponent its tool: "But the expert may be required to disclose those facts or data on cross-examination." The advisory committee's original note explained that the rule "assumes that the cross-examiner has the advance knowledge which is essential for effective cross-examination," and pointed to discovery under Rule 26(b)(4) as the source of that knowledge.

The review is where that advance knowledge is organized. It separates findings the expert tested himself from findings he took from the investigation, and for each of the second group it notes what document, interview or sample supports it.

What does the AICPA forensic standard mean for a CPA's investigation report?

SSFS No. 1 binds AICPA members. As the Journal of Accountancy reported, it covers investigations of suspected wrongdoing accepted from January 1, 2020, and bars a member from opining that fraud occurred.

In the Journal of Accountancy's report of September 1, 2019, SSFS No. 1 treats an investigation of suspected wrongdoing as its own kind of forensic service, alongside litigation work. For a report signed by a CPA, the reviewer therefore checks two points the article names: whether the report says that someone committed fraud, and whether the engagement letter ties the fee to recoveries, since the standard bans contingent fees for certain forensic services. Where lawyers or investigators who are not CPAs wrote parts of the report, the review records which parts, because the standard reaches only AICPA members.

What does a reviewer check in the scope of the investigation?

Who commissioned it, who set the questions, which entities, accounts and period it covered, what it excluded and whether the scope matches the claims now in the lawsuit. A report answering a narrower question cannot carry a broader damages claim.

An investigation begins with a mandate: a board resolution, an engagement letter from counsel or a request from an audit committee. The mandate fixes the questions. A report written to find out whether one manager approved improper payments does not measure the company's total loss, and an expert who presents its figure as the loss in the lawsuit stretches it beyond its purpose.

The reviewer lists the period covered, the entities and bank accounts tested, the selection method for transactions, and anything the report says was out of scope. Each of these is then compared with the claims in the pleadings. A claim that runs over five years cannot be measured by an investigation that tested two.

Sampling deserves its own check. If the investigation tested a sample of transactions, the report should say how the sample was drawn and whether the results were projected to the whole population. A projected figure is an estimate, and the reviewer asks whether the opposing expert treated it as a count.

Are the interview summaries in the report evidence?

Not by being in the report. Rule 703 lets an expert rely on such material, but otherwise inadmissible facts reach the jury only if their value in evaluating the opinion substantially outweighs their prejudicial effect.

An investigation report may summarize what employees said. Those summaries are statements made out of court, and when the opposing expert relies on them, Rule 703 governs: the expert may rely on them if experts in the field reasonably rely on such information, and the jury hears them only under the balancing test in the rule's last sentence.

The 2000 note to Rule 703 makes the purpose of disclosure narrow: the underlying information is disclosed to help the jury evaluate the opinion, and on request the judge instructs the jury that it "must not be used for substantive purposes."

The review lists each finding that depends only on an interview and has no document behind it. Under KBR the memoranda of those interviews may be privileged, so the opposing side may decline to produce them. The review then asks whether the expert can rely on a finding whose source he has not seen and the other side cannot test.

What if the report states that fraud occurred?

As the Journal of Accountancy describes SSFS No. 1, an AICPA member may not opine on the occurrence of fraud, and under Rule 702 an opinion must stay within what its basis and method support.

An investigation report may use words such as embezzled, misappropriated or fraudulent. According to the Journal of Accountancy, SSFS No. 1 includes "prohibitions on opining on the occurrence of fraud" for members performing forensic services.

Rule 702 sets the same boundary for testimony. The 2023 committee note states that "each expert opinion must stay within the bounds of what can be concluded" from a reliable application of the expert's basis and methodology. An accountant can say that payments went to an account controlled by a named person, that they lacked supporting invoices and how much they totaled; the word fraud adds a conclusion the accounting does not supply.

The review separates the two layers in the report: the accounting findings, with their documents, and the characterizations. The first layer is tested on the numbers. The second is listed for counsel as material for a motion or for cross-examination.

How does a reviewer test the investigation's figures?

By tracing each figure to the general ledger, bank statements and source documents, and by separating figures supported by records from figures supported only by what someone said. Courts have looked at exactly that distinction.

In Morton v. BCAP GDI 1, Inc., a memorandum order of the District of Delaware issued after briefing closed on March 20, 2026, the plaintiffs argued that the opposing damages expert set her gross profit margin by relying "solely on her conversations with" a company executive. The court found that her opinion "is based on more than personal conversations": she had also reviewed the "general ledger detail and profit and loss by customer reports," and Rule 703 lets an expert rely on facts or data "that the expert has been made aware of or personally observed." The opinion stayed in, and the court left the criticisms for cross-examination.

The same test applies to an investigation's loss figure. The reviewer rebuilds it from the ledger and the bank records that the parties produced. Where the rebuilt figure matches, the dispute moves to intent and causation. Where it does not, the review lists each difference with the document that explains it.

The review also checks the arithmetic of recoveries and offsets. If the investigation report presents gross amounts of questioned payments, a loss figure for litigation still deducts what the company received in return and what it later recovered, and the review states whether the opposing expert made those deductions.

What does IAE do when the other side relies on an internal investigation?

A forensic accountant from the IAE registry reviews the opposing report and the investigation material behind it and prepares a review, a rebuttal report or deposition questions in up to 5 business days.

The IAE review page for forensic accounting is written for attorneys facing the other side's damages, solvency or tracing report. The reviewer rebuilds the opposing calculation from the record, marks each figure without a source and writes a rebuttal report within the Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii) period or the court's schedule. The page lists a review of the opposing report, a rebuttal report and deposition questions.

The page also states that, for AICPA members, SSFS No. 1 covers litigation engagements accepted on or after January 1, 2020, including work as an expert witness or consultant, bars opinions on whether fraud occurred and prohibits contingent fees for certain forensic services.

The client sends the report, the investigation material produced and the questions. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day, and within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry; the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. Cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush. Specialists are members of the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code. Neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member