Expert report review

SEC disgorgement: how is the amount calculated, and how does a defense forensic accountant review the SEC's number?

In an SEC enforcement case disgorgement is the gain the defendant is ordered to give up. Since Liu v. SEC in 2020 that number is limited to net profits, and since Sripetch v. SEC, decided June 4, 2026, the SEC need not prove that investors lost money. A defense forensic accountant reviews the SEC's calculation receipt by receipt, expense by expense and year by year.

Hands separate a thin stack of blank checks from a thick closed binder on a wood desk

What is SEC disgorgement, and where does the authority for it come from?

Disgorgement is an order to give up gains obtained through a securities violation. The authority is in 15 U.S.C. 78u(d): paragraph (5) on equitable relief and paragraph (7), which names disgorgement expressly.

Section 78u(d)(5) lets the Commission seek, and a federal court grant, "any equitable relief that may be appropriate or necessary for the benefit of investors." Paragraph (7) says that in any action or proceeding brought by the Commission under the securities laws, the Commission "may seek, and any Federal court may order, disgorgement."

Paragraph (3)(A)(ii) describes the object: the court may require disgorgement, under paragraph (7), of what a person unjustly gained as a result of the violation, and the order runs against the person who received that gain.

The Supreme Court read paragraph (5) in Liu v. SEC, decided June 22, 2020. Justice Sotomayor wrote for eight Justices that "a disgorgement award that does not exceed a wrongdoer's net profits and is awarded for victims" is equitable relief the statute permits. Each half of that sentence is a limit the SEC's calculation has to meet.

Is disgorgement measured by the money raised or by net profits?

By net profits. Liu holds that courts must deduct legitimate expenses before ordering disgorgement. The exception is a business whose entire profit results from wrongdoing, and even then each expense is examined.

In Liu the defendants had solicited nearly $27 million from foreign investors under the EB-5 Immigrant Investor Program. The district court ordered disgorgement of the full amount raised, less $234,899 that remained in the project's corporate accounts. The Supreme Court vacated the judgment and remanded.

The opinion states the rule in one sentence: "courts must deduct legitimate expenses before ordering disgorgement under §78u(d)(5)." The Court recognized an exception where the "entire profit of a business or undertaking" comes from wrongdoing. Even in that situation a court has to ask whether an expense is legitimate or is, in the Court's words, merely wrongful gains "under another name."

For the accountant this turns one number into a ledger. Each payment out of investor money is classified: a cost of carrying on the business the investors were told about, or a transfer to the defendant under a different label. Lease payments and equipment with invoices sit on one side. Payments to entities the defendant controls, with no service behind them, sit on the other.

How exact does the SEC's number have to be?

Not exact. A concurring opinion in SEC v. Unioil quotes the standard of SEC v. First City Financial: disgorgement need only be a reasonable approximation of profits causally connected to the violation. The burden then shifts to the defendant.

The wording below is taken out of Judge Edwards's concurrence in SEC v. Unioil, which the D.C. Circuit decided on December 27, 1991. He quoted SEC v. First City Financial Corp., 890 F.2d 1215 (D.C. Cir. 1989): "disgorgement need only be a reasonable approximation of profits causally connected to the violation." In his words, the SEC always bears the burden of persuasion, but it "need only offer a prima facie reasonable approximation." Once it has done so, the defendant has to rebut the showing.

The risk of uncertainty falls on the defendant. Quoting SEC v. Shapiro, a Second Circuit decision of 1974, the concurrence repeats that "the violator should take the risks of the market himself." At the same time only profits causally tied to the violation may be disgorged, and the remedy may not be used punitively.

Two consequences follow for the defense. Criticism of the SEC's figure is not enough: the court expects a competing calculation with documents. And the phrase "causally connected" is where that calculation starts, because every receipt in the SEC's total has to be tied to the charged violation.

What happens when the defendant offers no calculation of its own?

In Unioil the defendant said he gained nothing and offered no figure. The court affirmed the SEC's amount, although a concurring judge listed three flaws in how the SEC had computed it.

The appellant held an option to buy 3,000,000 shares at $0.25 per share and exercised it in December 1986, when the market price was $1 3/16. The SEC multiplied the spread by the number of shares and discounted the total by one-third because the stock was restricted under Rule 144.

Judge Edwards wrote that the SEC had not separated legitimate profit and illegitimate profit: the appellant held the option lawfully, so only the increase caused by the fraudulent promotion should have been disgorged. The question, he wrote, was "How much lower would the stock have been in the absence of the fraudulent campaign?" The SEC had not compared prices before and after the campaign. It had also ignored dilution: before the exercise the company had 5,791,241 shares outstanding, and the appellant bought 3,000,000 more at a much lower price.

The per curiam opinion nevertheless held that the amount was not plain error, mainly because the appellant had offered no alternative calculation. The points in the concurrence, a price comparison and a dilution adjustment, had not been raised by the appellant.

Does the SEC have to prove that investors lost money?

No. In Sripetch v. SEC, decided June 4, 2026, a unanimous Supreme Court held that a showing of pecuniary loss to investors is not required before the SEC may obtain a disgorgement award.

Ongkaruck Sripetch ran fraudulent schemes involving at least 20 penny-stock companies, including "pump and dump" operations. The SEC charged him with six counts of securities fraud and one count of selling unregistered securities and sought more than $4.1 million in disgorgement. He argued that Liu required proof of financial loss to investors.

The syllabus of the decision states the holding: "A showing of pecuniary loss to investors is not required before the SEC may obtain a disgorgement award." Justice Gorsuch's opinion for the Court says that traditional equitable principles "do not require a showing of pecuniary loss before a court may issue an award of unjust profits." The requirement in Liu that the award be "awarded for victims" comes out of those principles, and they do not demand pecuniary loss to make someone a victim. The Court affirmed the Ninth Circuit. The opinion notes that the Second Circuit "has taken the opposite view" and cites SEC v. Govil, 86 F.4th 89 (2023).

The measure stays the defendant's gain. The holding removes one threshold defense: the absence of proven investor loss does not bar an award. The work moves to the two questions Liu left with the trial courts: what the net profit was and how much of it is causally connected to the violation.

Who receives the money?

Liu says the equitable profits remedy generally requires the SEC to return a defendant's gains to wronged investors. Whether an order may send money to the Treasury was left to the lower courts.

The parties in Liu did not identify a specific order directing any proceeds to the Treasury, so the Court left that question for remand. In Sripetch the Court assumed, without deciding, that the "awarded for victims" rule also applies to disgorgement under paragraph (7), which Congress added after Liu.

The accountant's contribution here is a list: who paid in, how much each person paid and how much each has already received back. The same list shows whether money in the SEC's total came in through transactions outside the charged violation.

Can one defendant be ordered to give up another defendant's gains?

The statute speaks of the unjust gain of the person who received it. Liu adds that the common law permitted liability for partners engaged in concerted wrongdoing and left the application to the lower court.

Where the SEC asks for one joint figure against several defendants, the calculation has to be split before it can be tested. The reviewer follows the money out of the accounts into which investors paid and records which defendant received each transfer.

The legal question, whether two defendants were partners in concerted wrongdoing, belongs to counsel. The schedule of who received what is the factual basis for either answer.

How far back can the calculation reach?

Section 78u(d)(8) gives the SEC 5 years after the latest date of the violation to bring a disgorgement claim, and 10 years if the violation is one for which scienter must be established.

The background is Kokesh v. SEC, decided June 5, 2017. A unanimous Court held that disgorgement in the securities-enforcement context is a "penalty" within 28 U.S.C. 2462 and subject to its five-year period. Between 1995 and 2009 the defendant had allegedly taken $34.9 million from four business-development companies. The district court ordered disgorgement of the whole $34.9 million, of which $29.9 million came from conduct outside the five-year period, plus $18.1 million in prejudgment interest. The Supreme Court reversed.

Congress later wrote the periods into section 78u(d)(8). The 10-year period covers violations of section 78j(b), section 77q(a)(1), section 80b-6(1) and any other provision of the securities laws for which scienter must be established. Time during which the defendant is outside the United States does not count toward the period.

A calculation that mixes scienter-based and other violations may therefore have two cut-off dates. The reviewer dates every gain in the SEC's schedule and sorts it by the count it relates to. Kokesh is a reminder of the stakes: about six-sevenths of that award lay outside the period.

What does a defense forensic accountant check in the SEC's calculation?

Five things: the source of each receipt, the causal link to the charged violation, the expenses that qualify as legitimate, the dates against the limitation periods and the prejudgment interest computed on the result.

Receipts come first. The reviewer traces each amount in the SEC's schedule to a bank record and notes receipts that are counted twice, that belong to another person or that predate the charged conduct.

Causation is next. Revenue of a business that also had lawful operations is separated: the Unioil concurrence asked how much lower the price would have been without the fraud, and the same question applies to sales, fees or trading gains.

Expenses are documented one by one, because Liu requires deduction of legitimate expenses and denies it for wrongful gains under another name. An expense with a contract, an invoice and an unrelated payee is presented differently than a round-number transfer to a relative.

Interest is recomputed. In Kokesh prejudgment interest added $18.1 million to a $34.9 million award, so an error in the principal or in the starting date of interest is multiplied. The reviewer states the rate, the period and the base the SEC used and what each becomes after the corrections above.

What did Sripetch leave open?

Whether paragraph (7) changes the scope of the SEC's disgorgement powers, whether the "awarded for victims" rule applies under it, and whether a defendant is entitled to a jury on disgorgement.

The Court wrote that it could "simply assume without deciding that disgorgement under §78u(d)(7) remains an equitable remedy" subject to traditional equitable rules. It did not decide whether paragraph (7) changes the scope of the remedy.

Justice Thomas filed a concurrence. He wrote that Congress has made disgorgement a legal remedy, so that the Seventh Amendment requires a jury trial when the SEC seeks it. On whether disgorgement under paragraph (7) is a legal remedy he pointed to a division among the circuits, comparing SEC v. Hallam, a Fifth Circuit decision of 2022, with SEC v. Ahmed, a Second Circuit decision of 2023. If that view prevails in a later case, a jury would hear the SEC's disgorgement claim.

How does IAE review the SEC's disgorgement calculation?

A reviewer chosen in the IAE registry rebuilds the opposing calculation on the record, marks each figure without a source and writes a review report within the court's schedule, in up to 5 business days.

The IAE forensic accounting review is for attorneys facing the other side's damages, solvency or tracing report. The reviewer rebuilds the opposing calculation on the record, marks each figure without a source and writes a rebuttal report within the Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii) period or the court's schedule. The deliverables are a review of the opposing report, a rebuttal report and deposition questions.

The work is delivered in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, and the report under review and the questions are confirmed before work starts. Cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.

Every reviewer is a member of the public IAE registry, can be verified by Member ID or QR code and confirms no interest in the outcome of the case. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy; a review is evidence that the court weighs with the rest of the record, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member