Expert report review
Loss calculation in federal fraud sentencing: how does a defense forensic accountant review the government's number?
In a federal fraud case the loss figure moves the guideline range more than any other number. Since November 1, 2026, the loss table in USSG 2B1.1 adds 2 levels above $9,000 and 30 levels above $750 million. The government proves loss by a preponderance of the evidence, and the court needs only a reasonable estimate. A defense forensic accountant tests that estimate line by line against the bank records behind the schedule.

Why does the loss figure decide so much of a federal fraud sentence?
The loss table in USSG 2B1.1(b)(1) adds offense levels in steps tied to dollar amounts. Each step raises the guideline range, and the table runs in sixteen rows up to 30 added levels.
Section 2B1.1 of the United States Sentencing Guidelines covers theft, embezzlement, fraud and related offenses. Its first specific offense characteristic is the loss table. The court finds the amount of loss and adds the offense levels that the table assigns to it. Other specific offense characteristics are added on top; the Commission's 2026 data briefing reports that the sophisticated means enhancement applied in 20 percent of the fiscal year 2024 cases it analyzed.
Because the table moves in steps, a dispute of a few thousand dollars can matter as much as a dispute of millions. A loss just above a threshold and a loss just below it produce different ranges. The defense review therefore asks two questions: what is the right number, and on which side of the nearest threshold does it fall.
The government must prove the loss attributable to the defendant by a preponderance of the evidence. The Sentencing Commission's 2024 primer on loss states this rule in its section on the burden of proof. The court's finding is reviewed on appeal for clear error, so the record built at sentencing is usually the record that decides the issue.
What changed in the loss table on November 1, 2026?
The Commission adjusted the monetary tables for inflation. The first loss increase now starts above $9,000 instead of above $6,500, and every other threshold rose.
The Commission's amendment in brief states that the amendment "adjusts the monetary tables and values in the guidelines for inflation" and lists the effective date as November 1, 2026. It names 2B1.1 together with the burglary, robbery, bid-rigging and tax tables and the fine tables for individuals and organizations.
The amended loss table in the Commission's reader-friendly text reads: $9,000 or less, no increase; more than $9,000, add 2; more than $20,000, add 4; more than $55,000, add 6; more than $150,000, add 8; more than $200,000, add 10; more than $350,000, add 12; more than $750,000, add 14; more than $2,000,000, add 16; more than $5,000,000, add 18; more than $15,000,000, add 20; more than $35,000,000, add 22; more than $90,000,000, add 24; more than $200,000,000, add 26; more than $350,000,000, add 28; more than $750,000,000, add 30.
The Commission's 2026 data briefing on economic offenses modeled the change. Among the individuals in its analysis with losses above $6,500 and up to $9,000, 58 would lose the 2-level increase, and 37 percent of the individuals in the adjusted analysis would see a changed offense level.
For the review this means checking which manual the probation office applied. A presentence report prepared before November 1, 2026 for a sentencing after that date may show thresholds from the earlier table. The rules on which manual governs are set by the guidelines and the courts, and the attorney raises that question; the accountant recomputes the level under each table the attorney asks about.
What are actual loss and intended loss?
Actual loss is the reasonably foreseeable pecuniary harm that resulted from the offense. Intended loss is pecuniary harm the defendant purposely sought to inflict. Loss is the greater of the two.
The Commission's 2024 primer quotes the definitions. Actual loss means "the reasonably foreseeable pecuniary harm that resulted from the offense." Intended loss means "pecuniary harm that the defendant purposely sought to inflict." The primer notes that the Commission promulgated an amendment, effective November 1, 2024 absent congressional action, that created Notes to the loss table and moved the general rule into the guideline itself.
The definitions leave three factual questions for each case: what harm occurred, whether it was reasonably foreseeable, and what the defendant intended.
Each of those is an accounting question in part. The defense accountant separates amounts that were paid and lost from amounts that were promised on paper, and amounts lost by the victims from amounts recovered by them before the offense was detected.
How exact must the government's loss figure be?
The court need only make a reasonable estimate of the loss. The estimate must still rest on evidence in the record, and the defense can show that the method or the inputs are wrong.
The Commission's primer quotes the commentary: the court "need only make a reasonable estimate of the loss." Among the factors listed for the estimate is "the scope and duration of the offense and revenues generated by similar operations." The rule gives the government room to estimate where exact records do not exist.
The room has limits on appeal as well. In United States v. Courtright, No. 24-1115, decided October 17, 2025, the Seventh Circuit called the loss calculation "a factual determination" reviewed for clear error and said the defendant "bears a heavy burden" to show that the district court's figure lies outside the computations the record permits.
The same case shows how much a defense challenge can change at the district court. The government offered four formulas, which produced $91.3 million, $70 million, $86.3 million and $69.3 million. The district court adopted the fourth, which left out investors who had not submitted a claim to the receiver in the SEC case. Of the four deductions the defense requested, the court granted two: $6.9 million returned to investors in the SEC case and $7.8 million in claims extinguished when investors took over their websites. It denied a $22 million credit for a buy-back offer, because the offer was conditioned on Courtright's continued employment, and a credit for operating expenses. The opinion states the final loss as $52.5 million, which put the case at a 22-level increase instead of the 24 levels that applied above $65 million in the table then in force.
Which credits reduce the loss?
Money returned, and the fair market value of property returned and services rendered, before the offense was detected. Amounts the defendant spent on running the scheme are not credited without evidence that they benefited the victims.
The Commission's primer quotes the credit rule: loss is reduced by "money returned, and the fair market value of the property returned and the services rendered," if this occurred before the offense was detected. The detection date therefore cuts the credit in two. Repayments made after the offense was detected do not reduce the guideline loss under this rule.
Courtright gives an example of a credit the court refused. The defense sought a deduction for the company's operating expenses; the opinion refers to $42 million in the appellate discussion and to $34.73 million in its account of the sentencing. The agreements with investors allowed the upfront fees to be used for the purchase, hosting, maintenance and marketing of the websites identified for that investor, but the court found "no evidence in the record" that the company used the fees that way, noted that the company "appeared to commingle all company funds," and held that the defendant had not given the district court a workable way to measure the portion spent as the agreements allowed.
For a defense accountant, the lesson of the refused credit is about records. A credit for services rendered needs a trace that links the victim's payment with the cost of the service delivered to that victim. Where the funds were commingled, the accountant has to show an allocation method the court can apply, or the court may refuse the credit as a whole.
How is loss measured in an investment fraud or Ponzi scheme?
Loss is not reduced by money paid to an individual investor beyond that investor's principal. Payments to one investor do not offset the losses of other investors.
The Commission's primer quotes the special rule for schemes of this kind: "loss shall not be reduced by the money or the value of the property transferred to any individual investor" in excess of that investor's principal investment.
In practice the accountant builds an investor-by-investor schedule. For each investor, deposits are compared with payments received. Where payments are less than deposits, the shortfall counts toward loss. Where an investor received more than he or she deposited, the excess is not subtracted from the losses of others.
The defense review checks how each investor's principal was computed. Transfers between accounts of the same investor, deposits made through related entities and payments routed to family members can each put an investor in the other column. Each change is tied to a bank record, not to the scheme's own statements.
When can the court use the defendant's gain instead of the victims' loss?
Only if there is a loss that cannot reasonably be determined. Gain is an alternative measure, not a default, and the defense can ask the court to find that loss can be determined.
The Commission's primer quotes the rule: the court may "use the gain that resulted from the offense as an alternative measure of loss only if there is a loss" but it reasonably cannot be determined.
Gain can be larger or smaller than loss. Where the defendant kept a small share of what the victims lost, the defense may prefer that the court determine the victims' loss. Where the victims recovered most of their money, the defense may argue that the actual loss is small and that the government has not shown it cannot be determined.
Both arguments rest on records. The accountant who reviews the government's figure states which measure the schedule uses, whether the data exist to compute the other one, and what the result is under each.
Does a defendant answer for losses caused by co-conspirators?
Courts count losses the defendant could reasonably foresee from his own role and from co-conspirators' conduct. The government proves the foreseeable amount by a preponderance of the evidence.
In United States v. Nkeng Amin, No. 19-4780, an unpublished per curiam decision of March 18, 2021, the Fourth Circuit upheld a finding of at least $6 million in reasonably foreseeable loss. The court held that the government proved by a preponderance of the evidence that the defendant could foresee that loss from his own role and from his co-conspirators' conduct.
The accountant's part in such a dispute is to separate the transactions. Which accounts did the defendant control or see? Which transfers passed through accounts he used? When did his participation begin and end? A schedule that assigns every loss in a conspiracy to every defendant does not answer those questions, and the defense review lists the transactions with no link to the defendant in the record.
Whether a loss was foreseeable is a legal finding for the court. The accountant gives the court the transaction-level facts on which that finding rests.
How does restitution differ from the guideline loss figure?
Restitution is ordered victim by victim in the full amount of each victim's losses as the court determines them. The guideline figure can include intended loss. The government bears the burden of proving each victim's loss.
Under 18 U.S.C. 3664(a), the presentence report must include, to the extent practicable, "a complete accounting of the losses to each victim." Under 3664(f)(1)(A), the court orders restitution to each victim in the full amount of each victim's losses as the court determines them, "without consideration of the economic circumstances of the defendant."
Section 3664(e) places the burden of proving the amount of loss sustained by a victim on the attorney for the Government and requires disputes to be resolved by the preponderance of the evidence. If the victims' losses are not ascertainable by the date that is 10 days before sentencing, section 3664(d)(5) lets the court set a final determination not later than 90 days after sentencing.
For the defense accountant, the restitution figure and the guideline figure are two schedules, not one. The restitution schedule lists victims by name or number with each victim's actual loss and the source documents. The guideline schedule may include intended loss and may use estimates. A review that checks only the total misses errors in the allocation between victims.
When must the defense object to the loss figure?
Within 14 days after receiving the presentence report, under Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 32(f)(1). The report reaches the defense at least 35 days before sentencing unless the defendant waives that period.
Rule 32(e)(2) requires the probation officer to give the presentence report to the defendant, defense counsel and the government at least 35 days before sentencing unless the defendant waives the minimum period. Under Rule 32(f)(1), within 14 days after receiving the report, the parties must state in writing any objections, including objections to the guideline range.
At least 7 days before sentencing, under Rule 32(g), the probation officer submits the report to the court and the parties with an addendum listing unresolved objections. At sentencing the court may accept any undisputed portion of the report as a finding of fact, Rule 32(i)(3)(A), and for any disputed portion must rule on the dispute or determine that a ruling is unnecessary, Rule 32(i)(3)(B).
These periods set the schedule for the defense accountant. The review of the government's loss schedule has to be ready in time for the written objections, so that each objection cites a figure and a document. Under Rule 32(i)(2) the court may permit the parties to introduce evidence on the objections, and the accountant may testify at the sentencing hearing.
What evidence can the defense accountant use at sentencing?
Summaries, schedules and declarations, without the foundation a trial would require. Federal Rule of Evidence 1101(d)(3) lists sentencing among the proceedings where the evidence rules, except those on privilege, do not apply.
Rule 1101(d) lists proceedings where the Federal Rules of Evidence, except for those on privilege, do not apply, and the list includes sentencing. A defense accountant's summary of bank records, a schedule built from the government's discovery or a declaration on how a figure was computed can be put before the court without the foundation steps a trial would require.
The same rule works for the government. The government's case agent or forensic accountant may present a loss schedule through a summary or a declaration. In Courtright, the opinion notes that the FBI forensic accountant testified that the company could not have met its obligations without new site partners. The defense review asks for the workpapers behind such testimony: the account list, the transaction database and the formulas applied.
A defense schedule that ties every line to a Bates-numbered document lets the court check each figure against the record, line by line, before it adopts or rejects the figure.
What does a defense review of the loss calculation check?
The table applied, the measure used, the transaction data, credits, the victims' schedule, the link to the defendant, and whether the number crosses a threshold.
The review traces the government's schedule backward, total first and sources last. Each item below ends in a figure the defense can state in its written objections.
- The reviewer confirms which loss table the presentence report applied and recomputes the level under the table the attorney identifies.
- The reviewer identifies whether the government used actual loss, intended loss or gain, and recomputes the alternatives where the records allow.
- The reviewer rebuilds the transaction data from bank records and compares totals, account by account, with the government's schedule.
- The reviewer lists money returned and the value of property returned and services rendered before detection, with the detection date used.
- The reviewer checks investor principal and payments one investor at a time in an investment scheme.
- The reviewer marks transactions with no record link to the defendant in a multi-defendant case.
- The reviewer compares the restitution schedule with the guideline loss and checks the allocation between victims.
- The reviewer states the corrected figure and the nearest threshold of the loss table on either side of it.
How does IAE review the government's loss calculation?
A reviewer from the IAE registry rebuilds the opposing calculation from the record, marks each figure without a source and writes a review report within the court's schedule, in up to 5 business days.
The IAE forensic accounting review is for attorneys facing the other side's damages, solvency or tracing report. The reviewer rebuilds the opposing calculation from the record, marks each figure without a source and writes a rebuttal report within the Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii) period or the court's schedule. The deliverables are a review of the opposing report, a rebuttal report and deposition questions.
The work is delivered in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, and the report under review and the questions are confirmed before work starts. Cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.
Every reviewer is a member of the public IAE registry, can be verified by Member ID or QR code and confirms no interest in the outcome of the case. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy; a review is evidence that the court weighs with the rest of the record, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome.
Sources
- U.S. Sentencing Commission, Amendments in Brief: Inflationary Adjustment, amendments effective November 1, 2026
- U.S. Sentencing Commission, Reader-friendly version of amendments, May 2026
- U.S. Sentencing Commission, Data briefing: Economic Offenses, 2026
- U.S. Sentencing Commission, Primer on Loss Calculation under §2B1.1, 2024
- United States v. Courtright, No. 24-1115 (7th Cir. Oct. 17, 2025) (FindLaw)
- United States v. Nkeng Amin, No. 19-4780 (4th Cir. Mar. 18, 2021) (unpublished)
- 18 U.S. Code § 3664, Procedure for issuance and enforcement of order of restitution (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, Rule 32, Sentencing and Judgment (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 1101, Applicability of the Rules (LII, Cornell Law School)
Read also
All articles
SEC disgorgement: how is the amount calculated, and how does a defense forensic accountant review the SEC's number?
In an SEC enforcement case disgorgement is the gain the defendant is ordered to give up. Since Liu v. SEC in 2020 that number is limited to net
Prejudgment interest calculation: how do you check the other side's numbers?
Prejudgment interest can add a large figure to a damages award, and each input of the calculation is set by a statute, a contract or a court's
Supplementing a forensic accounting report after the rebuttal: what does Rule 26(e) allow, and when is it too late?
After a rebuttal points out errors in a damages report, the expert who wrote it often wants to answer with a supplemental report. Rule 26(e) requiresExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

