Expert report review

Prejudgment interest calculation: how do you check the other side's numbers?

Prejudgment interest can add a large figure to a damages award, and each input of the calculation is set by a statute, a contract or a court's ruling: the start date, the rate, the amount it runs on, whether it compounds and when it stops. A reviewer checks every input against the governing rule and rebuilds the opposing schedule. Below are those inputs under New York, Florida, Delaware and federal law and the errors a review looks for.

Hands rest a pencil on a closed date book beside a quiet calculator and face-down invoices

What is prejudgment interest and why does the calculation need a review?

Compensation for the time the plaintiff went without the money. The Supreme Court tied it to the foregone use of money, Florida treats it as an element of damages, and each input can move the total by a wide margin.

In General Motors Corp. v. Devex Corp., 461 U.S. 648, decided May 24, 1983, the Supreme Court held that under 35 U.S.C. 284 "prejudgment interest should ordinarily be awarded" absent some justification for withholding it. Justice Marshall wrote that the award puts the patent owner "in as good a position as he would have been in" had a reasonable royalty agreement been reached, and described the loss as "the foregone use of the money between the time of infringement and the date of the judgment."

The Florida Supreme Court reached the same idea under state law. In Argonaut Insurance Co. v. May Plumbing Co., 474 So. 2d 212, decided July 3, 1985, Justice Ehrlich wrote that Florida treats prejudgment interest as "merely another element of pecuniary damages" and that the plaintiff "is to be made whole from the date of the loss."

Because interest is damages, it is computed from inputs, and each input is a legal question with an arithmetic consequence. A start date two years earlier, a rate from the wrong statute, a base that includes amounts not yet due, compounding where the rule calls for simple interest: each choice changes the figure, and the choices add up.

The interest schedule is a separate exhibit from the damages model, with its own inputs. A review of the opposing damages report that stops before the interest schedule leaves part of the claimed amount untested.

Which law sets the rate and the rules of the calculation?

A statute of the jurisdiction whose law governs the claim, unless a contract sets its own rate. New York sets 9%, Florida a rate the Chief Financial Officer fixes each quarter, Delaware 5% over the Federal Reserve discount rate.

New York. CPLR 5004(a) provides: "Interest shall be at the rate of nine per centum per annum, except where otherwise provided by statute." Since the 2021 amendment, the same section sets two percent per annum in an action arising out of a consumer debt where a natural person is a defendant. The New York Senate site shows the section's latest revision as May 6, 2022.

Florida. Under section 55.03(1) of the Florida Statutes, the Chief Financial Officer sets the rate payable on judgments or decrees by averaging the discount rate of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York for the preceding 12 months and adding 400 basis points. The rate is set on December 1, March 1, June 1 and September 1, with quarterly adjustments on April 1, July 1 and October 1, and the Chief Financial Officer informs the clerk of the courts and the chief judge of each circuit.

Delaware. Under 6 Del. C. 2301(a), "where there is no expressed contract rate, the legal rate of interest shall be 5% over the Federal Reserve discount rate including any surcharge as of the time from which interest is due."

Federal judgments. 28 U.S.C. 1961(a) provides for interest on any money judgment in a civil case recovered in a district court, "calculated from the date of the entry of the judgment," at a rate equal to the weekly average 1-year constant maturity Treasury yield for the calendar week before the judgment. The statute speaks of the period after entry of judgment; the rate for the period before it comes from the law that governs the claim, as in Devex, where the source was the patent statute.

The first line of a review names the rule the opposing expert applied and checks whether that rule governs the claim. An expert who applies the New York rate to a contract governed by Delaware law, or the federal Treasury rate to a period before judgment, has made a legal choice that counsel can challenge.

From what date does prejudgment interest run?

In New York, from the earliest ascertainable date the cause of action existed, or from the date each item of damage was incurred, or from a single reasonable intermediate date. In Florida, Argonaut fixes it at the date of loss.

CPLR 5001(b) states: "Interest shall be computed from the earliest ascertainable date the cause of action existed," except that damages incurred at a later date carry interest from the date incurred. Where damages were incurred at various times, interest is computed on each item from the date it was incurred "or upon all of the damages from a single reasonable intermediate date." Under CPLR 5001(c), the start date for interest is specified in the verdict, report or decision, and if a jury is discharged without specifying it, the court fixes it on motion.

Argonaut held that once the finder of fact has set damages and liability, the plaintiff is entitled as a matter of law to prejudgment interest at the statutory rate from the date of the loss.

Delaware's statute ties the rate itself to the start date: the 5% spread is added to the Federal Reserve discount rate "as of the time from which interest is due." Under that text, the start date fixes the rate as well as the period.

The start date is the input a reviewer tests first. The reviewer tests three possible errors. Interest is run on the full damages amount from the date of the first breach, though part of the damages arose later. A future damages component, such as lost profits for years after trial, is included in the base and carries prejudgment interest for periods before it would have been earned. A single intermediate date is used without a stated reason, where CPLR 5001(b) asks for a reasonable one.

For each error the reviewer recomputes the figure with the date the record supports and shows the difference in a separate line, so counsel and the court can see how much the start date alone moves the total.

How does a reviewer check the interest rate the other side used?

By naming the statute or contract term that sets the rate, checking the published rate for each period, and testing whether the rate should be fixed at one date or change over time under that rule.

A fixed statutory rate, such as New York's 9% under CPLR 5004, leaves little room for error in the rate itself. The question becomes whether an exception applies: the consumer debt rate of two percent, or another statute that provides otherwise.

A variable rate gives more room. Florida's rate is set by the Chief Financial Officer and adjusted quarterly under section 55.03(1). A schedule that applies one rate across several years and a schedule that applies each quarterly rate to its quarter produce different totals. In Argonaut the Florida Supreme Court found the trial court's escalating rate scheme improper and remanded for an award at the statutory rate, so the method of applying the rate is itself a legal point the reviewer flags for counsel.

Delaware's text points to a single reference date: the Federal Reserve discount rate "as of the time from which interest is due." A schedule that floats the Delaware legal rate quarterly departs from that wording, and the reviewer states the figure under the statute's reference date.

For the period after judgment, the reviewer checks the published Treasury yield for the calendar week before the date of judgment under 28 U.S.C. 1961(a), and in Florida the rate the judgment bears on its face under section 55.03(2).

Every rate in the rebuilt schedule carries its source: the statute, the publication and the date of the published figure. A rate without a stated source is the first item marked in the opposing schedule.

What amount does the interest run on?

On the damages awarded for the period before judgment, item by item where they arose at different times. Amounts the plaintiff already received, damages for future periods and amounts not yet due are tested separately.

Interest compensates for money the plaintiff did not have. The base therefore includes only amounts that were due and unpaid during the period. CPLR 5001(b) builds this into the computation by allowing interest on each item from the date it was incurred.

In Devex the Court wrote that "an award of interest from the time that the royalty payments would have been received merely serves to make the patent owner whole." Under that approach, a reasonable royalty that would have been paid in installments produces a stream of start dates, one for each installment.

The reviewer checks four items in the base. Payments the defendant made during the dispute, and any partial payments or setoffs, are credited on their dates. Amounts that the damages model projects for periods after trial are excluded from the prejudgment base. Costs and attorney fees are listed apart from damages, and the reviewer asks for the authority for any interest on them. Amounts the contract or the statute treats separately, such as a contractual late fee, are not counted twice.

Each adjustment is shown against the opposing figure with the document that supports it: the payment record, the invoice, the date of the projected loss.

Is prejudgment interest simple or compound?

It depends on the governing statute or the contract. For federal post-judgment interest, 28 U.S.C. 1961(b) requires daily computation and annual compounding; for prejudgment interest the reviewer looks for the authority the opposing expert relied on.

28 U.S.C. 1961(b) states that interest "shall be computed daily to the date of payment" and compounded annually. That rule governs interest on federal judgments after entry.

For the period before judgment, the statutes cited in this article state a rate and a start date. CPLR 5004 sets a rate per annum; 6 Del. C. 2301(a) sets a legal rate tied to the discount rate; section 55.03 sets the rate the Chief Financial Officer fixes. Whether interest compounds in a given case turns on the governing law and on the contract, and the reviewer asks the opposing expert to name the authority for compounding where the schedule compounds.

The difference grows with time. Over a long dispute, monthly compounding at a high statutory rate yields a materially larger figure than simple interest at the same rate. The reviewer computes both and presents the simple-interest figure alongside the opposing compound figure, with the authority for each.

The reviewer does not choose the method for the court. The deliverable gives the figures under each method, with the authority each side cites, so that the choice can be made on the record.

What if the contract has its own interest rate?

Where the statute defers to the contract, the contract rate applies. Delaware's legal rate applies where there is no expressed contract rate, and post-judgment interest there runs at the lesser of the legal rate and the contract rate.

Delaware's statute is explicit on both periods. The legal rate applies "where there is no expressed contract rate." For a judgment on agreements governed by that subsection, "whether the contract rate is expressed or not," post-judgment interest runs from the date of the judgment at 5% over the Federal Reserve discount rate including any surcharge "or the contract rate, whichever is less."

New York's CPLR 5004 sets 9% "except where otherwise provided by statute." Whether a contract rate displaces the statutory rate in a particular contract is a question for counsel under the governing case law, and the reviewer computes the figure under both rates where the point is contested.

The contract can also define the base, the start date and the method. A late payment clause may provide for a rate on overdue invoices from the invoice due date; a credit agreement may provide for default interest and compounding. The reviewer reads the contract terms that the opposing expert cited and the terms the expert did not cite, and marks any departure between the schedule and the text.

Where the contract provides for a late fee or a liquidated amount, the reviewer checks that the schedule does not also add statutory interest for the same delay, unless the contract or the governing law permits both.

Can the plaintiff's own delay reduce the interest?

Under Devex, yes in federal patent cases: where the patent owner was responsible for undue delay in prosecuting the lawsuit, a court may limit prejudgment interest or deny it altogether.

The Supreme Court in Devex stated that "where the patent owner has been responsible for undue delay in prosecuting the lawsuit," it "may be appropriate to limit prejudgment interest, or perhaps even deny it altogether."

Whether delay limits interest in a state law claim turns on the governing law, and the court decides it. The reviewer's task is factual: a timeline of the dispute with the dates of the loss, the demand, the filing, any stay, any period of inactivity on the docket and the trial setting.

With that timeline, the reviewer can present the interest figure with and without the contested period. If counsel argues that a stretch of the case should carry no interest, the court sees what that argument is worth in dollars.

The same timeline answers the opposite argument. The docket entries show which party asked for each extension, which motions moved the trial setting and which productions came late, so the court can see where the time went.

When does prejudgment interest stop and post-judgment interest begin?

At the point the governing rule names. In New York the clerk computes interest to the date of the verdict, report or decision; federal post-judgment interest runs from entry of judgment; Florida fixes the rate when judgment is obtained.

Under CPLR 5001(c), the clerk computes interest to the date of the verdict, report or decision and includes it in the total sum awarded. Under 28 U.S.C. 1961(a), federal post-judgment interest is calculated from the date of the entry of the judgment.

In Florida, section 55.03(2) requires a judgment for money damages to bear on its face the rate of interest payable on it, and section 55.03(3) provides: "The interest rate is established at the time a judgment is obtained." The rate is then adjusted annually on January 1 under the rate then in effect, with stated exceptions.

A schedule that runs prejudgment interest past the verdict date, and then post-judgment interest from the same date, counts some days twice. A schedule that applies the prejudgment rate after judgment uses the wrong rate for that period. The reviewer separates the two periods with their own rates and their own rules for compounding.

Florida's Argonaut decision described the computation of prejudgment interest, once the jury has fixed damages as of a date certain, as "merely a mathematical computation" and "a purely ministerial duty" of the trial judge or clerk. The review supplies that computation in a form the clerk or the court can check line by line.

How does a reviewer rebuild the opposing interest schedule?

By splitting the claim into items with their own dates, applying the rate the governing rule sets for each period, recomputing day counts, and listing every difference from the opposing schedule with its source.

The rebuilt schedule has one row per item of damages and one column per input: amount, date incurred, start date, end date, number of days, rate and source of the rate, method (simple or compound), interest amount. Payments and setoffs appear as their own rows on their dates.

Next to each row the reviewer places the opposing figure and the difference. A difference column turns a dispute about method into a list of specific dollar amounts, each tied to one input. Counsel can then decide which differences to press and which to concede.

Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(a)(2)(D)(ii), absent a stipulation or a court order, evidence intended solely to contradict or rebut evidence on the same subject matter identified by another party's expert is disclosed within 30 days after the other party's disclosure. An interest schedule that answers the opposing schedule is rebuttal of that kind, and it stays within the subject of the opposing calculation.

Where the rebuttal is a written report under Rule 26(a)(2)(B), it contains the opinions with their basis and reasons, the facts or data considered, and the exhibits. For an interest schedule, the exhibits are the published rate tables, the payment records and the contract provisions the schedule uses.

The schedule is also a set of deposition questions. For each input that differs, the opposing expert is asked for the source: which statute, which publication, which document, which date.

How does IAE review the other side's interest calculation?

A reviewer from the IAE registry rebuilds the opposing calculation from the record, marks each figure without a source and writes a rebuttal report within the Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii) period or the court's schedule.

The IAE forensic accounting review is for attorneys facing the other side's damages, solvency or tracing report. The reviewer rebuilds the opposing calculation from the record, marks each figure without a source and writes a rebuttal report within the Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii) period or the court's schedule. The deliverables are a review of the opposing report, a rebuttal report and deposition questions.

The work is delivered in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, and the report under review and the questions are confirmed before work starts. Cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.

Every reviewer is a member of the public IAE registry, can be verified by Member ID or QR code and confirms no interest in the outcome of the case. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy; a review is evidence that the court weighs with the rest of the record, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member