Examinations

What happens in a psychological evaluation for child custody?

A court orders a child custody evaluation when parents dispute custody or parenting time. The evaluator interviews each parent, observes each parent with the child, reviews records, may give psychological tests and then reports findings to the court. In California, Rules of Court 5.220 and 5.225 set the steps and the evaluator's training, and the 2022 APA guidelines set the professional standard for psychologists who do this work.

A child seen from behind builds with blocks while a psychologist sits nearby with a notebook

What is a child custody evaluation?

A study of the family that a qualified mental health professional carries out on court order and reports to the court. California distinguishes full evaluations from partial ones limited by the order in time or scope.

Under Rule 5.220(b) of the California Rules of Court, an evaluation is ordered to assist the court in assessing the child's health, safety, welfare and best interest in a disputed custody or visitation matter. The rule applies to court-connected and private evaluators. Subdivision (c) treats "evaluation," "investigation" and "assessment" as synonyms.

The same subdivision defines two kinds. A full evaluation "is a comprehensive examination" of the issues. A partial evaluation is one "limited by court order in either time or scope." The order therefore tells the parties how wide the evaluation will be.

The American Psychological Association's Guidelines for Child Custody Evaluations in Family Law Proceedings, adopted as association policy in February 2022, start from the same point. Guideline 1 says the evaluation is "to assist in identifying the best interests of the child," in recognition that the child's welfare is paramount. Guideline 2 says it "focuses upon parenting abilities, the children's needs, and the resulting fit."

Who may perform a custody evaluation?

In California, a psychiatrist, psychologist, marriage and family therapist, clinical social worker, professional clinical counselor or a court-connected evaluator certified by the court, after 40 hours of education and training and domestic violence training.

Rule 5.225(c) lists the professions: a physician who is a board-certified psychiatrist or has completed a residency in psychiatry, a psychologist, a marriage and family therapist, a clinical social worker, a professional clinical counselor qualified to assess couples and families, or a person the court certifies as a court-connected evaluator who meets the rule's qualifications.

Each evaluator must complete 40 hours of education and training on the subjects in Rule 5.225(d), take 8 hours of update training on the same subjects, and meet the basic and advanced domestic violence training requirements of Rule 5.230. A private evaluator files a declaration on form FL-326 with the clerk no later than 10 days after notice of each appointment; a court-connected evaluator submits form FL-325 to the court executive officer.

APA Guideline 4 asks psychologists to obtain and maintain the competencies needed for custody evaluations, and Guideline 5 asks for specialized competencies for complex and high-risk issues.

What does the court order set?

The evaluator, the questions or scope, and whether the evaluation is full or partial. The court also gives the evaluator the order and decides how the fees are allocated between the parties.

Evidence Code section 730 lets a court, on its own motion or on motion of any party, appoint one or more experts to investigate, render a report as ordered and testify. The court may fix the expert's compensation.

Rule 5.220(d) makes the court responsible for the evaluation services. Each court adopts a local rule to implement Rule 5.220, with provisions on peremptory challenges to evaluators, on withdrawal and on complaints. The court gives the evaluator a copy of the appointing order and allocates the fees.

APA Guideline 3 asks psychologists to identify the evaluation's "stated purpose, anticipated use," "specific scope, and agreed-upon time frame before accepting referrals." When the order limits the evaluation to one question, the evaluator works within that question.

What does the evaluator look at?

Each parent's strengths and weaknesses as a parent, the child's needs and the fit between them. APA also asks psychologists to screen for family violence, child maltreatment, intimate partner violence and substance use.

Guideline 14 of the 2022 APA guidelines asks psychologists, when interviewing parents, to collect and assess information relevant to "parenting strengths and weaknesses, to ascertain the best interests of the child." Guideline 13 covers the child: developmentally appropriate and empirically supported techniques, interpreted in a way that explains the child's best interests.

Two guidelines concern screening. Under Guideline 15 psychologists screen "for family violence, child maltreatment," intimate partner violence and resultant trauma. Under Guideline 16 they screen examinees for substance use.

Rule 5.220(d) adds a duty toward the child: evaluators consider the child's best interest and work to minimize psychological trauma to the child.

What happens during the evaluation?

A written explanation of the process, interviews with each parent, observation of each parent with the child, review of records and corroborating information, and tests if the evaluator uses them. Each party is observed in comparable ways.

Rule 5.220(e) starts with a written explanation of the process for the parties: its purpose, procedures, who receives the report, the limits of confidentiality and the costs. APA Guideline 7 asks psychologists to obtain informed consent when it is both feasible and appropriate.

Data collection must "allow the evaluator to observe and consider each party in comparable ways." Rule 5.220(e)(2) lists the methods: reviewing pertinent documents related to custody, including local police records; observing parent-child interaction unless contraindicated to protect the child's best interest; interviewing the parents conjointly, individually or both; collecting relevant corroborating information or documents as permitted by law; and consulting other experts.

Observation of each parent with the child is part of the APA standard as well. Guideline 18 reads: "Psychologists strive to include an observation of parent-child interactions when conducting child custody evaluations," and the commentary notes that such observation "often provides highly relevant information." Guideline 8 asks psychologists to identify, request and review relevant records.

How is the child interviewed?

In terms suited to the child's age and without pressure about which parent to live with. California evaluators explain the process to the child, work to minimize trauma and must not pressure the child to state a preference.

Rule 5.220(d) requires evaluators to explain the process to children in age-appropriate terms. If a child changes his or her choice about addressing the court, the evaluator gives notice of that change. The ethics subdivision, Rule 5.220(j), bars pressuring children to state a custody preference.

APA Guideline 13 asks psychologists to select developmentally appropriate and empirically supported techniques for children. The commentary adds that "interviewing children requires specific knowledge and skills." The commentary to Guideline 1 notes that "considerations of the children's wishes are often regulated by law."

How much weight a child's wishes carry depends on state law and on the judge. The evaluator reports what the child said, in what setting, and how that fits with the observations and the other data.

Which psychological tests are used?

No rule requires a fixed test list. APA asks for standardized, methodologically sound measures, and Rule 5.220 asks the evaluator to state how test results confirm or question other information.

Under Rule 5.220(e)(1)(B), the written explanation states, "if psychological tests will be used, the role of the results in confirming or questioning other information." Tests are optional under the rule, and their results are weighed against interviews, observation and records.

APA Guideline 17 asks psychologists to use assessment measures "administered in a standardized and methodologically sound fashion." Guideline 10.02 of the APA Specialty Guidelines for Forensic Psychology asks forensic practitioners to use instruments "whose validity and reliability have been established" and, when that is not the case, to describe the strengths and limitations of their findings.

The commentary to the custody guidelines explains why several methods are combined: "Multitrait and multimethod assessments help balance the limitations on reliability and validity of single measures."

How is the time frame for the evaluation set?

By the court order and the referral. APA Guideline 3 asks psychologists to agree on the time frame before accepting the referral, and Rule 5.220(f) requires the report to state the time spent.

Rule 5.220 sets no statewide number of weeks for an evaluation. Under APA Guideline 3 the psychologist agrees on the time frame before accepting the referral, and the written explanation under Rule 5.220(e) tells the parties which procedures to expect.

Under Rule 5.220(f), the report must "summarize the data-gathering procedures, information sources, and time spent." Parents can compare the hours spent with each of them from that summary.

Under Rule 5.220(f)(2), the report describes any limitations that result from unobtainable information. Rule 5.220(h) lets the evaluator rely on a qualified neutral professional in another jurisdiction when a party lives there, with a written request and a report limited to facts and behavioral observations.

What goes into the custody evaluation report?

The procedures, sources and time spent, information that does and does not support the conclusions, the limitations, and clear and detailed recommendations, made only for parties who were evaluated.

Rule 5.220(f) lists the contents. The evaluator presents relevant information "including information that does not support the conclusions reached" and must "describe any limitations in the evaluation that result from unobtainable information." The evaluator may "only make a custody or visitation recommendation for a party who has been evaluated."

Written reports under Family Code section 3111 are confidential. Rule 5.220(g) requires them to be filed and served with form FL-328 attached as the first page. Where the evaluation concerns allegations of child sexual abuse under Family Code section 3118, the report goes on form FL-329 and contains a full analysis of the allegations.

APA Guideline 22 asks psychologists to make recommendations that "address and support the best interests of the child." Guideline 23 asks for reports that are "clear, concise, accurate, and objective."

What happens after the report is filed?

The court considers it with the rest of the evidence. Any party may call the court-appointed evaluator for examination, and a party may present its own expert on the same matter at its own cost.

Under Evidence Code section 732, an expert appointed under section 730 "may be called and examined by the court or by any party to the action." Rule 5.220(k) requires each local court to develop procedures for expeditious and cost-effective cross-examination of evaluators.

Section 733 lets a party produce other expert evidence on the same matter. That party pays its own expert, and only ordinary witness fees are taxed as costs.

A parent who disagrees with the report can ask another psychologist to review it, together with the evaluator's file, against Rule 5.220 and the APA guidelines.

What does IAE do in custody cases?

A psychologist from the IAE registry writes an expert report on the client's questions or a review of the opposing evaluation. Delivery takes up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.

The forensic psychological evaluation and review page covers child custody and parenting time, decision-making capacity in contract and will disputes, and emotional distress claims. Under the 2022 APA custody guidelines, the evaluator combines several methods, standardized measures and observation of parent-child interaction (Guidelines 10, 17 and 18); the IAE review checks the opposing report on these points.

IAE frames the questions from the pleadings, the records and the opposing evaluator's report and confirms them with the client before work starts. Receipt is confirmed the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV. Cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.

Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry, verified by Member ID or QR code, and confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. Materials go through the contact form or to info@iaexperts.com and are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. The court decides custody; neither IAE nor the psychologist guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert examinations

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member