Examinations
Capacity evaluation for guardianship: who examines the person, and what must the report contain?
Before a court appoints a guardian for an adult, professionals examine the person and report on which rights he or she can still exercise. Florida uses a three-member examining committee whose reports are due within 15 days; Texas requires a letter or certificate from a physician or, for a mental condition, a psychologist. The court then decides right by right, and incapacity must be proved by clear and convincing evidence in Florida.

What is a capacity evaluation for guardianship?
It is a court-ordered examination of an adult alleged to be incapacitated. The examiners assess medical condition, mental functioning and daily functioning and report which rights the person can exercise and which he or she cannot.
A guardianship petition asks the court to transfer some of a person's rights to someone else: to manage money, sign contracts, choose a residence or consent to medical treatment. The evaluation supplies the factual basis for that decision. In Florida the statute requires the committee examination and reports before the hearing on incapacity.
The evaluation is not a diagnosis exercise. A diagnosis of dementia, a brain injury or a psychiatric illness says little by itself about whether the person can pay bills, follow medical advice or recognize exploitation. The statutes ask for the connection between the condition and specific tasks, and the report is judged by whether it makes that connection.
The American Psychological Association described the handbooks of the ABA-APA Working Group on the Assessment of Capacity in Older Adults in its Monitor in March 2009. The article lists six elements from the judges' handbook: medical condition, cognition, everyday functioning, values and preferences, risk and level of supervision, and means to enhance capacity.
Who evaluates the person in a Florida guardianship case?
An examining committee of three members appointed by the court within 5 days after the petition is filed. Under section 744.331(3)(a), one member must be a psychiatrist or other physician; the others may include psychologists, gerontologists and nurses.
Section 744.331 of the Florida Statutes sets the procedure. Under subsection (3)(a), the court appoints the committee within 5 days after the petition to determine incapacity is filed. The statute states: "One member must be a psychiatrist or other physician." The remaining members come from listed professions, among them psychologists, gerontologists and nurses.
The statute keeps the committee independent. Members may not be related to or associated with the parties, and the person's attending or family physician is generally excluded. The point is that the examiners have no stake in the result and no prior relationship that shapes what they see.
Subsection (2) adds a lawyer. The court appoints an attorney for each alleged incapacitated person, and the person may substitute an attorney of his or her choice. The attorney cannot serve as guardian or as counsel for the guardian or the petitioner, and must complete at least 8 hours of guardianship education, subject to exceptions for experienced attorneys.
What does each committee examination include?
Under section 744.331(3), the examination must include, if indicated, a physical examination, a mental health examination and a functional assessment. If any part is omitted, the examiner explains why in the report.
The three parts answer different questions. The physical examination looks for medical causes of the impairment, some of them treatable. The mental health examination covers cognition, mood, thought content and judgment. The functional assessment looks at what the person can do: manage money, take medication, prepare food, use transportation, recognize danger.
The words "if indicated" give the examiner room to skip a part that does not apply, but not to skip it silently. A report that omits the functional assessment without an explanation leaves the court without the part that ties the condition to the rights at issue, and an objection can point to that gap.
When a psychologist sits on the committee, the mental health examination and the functional assessment are within that member's field. Standardized cognitive tests and structured functional measures give numbers that can be compared with norms, but the statute asks for an evaluation of abilities, and the report has to translate test results into the tasks the court is deciding about.
What must the examining committee report contain?
Diagnosis, prognosis and recommended treatment where possible, an evaluation of the ability to retain each right, such as voting, contracting and consenting to treatment, the factual basis for each finding and the names of those present.
Section 744.331(3) requires the report to address the person's ability to exercise the rights listed in the statute. For each right the person is found unable to exercise, the report describes the factual basis for that finding. A conclusion such as "unable to manage finances" without the observations, test results or history behind it does not meet the statute.
The report also records the names of all persons present during the examination and bears the examiner's signature with the date and time of the examination. Those details matter when a party later claims that a relative directed the person's answers or that the examination was too short for the conclusions drawn.
A reviewing psychologist reads the report against this list. Each right should be addressed separately, each finding should point to data, and the recommended treatment should be compared with the alternatives the court must consider before appointing a guardian.
When are the reports filed, and can a party object to them?
Each member files a report within 15 days after appointment. The clerk serves reports within 3 days, parties receive them at least 10 days before the hearing, and written objections are due 5 days before it.
The timetable in section 744.331(3) is short. Fifteen days for the examination and report, three days for the clerk to serve the reports, and at least ten days between service and the hearing. Written objections to the admission of the reports must be filed at least 5 days before the hearing.
The objection period is where a review of the reports does its work. A family member who believes the committee missed a reversible medical cause, relied on one interview or ignored a functional ability needs a written analysis in hand before the 5-day deadline. An analysis that arrives after the hearing reaches the court only through a later motion to restore rights.
Section 744.331(4) gives the reports weight of their own: if a majority of the committee members find that the person is not incapacitated in any respect, "the court shall dismiss the petition."
What must be proved at the hearing in Florida?
Under section 744.331(5)(c), partial or total incapacity must be established by clear and convincing evidence. The order removes only the rights it names, and the court first considers whether an alternative to guardianship would be enough.
The adjudicatory hearing is held at least 10 days and no more than 30 days after the last committee report is filed, absent good cause; the 10-day minimum can be waived. The person attends unless excused. The statute states: "Partial or total incapacity must be established by clear and convincing evidence."
Under subsection (6), the court that finds incapacity issues a written order with specific findings, and "A person is determined to be incapacitated only with respect to those rights specified in the order." The person keeps every right not specifically removed. Total incapacity requires findings that the person cannot care for himself or herself or the property.
Before appointing a guardian for delegable rights, the court must consider whether an alternative to guardianship would suffice, such as an existing power of attorney or trust. A verified statement challenging a trust or power of attorney can keep it from counting as such an alternative. For the evaluator this means the report should say what supports already exist and whether they work.
Who evaluates the proposed ward in Texas?
Under Texas Estates Code section 1101.103, a Texas-licensed physician, or for a mental condition a licensed or HHSC-certified psychologist, provides a letter or certificate dated within 120 days before the application.
The physician route covers incapacity from a physical or mental condition. The psychologist route covers a mental condition, and under subsection (b-1) a psychologist's letter addresses only mental capacity, within the psychologist's scope of practice. The examiner must have experience with the condition or an established patient relationship with the proposed ward, and the court may appoint an examiner if it finds an examination necessary.
The 120-day window runs from the filing of the application: both the letter or certificate and the examination must be no earlier than the 120th day before filing. A report from an examination done five months earlier does not qualify, however thorough it was.
The content list is detailed. The physician describes the nature, degree and severity of the incapacity, including functional deficits in business, finances, driving, personal decisions and consent to treatment; states whether the person has the capacity to vote and can safely operate a motor vehicle; explains how the condition affects understanding, problem-solving, logical reasoning and daily living with or without supports; notes whether current medication affects demeanor or participation in court; and states whether improvement is possible, when to reevaluate and whether a guardianship is needed or the guardian's powers should be limited if supports are provided.
Who pays for the guardianship evaluation in Florida?
Under section 744.331(7) the court sets the committee and attorney fees. The guardian pays from the ward's property, or the state pays for an indigent ward; if the petition is dismissed, committee fees are paid as expert witness fees.
When the state pays for an indigent ward, it holds a creditor's claim against the guardianship property, which must be filed within 90 days. The statute also lets the court assess costs and attorney fees against a petitioner who filed in bad faith.
A party who wants its own psychologist to review the committee's reports pays for that review separately. The review works from the reports, the records and the examination notes that the parties can obtain.
How is a committee report challenged?
By written objection to its admission at least 5 days before the hearing, by questioning the examiners, and with a reviewing psychologist's analysis of whether each finding rests on data and whether each statutory part of the examination was done.
A review of a capacity report asks a fixed set of questions. Was each of the three parts of the examination done, or was its omission explained? Were the tests appropriate for the person's age, language and education? Did the examiner speak to anyone besides the petitioner? Is each right addressed separately, with a factual basis? Were reversible causes, such as medication effects or infection, considered?
The reviewer does not examine the person and does not offer an opinion on whether the person is incapacitated. The review addresses the method and the support for the conclusions, and it is filed or used in questioning according to the court's procedure.
The same questions apply to a Texas letter or certificate: whether the examiner met the qualification and the 120-day window, and whether each item of the statutory content list is answered with facts. For other states, a chart of state guardianship statutes dated April 6, 2022 and published on the U.S. Department of Justice website sets out, state by state, the statutory language on the clinician's evaluation and the report filed with the court.
What does IAE do when a guardianship evaluation is in dispute?
A psychologist from the IAE registry writes an expert report on the client's questions or a review of the examining committee's or the opposing examiner's report. Delivery takes up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.
The IAE forensic psychological evaluation page covers child custody and parenting time, decision-making capacity in contract and will disputes, and emotional distress claims. A psychologist from the IAE registry writes an expert report on the client's questions or a review of the opposing psychologist's evaluation. On capacity, the page notes that in California a finding of incapacity needs evidence of a deficit in a mental function linked to the decision at issue, and a diagnosis alone is not enough (Probate Code 811).
The page also names the APA Specialty Guidelines for Forensic Psychology, adopted on August 3, 2011, as a basis for review: corroboration from more than one source (9.02), instruments with established validity and reliability (10.02) and stated limits for persons not examined (9.03).
The client sends the petition, the committee reports or the physician's or psychologist's letter, the medical records and the court orders and describes the task. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. Delivery takes up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, with a 48-hour rush for tight deadlines, which matters when the 5-day objection deadline is near.
Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry, can be verified by Member ID or QR code and confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. Materials are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. Neither IAE nor the psychologist guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.
Sources
- Florida Statutes 2026, section 744.331, Procedures to determine incapacity (The Florida Senate)
- Texas Estates Code section 1101.103, Determination of incapacity of certain adults: physician or psychologist examination (Texas.Public.Law)
- American Psychological Association, Monitor on Psychology, March 2009, New help for assessing older adults
- States Guardianship Statutes: Requirements for the Clinician's Capacity Evaluation Report Provided to the Court, chart dated April 6, 2022 (U.S. Department of Justice)
Read also
All articles
Undue influence expert witness: what can a psychologist assess in a will, trust or contract dispute?
In California a will, or a part of one, is ineffective to the extent undue influence procured it, and that claim is separate from a claim that
Supervised visitation: when does a court order it, and what does a psychologist assess?
A court orders supervised visitation when contact with a parent is in the child's interest but carries a risk that a neutral third person can manage
Forensic psychologist or psychiatrist: who evaluates what in family and civil cases?
Courts decide who may evaluate a person by the question in the case and the examiner's license and training. California lets a psychiatristExpert examinations
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

