Examinations

Undue influence expert witness: what can a psychologist assess in a will, trust or contract dispute?

In California a will, or a part of one, is ineffective to the extent undue influence procured it, and that claim is separate from a claim that the signer lacked capacity. The state defines undue influence by statute and lists four groups of factors for the court. Two of them, the person's vulnerability and the tactics used, are questions a psychologist can address on medical records, communications and testimony. Whether the result was inequitable is for the court.

A psychologist from behind sits with a closed notebook as two blurred figures share a dining table

What is undue influence in a will, trust or contract dispute?

In California it is excessive persuasion that causes another person to act or refrain from acting by overcoming that person's free will and that results in inequity. Welfare and Institutions Code section 15610.70 gives the definition.

The statute opens with the words "excessive persuasion that causes another person to act or refrain from acting." Two more elements follow: the persuasion overcomes the person's free will, and the result is inequitable.

Probate Code section 86 gives the term the same meaning in probate matters. The Legislature stated there that it intended to supplement the common law meaning of undue influence without superseding or interfering with the operation of that law. For wills the consequence is in Probate Code section 6104: the execution or revocation of a will, or of a part of it, is ineffective to the extent it "was procured by duress, menace, fraud, or undue influence."

Contracts have their own text. Civil Code section 1575 lists three forms: use of a confidence or of real or apparent authority to obtain an unfair advantage, "taking an unfair advantage of another's weakness of mind," and "taking a grossly oppressive and unfair advantage of another's necessities or distress."

Which factors does a court weigh?

Four groups under section 15610.70(a): the vulnerability of the victim, the influencer's apparent authority, the actions or tactics used, and the equity of the result. An inequitable result alone is not enough.

Vulnerability comes first. The statute lists incapacity, illness, disability, injury, age, education, impaired cognitive function, emotional distress, isolation and dependency as evidence of it, and asks whether the influencer knew or should have known of the vulnerability.

Apparent authority is the second group. The examples are status as a fiduciary, family member, care provider, health care professional, legal professional, spiritual adviser or expert.

Tactics are the third. The statute names controlling the necessaries of life, medication, the person's interactions with others, access to information or sleep. It names the use of affection, intimidation or coercion. It also names initiating changes in personal or property rights with haste or secrecy, at inappropriate times and places, or with claims of expertise.

Equity of the result is the fourth: the economic consequences to the victim, any divergence from the person's prior intent or course of conduct, the relationship of the value conveyed to the value of services or consideration received, and whether the change fits the length and nature of the relationship. Subdivision (b) then limits the weight of that last group. "Evidence of an inequitable result, without more, is not sufficient to prove undue influence."

Which of those factors can a psychologist address?

Mainly the first and the third. Cognitive impairment, emotional distress, isolation and dependency are conditions a psychologist assesses, and control over contacts, information, medication and sleep is conduct whose effect on a vulnerable person a psychologist can explain.

On vulnerability the psychologist answers a narrower question than a diagnosis: what the person could and could not do in the weeks around the signing. Scores on cognitive screening, notes on orientation and memory, medication lists and descriptions of mood in the medical record are the raw material. The statute's list puts conditions short of incapacity, such as emotional distress, isolation and dependency, next to incapacity itself, so the assessment does not stop at the question of dementia.

On tactics the psychologist does not decide who did what. That is fact-finding. The contribution is to explain how the conduct shown by the records would act on this person: what it means for decision-making when one caregiver controls the telephone, the visitors and the medication of someone with impaired memory, or when a document is presented for signature without warning and without the person's usual adviser.

Apparent authority and the equity of the result are mostly outside psychology. The status of a relative, caregiver or lawyer is proved by documents and testimony, and the comparison of what was given with what was received is an accounting and legal question.

How is undue influence different from lack of capacity?

Capacity asks whether the person had the mental functions needed for the act. Undue influence assumes the person may have had them and asks whether someone else's persuasion overcame the person's free will.

California's capacity standard is in Probate Code section 811. A determination that a person lacks capacity must be supported by evidence of a deficit in at least one listed mental function and by "evidence of a correlation between the deficit or deficits and the decision or acts in question." The functions are grouped as alertness and attention, information processing, thought processes, and the ability to modulate mood and affect. A deficit counts only if it significantly impairs the person's ability to understand and appreciate the consequences of his or her actions. Under subdivision (d) the mere diagnosis of a mental or physical disorder is not sufficient in and of itself.

The two claims can be tried on the same records and come out differently. A person with mild impairment may pass the test of section 811 and still be vulnerable within section 15610.70. A report that treats a finding of capacity as the end of the undue influence question has answered only one of the two.

When is undue influence presumed, and who must disprove it?

In California a gift to the drafter of the instrument, to certain fiduciaries and to a care custodian of a dependent adult is presumed to be the product of fraud or undue influence under Probate Code section 21380.

The section covers a donative transfer to the person who drafted the instrument, to a person who transcribed it or caused it to be transcribed while in a fiduciary relationship with the transferor, and to a care custodian of a transferor who is a dependent adult if the instrument was executed while the custodian provided services or within 90 days before or after that period. It reaches relatives within the third degree, cohabitants and employees of those persons, and partners, shareholders and employees of a law firm in which the drafter or transcriber has an ownership interest.

The presumption affects the burden of proof. It may be rebutted by clear and convincing evidence that the transfer was not the product of fraud or undue influence, except that for the drafter and persons connected to the drafter the presumption is conclusive. A beneficiary who fails to rebut it bears all costs of the proceeding, including reasonable attorney's fees.

Florida states the allocation in section 733.107. The proponent of a will first establishes prima facie its formal execution and attestation, and the contestant then has the burden of establishing the grounds of the contest. Under subsection (2), in any transaction or event to which the presumption of undue influence applies, the presumption "implements public policy against abuse of fiduciary or confidential relationships" and shifts the burden of proof.

Where a presumption applies, the psychologist may be retained by the beneficiary. The questions are the same. The party who needs the answers has changed.

Can a psychologist give an opinion about a person who has died?

Yes, on records, with the limits stated. When the signer has died or can no longer be interviewed, the psychologist works from documents, and under Rule 702 the opinion must rest on sufficient facts or data.

A retrospective evaluation is a reconstruction. Medical and nursing records supply the clinical picture near the date of signing. Caregiver logs, telephone and visitor records, messages and emails show who had access to the person and how often. Bank and brokerage statements show when the pattern of spending or giving changed. The drafting lawyer's file shows who made the appointment, who was in the room and what the person said. Video of the signing, where there is one, shows the person at a single moment.

Federal Rule of Evidence 702 requires the proponent to show that it is more likely than not that the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data and is the product of reliable principles and methods reliably applied to the facts of the case. For a records-only opinion that means saying which records were available, which were missing and which conclusions cannot be drawn without an examination.

May the expert say that undue influence occurred?

In a federal civil case an opinion is not objectionable just because it embraces an ultimate issue (Rule 704(a)). The statutory test also includes the equity of the result, which lies outside psychology.

Rule 704(a) reads: "An opinion is not objectionable just because it embraces an ultimate issue." Paragraph (b) restricts experts only in criminal cases, where an expert must not state an opinion about whether the defendant had a mental state or condition that constitutes an element of the crime charged or of a defense.

The definition in section 15610.70 sets a practical limit of its own. Undue influence under that section requires an inequitable result, and equity is measured by economic consequences and by the fit between the transfer and the relationship. A psychologist who declares that undue influence occurred has given an opinion on matters outside the discipline. An opinion that the person was highly susceptible in a named period, for stated reasons, and that the documented conduct matches the tactics the statute lists stays within it.

Which records does the psychologist need?

Medical and nursing records for the period around the signing, the instrument and its earlier versions, the drafting lawyer's file, caregiver logs, communications, financial statements and the deposition testimony of people who saw the person regularly.

Earlier wills and trust amendments matter because the statute treats divergence from the person's prior intent or course of conduct as evidence. A change that reverses long-standing planning reads differently against the medical record than a change that continues it.

The questions should be put in the terms of the statute: the person's vulnerability in the named period, what the influencer knew of it, and the effect of the specific conduct alleged. A question that asks only for a diagnosis returns an answer the court cannot use on either claim.

What does IAE do when undue influence is alleged?

A psychologist from the IAE registry writes an expert report on the client's questions or a review of the opposing psychologist's evaluation. Delivery takes up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.

The IAE forensic psychological evaluation page covers child custody and parenting time, decision-making capacity in contract and will disputes, and emotional distress claims. On capacity the page notes that in California a finding of incapacity needs evidence of a deficit in a mental function linked to the decision at issue, and that a diagnosis alone is not enough (Probate Code 811).

For review of an opposing report the page names the APA Specialty Guidelines for Forensic Psychology, adopted by the APA Council of Representatives on August 3, 2011: corroboration from more than one source (9.02), instruments with established validity and reliability (10.02) and stated limits for persons not examined (9.03). The questions are framed from the pleadings, the records and the opposing evaluator's report and confirmed before work starts.

The client sends the instrument, the medical records, the communications and the opposing report, where there is one, and describes the task. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. Cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.

Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry, can be verified by Member ID or QR code and confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. Materials are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. Neither IAE nor the psychologist guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert examinations

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member