Expert report review
Two handwriting experts disagree: how does a court decide?
When two handwriting examiners reach opposite conclusions about one signature, a federal judge does not pick the winner on paper. Each opinion passes or fails Rule 702 on its own, a real conflict usually defeats summary judgment, and the jury or, in a bench trial, the judge decides whom to believe. Before any of that, a reviewer checks whether the two reports truly conflict and why they differ.

What happens when two handwriting experts reach opposite conclusions?
If both opinions meet Rule 702, both go to the factfinder. The jury, or the judge in a bench trial, decides which examiner to believe; credibility and weight are not settled on a motion.
The Supreme Court described the division of labor in Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc., 477 U.S. 242, decided June 25, 1986. Justice White wrote for the majority that "Credibility determinations, the weighing of the evidence, and the drawing of legitimate inferences from the facts are jury functions, not those of a judge." Two examiners who look at the same signature and disagree present that kind of question.
The committee note to the 2000 amendment of Federal Rule of Evidence 702 speaks to competing experts. When a court rules that one expert's testimony is reliable, "this does not necessarily mean that contradictory expert testimony is unreliable." The amendment "is broad enough to permit testimony that is the product of competing principles or methods" in the same field, and the gatekeeper role "is not intended to serve as a replacement for the adversary system."
A handwriting dispute therefore passes through three stages, and each asks a different question. At the Rule 702 ruling the court asks whether each opinion rests on sufficient facts and a reliable method reliably applied. On summary judgment it asks whether a reasonable factfinder could side with either examiner. At trial the factfinder chooses.
Do the two reports actually contradict each other?
Not always. An examiner who reaches no conclusion has not contradicted one who names the writer, and an opinion whose basis is missing from the record may carry no weight on a motion.
The SWGDOC Standard Terminology for Expressing Conclusions of Forensic Document Examiners, version 2013-2, lists nine recommended terms in section 4.1. Identification, strong probability, probable and indications sit on one side; indications did not, probably did not, strong probability did not and elimination sit on the other. In the middle is no conclusion, which the standard calls "the zero point of the confidence scale." Two reports that say "probable" and "indications" lean the same way with different strength. Only opinions on opposite sides of the zero point point in different directions.
New York's Court of Appeals decided such a case in Banco Popular N. Am. v. Victory Taxi Mgt., 1 N.Y.3d 381, decided February 19, 2004. The defendant, Jafa Albaz, swore that her signatures on taxi financing contracts were forged and offered a document examiner's sworn statement. In substance the examiner was not able to determine whether she signed. The court held that this did not raise a triable issue of fact and affirmed summary judgment for the bank.
The Appellate Division, First Department, looked at the basis of an opinion in Al-Kabyalle v Ali, 159 A.D.3d 477, decided March 8, 2018. The plaintiff said his signature on a written consent of the directors of a realty company was forged. The moving defendant's examiner said he was "virtually certain" that the signature matched seven exemplars, but, the court wrote, "the expert did not describe the exemplars, nor are they in the record." The court held that Ali "failed to show that plaintiff's signature was genuine" and affirmed the denial of his motion.
Why do two qualified examiners read the same signature differently?
Often they did not examine the same material or answer the same question: different known writing, an original against a copy, a different set of hypotheses. Bias and motivation are a further cause named in the literature.
ANSI/ASB Standard 070, Standard for Examination of Handwritten Items (2022), names the variables. Under section 6.3.2 the examiner determines whether the questioned writing is original and, if it is not, requests the original. Section 6.5.2.1 lists features that limit comparability between questioned and known writing: "the type of writing, noncontemporaneousness, dissimilarities in text content, capture methods, writing instruments, and writing surfaces." If one examiner had a scan and known signatures written years earlier and the other had the original and signatures written in the year of signing, they did not run the same comparison.
The question can differ too. Section 6.2.4 requires the examiner to document the scope of the examination, and its note says the scope may be written as "two or more mutually exclusive competing hypotheses." One of the examples is that the questioned material "was written by another specified writer." If one examiner tested the signature against the named signer and the other against a specific suspect, their reports answer different questions.
Andrew Sulner, a forensic document examiner in New York, presented a case review to the Jurisprudence Section of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences in 2014 under the title "A Case Review of Conflicting Expert Opinions Based Upon Examinations of the Same Questioned Signatures and Exemplars." He attributed the conflict to bias and motivational factors. The insistence that examiners with comparable training will rarely disagree, he wrote, "is a myth that still prevails."
Does a conflict between handwriting experts stop summary judgment?
Usually. Rule 56(a) permits summary judgment only where there is no genuine dispute as to any material fact, and choosing between two admissible examiners is a credibility decision reserved for trial.
Under Rule 56(a) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure the court grants summary judgment only if the movant establishes that no genuine dispute exists as to any material fact and that it is entitled to judgment as a matter of law. In Anderson v. Liberty Lobby the Court explained that a dispute is genuine "if the evidence is such that a reasonable jury could return a verdict for the nonmoving party." Two admissible handwriting opinions on whether one person signed usually meet that test.
When only one side has an examiner, Rule 56(d) gives the other side a route. A nonmovant who shows by affidavit or declaration that it cannot present facts essential to its opposition may ask the court to defer or deny the motion, to "allow time to obtain affidavits or declarations or to take discovery," or to issue another appropriate order.
Primerica Life Insurance Co. v. Williamson, No. 1:21-CV-0705, decided by Judge Lawrence E. Kahn of the Northern District of New York on September 20, 2022, is an example. The cross-claimants' handwriting expert concluded that someone forged the decedent's signature on the questioned document. The other claimant had no expert and asked for time to obtain one. The court denied the cross-motion without prejudice, with leave to renew after discovery, expressed no opinion on the admissibility of the expert's report, and cited New York law that "an assertion that a signature was forged cannot ordinarily be resolved on summary judgment."
Banco Popular marks the limit. An opinion that the examiner cannot tell does not create the dispute, so a party opposing summary judgment needs an examiner who reaches a conclusion on the signature.
Can the judge exclude one examiner and leave the other?
Yes, if one opinion fails Rule 702. The court tests each opinion separately; admitting one does not make the contrary opinion unreliable, and excluding one does not prove the other correct.
Since December 1, 2023, Rule 702 requires the proponent to show the court that it is more likely than not that the opinion rests on sufficient facts or data and on a reliable method reliably applied. The 2023 committee note adds that "each expert opinion must stay within the bounds of what can be concluded from a reliable application of the expert's basis and methodology." In a handwriting case the bounds are set by the material: a conclusion stronger than a copy or a thin set of known writing supports goes beyond them.
The ruling is made opinion by opinion. Each examiner's report is tested against its own file, so a gap in one report does not add support to the other.
If one opinion is excluded, the other may stand unopposed on the signature, and the summary judgment analysis changes. For that reason a review of two conflicting reports is timed for the Rule 702 briefing, before the summary judgment schedule runs.
Can the court appoint its own handwriting examiner?
Yes. Under Federal Rule of Evidence 706 the court, on a party's motion or on its own, may appoint an expert the parties agree on or one of its own choosing, if the expert consents to act.
Rule 706(b) sets the appointed expert's position. The court informs the expert of the duties in writing or at a conference in which the parties have an opportunity to participate. The expert must advise the parties of any findings, may be deposed by any party, may be called to testify by the court or any party, and may be cross-examined by any party, including the party that called the expert.
Under Rule 706(c), in an ordinary civil case the compensation is paid by the parties in the proportion and at the time the court directs, and then charged like other costs. Under Rule 706(d) the court may disclose to the jury that it appointed the expert. Rule 706(e) keeps each party's right to call its own experts.
The Advisory Committee's note on the proposed rule calls the practice of shopping for experts and the reluctance of many reputable experts to involve themselves in litigation "matters of deep concern," and it mentions the contention that court-appointed experts acquire "an aura of infallibility." A motion for a court-appointed examiner after two conflicting reports asks the court to add a third opinion on the same signature, and the parties still cross-examine it.
What does a jury hear about weighing two expert opinions?
In the Ninth Circuit's model civil instruction 2.13, jurors hear that they may accept or reject opinion testimony and give it the weight they think it deserves, considering qualifications, reasons and the other evidence.
The Manual of Model Civil Jury Instructions for the Ninth Circuit, instruction 2.13, revised in March 2025, tells jurors that opinion testimony "is allowed, because of the specialized knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education of this witness." It continues: "Such opinion testimony should be judged like any other testimony."
The operative sentence says the jurors "may accept it or reject it and give it as much weight as you think it deserves, considering the witness's specialized knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education, the reasons given for the opinion, and all the other evidence in the case." With two examiners, the comparison of reasons decides most cases: which known writing each used, which features each relied on and how each explained the differences.
Other circuits and the states publish their own pattern instructions, and the trial court settles the final wording. Counsel who expects a contest between examiners proposes instructions with the rest of the pretrial filings.
What happens on appeal after a trial judge picks one examiner?
The finding is reviewed for clear error. Rule 52(a)(6) requires due regard to the trial court's opportunity to judge credibility, and a choice between two permissible views of the evidence is not clearly erroneous.
In a bench trial Rule 52(a)(1) requires the court to "find the facts specially and state its conclusions of law separately." Rule 52(a)(6) then provides that findings of fact "must not be set aside unless clearly erroneous," and that the reviewing court "must give due regard to the trial court's opportunity to judge the witnesses' credibility."
The Supreme Court applied this in Anderson v. City of Bessemer City, 470 U.S. 564, decided March 19, 1985: "Where there are two permissible views of the evidence, the factfinder's choice between them cannot be clearly erroneous." The Court added that when findings rest on credibility, "Rule 52(a) demands even greater deference to the trial court's findings."
Under that standard an appeal does not reopen the handwriting question when both views of the evidence were permissible. The work has to be done before and during trial: in the Rule 702 ruling, in cross-examination of the other examiner and in proposed findings that address each difference between the two reports.
What does a reviewer compare in two conflicting handwriting reports?
The material each examiner had, the hypotheses each tested, the steps each documented and the wording of each conclusion. The comparison tells counsel whether the conflict is real and which report has the gap.
Each retained examiner who testifies serves a report under Rule 26(a)(2)(B) with all opinions, the basis and reasons for them, and the facts or data considered. The reviewer starts with a side-by-side table built from those parts: the questioned document and its form, original or copy; the known writing, its number, dates and source; the scope or hypotheses; the features described; the conclusion term on the SWGDOC scale.
The second layer is the file behind each report. Standard 070, section 6.1, requires the examiner to document the examinations contemporaneously, with observations and the basis for results, in enough detail for an internal or external review. A report whose file does not show which exemplars were used meets the problem the New York court identified in Al-Kabyalle.
The reviewer then writes what the comparison establishes: whether the reports sit on opposite sides of the zero point, which difference in material explains the split, and which conclusion goes beyond its material. Counsel uses the result for the Rule 702 motion, for questions to the opposing examiner and for the choice between asking for a court-appointed expert and trying the conflict to the jury.
What does IAE prepare when two handwriting reports conflict?
IAE prepares a review of the opposing handwriting examiner's report, or a report on your questions, for federal and state cases. The document is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.
The review answers six questions about the opposing report: whether the method fits the questions and was followed at every stage, whether all materials were examined, whether the conclusions follow from the examination, whether the examiner's education and experience match the subject, whether formal and procedural requirements were met, and whether the report can be relied on. On handwriting it checks whether the report states each opinion with its basis and the facts or data considered, as Rule 26(a)(2)(B) requires, and whether the examiner followed Standard 070 on originals and comparability.
The client sends both reports and what is available of the questioned document and the known writing. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day, and within one business day IAE confirms the format, cost, deadline and the specialist from its registry. The client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. A 48-hour rush is available for cases with tight deadlines.
Specialists are members of the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code. The specialist confirms in the document that they have no interest in the outcome of the case. A review is evidence the court weighs with the other materials; neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.
Sources
- Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc., 477 U.S. 242 (1986) (Justia)
- Anderson v. City of Bessemer City, 470 U.S. 564 (1985) (LII)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702, Testimony by Expert Witnesses, with Committee Notes (LII)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 706, Court-Appointed Expert Witnesses, with Committee Notes (LII)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 56, Summary Judgment (LII)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 52, Findings and Conclusions by the Court (LII)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26, Duty to Disclose; General Provisions Governing Discovery (LII)
- Manual of Model Civil Jury Instructions for the Ninth Circuit, Instruction 2.13, Expert Opinion (revised March 2025)
- Banco Popular N. Am. v Victory Taxi Mgt., 1 NY3d 381 (2004), 2004 NY Slip Op 01059 (New York Court of Appeals)
- Al-Kabyalle v Ali, 159 AD3d 477 (1st Dept 2018), 2018 NY Slip Op 01556
- Primerica Life Insurance Co. v. Williamson, No. 1:21-CV-0705 (N.D.N.Y. Sept. 20, 2022) (govinfo)
- ANSI/ASB Standard 070, Standard for Examination of Handwritten Items, First Edition, 2022 (AAFS Standards Board)
- SWGDOC Standard Terminology for Expressing Conclusions of Forensic Document Examiners, ver. 2013-2
- Sulner A. A Case Review of Conflicting Expert Opinions Based Upon Examinations of the Same Questioned Signatures and Exemplars, AAFS Jurisprudence Section abstract E9, 2014
Read also
All articles
The handwriting examiner's opinion is inconclusive: what does that mean, and what does a reviewer check?
An inconclusive handwriting result is a defined conclusion. In the Department of Justice's uniform language it means that "no determination can be
Comparison charts in the opposing handwriting report: what does a reviewer check?
The part of a handwriting report that a judge or jury remembers is often the chart: questioned letters set beside matching letters from the known
The report says the signature was written under unusual conditions: what does that mean, and how is it reviewed?
A handwriting report may find that a questioned signature was written under unusual conditions: slowly, with tremor, poor line quality or an oddExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

