Expert witnesses
Construction delay expert witness: what does the schedule analysis have to prove?
A construction delay expert rebuilds the project schedule, finds the events that moved the completion date, assigns each delay to a party and prices the compensable days. On a federal fixed-price project two clauses turn on that work: FAR 52.249-10 extends the time for excusable delay, and FAR 52.242-14 pays for unreasonable delay caused by the contracting officer. In 2019 the ASBCA repeated that the contractor must prove an effect on the critical path.

What does a construction delay expert witness do?
The expert builds or tests the project schedule, identifies the events that moved the completion date, assigns each delay to the owner, the contractor or neither party, and prices the compensable days in a report.
The Civilian Board of Contract Appeals (CBCA) listed the steps in Yates-Desbuild Joint Venture v. Department of State (CBCA 3350, 3672, 4658, 4659, June 4, 2015). In a construction delay case, the CBCA wrote, "a scheduling expert may have to identify and isolate the various interrelated subprojects," set a baseline schedule for how they would have been performed with no delays, measure how changes and delays on one subproject affected the rest of the work, and "attempt to assign responsibility for and quantify the various delays."
The project in that case was the U.S. Consulate compound in Mumbai, India. The design-build contract, awarded in 2005, required substantial completion of nine buildings by March 18, 2008. The government certified substantial completion on October 6, 2011. On August 30, 2012 the contractor asked for a time extension of 1,184 days, 868 of which it considered compensable. On February 21, 2013 the contracting officer denied the requests and demanded payment of over $11 million in liquidated damages.
A scheduling expert does not have to be an expert in every cause of delay. The CBCA found it highly unlikely that one person would have expertise in every underlying cause and held that, as long as the witness has expertise in scheduling analysis itself, he can rely "upon factual assumptions provided to him or upon opinions of other experts" for technical causes he cannot address himself. In Yates-Desbuild one such cause was the Mumbai building permit process.
Why does a delay claim depend on the critical path?
Only delay to a critical activity moves the finish date. GAO's schedule guide treats an activity with zero or negative total float as critical; with zero total float, any delay moves the finish date by an equal amount.
The scheduling guide that the U.S. Government Accountability Office publishes at gaoinnovations.gov defines total float as "the amount of time an activity can be delayed or extended before delay affects the program's finish date." Free float is the part of total float available before the delay reaches the activity's immediate successor. In the guide's words, "An activity with negative or zero total float is considered to be critical."
For an activity with zero total float, the guide states that "any amount of activity delay will delay the program's finish date by an equal amount." An activity with 15 days of total float can start 15 days late and the finish date stays where it was. A late approval or a late delivery therefore matters for a time extension only if, on the day it happened, it sat on a path with no float left.
The boards of contract appeals require proof of that effect. In BES Construction, LLC (ASBCA No. 60608, October 23, 2019), the Armed Services Board of Contract Appeals (ASBCA) wrote that "the contractor must show that the government's actions affected activities on the critical path." For the rule the ASBCA cited the CBCA's later decision in Yates-Desbuild (17-1 BCA ¶ 36,870), which it described as a sister-board decision that does not bind it. In its 2015 ruling the CBCA had cited Haney v. United States (Ct. Cl. 1982) and Mega Construction Co. v. United States (Fed. Cl. 1993) for the tasks a scheduling expert performs in a complex delay case.
What happens to a delay claim that has no schedule analysis?
In BES Construction the contractor offered no critical path analysis and no expert. The ASBCA awarded $69,483.88, the government expert's figure, which was less than the contracting officer's own award of $134,886.29.
BES Construction renovated ball fields at a joint base in South Carolina under an Air Force contract awarded in 2013. Its certified claim, received on October 1, 2015, sought $608,568.67 in delay costs. The contracting officer's final decision found 172 days of compensable delay and awarded $134,886.29. BES appealed.
The government's expert, Mr. Weathers, testified that the government owed BES "not $134,886.29, but only $69,483.88, arising from 25 days of compensable delay." BES did not present any expert opinion. Its only opinion evidence came from its owner. BES conceded that the project encountered delays "arguably attributable to both BES and the government," and the ASBCA noted that BES "points to no such critical path analysis of its own."
Review at the ASBCA is de novo. Citing Wilner v. United States (Fed. Cir. 1994), the ASBCA wrote that "the contracting officer's award is not a floor." It treated the government expert's opinion as a concession that BES was owed $69,483.88 and sustained the appeal in that amount, with interest under 41 U.S.C. 7109 from October 1, 2015. The Board's award was $65,402.41 below the contracting officer's.
What is the difference between excusable and compensable delay?
Excusable delay under FAR 52.249-10 gives the contractor more time and protects it from default and damages. Compensable delay under FAR 52.242-14 also pays the added cost, without profit, when the contracting officer caused it.
FAR 52.249-10, Default (Fixed-Price Construction) (Apr 1984), lets the government terminate the contractor's right to proceed if the work is not finished on time. Paragraph (b) removes that risk, and the contractor is not charged with damages, when the delay arises from unforeseeable causes beyond the contractor's control and without its fault or negligence. The clause lists examples: acts of God or of the public enemy, acts of the government in its sovereign or contractual capacity, acts of another government contractor, fires, floods, epidemics, quarantine restrictions, strikes, freight embargoes, unusually severe weather, and delays of subcontractors or suppliers at any tier.
A subcontractor's delay counts only if it also arose from causes beyond the control and without the fault or negligence of both the contractor and the subcontractor or supplier. The contractor must notify the contracting officer in writing of the causes of delay within 10 days from the beginning of any delay, unless the contracting officer extends that period. The contracting officer then determines the facts and the extent of the delay and extends the time for completion when the findings justify it. The findings can be appealed under the Disputes clause.
Paragraph (b) speaks of time and of damages. It says nothing about paying the contractor's added costs. Money for delay comes from other clauses, most often FAR 52.242-14, Suspension of Work. A delay expert on a federal project therefore sorts the days into three groups: days caused by the government, days excused by another cause such as unusually severe weather, and days for which the contractor answers. If the termination for default is later found improper, paragraph (c) gives the parties the same rights as after a termination for the government's convenience.
When does FAR 52.242-14 pay for a suspension of work?
When an act of the contracting officer, or a failure to act within the contract time or a reasonable time, suspends, delays or interrupts the work for an unreasonable period. The adjustment covers increased cost of performance, excluding profit.
FAR 42.1305(a) prescribes the clause for fixed-price construction and architect-engineer contracts. Under paragraph (a), the contracting officer "may order the Contractor, in writing, to suspend" all or any part of the work for the period the contracting officer considers appropriate for the government's convenience.
Paragraph (b) gives an adjustment for the increase in the cost of performance, excluding profit, necessarily caused by an unreasonable suspension, delay or interruption, and the contract is modified in writing. There is no adjustment to the extent that performance would have been suspended, delayed or interrupted by any other cause, including the fault or negligence of the contractor, or where another term of the contract provides for or excludes an adjustment.
Paragraph (c) sets two limits that the expert has to build into the calculation. No claim is allowed for costs incurred more than 20 days before the contractor notified the contracting officer in writing of the act or failure to act; this limit does not apply to a claim arising from a suspension order. The claim must be asserted in writing, with an amount, as soon as practicable after the suspension, delay or interruption ends, and no later than the date of final payment under the contract. The date of the first written notice therefore fixes the earliest day from which costs can be counted.
How do boards treat concurrent delay?
The contractor has to prove its own delay and the government's delay separately. In BES the ASBCA wrote that when the delays are concurrent, the contractor "must establish its delay apart" and cited the CBCA.
Two FAR clauses set the same limit. FAR 52.242-14(b) bars an adjustment to the extent the work would have been delayed by any other cause, including the contractor's fault or negligence. FAR 52.249-10(b) excuses a delay only if it occurred without the contractor's fault or negligence.
In BES the contractor admitted delays on both sides and had no critical path analysis to divide them. The only division in the record came from the government's expert, and the ASBCA used his figure of 25 compensable days.
For each delay event the expert states whether the activity was critical when the event occurred, which party caused it and whether a delay of the other party ran at the same time. Days found excusable under FAR 52.249-10 are days for which the contractor is not charged damages, and in Yates-Desbuild the contracting officer's demand for liquidated damages exceeded $11 million.
Which schedule analysis method will a board or court accept?
No FAR clause prescribes a method. In Yates-Desbuild the contractor argued that the government's expert departed from AACE Recommended Practice 29R-03; the CBCA refused to exclude him and left the method dispute for the hearing.
On May 4, 2015 the contractor moved to exclude the government's scheduling expert, Mark Boe, on two grounds: he was not qualified to give opinions on the Mumbai building permit process, and his methodology was flawed and not recognized in the industry. The contractor argued that his report claimed to follow AACE RP 29R-03, the recommended practice for forensic schedule analysis, but did not. The government answered that the recommended practice itself calls forensic schedule analysis "both a science and an art."
The CBCA applied Rule 702, Daubert and Kumho Tire, and quoted the Federal Circuit in Libas, Ltd. v. United States (1999): "reliability is the touchstone." A party seeking exclusion before the hearing had to show that the evidence was "clearly inadmissible for any purpose." Citing Seaboard Lumber Co. v. United States (Fed. Cir. 2002), the CBCA added that reliability concerns "are of lesser import in a bench trial."
The disputes over the recommended practice, the CBCA wrote, "seem better resolved at a hearing on the merits." The motion was denied. The contractor kept the right to object at the hearing to any permit opinion beyond the expert's field, to cross-examine him and to ask the CBCA to reconsider.
How does a federal court test a scheduling expert under Rule 702?
The party offering the expert must persuade the court that it is more likely than not that the opinion rests on sufficient facts or data and on reliable methods reliably applied to the facts of the case.
Rule 702 admits a witness qualified by knowledge, skill, experience, training or education if four conditions are met: the specialized knowledge will help the trier of fact, the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data, it is the product of reliable principles and methods, and the principles and methods were reliably applied to the facts of the case. The current text was adopted by the Supreme Court's order of April 24, 2023 and took effect on December 1, 2023.
The committee note to the 2023 amendment addresses the sufficiency of the expert's basis and the application of the method. It states that "many courts have held that the critical questions of the sufficiency of an expert's basis, and the application of the expert's methodology, are questions of weight and not admissibility," and calls these rulings "an incorrect application of Rules 702 and 104(a)."
For a schedule analysis the basis is the set of schedules and project records the expert used, and the application is the way the method was run on this project's data. An expert who skipped schedule updates, or who assigned delay without testing whether the activity was critical at the time, faces those questions at the admissibility stage in federal court.
Which records does a delay expert need, and how are they obtained?
The baseline schedule, every update, and the records behind each delay event, including the written notices. In federal court Rule 34 reaches electronically stored information, produced as ordinarily maintained or in a reasonably usable form.
Rule 34(a)(1)(A) lets a party request "any designated documents or electronically stored information," and the other side must respond in writing within 30 days of service. If the request does not specify a form, Rule 34(b)(2)(E)(ii) requires production in a form in which the information is ordinarily maintained or in a reasonably usable form. A request for schedules can name the form, for example the native files of the scheduling software together with printouts.
The written notices form part of the record. FAR 52.249-10 requires notice of the causes of delay within 10 days, and FAR 52.242-14 counts costs only from 20 days before the written notice. The expert compares the dates of those letters with the dates of the delay events.
Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(ii) requires the report to list the facts or data the expert considered. Communications between counsel and the expert are generally protected, but Rule 26(b)(4)(C) makes discoverable the facts and data counsel provided and the expert considered, and the assumptions counsel provided and the expert relied on. When a scheduling expert relies on assumptions about a permit process or a design change, as the CBCA allowed in Yates-Desbuild, the other side can learn where those assumptions came from.
When is the delay expert's report due, and how does it connect to the claim?
In federal court, absent a stipulation or order, at least 90 days before trial, and rebuttal within 30 days of the other side's disclosure. On a federal contract the analysis usually starts earlier, as support for the certified claim.
Under Rule 26(a)(2)(B) the report contains all opinions with the basis and reasons for them, the facts or data considered, the exhibits, the expert's qualifications with publications from the previous 10 years, the cases in which the expert testified at trial or by deposition in the previous 4 years, and the compensation for the study and testimony. A deposition of the expert may take place only after the report is provided, and the party seeking it pays a reasonable fee for the expert's time unless manifest injustice would result.
Under the Contract Disputes Act, 41 U.S.C. 7103 requires each contractor claim to be in writing and submitted to the contracting officer within 6 years after it accrues. For a claim over $100,000 the contractor certifies that the claim is made in good faith, that "the supporting data are accurate and complete to the best of the contractor's knowledge and belief," that the amount requested is the adjustment the contractor believes the government owes, and that the certifier is authorized to certify. A delay analysis attached to the claim is part of those supporting data.
For a certified claim the contracting officer must, within 60 days, either issue a decision or tell the contractor when the decision will be issued. A failure to decide within the required time is deemed a denial, which the contractor can appeal. In BES the claim was received on October 1, 2015, and interest ran from that date.
How does IAE find a construction delay expert?
In the IAE request choose the case type Construction and name schedule delay analysis as the field. Within 5 business days IAE sends 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.
The construction expert witness page lists seven specialties, scheduling and cost estimating among them, for delays, cost disputes and claims on federal contracts. The request form asks for the field of expertise, the case type, the state and court, the firm's side, the expert disclosure deadline and the parties with their counsel. In the short description, state the type of project, whether the contract is federal or private, the forum, such as a federal court, the ASBCA or the CBCA, and the delay question: time extension, compensable days, concurrent delay or liquidated damages.
Within 1 business day IAE replies whether it can search in that field by that deadline. Candidate names and CVs come after the search fee of $2,000 per case is paid in advance. Each candidate confirms in writing that he or she has no ties to the parties or their counsel; on a construction project the list of parties can include the owner, the general contractor, subcontractors, the designer and the surety.
For each candidate the firm receives a CV, hourly rates, testimony in the last 4 years and publications in the last 10 years, the lists that Rule 26(a)(2)(B) requires. If no candidate fits, the second search is free, and if IAE finds no candidates, it refunds the fee. The expert bills the firm directly or through IAE under the agency option, for hours at the expert's rate plus $100 per hour, for fixed fees, minimum charges and surcharges plus 40%, and for expenses at cost, with the search fee credited to the first invoice. The expert's hourly rate never depends on the outcome of the case or on the content of testimony.
IAE is not a law firm. Case strategy and the decision to retain an expert stay with the attorney.
Sources
- FAR 52.242-14, Suspension of Work (acquisition.gov)
- FAR 52.249-10, Default (Fixed-Price Construction) (acquisition.gov)
- Appeal of BES Construction, LLC, ASBCA No. 60608 (October 23, 2019)
- Yates-Desbuild Joint Venture v. Department of State, CBCA 3350, 3672, 4658, 4659 (June 4, 2015)
- GAO schedule guide, Definitions of Total Float and Free Float
- GAO schedule guide, Total Float
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702, Testimony by Expert Witnesses (LII)
- Supreme Court of the United States, order amending the Federal Rules of Evidence (April 24, 2023)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26 (LII)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 34 (LII)
- 41 U.S.C. 7103, Decision by contracting officer (LII)
Read also
All articles
Spearin doctrine: when does the owner bear the cost of defective plans and specifications, and what does the contractor's expert have to prove?
Under the Spearin doctrine, an owner who gives the contractor plans and specifications impliedly warrants that work built to them will be adequate
Differing site conditions claim: what must the contractor prove, and which experts carry the proof?
A differing site conditions claim asks the owner to pay for ground the contract did not describe. On federal projects the clause is FAR 52.236-2
SB 800 construction defect claims in California: which standards apply, what comes before a lawsuit and what must the expert prove?
SB 800, enacted in 2002, governs construction defect claims against builders of new homes in California. Civil Code section 896 lists buildingExpert witnesses
Need an expert witness for your case?
Describe the question, the case type and the court. Within 5 business days you receive 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

