Expert witnesses
SB 800 construction defect claims in California: which standards apply, what comes before a lawsuit and what must the expert prove?
SB 800, enacted in 2002, governs construction defect claims against builders of new homes in California. Civil Code section 896 lists building standards with their own deadlines, a homeowner must give the builder notice and a chance to repair before suing, and the California Supreme Court held in McMillin (2018) that this process covers defect claims whether or not they caused property damage. The expert's task is to show which standard the home fails.

What is SB 800, and which homes does it cover?
A 2002 California law that added Civil Code sections 895 through 945.5. It sets standards for new residential construction, a prelitigation procedure that gives builders a chance to repair, and the remedies and defenses for defect claims.
SB 800 was chaptered on September 20, 2002. It added title 7 to part 2 of division 2 of the Civil Code, starting with definitions in section 895 and ending with affirmative defenses in section 945.5. As enacted, section 896 makes builders liable for construction and design deficiencies and limits claims to the listed standards. Subcontractors, suppliers, manufacturers and designers can also be liable in some situations.
Section 896 states that the title does not apply to or supersede other statutory or common law as to condominium conversions. The current text of section 896, last amended by Stats. 2012, ch. 770, keeps that rule and the standards described below.
In McMillin Albany LLC v. Superior Court, decided on January 18, 2018, the California Supreme Court described the Act as "a broad reform package that would substantially change existing law". The court quoted the Senate analysis on "the builder's absolute right to attempt a repair prior to a homeowner filing an action in court."
Which building standards does section 896 set?
Standards for water intrusion, structural performance, soils, fire protection, plumbing and sewer, electrical systems and a list of other components, several with their own time limits counted from the close of escrow.
Section 896(a), as enacted, addresses water. Doors, windows, patio and deck doors, roofs, decks and balconies, stucco and siding must not allow unintended water to pass. Foundations and slabs must not let water or vapor damage other components. Plumbing and sewer lines must not leak, and water from showers and tile must not get into the walls.
Section 896(b) addresses the structure. Foundations, load-bearing components and slabs must not contain significant cracks or significant vertical displacement and must not make the structure unsafe. They must meet the code criteria for corrosion resistance and for earthquake and wind loads in effect when the home was built. Section 896(c) addresses soils: soils and engineered retaining walls must not damage the structure or make it unsafe, and must not make land without a structure unusable for its represented purpose.
Section 896(d) through (f) adds fire protection, plumbing and sewer, and electrical standards. Section 897 covers the rest: the standards are meant to address every function or component of a structure, and an item not specifically addressed is still actionable if it causes damage.
Section 895 defines terms the standards use. A designed moisture barrier is one specified in the plans, contract documents or manufacturer recommendations; an actual moisture barrier is any installed component that works as a moisture barrier to some degree; unintended water is water that passes something built to stop it.
Which standards have their own deadlines?
Plumbing, sewer, electrical and hardscape claims have 4 years from close of escrow, noise between attached units 1 year from occupancy, irrigation and drainage 1 year, landscaping and dryer ducts 2 years, paint and stains 5 years.
Section 896 attaches specific periods to several items. In the current text, as in the 2002 text, plumbing and sewer claims and electrical claims must be brought within 4 years after close of escrow. Pathways, driveways, patios and similar hardscape have 4 years from close of escrow. Untreated steel fences have 4 years, untreated wood posts 2 years, paint and stains 5 years, landscaping survival 2 years and dryer ducts 2 years.
Two periods run from a different starting point or are shorter. Noise transmission between attached units has 1 year from the original occupancy of the adjacent unit. Irrigation and drainage have 1 year from close of escrow.
Over all of these sits the outer limit in section 941(a): an action must be brought within 10 years after substantial completion of the improvement. A claim on an item with its own shorter period must meet that shorter period as well.
For the expert the dates come first. Before inspecting, the expert collects the close of escrow date for each home, the occupancy dates for attached units and the date of substantial completion, so that each finding can be matched to its period.
What has to happen before the homeowner can sue?
Written notice to the builder under section 910, acknowledgment within 14 days, an inspection within 14 days after acknowledgment, an offer to repair within 30 days after the inspection, and repairs completed within 120 days if the offer is accepted.
Section 910 requires the claimant, before filing an action, to give the builder written notice by certified mail, overnight mail or personal delivery. The notice describes the claim in reasonable detail. The current text of section 910 gives the notice "the same force and effect as a notice of commencement of a legal proceeding."
The builder's steps follow on fixed clocks, given here as enacted in 2002; the 2025 code keeps the 14 and 40 days of section 916. Under section 912 the builder provides plans and related documents within 30 days of a written request. Under section 913 it acknowledges the claim in writing within 14 days. Section 916 sets the initial inspection within 14 days after acknowledgment, with any second inspection completed within 40 days of the first. Section 917 requires the builder's offer to repair within 30 days after the inspection.
The homeowner then has 30 days to authorize the repair under section 918. Section 919 provides for mediation limited to four hours within 15 days of a request. Section 921(b) says that every effort shall be made to complete the repair within 120 days. Section 926 bars the builder from requiring a release or waiver in exchange for repair work, and section 927 extends the statute of limitations to 100 days after the repair is completed.
Each step creates a record the expert later uses: the notice describing each defect, the builder's inspection findings and test results, the offer of repair with its scope, and the work actually done.
What did the California Supreme Court decide in McMillin?
That the Act's standards and prelitigation procedures apply to construction defect claims for new homes whether or not the defects caused property damage. Homeowners cannot avoid the process by pleading negligence or strict liability instead.
Carl and Sandra Van Tassel and several dozen other homeowners had bought 37 new single-family homes from McMillin Albany LLC, the developer and general contractor, after January 2003. They sued for negligence, strict product liability, breach of contract, breach of warranty and violation of section 896, alleging both property damage and economic loss. The case started in the Superior Court of Kern County.
McMillin asked the homeowners to stipulate to a stay so the parties could go through the Act's prelitigation process. The homeowners declined and dismissed their section 896 claim. McMillin moved for a stay under section 930(b). The trial court denied it, relying on Liberty Mutual; the Court of Appeal issued a writ for McMillin, and the Supreme Court affirmed.
The court held that "the Legislature intended the broader displacement": claims for defects in new residential construction must go through the Act, even when they are pleaded in negligence or strict liability. It quoted section 943(a): "Except as provided in this title, no other cause of action for a claim covered by" the title is allowed. The court disapproved Liberty Mutual and Burch to the extent they conflict. The Act leaves in place claims for breach of contract, fraud and personal injury, which the statute preserves.
What does the homeowner have to prove, and what does the expert show?
That the home fails a standard. Under section 942, as the court described it in McMillin, no further showing of causation or damages is required to prove a violation of a standard. The expert ties each finding to a standard.
The Act changes the shape of a defect case. A claimant proves that the home does not meet a listed standard; section 942 provides that no further showing of causation or damages is required to establish the violation. Damages are then measured under section 944.
The expert's report follows the statute's structure. For each finding it names the standard in section 896 (water, structure, soils, fire protection, plumbing, electrical or the listed components), the location, the evidence (photographs, test results, measurements) and the date the item became subject to its time limit. A crack in a slab, for example, is tested against the significant crack and significant vertical displacement standard of section 896(b), not against a general idea of good workmanship.
Items that the standards do not address are handled through section 897: they remain actionable if they cause damage. For those items the expert has to show the damage, because the shortcut in section 942 is tied to the listed standards.
Which damages can be recovered under the Act?
Section 944 lists them: the reasonable value of repairing violations, damage caused by the repair efforts, resulting damages, removal and replacement of improper repairs, relocation and storage, lost business income in some cases, and reasonable investigative costs.
As enacted, section 944 permits recovery of the reasonable value of repairing any violation of the standards, the reasonable cost of repairing damage caused by the repair efforts, the reasonable cost of repairing and rectifying damages that result when the home fails the standards, and the reasonable cost of removing and replacing an improper repair by the builder.
The list continues with reasonable relocation and storage expenses, lost business income if the home was the principal place of a business licensed to be operated from the home, reasonable investigative costs for each established violation, and other costs recoverable by contract or statute.
Investigative costs are on that list, which brings the expert's work into the damages claim. The expert's invoices for each established violation are part of the evidence, and the report is easier to use for that purpose when it separates the work by standard.
Which defenses can the builder raise, and how do they turn on expert evidence?
Section 945.5 lists them: acts of nature beyond the code design criteria, the homeowner's unreasonable failure to mitigate, failure to follow maintenance recommendations, alterations, wear and tear, misuse or neglect, the time limits, a release and a successful repair.
In the 2002 text, section 945.5 lets the builder avoid liability in whole or in part by proving one of the listed defenses. Several of them are technical. An act of nature counts only if it exceeded the design criteria of the code in effect when the home was built. A failure to follow maintenance recommendations requires showing what the recommendations were and that the homeowner did not follow them. Alterations, ordinary wear and tear, misuse, abuse or neglect each require evidence of what happened to the component after the sale.
Each of those defenses is answered with the same kind of evidence the claim uses: the condition of the component, the cause of the failure and the timeline. The builder's expert looks for maintenance lapses, later modifications and storm data; the homeowner's expert addresses them before the builder raises them.
The repair defense depends on the prelitigation record. If the builder repaired under the Act and the repair corrected the violation, that is a defense. The expert's inspection of the repaired work, compared with the original notice and the offer of repair, answers whether it did.
How does IAE find a construction expert for an SB 800 claim?
Choose the case type Construction and describe the homes, the county, the standards at issue and the stage of the prelitigation process. Within 5 business days IAE sends 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and testimony lists.
The IAE page on construction expert witnesses lists 7 specialties: structural engineering, geotechnical engineering, architecture, building envelope, MEP systems, cost estimating and scheduling. On that page envelope consultants water-test windows under ASTM E1105, MEP engineers check HVAC, electrical and plumbing systems, and cost estimators price the repair scope the engineers define. Those specialties line up with the water, structure, soils, plumbing and electrical standards of section 896.
The request asks for the field, the case type, the court, the firm's side and the expert disclosure deadline, and for the parties and their counsel for the conflict check. Privileged or sealed information stays out of the request. IAE replies whether it can search in that field by the deadline. The search costs $2,000 per case, paid in advance, and candidate names and CVs come after payment.
Each candidate confirms in writing that he or she has no ties to the parties or their counsel, and the candidate materials include testimony in the last 4 years and publications in the last 10 years. If none of the candidates fits, the second search is free. IAE is not a law firm: the notice, the response to the builder's offer and the decision to sue stay with the homeowner's attorney.
Sources
- SB 800 (2001-2002), chaptered bill text of September 20, 2002, adding Civil Code sections 895-945.5 (California Legislature, leginfo.ca.gov)
- McMillin Albany LLC v. Superior Court (Van Tassel), No. S229762 (Cal. Jan. 18, 2018), opinion (SCOCAL, Stanford Law School)
- California Civil Code section 896, current text with history (amended by Stats. 2012, ch. 770), reproduction (CounselStack)
- California Civil Code section 910, current text (California Public Law)
- California Civil Code section 941, current text (California Public Law)
- California Civil Code section 916, 2025 California Code (Justia)
Read also
All articles
Spearin doctrine: when does the owner bear the cost of defective plans and specifications, and what does the contractor's expert have to prove?
Under the Spearin doctrine, an owner who gives the contractor plans and specifications impliedly warrants that work built to them will be adequate
Differing site conditions claim: what must the contractor prove, and which experts carry the proof?
A differing site conditions claim asks the owner to pay for ground the contract did not describe. On federal projects the clause is FAR 52.236-2
Florida construction defect statute of repose: when does the 7-year period start, and what can still be filed?
In Florida an action founded on the design, planning or construction of an improvement to real property must be commenced within 7 years afterExpert witnesses
Need an expert witness for your case?
Describe the question, the case type and the court. Within 5 business days you receive 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

