Expert witnesses

Custom and practice expert witness in a contract dispute: what may an industry expert say about trade usage, and where does the court draw the line?

In a contract dispute, an industry expert can tell the court how a term is used in the trade and how businesses in that trade ordinarily perform. Under UCC 1-303 the existence and scope of a usage of trade must be proved as facts. The expert may not tell the jury what the contract means or whether it was breached: the Second Circuit held it error in 1977.

Two people from behind at a lumber counter, one passing a wood sample, a closed folder on the bench

What does a custom and practice expert testify about?

About facts of the trade: what a term means among people in that business, how a step is ordinarily performed, and whether a practice is regular enough that parties expect it. The expert does not interpret the contract.

Contract disputes often turn on words that have a trade meaning: delivery terms, tolerances, acceptance, a lease clause, a cost estimate class. A judge or a jury does not know that meaning from ordinary language. An expert who has worked in the trade can describe it.

The Second Circuit explained the basis in Marx & Co. v. Diners' Club, Inc., 550 F.2d 505, decided February 25, 1977: "Testimony concerning the ordinary practices of those engaged in the securities business is admissible under the same theory as testimony concerning the ordinary practices of physicians or concerning other trade customs." The purpose is "to enable the jury to evaluate the conduct of the parties against the standards of ordinary practice in the industry."

The same decision drew the limit. The court held that the district court "erred in permitting Friedman, an expert witness called by plaintiffs, to give his opinion as to the legal obligations of the parties under the contract."

How does the UCC define usage of trade?

As a practice observed so regularly in a place, vocation or trade that the parties can expect it to be observed in their transaction. Its existence and scope are proved as facts.

Section 1-303(c) of the Uniform Commercial Code describes a usage of trade by its "regularity of observance in a place, vocation, or trade as to justify an expectation" that it will be observed in the transaction in question. The same subsection states: "The existence and scope of such a usage must be proved as facts."

If the usage is embodied in a trade code or a similar record, the subsection assigns the interpretation of that record to the court: "the interpretation of the record is a question of law." An expert can prove that the code exists and that the trade follows it; what its words mean is then for the judge.

Section 1-303 also defines two related sources. A course of performance, under 1-303(a), is the parties' own conduct on "repeated occasions for performance" under the agreement, which the other party accepts or acquiesces in "without objection." A course of dealing, under 1-303(b), is a sequence of earlier transactions between the parties that is "fairly to be regarded as establishing a common basis of understanding." Both are proved from the parties' own records and correspondence.

Can trade usage evidence explain a written contract?

Yes, under UCC 2-202 for sales of goods, a final writing may be explained or supplemented by usage of trade. It may not be contradicted, and express terms prevail over usage when the two cannot be read together.

Section 2-202 provides that a final written expression of the parties' agreement "may not be contradicted by evidence of any prior agreement or of a contemporaneous oral agreement but may be explained or supplemented" by course of dealing or usage of trade, by course of performance, and by evidence of consistent additional terms unless the court finds the writing was a complete and exclusive statement of the terms.

Section 1-303(d) states what the evidence can do: a course of performance, course of dealing or usage of trade is relevant in determining the meaning of the agreement, may give particular meaning to specific terms, and may supplement or qualify those terms.

Section 1-303(e) sets the order when sources conflict. The express terms and the usage are construed as consistent with each other wherever reasonable. If that is unreasonable, "express terms prevail over course of performance, course of dealing, and usage of trade," course of performance prevails over course of dealing and usage, and course of dealing prevails over usage. A usage expert who testifies against a clear express term therefore starts in last place.

Does a party have to give notice before offering trade usage evidence?

Yes. Under UCC 1-303(g), evidence of a relevant usage of trade offered by one party is not admissible unless that party has given the other party notice that the court finds sufficient to prevent unfair surprise.

The text of 1-303(g) states that the evidence "is not admissible unless that party has given the other party notice" that the court finds sufficient to prevent unfair surprise to the other party. The rule is separate from the expert disclosure rules of civil procedure.

In federal court, a retained expert's report under Rule 26(a)(2)(B) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure contains a complete statement of all opinions and their basis, the facts or data considered and the exhibits. A report that describes the usage, its scope and the evidence of its regular observance puts the usage before the other party in writing; whether that notice is sufficient is decided by the court under 1-303(g).

For counsel, the practical step is to name the usage in the pleadings or the disclosures as early as the theory exists, and to make sure the expert report states it in the same words.

Where is the line between industry practice and contract interpretation?

The expert may describe the practice and the trade meaning of a term. The expert may not state what the parties' contract requires, whether it was breached or what the law is. Those are for the judge and the jury.

In Marx, the plaintiffs called Stanley Friedman, a lawyer qualified as an expert in securities regulation, as a rebuttal witness. The Second Circuit found him "competent to explain to the jury the step-by-step practices ordinarily followed by lawyers and corporations" in registering securities. His views on what the contract's best efforts covenant required were different: they "were rather legal opinions as to the meaning of the contract terms at issue."

The court stated the principle in one sentence: "It is not for witnesses to instruct the jury as to applicable principles of law, but for the judge."

Federal Rule of Evidence 704(a) does not remove this limit. It provides that "an opinion is not objectionable just because it embraces an ultimate issue." An expert can say that a delivery took 40 days when the trade standard is 10, which bears on the ultimate issue. The expert cannot say that the delay was a breach of the contract, which is the legal conclusion itself.

How did a federal court apply the line in a recent contract case?

In North Wind v. Campos EPC (D. Idaho 2023), the court let an engineer present cost estimating guidelines as a possible trade usage but barred him from calling them contract terms or finding a breach.

Chief Judge David C. Nye decided the motion in limine on July 18, 2023, in case No. 4:21-cv-00096-DCN. Campos submitted the expert report of an engineer, Myron Temchin, who addressed the cost estimating guidelines of AACE.

The court allowed Temchin to testify that the AACE guidelines are "a generic and generally acceptable classification system for process industries" and to offer them as a possible trade custom or usage to interpret the contract terms "professional quality" and "technical accuracy." Whether that custom was clearly proven, the court said, belongs in a jury instruction, not in a ruling on a motion in limine. The court cited Perkins v. Highland Enterprises, 817 P.2d 177, 182 (Idaho 1991): for a trade usage to resolve an ambiguity conclusively, it must be "clearly proven."

The court excluded any claim that the AACE guidelines were expressly incorporated into the agreement, any claim that they were binding standards that independently set the standard of care, and legal conclusions on whether Campos complied with or breached the contract. It quoted the Ninth Circuit in Nationwide Transport Finance v. Cass Information Systems, 523 F.3d 1051, 1058 (2008), that "an expert witness cannot give an opinion as to her legal conclusion." The written report itself was excluded as an exhibit, because written reports are "hearsay and duplicative of oral testimony," while Figure 2 and Table 5 from it were not excluded.

How does an expert prove that a custom exists?

With facts about regular observance: the expert's own experience in the trade, published standards and codes, forms in common use, and records of how comparable transactions were performed. The opinion states the scope of the usage.

Because 1-303(c) requires the existence and scope of a usage to be proved as facts, the expert's report sets out the facts. The first is the expert's experience: years, roles, companies and the number of transactions handled in which the practice applied.

The second is documentary. Published guidelines of a trade association, standard forms and model contracts, and written codes of practice show what the trade expects. The North Wind ruling marks the limit: a guideline can be evidence of a usage, but the expert may not present it as a binding standard or as a term of the parties' contract unless the contract incorporates it.

The third is scope. A usage may be regular in one region, one type of goods or one size of transaction and not in others. Section 1-303(c) speaks of regular observance "in a place, vocation, or trade." The report states where and among whom the practice is observed, so the court can decide whether the parties to the case belonged to that group.

What goes into the industry expert's report in federal court?

The six items of Rule 26(a)(2)(B): opinions with basis and reasons, facts or data considered, exhibits, qualifications with publications for 10 years, prior testimony for 4 years, and compensation.

Rule 26(a)(2)(B) requires "a complete statement of all opinions the witness will express and the basis and reasons for them", "the facts or data considered by the witness in forming them", any exhibits, the witness's qualifications "including a list of all publications authored in the previous 10 years", a list of cases in which the witness testified as an expert during the previous 4 years, and a statement of compensation.

Communications between counsel and the expert are protected under Rule 26(b)(4)(C), with three exceptions: those relating to compensation, those that identify facts or data that counsel provided and the expert considered, and those that identify assumptions that counsel provided and the expert relied on. An industry expert who was told by counsel how the contract should be read and then built an opinion on that reading has relied on an assumption the other side can discover.

Rule 702 requires the proponent to show the court that it is more likely than not that the testimony will help the trier of fact, rests on sufficient facts or data, comes from reliable principles and methods, and applies them reliably to the case. For a custom expert, sufficient facts are the facts of regular observance described above.

Who qualifies as a custom and practice expert?

A witness qualified by knowledge, skill, experience, training or education in the trade, under Rule 702. The qualification has to match the specific practice the expert describes.

Rule 702 lists five sources of qualification: "knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education." In Marx, the court found a securities lawyer competent to explain the practices followed in registering securities.

Qualification and subject must match. An engineer qualified on cost estimating practice may testify about estimating practice; the same engineer is not qualified by that experience to testify about how the contract allocates risk. In North Wind the court also allowed testimony on the standard of care of a professional engineer, compared with the facts, while barring the step to a conclusion that the standard was breached.

Counsel screens a candidate on three points before retention: years in the specific practice at issue, prior testimony in which a court limited or excluded the candidate's opinions, and any ties to the parties.

How does IAE find an industry expert for a commercial dispute?

In the request, choose the case type Commercial dispute and name the trade and the practice at issue. Within 5 business days IAE sends 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and testimony lists.

The IAE page on commercial litigation expert witnesses lists industry specialists among the specialties, together with damages, forensic accounting, business valuation, solvency, securities and insurance claims handling. The page notes that state courts apply their own rules on expert admissibility, so the request names the state, the court and the subject of the testimony.

The search is paid in advance. Within 5 business days the firm receives 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates, testimony in the last 4 years and publications in the last 10 years, and each candidate confirms in writing that he or she has no ties to the parties or their counsel. If no candidate fits, the second search is free.

The firm chooses the expert, who bills the firm directly or through IAE under the agency option, and the expert's hourly rate never depends on the outcome of the case or on the content of testimony. IAE is not a law firm: case strategy and the decision to retain an expert stay with the attorney, and neither IAE nor the expert guarantees the outcome of the case.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert witnesses

Need an expert witness for your case?

Describe the question, the case type and the court. Within 5 business days you receive 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

Expert request

Received

Candidates, rates and prior testimony within 5 business days

Candidates2-3 with CVs
Timeline5 business days
Search$2,000 per case