Expert witnesses

Purchase price adjustment dispute: who decides working capital, the independent accountant or the court?

A purchase price adjustment trues up the price for changes in working capital between signing and closing, and the agreement sends disputes over the closing statement to an independent accountant. When the buyer's objection is a claim that the seller's books broke GAAP, Delaware and New York courts have asked whether it belongs to the accountant or to the court, and the answer turned on the contract. Below are three decisions and the expert's work on each side.

An accountant from behind faces a closing binder while a gavel rests at the far end of the table

What is a purchase price adjustment dispute?

A dispute over the closing statement: the buyer and the seller compute net working capital or net assets at closing differently, and the difference changes the price under the agreement's adjustment clause.

In Westmoreland Coal Co. v. Entech, Inc., 100 N.Y.2d 352, decided by the New York Court of Appeals on July 1, 2003, the buyer acquired the stock of coal mining companies for $138 million, subject to adjustment based on a closing date certificate. The buyer could object to the certificate, and unresolved disputes went to an independent accountant whose determination was final and binding.

In Alliant Techsystems, Inc. v. MidOcean Bushnell Holdings, L.P., C.A. No. 9813-CB, decided by the Delaware Court of Chancery on April 24, 2015, the seller's estimate of closing net working capital was $192,407,000 and the buyer's was $166,447,000. In Chancellor Bouchard's words, "the net amount of the parties' dispute stands at approximately $22 million."

In Chicago Bridge & Iron Co. N.V. v. Westinghouse Electric Co., No. 573, 2016, decided by the Delaware Supreme Court on June 27, 2017, "the purchase price to be paid at closing by Westinghouse was set in the contract at zero," subject to the True Up. Based on Westinghouse's calculation, "Chicago Bridge owed Westinghouse over $2 billion."

In each case the figure at stake depended on a threshold question: may the disputed items go through the adjustment procedure at all?

Who decides the dispute: the independent accountant or the court?

The contract decides. Courts read the adjustment clause together with the indemnification and liability provisions, and send to the accountant only the disputes the parties assigned to that procedure.

In Westmoreland, the Court of Appeals reversed and held that the buyer's objections that asset values violated GAAP were claims for breach of representation or warranty. They "unambiguously fall within the Agreement's indemnification provisions, not its purchase price adjustment provisions," and "these claims may only be pursued in a court of law." The case was remitted for the trial court to evaluate each objection.

In Alliant, the Court of Chancery reached the opposite result on a different contract. Section 9.5 made indemnification the exclusive remedy, but Proviso (y) provided that nothing in that sentence would "interfere with or impede the operation of the provisions of Section 2.4," the adjustment procedure. The court read that proviso as creating a hierarchy: "Read in that context, Section 9.5 establishes a hierarchy for resolving disputes in the event of an overlap." The net working capital dispute went to the Accounting Firm under Section 2.4, and the court granted the buyer's motion for judgment on the pleadings seeking specific performance.

In Chicago Bridge, the Delaware Supreme Court read the agreement as a whole and held that the True Up could not be used to bring claims the Liability Bar excluded. Chief Justice Strine wrote that the Court of Chancery's reading "rendered meaningless the Purchase Agreement's Liability Bar," under which the seller had "no liability for monetary damages after the Closing."

The three decisions apply one method to different texts: the court reads the adjustment clause in the context of the whole agreement and asks which remedy the parties chose for which kind of dispute.

Can the buyer challenge the seller's GAAP compliance through the adjustment?

Under the Westmoreland and Chicago Bridge agreements, no: those challenges were warranty or liability claims. Under the Alliant agreement, yes, because the net working capital definition itself required GAAP compliance.

In Westmoreland the closing certificate had to use accounting methods consistent with the interim financial statements, and the seller had warranted that those statements complied with GAAP. The court reasoned that letting the buyer use the adjustment to challenge GAAP compliance would bypass the agreement's exclusive remedy, its waiver and its $1.75 million threshold on indemnification claims.

In Chicago Bridge the court described the True Up as addressing changes in working capital between signing and closing, measured with the same accounting principles and past practices the seller had used for its represented financial statements. Allowing Westinghouse to attack the seller's historical GAAP compliance through the True Up would have made the Liability Bar meaningless. The court directed that GAAP-based challenges to the historical financials could not be heard by the Independent Auditor, and left open changes in facts or circumstances between signing and closing.

In Alliant the definition of net working capital required GAAP compliance, so the court held that "the present dispute over the calculation of net working capital fairly may be raised" in the Section 2.4 procedure, including the buyer's GAAP objections.

For counsel, the question is textual: how the agreement defines working capital or net assets, which accounting principles the closing statement must follow, and what the indemnification and liability provisions exclude. An accounting expert's work starts after counsel has answered it.

What is the independent accountant's role under the agreement?

In Chicago Bridge, an expert rather than an arbitrator: the Independent Auditor decided a narrow set of disputes on written submissions and "did not have a wide-ranging brief to adjudicate all disputes."

The Delaware Supreme Court in Chicago Bridge called the True Up "an important, but narrow, subordinate, and cabined remedy." The Independent Auditor acted as an expert rather than an arbitrator, decided only the disputes the clause assigned to it and relied solely on written submissions. "Thus, the Independent Auditor did not have a wide-ranging brief to adjudicate all disputes."

In Westmoreland the Court of Appeals weighed what the parties would have intended. The buyer, an experienced coal company, had the chance to examine the companies' accounting before the purchase, and the court wrote that the parties "surely could not have intended to consign a significant portion of the purchase price to ADR".

The mandate defines what a party's accounting submission must do. Before the independent accountant, the submission addresses the items in dispute under the agreement's accounting principles and past practice. A submission that argues the historical statements were wrong, under an agreement like the one in Chicago Bridge, invites a motion to stop the proceeding.

Where does an accounting expert witness work in these disputes?

In two places: in the adjustment procedure, preparing the written submission on the disputed items, and in court, on indemnification or breach claims that the contract keeps out of the accountant's mandate.

In the adjustment procedure the expert recomputes each disputed line of the closing statement under the agreement's accounting principles and the seller's past practice, and ties each figure to the ledgers, the reconciliations and the interim statements. In Chicago Bridge the measure was the same accounting principles and past practices used for the represented financial statements; an expert submission on that clause compares the closing balance with that baseline, item by item.

In court, the expert testifies on the claims the contract assigns to litigation. In Westmoreland those were the GAAP objections that the Court of Appeals held belonged to the indemnification provisions; on remittal the trial court had to evaluate each objection. Testimony on those claims is subject to the court's rules on expert evidence.

In federal court, Federal Rule of Evidence 702, as amended December 1, 2023, requires the proponent to show the court that it is more likely than not that the testimony rests on sufficient facts or data, is the product of reliable principles and methods, and that the expert's opinion applies those principles and methods reliably to the facts of the case. A retained expert's written report under Rule 26(a)(2)(B) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure contains the opinions with their basis and reasons, the facts or data considered, exhibits, qualifications including publications in the previous 10 years, a list of cases with testimony in the previous 4 years, and the compensation.

The same expert can serve on both tracks if the case moves between them, but the mandate differs: before the accountant, the submission stays within the adjustment clause; in court, the opinion answers the claim pleaded.

How does IAE find an accounting expert for a purchase price adjustment dispute?

In the request, choose the case type Commercial dispute and name the calculation: the closing working capital or net assets under the agreement. Within 5 business days IAE sends 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and testimony lists.

The IAE page on commercial litigation expert witnesses lists forensic accountants and business appraisers among the specialties, and the page notes that state courts apply their own rules on expert admissibility, so the request names the state, the court and the type of calculation.

The search is paid in advance. Within 5 business days the firm receives 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates, testimony in the last 4 years and publications in the last 10 years, and each candidate confirms in writing that he or she has no ties to the parties or their counsel. If no candidate fits, the second search is free.

The firm chooses the expert, who bills the firm directly or through IAE under the agency option, and the expert's hourly rate never depends on the outcome of the case or on the content of testimony. IAE is not a law firm: case strategy and the decision to retain an expert stay with the attorney, and neither IAE nor the expert guarantees the outcome of the case.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert witnesses

Need an expert witness for your case?

Describe the question, the case type and the court. Within 5 business days you receive 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

Expert request

Received

Candidates, rates and prior testimony within 5 business days

Candidates2-3 with CVs
Timeline5 business days
Search$2,000 per case