Expert witnesses
How do you prove lost profits with reasonable certainty, including for a new business?
Lost profits are recoverable when the plaintiff proves that the breach caused them and proves the amount with reasonable certainty, not with mathematical precision. New York adds that the damages must have been within the contemplation of the parties and holds a new business to a stricter standard. Texas requires objective facts, figures or data. Florida lets a new business recover if a yardstick exists. Courts in each state have admitted some damages experts' models and excluded others.

What does reasonable certainty mean for lost profits?
The amount must be shown by competent evidence, not guessed. Texas does not require exact calculation but requires estimates based on objective facts, figures or data; New York bars damages that are merely speculative, possible or imaginary.
The Supreme Court of Texas stated the rule in Holt Atherton Industries, Inc. v. Heine, 835 S.W.2d 80, decided on June 17, 1992 in an opinion by Justice Cook. "Recovery for lost profits does not require that the loss be susceptible of exact calculation." But "the injured party must do more than show that they suffered some lost profits," and "the amount of the loss must be shown by competent evidence with reasonable certainty." The court added: "As a minimum, opinions or estimates of lost profits must be based on objective facts, figures, or data from which the amount of lost profits can be ascertained."
New York's Court of Appeals put the same idea negatively in Kenford Co. v. County of Erie, 67 N.Y.2d 257 (1986): "the damages may not be merely speculative, possible or imaginary." The measure is net profit. In a footnote in Holt Atherton the Texas court took up the defendant's argument that "the correct measure of damages is lost net profit, not gross profits," and read the award as based on the amount left after expenses.
Reasonable certainty applies to the amount, but the fact of damage must also be proved. In Kenford the court listed causation first and required certainty "that such damages have been caused by the breach." A plaintiff that cannot connect the loss to the breach loses before the amount is reached.
For counsel the practical meaning is a test of the record. Can the damages figure be traced, step by step, to documents the other side can check: tax returns, ledgers, contracts lost, market data? If the answer is yes for every step, the claim has a chance. If any step is the owner's estimate without a source, that step is where the defense will attack.
What did Kenford v. County of Erie decide?
That 20 years of projected profits from a domed stadium near Buffalo were not recoverable. The proof was massive, but it rested on assumptions, and the parties had not contemplated liability for such profits.
Erie County contracted with Kenford Company and Dome Stadium, Inc. (DSI) to build a domed stadium near Buffalo, and the contract included a 20-year management contract for DSI. When the county breached, DSI claimed the profits it would have earned over those 20 years. Its experts projected them from data on other domed stadiums and from a marketing study of the Buffalo area. The trial ended in a multimillion dollar jury verdict.
The Court of Appeals, in a per curiam opinion decided on May 6, 1986, restated three requirements for recovering loss of future profits: certainty "that such damages have been caused by the breach"; "the alleged loss must be capable of proof with reasonable certainty"; and "the particular damages were fairly within the contemplation of the parties" when they contracted.
The court described the proof as "massive." It still affirmed the Appellate Division's order setting aside the lost profits award. At the time of the breach "there was only one other facility in this country to use as a basis of comparison, the Astrodome in Houston," and the projections rested on assumptions that "require speculation and conjecture." The court also found no proof that liability for 20 years of lost profits was within the parties' contemplation.
Kenford rejected a looser "rational basis" test drawn from Perma Research & Development Co. v. Singer Co. and reaffirmed Cramer v. Grand Rapids Show Case Co. The First Department applied the same three requirements in Wathne 26 years later.
Can a new business recover lost profits?
In New York, rarely: Kenford imposes a stricter standard. In Florida, yes, if the business proves causation and a standard, such as a yardstick, by which the amount can be adequately determined.
Kenford states the New York rule in one sentence: "If it is a new business seeking to recover for loss of future profits, a stricter standard is imposed." In Wathne Imports, Ltd. v. PRL USA, Inc., 101 A.D.3d 83, decided on October 18, 2012, the Appellate Division, First Department, observed that it had dismissed lost profits claims on summary judgment where the business was a "new business endeavor" with no track record, or was in the "development stage" and "had never generated any revenue."
Florida took a different path. The Florida Supreme Court decided W.W. Gay Mechanical Contractor, Inc. v. Wharfside Two, Ltd., 545 So. 2d 1348, in 1989. As a Florida District Court of Appeal quoted it in Halliburton Co. v. Eastern Cement Corp., 672 So. 2d 844 (May 13, 1996): "A business can recover lost prospective profits regardless of whether it is established or has any 'track record.'" The party "must prove that 1) the defendant's action caused the damage and 2) there is some standard by which the amount of damages may be adequately determined." Gay quoted an earlier decision: "if there is a 'yardstick' by which prospective profits can be measured, they will be allowed if proven."
Halliburton marks the limit of the Florida rule. The buyer, Eastern Cement, claimed among its damages profits from a future containerized cargo business. The court affirmed liability but reversed the damages award, directed the trial judge to strike the future-business profits as too speculative in their causal link to the defect, and remanded for judgment of $928,000 in direct consequential damages that the seller had conceded.
For a new business, then, the expert's task is to find the yardstick: comparable businesses, comparable products, the experience of the people running the venture, signed contracts. The weaker the record of the plaintiff itself, the more the claim depends on the quality of that comparison.
What evidence of lost profits did the Texas Supreme Court find insufficient?
An owner's lump-sum figure without a calculation. In Holt Atherton the court reversed a lost profits award to the owners of a bulldozer business because the testimony gave pieces of several methods but no complete calculation.
The Heines ran a business with bulldozers; the dissent describes two D-8 Caterpillar bulldozers and land clearing contracts. Holt Atherton took one bulldozer in under an alleged oral warranty and kept it for eight months before starting repairs. In the majority's reading, Mr. Heine's testimony to $200,200 in lost income was a single question and answer that gave no indication of how the figure was reached. The dissent read the record differently.
Questioned by the trial judge, the Heines referred to about $120,000 in profit on their tax returns, to the two bulldozers operating about half-time in 1985 and to several lost contracts. Mr. Heine could not identify the contracts, their number, their profit or who would have awarded them. The trial court awarded $120,000.
The Supreme Court of Texas held the evidence legally insufficient. The testimony offered parts of several methods without completing any of them, and it did not show lost profits for the whole thirteen-month period of the claim. The court reversed and remanded for a new trial on lost profits. Justice Doggett, joined by Justice Mauzy, concurred in affirming liability and dissented on lost profits.
The case is a checklist for any lost profits claim. A figure needs a method; a method needs inputs; each input needs a document. Tax returns, a fleet's utilization records and the identity of each lost contract were the facts, figures and data the court found missing.
Must the parties have contemplated lost profits when they made the contract?
In New York, yes: Kenford requires that the damages were fairly within the parties' contemplation. In sales of goods, UCC 2-715(2)(a) limits consequential damages to needs the seller had reason to know of at contracting.
Kenford turned in part on this requirement. The court found no proof that liability for 20 years of lost profits from the stadium was within the parties' contemplation when they contracted or when the breach occurred. The Appellate Division in Wathne restated the same element: the damages must be "fairly within the contemplation of the parties."
For the sale of goods, Article 2 of the Uniform Commercial Code states a parallel rule. Section 2-715(2)(a) defines a buyer's consequential damages as "any loss resulting from general or particular requirements and needs of which the seller at the time of contracting had reason to know and which could not reasonably be prevented by cover or otherwise."
This element concerns the contract and its negotiation as much as the numbers. The damages expert does not decide it, but the expert's report should not assume it either. Counsel gathers the evidence of what the defendant knew, and the expert measures only the categories of loss counsel says the law permits.
How does a damages expert meet the reasonable certainty standard, and when do courts exclude the expert?
With a method tied to the plaintiff's own data or a tested comparable. Courts excluded a forensic accountant's estimate whose market data was not shown comparable, and admitted models built on comparable products and market share.
In Everett Financial, Inc. v. Primary Residential Mortgage, Inc., No. 3:14-CV-1028 (N.D. Tex.), Judge Sidney A. Fitzwater ruled on December 19, 2016 on a forensic accountant, Jeffrey Matthews, who estimated 2014 lost profits for 19 mortgage branches after their managers left. He started from each branch's 2013 loan volume, projected growth from third-party RealtyTrac loan-count data for the branches' counties, subtracted actual 2014 volume and converted the shortfall to profit with historical coefficients. Six branches sat in counties without RealtyTrac data and were estimated from averages.
The court struck the testimony under Rule 702 and Daubert. The yardstick method requires "a reasonable similarity between the plaintiff's business and the business to which it is being compared," and the proponent had not shown that the county market data represented businesses similar in size, market or costs. Matthews' own validation produced a gap the court called "not an acceptable rate of error."
Wathne went the other way. The First Department reversed an order that had barred the plaintiff's expert from using Coach handbag sales as a growth comparable and from testifying about international sales. A degree of uncertainty is expected, the court held, and "the jury must decide whether or not his methodology was appropriate." It noted that federal courts exclude expert testimony as speculative "if it is based on unrealistic assumptions" about a party's prospects.
In Innovation Ventures, L.L.C. v. Custom Nutrition Laboratories, L.L.C., No. 4:12-cv-13850 (E.D. Mich.), Judge Terrence G. Berg denied on February 16, 2021 the defendants' motion to exclude the plaintiff's damages expert, Rodney Crawford, who offered market-share lost profits. The court found the challenges to his data, assumptions and omissions went to weight and left them for cross-examination; it also rejected the plaintiff's challenge to the defendants' rebuttal expert, Dr. Christopher Pflaum. The court quoted the Sixth Circuit: "Defendants may then submit rebuttal evidence concerning the weaknesses of this specific calculation."
Who decides whether lost profits are reasonably certain: the judge or the jury?
Both, at different stages. The judge decides under Rule 702 whether the expert's opinion is admissible; the jury weighs it; and an appellate court can hold the evidence legally insufficient, as in Holt Atherton.
Under Federal Rule of Evidence 702, a qualified expert may testify only if the proponent establishes to the court that it is more likely than not that the testimony will help the trier of fact, rests on sufficient facts or data, is the product of reliable principles and methods, and applies them reliably to the facts of the case. Everett Financial ended at this gate.
Once the opinion is admitted, its weaknesses go to the jury. Wathne and Innovation Ventures both left disputes over comparables and assumptions to cross-examination and contrary evidence.
After the verdict, the reasonable certainty rule returns as a question of law. In Kenford the Court of Appeals affirmed the setting aside of a jury verdict; in Holt Atherton the Supreme Court of Texas found the evidence legally insufficient and ordered a new trial. In both cases a plaintiff that had won at trial lost the lost profits award after it.
The report sets the record for all three stages. Rule 26(a)(2)(B) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure requires a complete statement of all opinions and the basis and reasons for them, and the facts or data considered. A report that shows every input and its source gives the judge the basis for admission and the appellate court the objective facts, figures and data Holt Atherton asks for.
How does IAE find a damages expert for a lost profits claim?
In the request, choose the case type Commercial dispute and name the calculation: lost profits, and whether the business is new or established. Within 5 business days IAE sends 2-3 candidates with CVs, rates and testimony lists.
The IAE page on commercial litigation expert witnesses lists damages economists among the specialties, with work such as a seller's lost profits under UCC 2-708(2) and a buyer's consequential damages under 2-715(2)(a). The page notes that state courts apply their own rules on expert admissibility and asks firms to name the state, the court and the type of calculation.
The search costs $2,000 per case, paid in advance. Within 1 business day IAE replies whether it can search in that field by the firm's deadline. Within 5 business days the firm receives 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates, testimony in the last 4 years and publications in the last 10 years, and each candidate confirms in writing that he or she has no ties to the parties or their counsel.
If no candidate fits, the second search is free. The firm chooses the expert, who bills the firm directly or through IAE under the agency option, and the expert's hourly rate never depends on the outcome of the case or on the content of testimony. IAE is not a law firm: case strategy and the decision to retain an expert stay with the attorney.
Sources
- Kenford Co. v. County of Erie, 67 N.Y.2d 257 (N.Y. 1986), text of the decision (hallapproved.com)
- Holt Atherton Industries, Inc. v. Heine, 835 S.W.2d 80 (Tex. 1992), text of the decision (hallapproved.com)
- Halliburton Co. v. Eastern Cement Corp., 672 So. 2d 844 (Fla. Dist. Ct. App. 1996), quoting W.W. Gay Mechanical Contractor, Inc. v. Wharfside Two, Ltd., 545 So. 2d 1348 (Fla. 1989) (syfert.com)
- Wathne Imports, Ltd. v. PRL USA, Inc., 101 A.D.3d 83, 2012 NY Slip Op 07045 (1st Dep't Oct. 18, 2012) (New York State Law Reporting Bureau)
- Uniform Commercial Code, section 2-715, Buyer's Incidental and Consequential Damages (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Everett Financial, Inc. v. Primary Residential Mortgage, Inc., No. 3:14-CV-1028-D, Document 190 (N.D. Tex. Dec. 19, 2016) (Justia)
- Innovation Ventures, L.L.C. v. Custom Nutrition Laboratories, L.L.C., No. 4:12-cv-13850, Document 446 (E.D. Mich. Feb. 16, 2021) (Justia)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702, Testimony by Expert Witnesses (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26, Duty to Disclose; General Provisions Governing Discovery (LII, Cornell Law School)
Read also
All articles
Banking expert witness in a wire transfer fraud case: what makes a security procedure commercially reasonable under UCC 4A-202?
When a fraudster moves money out of a business account by wire, UCC Article 4A decides who absorbs the loss: the bank or its customer. The bank keeps
Custom and practice expert witness in a contract dispute: what may an industry expert say about trade usage, and where does the court draw the line?
In a contract dispute, an industry expert can tell the court how a term is used in the trade and how businesses in that trade ordinarily perform
Purchase price adjustment dispute: who decides working capital, the independent accountant or the court?
A purchase price adjustment trues up the price for changes in working capital between signing and closing, and the agreement sends disputes overExpert witnesses
Need an expert witness for your case?
Describe the question, the case type and the court. Within 5 business days you receive 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

