Examinations

Diminished value damages for breach of warranty: how is the value of defective goods proved?

When a buyer keeps defective goods, warranty damages are the difference, at the time and place of acceptance, between the value of the goods accepted and the value they would have had as warranted. The price paid usually proves the second figure. The first needs its own evidence: in 2018 a Florida appeals court reduced a $15,000 jury award to nominal damages because no one valued the defective car.

A buyer from behind compares a scratched item with an intact one on a linen counter

How are damages measured when the buyer keeps defective goods?

By the difference, at the time and place of acceptance, between the value of the goods accepted and their value as warranted, unless special circumstances show proximate damages of a different amount. The buyer proves both values.

The rule is section 2-714(2) of the Uniform Commercial Code, enacted in each state under its own number. Florida's version, section 672.714(2), is quoted in full in Kia Motors America, Inc. v. Doughty: "The measure of damages for breach of warranty is the difference at the time and place of acceptance between the value of the goods accepted and the value they would have had if they had been as warranted unless special circumstances show proximate damages of a different amount."

North Carolina applies the same text as G.S. 25-2-714. In Williams v. Hyatt Chrysler-Plymouth, Inc., decided on August 19, 1980, the Court of Appeals added: "The buyer bears the burden of proving that difference in value." Chrysler's limited warranty excluded consequential damages, such as loss of use of the vehicle. It did not say that repair was the exclusive remedy, so the court held that the other remedies of the Code remained available.

The formula applies to goods the buyer has accepted. In Williams the buyer knew within a day that the vibration remained and kept driving, so the court treated the vehicle as accepted and the claim as one for the difference in value. The Kia jury awarded nothing for incidental or consequential damages, and the buyers did not cross-appeal that finding.

Which two values must the buyer prove, and what proves each?

The value as warranted and the actual value of the defective goods when accepted. In the Florida case both sides agreed that the purchase price proved the first value. Nothing in the record proved the second.

In Kia the buyers paid $25,676.50 for a new 2012 Kia Optima hybrid in April 2013, or $21,867 after rebates. The Second District Court of Appeal recorded the parties' agreement that by proving the price they paid, the buyers presented sufficient evidence of the value of the car as warranted at the time and place of acceptance.

The second figure is harder. The value of the goods accepted is the value of the defective item at the time and place of acceptance. That figure does not appear on any invoice. In Kia and in the Alabama house case below, the buyers offered no evidence of it.

An Alabama court applied the same two-value rule to a house in Hubbard Bros. Construction Co. v. Brackner, decided November 5, 1980. The buyers proved what the house would have been worth if built as warranted, roughly the $43,500 contract price. They offered no evidence of its value with the leaks and cracks. The court held that the $7,000 verdict "was based upon mere speculation and conjecture and cannot stand", reversed it and ordered a new trial.

Why did the Florida court reverse a $15,000 diminished value verdict?

Because no evidence fixed the value of the car with its defects when the buyers received it. A dealer's refusal to take the car in trade and a failed $5,000 private sale years later proved nothing about that value.

The Kia hybrid carried a limited warranty for six years or 60,000 miles. Starting in early to mid 2014 it showed a check engine light and a "hybrid system failure" warning, its transmission ground and it lost power. Repeated repairs failed, and twice its wheels locked up and the car skidded off the road. The buyers sued under the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act for breach of express warranty, and the jury awarded $15,000 for diminished value and nothing for incidental or consequential damages.

Judge Salario wrote for the court on March 14, 2018, in case No. 2D16-3861. The buyers had offered two facts about value: a Kia dealer would not take the car in trade, and a private buyer could not be found at $5,000. Neither fact, the court held, "would permit a jury to determine what the value of the car was" when the buyers received it from Kia. Any such inference "would be nothing but speculation, which is an impermissible basis for an award of damages." Quoting an earlier decision, Swindell v. Crowson, the court added: "Damages cannot be based on speculation, conjecture or guesswork."

The court affirmed the finding of breach and reversed the damages award, with instructions to enter judgment for nominal damages. It limited the holding to the record: "We hold only that in this case, Mr. Doughty and Ms. Dziewiecien failed to produce any evidence to prove that value."

Is an expert witness required to prove diminished value?

Not as a rule. The Florida court said that no particular type of evidence is necessary, and an Illinois court held that lay witnesses with sufficient knowledge may testify to value. Some competent evidence of the defective value is required.

In Kia the court wrote that it was not holding that expert testimony, or any other particular type of evidence, is necessary. It also noted that the buyers "did not present an expert witness to testify as to that subject," and that Mr. Doughty "was never asked his opinion as to the value of the car in its defective condition." When his lawyer asked about research he had done on the car's value, an objection was sustained, and he did not make a proffer of what he would have said.

The Illinois Appellate Court decided Shoop v. DaimlerChrysler Corp., reported at 371 Ill. App. 3d 1058, on two affidavits. Thomas Walters used Kelly Blue Book values and his professional experience and estimated the diminution in value of the buyer's truck at 35 percent. Joseph Pennacchio reviewed the repair records and valued the truck at $22,300 at purchase. The court wrote: "Even lay witnesses are permitted to testify as to the value of property," and "Both of these witnesses were experienced in the inspection or appraisal of vehicles."

Can the owner testify to what the defective goods were worth?

Yes, in North Carolina, if the owner knows the goods well. The Court of Appeals held in 1980 that excluding a buyer's opinion of about $2,500 for his vibrating Dodge Ramcharger was error. The Florida court left the question open.

The buyer in Williams paid $6,372.00 for a 1976 Dodge Ramcharger on August 26, 1976. The vehicle vibrated so hard that it shook the steering column and seats, and once the gearshift broke off its mount. He took the vehicle back to the selling dealer many times and to a dealer recommended by Chrysler eight times. Chrysler's representative first blamed the tires and later called the shake a characteristic of Ramchargers. The vibration was eliminated in November 1978, about 26 months after the sale.

The trial court excluded the buyer's opinion that the vehicle was worth about $2,500 when he accepted it. The Court of Appeals held that his account of the vibration and of roughly 40,000 miles of driving was enough: "This testimony furnished an ample foundation upon which his opinion as to value could be based." The opinion "was competent evidence of the fair market value of the vehicle in its condition at the time of acceptance", and its weight was for the trier of fact.

The trial court had awarded $23.84 against the dealer, $1.00 in nominal damages and $22.84 in consequential damages, and nothing against Chrysler. The Court of Appeals vacated the judgment and sent the case back for a new trial. In Kia the Florida court cited the general principle that an owner is qualified to testify to the value of his property, but expressed no opinion on whether Mr. Doughty could have done so.

Does a later trade-in or resale price fix the damages?

No. Value is measured at acceptance, not at resale. In Shoop the buyer traded his truck for $16,500, above the average NADA trade-in value of $14,425, and the Illinois court still reversed the summary judgment against him.

The buyer in Shoop paid $28,000 for a 2002 Dodge Dakota on April 4, 2002, under a limited warranty for three years or 36,000 miles. Defects in the engine, suspension, steering and transmission took the truck to a dealer 12 times in 18 months, and one defect came back at least five times without being fixed. On May 6, 2005, with more than 39,000 miles, he traded it in for $16,500. The NADA guide listed an average trade-in value of $14,425 and an average retail value of $17,225.

The trial court granted summary judgment to DaimlerChrysler: the buyer had received more than fair market value, so he had no present injury. The Appellate Court reversed. Under section 2-714(2) damages are measured at the time and place of acceptance, not at resale or trade-in. "The diminished value of a product is a compensable injury in a breach of warranty claim," the court wrote. A resale price is evidence of value but not conclusive, and resale profits are deducted to prevent a windfall.

The Florida court reasoned the same way about later events. A dealer's refusal and a failed sale more than two years after delivery said nothing about the value on the day of acceptance.

When do courts use the cost of repair instead of the loss in value?

As evidence, within limits. Alabama courts admit repair costs only as an aid to fixing the diminished value, and a Missouri court held that repair cost was the correct measure when it was lower than the loss in value.

In Kaiser Pools v. Cantwell, decided by the Alabama Court of Civil Appeals on March 24, 2000, a pool builder sued for the unpaid $1,862 of a $17,692 contract, and the owner counterclaimed for breach of warranty. The circuit court awarded the owner $5,000. The appellate court applied the diminished value measure, "the difference between the market value of the pool as completed and the market value of the pool as warranted." Repair costs may be admitted, "but only as an aid to determining the diminished value."

The owner's evidence was a damaged $1,200 ladder and an estimate of about $2,000 to replace sod. There "was no testimony as to the current value of the pool", and his family had used the pool after it was built. The court reversed the $5,000 judgment and remanded the case.

Farning v. Brendal, decided by the Missouri Court of Appeals on December 14, 2004, concerned vinyl flooring installed for $2,468.26 that bubbled within weeks. The manufacturer traced the problem to the wrong adhesive and supplied new flooring free, and another installer charged $1,311.55. The trial court awarded $3,779.81, the contract price plus the new installation. The appellate court called that a windfall and cut the award to $1,311.55: "The cost of repair was less than the diminution in value and was, therefore, the correct measure of damages." Neither opinion cites the Uniform Commercial Code: Kaiser Pools concerned the construction of a pool and Farning a flooring installation. Both courts compared the loss in value with the cost of repair.

What if the seller fixes the defect after the buyer accepted the goods?

The value the repair added can be offset against the damages. In Williams the court held that the defendants carry the burden of proving that amount, computed from depreciated values with and without the defect on the repair date.

The Ramcharger's vibration was cured in November 1978, after about 26 months of use. The North Carolina court held that, if a breach is found, the defendants may offset the value that the eventual repair added to the vehicle. The burden of proving the offset is theirs.

The court described the computation: compare the depreciated value of the vehicle with the defect and its depreciated value without it, both as of the date of the repair. The result reduces the difference in value measured at acceptance. The calculation needs two more values, on a later date, and the same kind of evidence as the first two.

How certain must the damages figure be?

Reasonably certain, not mathematically exact. The Illinois court said damages based on conjecture or speculation are precluded, and Florida and Alabama courts reversed awards that rested on speculation about the defective value.

Shoop states both halves of the rule. "It is not necessary that damages for breach of warranty be calculated with mathematical precision," the court wrote, but "basic contract theory requires that damages be proved with reasonable certainty" and "Damages based on conjecture or speculation are precluded." The buyer in Shoop got past summary judgment because two experienced witnesses gave figures for value at acceptance.

In Hubbard Bros. the buyers relied on a rule that relaxes the proof of damages when the defendant's wrong has made them hard to show. The court held that the rule applies when the defendant's conduct has made proof impossible or unreasonably difficult, and the buyers had not shown that.

What does IAE do when a warranty case turns on the value of the goods?

An IAE expert sets both values of UCC 2-714(2), as accepted and as warranted, at the time and place of acceptance, in a report on your questions or a review of the opposing report, within 5 business days.

For warranty and supply disputes in US courts, IAE prepares an expert report on the client's questions or a review of the opposing expert's report. The service page lists three questions: whether the goods were defective when delivered, whether the failure came from manufacturing or from misuse, and what the goods were worth as accepted. On value, the expert sets both figures of section 2-714(2) at the time and place of acceptance. On the defect, the expert tests the item against the merchantability rule of UCC 2-314 and the contract description and reads fracture surfaces, wear and repair marks.

The client describes the task through the Request a quote button on the service page and names the goods, the defect, the purchase and delivery dates and what is attached: the contract or bill of sale, repair orders, photographs, any appraisal and any report by the other side's expert. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. Cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush. Under Rule 26(a)(2)(B) a retained expert's report states all opinions with their basis and reasons and the facts or data considered.

Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome, and materials are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. The court weighs the report with the rest of the record. Neither IAE nor the expert guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert examinations

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member