Profile audit
Published material about you in EB-1A: which articles does USCIS count?
An article counts for the EB-1A published material criterion when it is about the applicant and the applicant's work, appears in a professional or major trade publication or other major media, and shows its title, date and author. Chapter 2 of the USCIS Policy Manual excludes marketing materials and paid content. AAO decisions of 2010-2024 rejected press releases, passing mentions and quotes, and accepted coverage of a petitioner's own study.

What does the published material criterion require?
Three things. The material is about the applicant and the applicant's work in the field, it appears in a professional or major trade publication or other major media, and it shows its title, date and author.
The criterion is item (iii) of 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3). The AAO decision of October 5, 2023 quotes it: "Published material about the alien in professional or major trade publications or other major media, relating to the alien's work in the field for which classification is sought." Chapter 2 of the USCIS Policy Manual adds that the evidence "must include the title, date, and author of the material, and any necessary translation."
Chapter 2 asks two questions. The first is about content: "The published material should be about the person, relating to the person's work in the field." Material about the employer and the employer's work, or about another organization and its work, does not meet this test. The second is about the outlet. For professional and major trade publications "relevant factors include the intended audience," and for major trade publications and other major media the factor is "the relative circulation, readership, or viewership."
The same subsection lists the forms the evidence may take: "print or online newspaper or magazine articles, popular or academic journal articles, books, textbooks, similar publications, or a transcript of professional or major audio or video coverage of the person and the person's work."
The O-1A rule in Volume 2, Part M, Chapter 4 uses nearly the same words: "Published material in professional or major trade publications or major media about the beneficiary, relating to the beneficiary's work in the field for which classification is sought, which must include the title, date, and author of such published material, and any necessary translation." The decisions below concern EB-1A petitions.
Does an article that quotes or mentions you count?
Only if it discusses your work in substance. The AAO rejected articles that quoted a urologist or cited his paper, and accepted coverage of a neuroscientist's own study in which he was quoted extensively.
Chapter 2 does not require that the applicant be the only subject: "However, the person and the person's work need not be the only subject of the material; published material that covers a broader topic but includes a substantial discussion of the person's work in the field and mentions the person in connection to the work may be considered material about the person relating to the person's work." A mention without that discussion is not enough.
In the decision of June 24, 2020 (In Re: 8185333) the petitioner was a urologist at a Pennsylvania clinic. He filed three articles. A 2017 article from MyTwinTiers.com quoted him on the benefits of robotic surgical assistants for his practice. A 2012 article on www.prostate.net cited his Journal of Sexual Medicine paper among other sources. The AAO wrote: "Those articles were not about the Petitioner, either because they were primarily about the authors' own work or recent trends in the field." The third item was a 2006 newsletter press release about a study. It carried his photograph and a caption, and the AAO noted that it "does not mention the Petitioner."
A visual artist in the decision of September 29, 2014 (AAO, September 29, 2014) relied on an article titled "Art league shows off some of its true colors." The AAO answered: "The regulation requires that the published material be 'about the alien' and relate 'to the alien's work in the field.' It is insufficient that the published material mentions the petitioner."
The decision of April 23, 2020 (In Re: 7144255) went the other way. A neuroscientist filed online coverage of his 2014 study in Current Biology, including articles in the Los Angeles Times and BBC News. The Director had found that the articles were not about him. The AAO disagreed, because the articles "focus on the Petitioner's own published study," and "The Petitioner is quoted extensively in many of the articles and provides commentary on his research methods and the potential implications of his findings." The same record held a 2016 article in which he was one of several neuroscientists interviewed, and about that article the AAO wrote that it "is not about the Petitioner."
Does an article about your company, product or team count?
An article about the employer or its product does not. An article about a team counts when it names you in connection with the work or other evidence in the record documents your significant role.
The rule for teams is in the same subsection of Chapter 2: "officers may consider material that focuses solely or primarily on work or research being undertaken by a team of which the person is a member, provided that the material mentions the person in connection with the work or other evidence in the record documents the person's significant role in the work or research." Where the article names only the team, the applicant's role has to be documented separately.
On September 27, 2011 (AAO, computer scientist) the AAO reviewed the evidence of a computer scientist who ran his own company. A press release about the company's streaming products quoted him. The AAO wrote: "While the press release quotes the petitioner, it is not about the petitioner relating to his work rather than iMedia Streams' technology. Articles that are not about the petitioner do not meet this regulatory criterion."
Two more items in that record failed for the same reason. A screenshot about a product launch "never mentions the petitioner let alone published material about him relating to his work." A page from the website of his own business gave "the petitioner's description of the company rather than published material about the petitioner relating to his work."
Under Chapter 2 an article about a product counts only when it discusses the applicant's work and names the applicant in connection with it.
Do press releases, paid articles and marketing materials count?
Generally not. Chapter 2 excludes marketing materials and content that the person or the employer paid for, and in 2012 the AAO wrote that a press release is not independent, journalistic coverage.
The sentence in Chapter 2 reads: "Marketing materials created for the purpose of selling the person's products or promoting the person's services are not generally considered to be published material about the person (this includes seemingly objective content about the person in major print publications that the person or the person's employer paid for)." An article placed for a fee in a known magazine falls under the words in parentheses.
In the decision of March 30, 2012 (AAO, marketing director) the petitioner was "an executive marketing director in the car rental and tourism field." Counsel described one item as a press release. The AAO wrote that "a press release does not constitute published material as it is not independent, journalistic coverage." Another item was a photograph in a magazine's table of contents, and the AAO held that "a photograph is not published material about the petitioner relating to her work."
A postdoctoral researcher in nuclear astrophysics (AAO, May 21, 2010) relied on press releases posted on websites, including the site of the institute that sponsored his research, and on an identically worded article at www.spacedaily.com "credited to 'staff writers.'" The AAO wrote: "While these press releases are about the petitioner's work, they are not about the petitioner relating to his work." It added that he had submitted no evidence that the websites were professional or major trade publications or other major media.
In the decision of October 5, 2023 (In Re: 28156055) a fashion model filed magazine pages with her photographs, covers, credit pages and advertising that was later posted on billboards. On one page she was "credited" as the model, but "the article does not otherwise discuss or mention the Petitioner or her work as a fashion model." The AAO concluded that these articles "were published for the purpose of reporting on current fashion trends and marketing designer clothing for purchase by retail establishments and the public," and that "the published content is not focused on her and her work in the field."
The petitioner argued that the photographers and magazines were prestigious. The AAO replied: "But we must adhere to the criterion's requirements and to agency policy in evaluating whether the evidence submitted satisfies the criterion."
Does an interview with you count?
It depends on what the author writes. The AAO rejected an interview that only recorded the petitioner's answers and accepted articles in a trade magazine that interviewed a videographer and discussed her work.
In the March 2012 decision one item was an article based on an interview "in which her answers are simply recorded." The AAO continued: "The author does not discuss the petitioner, and the material does not qualify as published material about the petitioner relating to her work."
On April 3, 2024 (In Re: 30233212) the AAO reached the opposite result for a videographer who had worked on camera crews in television and film production. It wrote: "The Petitioner has submitted articles showing that she has been interviewed and her work has been discussed in at least one major trade publication, ICG Magazine, which discusses the Petitioner's transition from China and her work on several productions." The AAO found that "The evidence of record meets the plain language of this criterion," withdrew the denial and remanded the case for a new decision.
Broadcast interviews raise a separate question. In September 2011 the AAO wrote: "As a video clip from YouTube, as well as an interview on a television show, is not published material in professional or major trade publications or other major media, it clearly does not meet the plain language of this regulatory criterion." Chapter 2 in its current text lists "a transcript of professional or major audio or video coverage of the person and the person's work" among the forms of evidence, so a broadcast is filed as a transcript together with evidence about the broadcaster's audience.
How do you prove that an outlet is major media or a major trade publication?
With independent data on its audience, circulation, readership or viewership. The AAO compared circulation with other outlets and gave little weight to publishers' promotional statements and to Wikipedia.
In the March 2012 decision the record put the average circulation of The Citizen at 70,563. The same document listed 511,087 for the Daily Sun. The AAO wrote that it "is not persuaded that The Citizen is a professional or major trade publication or other major media." An article in Financial Mail was about the petitioner's work, but the record held only self-promotional material from the magazine's own site, and the petitioner "failed to submit any independent, objective evidence" that it was a professional or major trade publication or other major media.
The same decision set aside an online encyclopedia: "As there are no assurances about the reliability of the content from this open, user-edited Internet site, the AAO will not assign weight to information from Wikipedia."
In Matter of J-C- of May 12, 2017 (AAO non-precedent decision) the petitioner was president and co-founder of two Chinese agricultural products companies. An editor stated that one newspaper "has a daily circulation of 400,000 copies," and another publication was described as "sold at airports, bookstores, and business training companies." The AAO found that he met "the plain language of this regulatory criterion." The decision also states that "USCIS need not rely on general, self-promotional assertions of the publisher."
In April 2024 the AAO accepted ICG Magazine as a major trade publication on the basis of "Information from the publisher and from California State University's Entertainment Alliance" about "the magazine's significance to the film and television industries." For World Journal it took administrative notice that the paper is "one of the largest Chinese language newspapers in the United States with independent operations in several major cities in North America and worldwide circulation," and treated it as major media.
Two decisions show the gap that follows when this evidence is missing. In September 2011 "The petitioner failed to submit any documentary evidence establishing that the websites are considered major media." In September 2014 the petitioner did not show that a newsletter had "a distribution or circulation consistent with a major trade publication." Foreign-language outlets also need full certified translations, covered in Foreign-language articles for the EB-1A published material criterion.
Do online articles, blogs and websites count?
Online articles count on the same terms as print. A blog post, a page listing speakers, police website printouts and a printout without its web address failed in AAO decisions.
Chapter 2 names "print or online newspaper or magazine articles" together. The tests for content and for the outlet are the same for both.
The computer scientist of September 2011 filed a blog post announcing that he would be one of the presenters at a networking event and a web page that listed him as one of eight speakers at a seminar. Neither was shown to be about him in a major outlet. In the karate case of April 23, 2012 (AAO, karate practitioner and coach) printouts from the Italian State Police website failed, and the AAO wrote that "the petitioner has not shown that any of the online material constitutes an article."
The form of the printout matters. In September 2014 the AAO noted: "The article in [...] does not bear the article's uniform resource locator, or URL, normally displayed on printed website pages." The petitioner's statement that the article had appeared online did not replace that detail.
Writing platforms were weighed in the April 2020 case. The record described Medium as an "online publishing platform" that is "regularly regarded as a blog host." The petitioner was among the few writers paid for contributions there, and the AAO wrote that this "is not an indicator that he has been recognized as one of the small percentage at the very top of his scientific field."
Pages change after filing. In April 2024 the Director found that a link to the World Journal article no longer worked and that the article had been revised. The AAO compared the versions and found that "the foreign-language articles appear identical in content; the main difference is that the order of photos of the Petitioner has changed slightly." It wrote: "We see no reason to question the credibility of this article."
How many articles are needed, and how are they weighed at the final merits stage?
The criterion names no number. At the final merits stage the AAO weighed how many articles there were, when they appeared and whether they covered the applicant's body of work, and found two or three pieces insufficient.
Meeting three criteria is the first step. In the final merits determination the officer asks whether the person is "one of that small percentage who have risen to the very top of the field of endeavor" and has sustained acclaim. Footnote 5 of Chapter 2 defines sustain as "to support or maintain, especially over a long period of time."
The neuroscientist of April 2020 met the published material criterion and still lost the appeal. The AAO wrote that the articles "do not, however, focus on him" or on his body of work and reputation in the field, and that "The Petitioner has not shown, for example, that he or his work have received major media attention since 2014." The decision came six years after the coverage.
In the urologist's case of June 2020 the AAO found that three published pieces were not consistent with the sustained acclaim the classification requires, and that the limited media reporting did not show a "career of acclaimed work in the field," a phrase it took from a House report and 56 Fed. Reg. at 30704.
In Matter of J-C- the published material criterion was the only one the petitioner met. In its final merits analysis the AAO described the evidence as "two brief articles written about the Petitioner and his company in trade publications." The appeal was dismissed.
How does an IAE audit check the published material criterion?
An IAE registry expert marks each EB-1A criterion, published material included, as met, partly met or not met, names the documents behind each mark and sends a written report within 5 business days of receiving the materials and payment.
On the profile audit page one report covers one category: EB-1A, EB-2 NIW, O-1A or O-1B. The assessment follows the criteria of 8 CFR 204.5(h), the Dhanasar test and 8 CFR 214.2(o). The sample report on the page lists "Published material about the applicant" among the EB-1A rows and marks it "No."
The report has four parts. The criteria map marks each criterion as met, partly met or not met and names the documents behind each mark. The gaps part lists missing or weak evidence, such as a single source, no independent confirmation or the wrong form of document. The collection plan says what to obtain before filing, in what order and from whom. The last part names the category closest to the profile now and what changes in six to twelve months if the plan is followed.
The request form takes a CV and up to 10 files or one archive in .pdf, .docx, .jpg, .png or .zip, up to 25 MB each. Press articles go in with the publications, and data on an outlet's circulation or audience can go in beside them. A request for evidence, a NOID or a denial can be attached. If the CV and documents are not enough for the criteria map, the expert requests what is missing in one email within 1-2 business days.
The report names the expert and the registry record number. Questions about the report are answered by email for 14 days after delivery. IAE membership is not required and does not affect the assessment or the timing. The audit is an expert assessment against published criteria, not legal advice and not a forecast of the USCIS decision; the petition is filed by the applicant or the applicant's attorney. To start, order an audit.
Sources
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2, Extraordinary Ability
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 2, Part M, Chapter 4, O-1 Beneficiaries
- AAO non-precedent decision, In Re: 28156055 (October 5, 2023)
- AAO non-precedent decision, In Re: 30233212 (April 3, 2024)
- AAO non-precedent decision, In Re: 7144255 (April 23, 2020)
- AAO non-precedent decision, In Re: 8185333 (June 24, 2020)
- AAO non-precedent decision, Matter of J-C- (May 12, 2017)
- AAO non-precedent decision, computer scientist (September 27, 2011)
- AAO non-precedent decision, executive marketing director (March 30, 2012)
- AAO non-precedent decision, postdoctoral researcher in astrophysics (May 21, 2010)
- AAO non-precedent decision, visual artist (September 29, 2014)
- AAO non-precedent decision, karate practitioner and coach (April 23, 2012)
Read also
All articles
EB-2 NIW or EB-1A as a PhD student: can you file before you graduate, and what happens to F-1 status?
No rule makes a PhD student wait for the diploma. EB-2 NIW and EB-1A are self-petitions, and neither regulation asks for a particular immigration
O-1 visa salary requirement: is there a minimum, and how do you prove high remuneration?
An O-1 petition does not have to meet a salary threshold. The O-1A regulation lists high pay as one of eight criteria, and a petition needs three
O-1 or H-1B: which visa fits a specialist with a U.S. job offer?
H-1B is limited to 65,000 new workers a year plus 20,000 with U.S. master's degrees, chosen in a selection that now gives more chances to higher wageProfile audit
Is your profile ready for the petition?
A report on the EB‑1A, EB‑2 NIW, O‑1A or O‑1B criteria within 5 business days of receiving the materials and payment: what is proven, what is missing and what to collect before filing.

