For attorneys
EB-1B recommendation letters: who should write which letter for an outstanding researcher petition?
An EB-1B petition carries two kinds of letters. The regulation itself requires letters from current or former employers on at least three years of teaching or research and a letter with the job offer from the U.S. employer. Expert and recommendation letters are optional evidence, and in decisions of 2022 and 2024 the AAO found that letters without specific examples and corroborating documents did not establish international recognition.

Which letters does an EB-1B petition need?
Two are required by 8 CFR 204.5(i): letters from current or former employers on three years of teaching or research, and the job offer letter. Expert letters support the six criteria and the final merits determination.
Under 8 CFR 204.5(i)(1), "Any United States employer desiring and intending to employ a professor or researcher" may file the Form I-140. The beneficiary cannot file alone, and a labor certification is not required for this classification.
Paragraph (i)(3)(i) asks for evidence that the professor or researcher "is recognized internationally as outstanding in the academic field specified in the petition," through at least two of six criteria: major prizes or awards for outstanding achievement, membership in associations that require outstanding achievements, published material by others about the work, judging the work of others, original scientific or scholarly research contributions, and authorship of scholarly books or articles in journals with international circulation.
No criterion is called a letter. Expert letters describe and explain evidence under these criteria, for example the original contributions criterion (E). If the six standards do not readily apply, paragraph (i)(3)(ii) permits comparable evidence. According to the USCIS Policy Manual chapter on outstanding professors and researchers, the petitioner does not need to establish that a standard is not readily applicable and may submit "alternative, but qualitatively comparable evidence."
What must the experience letters say?
They come from current or former employers and include the writer's name, address and title and a specific description of the duties performed. Together they cover at least three years of teaching or research in the academic field.
The text of 8 CFR 204.5(i)(3)(iii) reads: "Evidence of teaching and/or research experience shall be in the form of letter(s) from current or former employer(s) and shall include the name, address, and title of the writer, and a specific description of the duties performed by the alien." Paragraph (g)(1) sets the same form for qualifying experience in the other employment-based classifications.
Experience gained while working on an advanced degree counts only if the beneficiary has acquired the degree, and only if the teaching duties gave full responsibility for the class taught or the research toward the degree "has been recognized within the academic field as outstanding." A letter that says only that the beneficiary was a teaching assistant does not answer either condition.
In a decision of January 11, 2024 (In Re: 29024063), the AAO noted a graduate advisor's letter stating that the beneficiary had completed coursework and thesis credits, and found that the record did not show he had received his M.S. degree.
What does the job offer letter need?
It comes from the prospective U.S. employer and offers a tenured or tenure-track teaching position or a permanent research position in the academic field. A private employer must also show at least three full-time researchers.
Paragraph (i)(3)(iv) lists three senders: a U.S. university or institution of higher learning offering a tenured or tenure-track teaching position, the same kind of institution offering a permanent research position, or a department, division or institute of a private employer offering a permanent research position. The Policy Manual adds that the offer is a letter addressed to the beneficiary by the prospective U.S. employer.
"Permanent" has a definition in paragraph (i)(2): tenured, tenure-track, "or for a term of indefinite or unlimited duration, and in which the employee will ordinarily have an expectation of continued employment unless there is good cause for termination." A research appointment with a fixed end date does not meet the words "indefinite or unlimited duration."
Under the last sentence of paragraph (i)(3)(iv), a private employer's department has to prove that it employs at least three persons full-time in research positions and that it has documented accomplishments in an academic field. The petition documents both facts, the full-time researchers and the accomplishments. "Academic field" means a body of specialized knowledge offered for study at an accredited U.S. university or institution of higher education.
How does USCIS weigh expert letters in an EB-1B case?
As advisory opinions. Under Matter of Caron International, USCIS may use expert statements and give less weight to an opinion that is not in accord with other information or is in any way questionable.
In Matter of Caron International, 19 I&N Dec. 791, decided on October 28, 1988, the Commissioner wrote that the Service "may, in its discretion, use as advisory opinions statements from universities, professional organizations, or other sources submitted in evidence as expert testimony." Where an opinion "is not in accord with other information or is in any way questionable," the Service "is not required to accept or may give less weight to that evidence."
The Policy Manual sets two steps. First the officer counts whether at least two criteria are met, without deciding international recognition. Then, in the final merits determination, the officer evaluates all the evidence together under the preponderance of the evidence standard. The AAO decisions of 2024 cite Kazarian v. USCIS, 596 F.3d 1115 (9th Cir. 2010), for this two-part review.
For the second step the chapter lists factors such as publication in highly ranked journals, citation rates including a high h-index, employment at leading institutions, unsolicited invitations to speak at recognized conferences and named roles on peer-reviewed, competitively funded U.S. government grants. It also says that petitioners must explain the significance of their evidence. An expert letter can give that explanation for each exhibit it cites.
Who should write the expert letters?
People whose statements the record can corroborate. In 2024 the AAO found that letters did not show how the academic field as a whole, rather than the references the beneficiary selected, viewed his work.
In a decision of March 22, 2024 (In Re: 30518950), the beneficiary was a software engineer, and the letters came from two university professors and a senior software manager. One professor wrote that the work "has the potential to drive significant progress in the field of computer vision." The manager wrote that the algorithms were "contributing to the accuracy and reliability of our autonomous driving system." The AAO wrote that the letters lacked sufficient information and explanation, and the record lacked adequate corroborating evidence, to show that the beneficiary and his work are viewed by the academic field as a whole, "rather than by the references he selected," as substantially influential.
In the decision of January 11, 2024 (In Re: 29024063), the authors were the petitioner's president, a vice president of another company, a chief engineer in Nepal and the beneficiary's thesis advisor. The president's letter did not detail the impact "beyond the Petitioner and its clientele." The chief engineer called the beneficiary a "significant resource internationally," and the AAO found that the record did not include corroborating evidence that his publications influenced the field, were widely cited or gained international recognition.
Neither 8 CFR 204.5(i) nor the Policy Manual chapter sets a number of expert letters or a required country of authors.
What did the AAO find missing in EB-1B letters?
Specific examples of impact on the field, documents behind claims about peer review or use of the work, and anything beyond the language of the regulation. Letters that only praised the work did not establish international recognition.
In a decision of March 4, 2024 (In Re: 30240228), a university petitioned for a sociological researcher. The AAO wrote that "repeating the language of the statute or regulations does not satisfy a petitioner's burden of proof." A letter said that she "has reviewed more than 20 papers from faculties and doctoral students at European universities" submitted for a conference, but the petitioner did not corroborate the claim or present official documentation of the requirements for selecting committee members. Another letter described her seminars and workshops at the writer's institution, and the AAO wrote that its author "did not provide specific examples indicating that the Beneficiary's work has had a meaningful impact in the academic field."
In a decision of June 8, 2022 (In Re: 20612340), a food ingredients manufacturer petitioned for a scientist. The AAO accepted that the letters gave detail about her research, yet one author did not say that he had cited it in his own published research, and statements about the journal's peer-review role were not supported by documents on how the journal selects reviewers. Her review of 20 manuscripts met the judging criterion. At the final merits step the Director called this work routine, and the AAO wrote that "the record does not establish that this work is indicative of international recognition as outstanding."
Each gap the AAO named was a missing document: the citing article, the journal's criteria for selecting reviewers, the record of who used the method. A letter that refers to such exhibits by number gives the officer something to check.
Can letters prove the original research contributions criterion?
Letters can establish the criterion itself, which does not require major significance. In 2024 the AAO still found that meeting criterion (E) did not by itself show international recognition at the final merits step.
The Policy Manual chapter states: "The regulations do not require that the beneficiary's contributions be of major significance." The contribution must be to the academic field "rather than an individual laboratory or institution," and contributions are considered separately from scholarly articles. The EB-1A criterion in paragraph (h)(3)(v), by contrast, requires contributions "of major significance in the field."
In the March 22 and January 11, 2024 decisions the AAO agreed that criterion (E) was met and then dismissed the appeals at the second step. Both decisions say that "not every research finding that broadens knowledge in a particular field" makes a person's work outstanding or internationally recognized. On a patent the March 22 decision says that it recognizes the originality of an idea but does not by itself establish international recognition.
For the second step a letter on contributions names who used the result outside the beneficiary's group, in which publication, product or standard, and with what effect, and the petition attaches those documents.
How does IAE prepare an expert letter for an EB-1B petition?
An expert from the IAE registry in the beneficiary's field signs the letter with a declaration of independence. The free case assessment comes within one business day, and the letter within 10 business days after payment.
The attorney sends the petition category, the beneficiary's field, the filing deadline, the beneficiary's CV and the draft petition through the page for attorneys. Within one business day the Secretariat replies which letters make sense for the case, who the expert is, the cost and the deadline. The assessment is free and carries no obligation.
Before the invoice the attorney receives the expert's CV, degree, memberships, publications and a link to the registry record, and may decline the candidate. The invoice carries the case number, and it goes to the firm or to the client. The deadline runs from payment and receipt of the full file: 10 business days for a letter, 5 in rush mode, and 5 business days for an RFE or NOID response, 3 in rush mode.
The Secretariat prepares the draft from the beneficiary's documents, and the expert checks it, makes changes and signs. One round of factual edits is included, and the conclusions remain the expert's own. In every letter the expert confirms no personal, financial or professional connection to the beneficiary, and one expert does not sign two letters for the same petition. Before delivery, facts and dates are checked against the beneficiary's documents.
From the fifth paid order in a calendar month a 10% discount applies automatically. IAE is not a law firm. The attorney is responsible for the case strategy, and USCIS weighs the letter together with the other evidence.
Sources
- 8 CFR 204.5, Petitions for employment-based immigrants (LII)
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 3, Outstanding Professor or Researcher
- Matter of Caron International, 19 I&N Dec. 791 (Comm. 1988)
- AAO, In Re: 30518950, Outstanding Professor or Researcher (March 22, 2024)
- AAO, In Re: 29024063, Outstanding Professor or Researcher (January 11, 2024)
- AAO, In Re: 30240228, Outstanding Professor or Researcher (March 4, 2024)
- AAO, In Re: 20612340, Outstanding Professor or Researcher (June 8, 2022)
Read also
All articles
Notice of intent to revoke an approved I-140: what triggers it, how do you respond, and can a court review the revocation?
An approved I-140 is not final. Under 8 U.S.C. 1155 the Secretary of Homeland Security may revoke the approval at any time for good and sufficient
USCIS signature requirements after the July 10, 2026 rule: who signs a petition, can the attorney sign for the client, and what happens to an invalid signature?
The petitioner signs the petition, and the attorney signs the G-28. The Policy Manual states that an attorney generally may not sign a benefit
Suing USCIS after a denial: what does a federal court review under the APA, and why must the evidence already be in the record?
A final USCIS denial can be challenged in federal district court under the Administrative Procedure Act. The court sets aside a decision that isRequest
Send your first case
The beneficiary's CV, the petition category and the deadline. The expert, the CV, the cost and the deadline within one business day.

