Membership

Membership in professional associations for EB-2 exceptional ability: which associations count?

An EB-2 petition based on exceptional ability needs at least three of the six types of evidence listed in 8 CFR 204.5(k)(3)(ii), and membership in professional associations is one of them. The USCIS Policy Manual says that membership of any caliber should satisfy this criterion. In three decisions issued in 2024, the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) still rejected memberships, because the record did not prove that the association admits only members of a profession.

Conference attendees with blank badges talk beside a registration desk in a lobby.

What does criterion (E) require?

Evidence of membership in professional associations. It is one of six types of evidence for exceptional ability, and the petition needs at least three of them before the officer weighs the record as a whole.

Under 8 CFR 204.5(k)(2), exceptional ability means "a degree of expertise significantly above that ordinarily encountered in the sciences, arts, or business." Paragraph (k)(3)(ii) lists six types of evidence: (A) an official academic record relating to the area of exceptional ability; (B) letters from current or former employers proving at least ten years of full-time experience in the occupation; (C) a license to practice the profession or certification for a particular profession or occupation; (D) a salary or other remuneration for services that is evidence of exceptional ability; (E) membership in professional associations; (F) recognition for achievements and significant contributions to the industry or field by peers, governmental entities, or professional or business organizations.

Criterion (E) has six words: "Evidence of membership in professional associations." It says nothing about outstanding achievements or about experts who judge candidates. Both of those requirements belong to the EB-1A and O-1A criterion, which the IAE guide on association membership in EB-1A and O-1 covers.

The USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 5 tells officers to use a two-step analysis. The first step is limited to whether the evidence covers at least three of the six criteria. If those criteria do not readily apply to the occupation, 8 CFR 204.5(k)(3)(iii) lets the petitioner submit comparable evidence. The Policy Manual adds that general assertions that the criteria do not readily apply are not acceptable.

What makes an association professional?

The regulation does not define the term. The AAO reads it through the definition of profession in 8 CFR 204.5(k)(2): a professional association requires its members to be members of a profession.

Section 204.5(k)(2) defines a profession as "one of the occupations listed in section 101(a)(32) of the Act, as well as any occupation for which a United States baccalaureate degree or its foreign equivalent is the minimum requirement for entry into the occupation." Section 101(a)(32) of the Immigration and Nationality Act (8 U.S.C. 1101(a)(32)) names architects, engineers, lawyers, physicians, surgeons and teachers in elementary or secondary schools, colleges, academies or seminaries, and the words "shall include but not be limited to" leave the list open.

On March 28, 2024 the AAO applied that definition to criterion (E) in In Re: 30354390: "a professional association is one which requires its members to be members of a profession as defined in the regulation." The heading of the decision reads "Non-Precedent Decision of the Administrative Appeals Office."

In the same decision the AAO found that material on the association's mission, its significance in the industry and the number of its members did not address who may join.

Which memberships did the AAO reject in 2024?

A pilots' association with no admission rules in the record, an aviation association that admits certified mechanics, and a business association that admits company founders by turnover. No record proved a degree requirement.

The petitioner in In Re: 30354390, a pilot, relied on membership in the Aircraft Owners and Pilots Association (AOPA). He filed a letter from AOPA confirming his membership, an AOPA web page and a page of the Congressional Record dated May 13, 2019 with a Senate resolution on AOPA's 80th anniversary. The AAO wrote that none of them contained information on the membership requirements, "including whether or not the association requires the minimum of a bachelor's degree or its foreign equivalent for admission." He met criteria (A) and (C), two of the three required.

In Re: 29344933, decided February 5, 2024, concerned an aircraft maintenance technician whose petition the Nebraska Service Center had denied. Under a print-out of the association's bylaws in the record, an applicant for regular membership must be certificated as a mechanic or repairman under 14 CFR part 65, hold an equivalent from a foreign aviation authority, or hold a Federal Communications Commission General Radio and Telephone certificate. The AAO found the evidence insufficient to prove a membership body "comprised of individuals who have earned a U.S. baccalaureate degree, or its foreign equivalent." He also met only criteria (A) and (C).

In Re: 28963349, decided January 5, 2024, concerned an entrepreneur and general business manager. The association's admission conditions asked for an enterprise with annual turnover above 50 million yuan, founded more than 3 years earlier, and a founder with more than 5 years in entrepreneurship, with priority for innovative industries that have government support. The AAO concluded that members "must run a business, but are not required to hold a baccalaureate degree." The Director of the Texas Service Center had found criteria (A) and (B) met and (E) and (F) not met. On appeal the AAO also found (E) and (F) not met.

All three appeals were dismissed.

Does the caliber of the association matter at the first step?

No. The Policy Manual says membership alone, regardless of caliber, should satisfy one of the three required criteria. The officer evaluates what the membership says about expertise later, in the final merits determination.

The Policy Manual uses membership as its example: "being a member of professional associations alone, regardless of the caliber, should satisfy one of the three required regulatory criteria." The next sentences say that the membership should also be evaluated for whether it indicates "a degree of expertise significantly above that ordinarily encountered in the sciences, arts, or business," and that this secondary evaluation is conducted as part of the final merits determination.

Caliber is how selective the association is. The 2024 decisions turned on an earlier question, whether the association admits only members of a profession.

Does a membership that begins after filing count?

No. Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(1) the petitioner must be eligible when the petition is filed. In January 2024 the AAO refused to consider a membership order dated after the filing date.

8 CFR 103.2(b)(1) requires a petitioner to establish eligibility "at the time of filing the benefit request" and to remain eligible through adjudication. Under 103.2(b)(12), a petition is denied where evidence filed in response to a request for evidence does not establish eligibility at the time of filing. A membership that begins after filing and arrives with the response falls under that rule.

The petitioner in In Re: 28963349 filed proof of payment for a "New Member Order" dated December 2022. Because that evidence postdates the filing of the petition, the AAO wrote, "we will not include it in our evaluation of this criterion."

The technician in In Re: 29344933 had a different record. He had been a member since February 2021, the petition was filed in April 2021, and the AAO examined that membership on its merits.

What documents prove membership in a professional association?

Proof that the applicant was a member on the filing date, the admission rules that require a bachelor's degree or membership in a profession, and certified English translations of every foreign-language document.

In the February 2024 decision the record held a print-out of the association's bylaws with the conditions for regular membership. In the January 2024 decision the petitioner provided the rules as documents titled "Membership Admission Conditions" and "Admission criteria." In both cases the AAO checked whether the conditions require a U.S. bachelor's degree or its foreign equivalent.

A set for one association can be built from these documents:

  • The association's certificate, card or letter names the member, the grade and the date membership began.
  • Receipts or a letter from the association show that membership was current on the date the petition was filed.
  • The bylaws or admission rules in force when the applicant joined contain the clause that sets the degree or occupation requirement for the grade held.
  • Each foreign-language document comes with a full English translation and the translator's certification that it is complete and accurate and that the translator is competent to translate from that language into English, as 8 CFR 103.2(b)(3) requires.

How does the officer weigh the membership in the final merits determination?

With the rest of the record. The officer decides whether a preponderance of the evidence proves expertise significantly above that ordinarily encountered, and asks what the membership says about that expertise.

The Policy Manual says that meeting the minimum of three types of evidence "does not, in itself, establish" that the person meets the requirements for exceptional ability, and that officers "must also consider the quality of the evidence." In the second step the officer evaluates the evidence together and decides whether the petitioner has proven, by a preponderance of the evidence, a degree of expertise significantly above that ordinarily encountered in the sciences, arts, or business. A footnote cites Matter of Chawathe, 25 I&N Dec. 369 (AAO 2010), where truth "is to be determined not by the quantity of evidence alone but by its quality."

The chapter adds two rules on documents. A degree, diploma, certificate or similar award from a college is not by itself sufficient evidence of exceptional ability. Formal recognition in certificates and other documents contemporaneous with the claimed contributions and achievements may have more weight than letters prepared for the petition.

In the March 2024 decision the AAO did not formally reach the final merits determination. It reviewed the totality of the evidence anyway and wrote that "the record does not show that his level of expertise is unusual or stands out in the field."

How does criterion (E) differ from EB-1A and Schedule A Group II?

Criterion (E) asks only for a professional association. EB-1A and Schedule A Group II require associations that demand outstanding achievement of their members, as judged by recognized experts, and Schedule A Group II requires international associations.

For EB-1A, 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(ii) requires membership in associations in the field "which require outstanding achievements of their members, as judged by recognized national or international experts in their disciplines or fields."

Schedule A Group II, in 20 CFR 656.15(d)(1), covers exceptional ability in the sciences or arts, excluding the performing arts. The employer must file evidence of "widespread acclaim and international recognition accorded the alien by recognized experts in the alien's field" and documentation from at least two of seven groups. Group (ii) is membership in international associations "which require outstanding achievement of their members, as judged by recognized international experts in their disciplines or fields." Under 8 CFR 204.5(k)(4)(i), an EB-2 petition is accompanied by an individual labor certification, by an application for Schedule A designation, if applicable, or by evidence of a shortage occupation in the Labor Market Information Pilot Program.

What comes after exceptional ability in an NIW petition?

The waiver itself. The Policy Manual says that qualifying for EB-2 does not automatically mean the person qualifies for a national interest waiver, which is decided under the three prongs of Matter of Dhanasar.

In the national interest waiver section of the same chapter, the first of two elements the petitioner must establish is that the person qualifies as a member of the professions holding an advanced degree or as a person of exceptional ability. The national interest part is assessed under Matter of Dhanasar, 26 I&N Dec. 884 (AAO 2016).

A petitioner with an advanced degree does not need exceptional ability. Under 8 CFR 204.5(k)(2), an advanced degree is a U.S. academic or professional degree or a foreign equivalent degree above that of baccalaureate, and a baccalaureate followed by at least five years of progressive experience in the specialty counts as a master's degree. On appeal, the pilot in the March 2024 decision did not claim that he qualified as a professional holding an advanced degree.

In all three 2024 decisions the AAO did not reach the Dhanasar analysis. In January 2024 it cited INS v. Bagamasbad, 429 U.S. 24, 25 (1976), and reserved the waiver arguments.

Where does IAE membership fit in an exceptional ability petition?

IAE admits members by application under published rules, decides in writing and issues a certificate and a registry record. IAE does not promise that its membership meets criterion (E); USCIS decides that on the record.

IAE has two grades by application. Senior Member (SM) requires at least 3 years of documented experience in a recognized field and an education document, and the Council decides after a document review. Certified International Expert (CIE) requires at least 4 of 6 points under the IAE Criteria Matrix: two Council members assess the application independently, and then the Council votes. The Council confers Fellow of the Association (F.IAE) on current SM and CIE members by its own decision, and the status cannot be requested, purchased or expedited.

The Secretariat confirms receipt of an application within one business day. The Council usually decides within 3 business days of receiving the complete set of documents, and no later than 30 days under the Charter. The decision comes with written reasons. After a positive decision and payment of the dues, the member receives a certificate with a QR code and a record in the public registry with a number in the format IAE-YYYY-XXXXX. A court, agency, employer or client checks the status by QR code or member number, free of charge and without registration.

In the 2024 decisions the AAO looked in the record for the association's admission rules. The rules for each IAE grade are published on the membership page and in the Criteria Matrix. The new member kit includes a letter to the employer in English, on IAE letterhead signed by the Executive Director, issued free of charge within one business day.

The self-check has six questions. With 3 or more years of experience it ends with a recommended grade, SM or CIE, and a list of documents; with less it says that it is too early to apply. The application is filed online.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Membership

Ready to apply for membership?

The Secretariat confirms receipt of the application within one business day. The Council usually decides within 3 business days of receiving the complete set of documents, and no later than 30 days under the Charter.

Membership application

Received

Confirmation within one business day

CategorySenior Member
Documents7 files
Council decisionup to 3 business days