Expert witnesses
Eichleay formula expert: how unabsorbed home office overhead is proved after a government delay
The Eichleay formula prices home office overhead that a contractor keeps paying while the government holds the work at a standstill. The Federal Circuit calls it the exclusive formula for unabsorbed overhead once performance has begun, and permits it only after the contractor proves a government-caused delay of uncertain duration, standby and an inability to take on other work. In Alderman (ASBCA, 2020) the board awarded $34,795 and denied $21,753 priced by an expert not accepted on cost accounting.

What is the Eichleay formula?
A three-step computation: home office overhead is allocated to the contract by its share of billings, divided by the days of performance to get a daily rate, and multiplied by the days of government-caused delay.
The Armed Services Board of Contract Appeals (ASBCA) first set out the formula in Eichleay Corp., decided on July 29, 1960 (60-2 BCA ¶ 2688). The Federal Circuit restated it in Nicon, Inc. v. United States, decided on June 10, 2003. First, contract billings divided by total billings for the contract period, multiplied by total overhead for the contract period, give the overhead allocable to the contract. Second, allocable overhead divided by the days of performance gives the daily contract overhead. Third, daily contract overhead multiplied by the days of delay gives the amount recoverable.
In Satellite Electric Co. v. Dalton (Fed. Cir. 1997), the court described home office overhead as costs "expended for the benefit of the whole business," which cannot be charged to a particular contract, and as "fixed costs that are allocated on a pro-rata basis among various contracts." The formula "seeks to equitably determine allocation of unabsorbed overhead."
In Interstate General Government Contractors v. West, decided on December 6, 1993, the Federal Circuit explained why the overhead goes unabsorbed: during a suspension the home office costs continue, while the direct-cost billings that would carry them stop. The court wrote that the formula "was devised to calculate reimbursable home office overhead costs in the event of suspension of work on a contract."
Which costs go into the home office overhead pool?
Indirect costs, grouped and allocated by the contractor's own accounting system. FAR 31.203 requires logical cost groupings, an allocation base chosen by the benefits to each contract, and no fragmenting of a base once accepted.
Under FAR 31.203(b), indirect costs are "those remaining to be allocated to intermediate or two or more final cost objectives" after direct costs are charged. Paragraph (c) requires the contractor to "accumulate indirect costs by logical cost groupings" and to allocate each grouping on "the basis of the benefits accruing to intermediate and final cost objectives." Under paragraph (d), once a base is accepted, "the contractor shall not fragment the base by removing individual elements." For contracts with full Cost Accounting Standards coverage, paragraph (a) sends allocation to those standards.
The two Eichleay inputs from the company books, total overhead and total billings for the contract period, come from that same accounting system. In Alderman the expert's claim summary listed unabsorbed home office overhead of $33,218 apart from direct labor of $23,073 and a bond premium of $257.
In Singleton Contracting Corp. v. Harvey (Fed. Cir. January 26, 2005), an Army contractor terminated for convenience on August 8, 1994 sought overhead in its termination settlement. The court affirmed the denial because "Singleton never submitted evidence to the Board of the company's total direct costs for 1993 and 1994" and never showed that it had no other contracts during those years.
What must the contractor prove before the formula applies?
A government-caused delay of uncertain duration, standby, and an inability to take on replacement work while on standby. The delay must also extend the time for performance or add costs against a planned early finish.
In Satellite Electric, the Federal Circuit listed three elements: a government-imposed delay occurred, the government required the contractor to "stand by" during the delay, and while standing by the contractor was "unable to take on additional work." The ASBCA used the same three elements in Alderman in 2020.
Nicon added that "there must have been a government-caused delay of uncertain duration" and that the contractor must show that "the delay extended the original time for performance" or that "the contractor incurred additional costs because he had planned to finish earlier." The court called use of the formula "an extraordinary remedy."
The court applied the early-finish test in Interstate General. The Army contract to repair heating, ventilation and air conditioning piping at Hunter Army Airfield, Georgia, signed on September 29, 1989, had a 472-day performance period. A bid protest held up the notice to proceed for about 136 days, and the contractor still finished 13 days ahead of the original completion date. It claimed $24,749.11 under Eichleay. The court required proof that it "intended to complete the contract early," "had the capability to do so" and "actually would have completed early, but for the government's actions." Its evidence met none of the three, and the denial was affirmed.
The delay also has to be the government's alone. In Singleton, the government's plans needed new drawings after the November 2, 1993 preconstruction conference, and the contractor never delivered its certificate of insurance; on February 15, 1994 the contracting officer barred work until it did. The court held that both failures "jointly caused delay in the project" and denied unabsorbed overhead for the contract period.
What does standby mean, and does it require a written order?
Standby means the contractor must stay ready to resume work immediately or on short notice during a suspension of uncertain length. A written order requiring that readiness proves it; without one, the contractor proves standby by indirect evidence.
P.J. Dick Inc. v. Principi, decided on April 7, 2003, arose under a fixed-price contract for the Clinical Addition to the VA Medical Center in Ann Arbor, Michigan, with completion due January 12, 1998. The VA issued more than 400 change orders and granted 107 extra days; P.J. Dick finished on September 29, 1998. The Department of Veterans Affairs Board of Contract Appeals denied home office overhead, and the Federal Circuit reviewed the standby ruling.
If the contracting officer issues a written order that suspends the work for an uncertain duration and requires the contractor to remain ready to resume immediately or on short notice, "the contractor need not offer further proof of standby." Without such an order, the contractor must show three things: the delay was "of an indefinite duration," the contractor was required to "resume full work immediately," and there was "effective suspension of much, if not all, of the work on the contract."
The board found that P.J. Dick "was able to progress other parts of the work" during the claimed suspensions. Its direct billings were $1,460,993 in the month before one delay, $687,464 during it and $1,035,792 in the month after. At worst they fell to 47% of earlier months, and the court held that they "can hardly be characterized as 'minor.'" The court added that the question is whether billings were less than they would have been absent the suspensions.
An express standby order is not required. In Appeal of Alderman Building Company (ASBCA No. 58082, May 21, 2020), the contracting officer's letter of July 7, 2009 directed the contractor "to suspend all work under the referenced contract" until further notice because of "Government delays in vacating the premises," without a standby instruction. The board still found standby: the subcontractor kept its workforce "chiefly because of the threat of liquidated damages and because of the absence of a time extension," rehiring qualified workers was uncertain, and the Navy had a "pattern of issuing short-notice postponements."
Who has to prove whether replacement work was available?
Once the contractor makes a prima facie case of standby during a government-caused delay of uncertain duration, the government must show that replacement work was practical, or that the inability to take it was not caused by the suspension.
In Alderman the ASBCA took this rule from Melka Marine, Inc. v. United States (Fed. Cir. 1999): the government must show that "it was not impractical for the contractor to obtain 'replacement work' during the delay," or that the inability to obtain or perform it "was not caused by the government's suspension." P.J. Dick split the same rule into two steps: the government first bears the burden of production on whether replacement work was practical, and the contractor then bears the burden of persuasion that it could not obtain enough of it.
The government won on this element in Satellite Electric. The Navy suspended a contract to install a power supply system twice, for 82 and 146 days, because it could not provide two items the contract required it to supply. Both suspensions came after Satellite had completed 96.7 percent of the work. Satellite bid on about 30 projects during the first period and 19 during the second and obtained only two contracts, citing limits in its bidding bond and economic conditions.
The board found that Satellite "was able to either reduce its overhead or take on other work during the delay," and the Federal Circuit affirmed. The government had to show only that the contractor was "able" to take on other work, and not that it actually obtained replacement work.
In Alderman the Navy pointed to five contracts the electrical subcontractor won during the delays, worth $3,552,312 in total, and to $147,416 it received under three replacement contracts. The board found the Navy had not met its burden. A witness testified that rehiring "cannot be accomplished during notification periods" of only 4 to 7 days.
Is Eichleay the only way to price unabsorbed overhead on a federal contract?
Once performance has begun, yes: Nicon called it the exclusive formula. When the government delays and then terminates before work starts, Nicon permits overhead in the termination settlement under another reasonable method of allocation.
Nicon held that "the Eichleay formula as it is set forth in our precedent is the exclusive formula" for unabsorbed overhead during government-caused delay after performance has begun. Earlier, Wickham Contracting Co. v. Fischer had called it the "only proper method of calculating unabsorbed home office overhead. No other formula may be used," and Melka Marine called it "the only means approved in our case law." Nicon read both statements in light of their facts, where work had started and then been interrupted.
The Army Corps of Engineers, Mobile District, awarded Nicon, a small Tampa contractor, a $1.4 million contract on March 30, 1998 to repair Dorm 371 at MacDill Air Force Base. A bid protest filed on April 3, 1998 suspended the contract before any repair work began. The protest was dismissed on July 15, 1998, no notice to proceed followed, and the government terminated for convenience on January 12, 1999, after 288 days in all.
After negotiation Nicon was awarded $184,757 for direct costs, related overhead and profit; the contracting officer denied $387,513 in unabsorbed overhead that Nicon computed with a modified formula: the contract price in place of billings and the planned performance period in place of days of performance. The Federal Circuit held that "constructive figures may not be substituted into the Eichleay formula."
The court also held that "there is no bar to the award of home office overhead in a termination for convenience settlement" when the other prerequisites are met and a reasonable method of allocation fits the facts, and it vacated and remanded. Judge Newman, concurring in part, called the formula "simply a mathematical equation for allocation of unreimbursed overhead costs."
Which expert does an Eichleay claim need?
One qualified for each opinion offered. In Alderman the ASBCA accepted Dr. Roger K. Seals as an expert in civil engineering, not cost accounting, and denied the $21,753 of direct standby costs he priced.
On March 27, 2009 the Navy awarded Alderman Building Company a task order for interior renovations and building system repairs to Building M403 at Marine Corps Base Camp Lejeune, North Carolina. Its electrical subcontractor was Big John's Electric Co. The board found "repeated government-caused delays that aggregated to 263 days," and the Navy later granted a 270-day time extension.
Alderman sponsored Big John's pass-through claim of $20,518, and the contracting officer denied it in full. During the appeal Dr. Seals recalculated the claim at $56,548: direct labor of $23,073, unabsorbed home office overhead of $33,218 and a bond premium of $257. He added $45,556 in interest and the cost of his reports. The Navy argued that the claim now exceeded $100,000; the board held that the $45,556 was not part of the claim and that the claim, at $56,548, stayed below that figure.
Dr. Seals, "a retired professor of Civil and Environmental Engineering at Louisiana State University," was accepted as "an expert in civil engineering." The board found "no credible evidence that Dr. Seals is qualified to render opinions regarding cost accounting issues" and did not accept his "equivalent hourly rate" pricing of $21,753 in direct standby costs.
The board also refused the jury verdict method. Under Dawco Construction, Inc. v. United States (Fed. Cir. 1991), that method needs "clear proof of injury" and proof that "there is no more reliable method of computing damages." The board deducted the $21,753, sustained the appeal for $34,795 with Contract Disputes Act interest, and denied the rest.
Do state courts accept the Eichleay formula?
Some do. In PDM Plumbing & Heating v. Findlen (1982), the Massachusetts Appeals Court affirmed a master who used the formula to measure a subcontractor's office overhead; the method only had to be fair.
In PDM Plumbing & Heating, Inc. v. Findlen (13 Mass. App. Ct. 950, February 17, 1982), the subcontractor sued over a construction delay that the opinion attributes partly to the owner and partly to the general contractor. A master found that the delay caused added costs, including office overhead, and the Superior Court entered judgment on his report.
The Appeals Court affirmed. The master did not have to use any particular method to compute office overhead for the delay period, only a fair one; where no precise method exists, the question is whether the method is reasonably calculated to measure the loss from the breach. The court held that two earlier cases, F.A. Bartlett Tree Expert Co. v. Hartney and Berley Industries v. New York, did not require a different result; in Berley it was unclear whether any overhead was attributable to the delay. In PDM the master found that overhead was actually incurred during the delay, so the formula only measured it.
Which records does an Eichleay calculation need?
Contract billings and total company billings for the contract period, the overhead pool for that period, the days of performance and of delay, and the orders, letters and invoices that show standby and replacement work.
The formula in Nicon uses five numbers: contract billings, total billings for the contract period, total overhead for the contract period, days of performance and days of delay. Singleton lost its termination overhead claim because one input of its allocation, total direct costs for 1993 and 1994, never reached the board.
In Alderman the board's standby findings rested on the July 7, 2009 suspension letter, the Navy's emails moving the start date and affidavits on rehiring. In P.J. Dick the court compared monthly direct billings before, during and after each delay.
On replacement work, the Alderman record held the award dates and amounts of five contracts and five invoices for a cumulative $188,452 under replacement contracts. In Satellite Electric the record showed 49 bids and two awards during the suspensions.
How does an Eichleay claim reach a decision?
Under 41 U.S.C. 7103 the contractor submits a written claim to the contracting officer within 6 years after it accrues and certifies a claim over $100,000. FAR 52.242-14 adds its own notice rules for suspension costs.
FAR 52.242-14, Suspension of Work (Apr 1984), lets the contracting officer order the contractor in writing to suspend, delay or interrupt all or part of the work. Under paragraph (b), an unreasonable suspension, delay or interruption caused by an act of the contracting officer, or a failure to act within the time the contract sets or a reasonable time, gives an adjustment for the increase in the cost of performance, excluding profit. There is no adjustment to the extent another cause, including the contractor's fault or negligence, would have delayed the work.
Paragraph (c) bars costs incurred more than 20 days before the contractor notified the contracting officer in writing, a limit that does not apply to claims arising from a suspension order. The claim, with its amount, is asserted in writing as soon as practicable after the suspension, delay or interruption ends, and no later than final payment.
Under 41 U.S.C. 7103, each contractor claim is in writing and submitted within 6 years after it accrues. For a claim over $100,000 the contractor certifies that it is made in good faith and that "the supporting data are accurate and complete to the best of the contractor's knowledge and belief." The contracting officer decides a claim of $100,000 or less within 60 days of a request; for a larger certified claim, the contracting officer decides within 60 days or states when a decision will issue.
How does IAE find an expert for an Eichleay claim?
In the IAE request choose the case type Construction and name the calculation, for example unabsorbed home office overhead under Eichleay. Within 5 business days IAE sends 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.
The construction expert witness page lists seven specialties, scheduling and cost estimating among them, and states that home office overhead for delay on a federal contract is computed with the Eichleay formula. The request form asks for the field of expertise, the case type, the state and court, the firm's side, the expert disclosure deadline and the parties with their counsel. In the short description, name the agency, the forum, the delay period, whether a written suspension order exists, and the part of the claim that needs an opinion: standby facts, the schedule, or the overhead pool and billings.
Within 1 business day IAE replies whether it can search in that field by that deadline. Candidate names and CVs come after the search fee is paid in advance. Each candidate confirms in writing that he or she has no ties to the parties or their counsel; on a federal project the list can include the agency, the prime contractor, the subcontractor whose claim is sponsored and the surety.
For each candidate the firm receives a CV, hourly rates, testimony in the last 4 years and publications in the last 10 years, the lists that Rule 26(a)(2)(B) requires. If no candidate fits, the second search is free, and if IAE finds no candidates, it refunds the fee. The expert bills the firm directly or through IAE under the agency option, with the search fee credited to the first invoice. The expert's hourly rate never depends on the outcome of the case or on the content of testimony.
IAE is not a law firm. Case strategy and the decision to retain an expert stay with the attorney.
Sources
- Appeal of Alderman Building Company, Inc., ASBCA No. 58082 (May 21, 2020)
- Nicon, Inc. v. United States, 331 F.3d 878 (Fed. Cir. 2003) (Justia)
- P.J. Dick Inc. v. Principi, 324 F.3d 1364 (Fed. Cir. 2003) (OpenJurist)
- Satellite Electric Co. v. Dalton, 105 F.3d 1418 (Fed. Cir. 1997) (Justia)
- Interstate General Government Contractors, Inc. v. West, 12 F.3d 1053 (Fed. Cir. 1993) (Justia)
- Singleton Contracting Corp. v. Harvey, No. 04-1119 (Fed. Cir. January 26, 2005)
- PDM Plumbing & Heating, Inc. v. Findlen, 13 Mass. App. Ct. 950 (1982) (copy of the opinion)
- FAR 31.203, Indirect costs (acquisition.gov)
- FAR 52.242-14, Suspension of Work (acquisition.gov)
- 41 U.S.C. 7103, Decision by contracting officer (LII)
Read also
All articles
Spearin doctrine: when does the owner bear the cost of defective plans and specifications, and what does the contractor's expert have to prove?
Under the Spearin doctrine, an owner who gives the contractor plans and specifications impliedly warrants that work built to them will be adequate
Differing site conditions claim: what must the contractor prove, and which experts carry the proof?
A differing site conditions claim asks the owner to pay for ground the contract did not describe. On federal projects the clause is FAR 52.236-2
SB 800 construction defect claims in California: which standards apply, what comes before a lawsuit and what must the expert prove?
SB 800, enacted in 2002, governs construction defect claims against builders of new homes in California. Civil Code section 896 lists buildingExpert witnesses
Need an expert witness for your case?
Describe the question, the case type and the court. Within 5 business days you receive 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

