Letter review
What must an experience letter for an I-140 include, and why do officers reject it?
An I-140 petition based on a labor certification has to prove that the worker held the required experience by the priority date. Under 8 CFR 204.5(g)(1), that proof takes the form of letters from current or former employers with the writer's name, address and title and a specific description of the duties. AAO decisions from 2019, 2020 and 2024 name the letters that fell short and the records the officer asked for instead.

What must an experience letter for an I-140 contain?
The name, address and title of the writer and a specific description of the duties the worker performed. The rule is in 8 CFR 204.5(g)(1), and 204.5(l)(3)(ii)(A) repeats it for EB-3 petitions.
The general rule for employment-based immigrant petitions sits in 8 CFR 204.5(g)(1): "Evidence relating to qualifying experience or training shall be in the form of letter(s) from current or former employer(s) or trainer(s) and shall include the name, address, and title of the writer, and a specific description of the duties performed by the alien or of the training received."
Paragraph (l)(3)(ii)(A), which governs skilled workers, professionals and other workers, states the same requirement in its own words. Requirements of training or experience "must be supported by letters from trainers or employers giving the name, address, and title of the trainer or employer, and a description of the training received or the experience of the alien."
Neither paragraph mentions letterhead, a notary or a fixed format. The text names four elements: who wrote the letter, where the writer can be reached, the writer's position and what the worker did. In a 2020 decision the AAO also faulted a certificate of employment that did not say whether the work was full-time or part-time and whose start date differed from the labor certification.
Which I-140 categories rely on experience letters?
EB-2 petitions that use a bachelor's degree plus five years of progressive experience, EB-3 skilled workers with at least two years of experience, and any petition whose labor certification lists experience as a minimum requirement.
For EB-2, paragraph (k)(3)(i)(B) accepts "An official academic record showing that the alien has a United States baccalaureate degree or a foreign equivalent degree, and evidence in the form of letters from current or former employer(s) showing that the alien has at least five years of progressive post-baccalaureate experience in the specialty." Paragraph (k)(2) treats that combination as the equivalent of a master's degree.
For EB-3, paragraph (l)(2) defines a skilled worker as a person capable "of performing skilled labor (requiring at least two years training or experience)." Paragraph (l)(3)(ii)(B) adds: "The minimum requirements for this classification are at least two years of training or experience." The same paragraph requires evidence that the worker "meets the educational, training or experience, and any other requirements of the individual labor certification."
A professional under (l)(3)(ii)(C) needs a U.S. baccalaureate or foreign equivalent degree, and an other worker under (l)(3)(ii)(D) must meet "any educational, training and experience, and other requirements of the labor certification." Any experience requirement on top of the degree is proved by letters under (l)(3)(ii)(A).
In every one of these categories the labor certification sets the bar. If it requires 24 months in the job offered, the letters have to account for 24 months in that job or in an alternative occupation the certification accepts.
By what date must the experience be complete?
By the priority date. For a petition with a labor certification, that is the date the Department of Labor accepted the application for processing. Experience gained after that date does not count.
Paragraph (d) of 8 CFR 204.5 sets the priority date of a petition with an individual labor certification as "the date the labor certification application was accepted for processing by any office of the Department of Labor."
In a decision of May 2, 2024 (In Re: 32462814), the AAO stated the rule: "A petitioner must establish a beneficiary's possession of all the education, training, and experience specified on an accompanying labor certification by a petition's priority date." It cited 8 CFR 103.2(b)(1) and (12) and Matter of Wing's Tea House, 16 I&N Dec. 158 (Acting Reg'l Comm'r 1977). Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(1), a petitioner "must establish that he or she is eligible for the requested benefit at the time of filing the benefit request and must continue to be eligible through adjudication."
The AAO applied the same rule to a license in a decision of October 1, 2020 (In Re: 11105889). The labor certification for a truck driver required 12 months of experience and an Illinois commercial driver's license or one obtained within 45 days of employment. The AAO wrote: "Thus, we cannot permit the Beneficiary to meet an offered position's requirements after a petition's priority date."
For experience letters this means two checks. The counted period must end on or before the priority date, and months after it stay out of the total even if the worker kept the same job.
Do the letters have to match the labor certification?
Yes. The dates, employers and positions in the letters are compared with the work history on the labor certification. In 2020 the AAO asked for an explanation of a nine-day difference in a start date.
In a decision of November 23, 2020 (In Re: 9502551), the petitioner sought EB-3 skilled worker status for an alterations tailor. The labor certification required two years of experience in the job offered, and the priority date was July 30, 2015. The record held a translated certificate of employment dated September 2004, which stated that the worker had been employed as a seamstress/tailor "from January 10, 2001 until June 30, 2004."
The labor certification gave January 1, 2001 as the start date. The AAO wrote: "The start dates on the labor certification and on the certificate of employment are not consistent." It also noted that the labor certification did not list the beneficiary's employment with a different employer, and directed the Director to ask the petitioner why that employment was left off.
The AAO remanded the case. It directed the Director to request "an explanation of the discrepancy in the start dates", whether the employment was full-time or part-time, "an employment letter that satisfies the requirements of 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(g)(1)", and a certificate from an independent source, "such as the National Tax Service of South Korea and/or the National Pension Service of South Korea."
What makes an experience letter insufficient?
A letter that gives a job and dates but describes no duties, does not say whether the work was full-time, or has no contact details for its author. The AAO named all three gaps in its 2020 decision.
In the November 2020 decision the AAO found that "the certificate is not sufficient evidence to establish the Beneficiary's employment experience because it does not describe the duties she performed, it does not state whether the position was full-time or part-time, and it does not have the author's contact information." It cited 8 CFR 204.5(g)(1).
Duties are the link between the letter and the labor certification, which describes a specific job. A letter limited to a job title and two dates gives the officer nothing to compare with the duties listed for the job offered.
Schedule matters because the requirement is counted in months. Twenty-four months of full-time work and twenty-four months of part-time work are different facts, and the letter is the document expected to say which one it was.
Paragraph (g)(1) lists the writer's address among the required elements. The 2020 decision counted the absence of the author's contact information against the certificate.
Can a former coworker write the letter instead of the employer?
Only with support. In 2024 the AAO dismissed an EB-3 appeal that rested on letters from former coworkers, because the petitioner neither showed that employer letters were unavailable nor filed payroll or tax records.
In the May 2024 decision the petitioner, an oilfield services company, offered a snubbing superintendent position. The labor certification required "96 months of experience in a related snubbing services position, with no education." The petitioner filed five letters, all dated July 2021, from former coworkers who had held operations, manager and supervisor positions; three of the letters came from one author.
The Director found the letters insufficient "because the letters were issued by former employees of the Beneficiary's former employers and not by the former employers directly." The AAO agreed: "Here, the Petitioner relies only on testimonial evidence from the Beneficiary's former coworkers in attempt to establish his claimed employment experience, without providing independent, objective evidence in support of this testimony."
The AAO then listed what was missing. "The Petitioner does not assert that letters from the Beneficiary's former employers are unavailable." The record also lacked "other documentation to corroborate the Beneficiary's claimed employment, such as income tax or payroll records," and "The Petitioner does not assert that these records are unavailable for any reason."
One letter had a problem of its own. Its author described the beneficiary's work with the company from September 1, 2000, "when his own employment did not begin until 2007," and the AAO noted that he "does not explain how he has information about or can attest to the Beneficiary's employment." The appeal was dismissed.
Can experience gained with the sponsoring employer count?
Only if it was gained in a position not substantially comparable to the job offered, which means the worker did not perform the same duties more than half of the time. Otherwise the employer cannot rely on it.
Under 20 CFR 656.17(i)(3), when the worker is already employed by the sponsoring employer, "The employer can not require domestic worker applicants to possess training and/or experience beyond what the alien possessed at the time of hire unless" the worker gained the experience "in a position not substantially comparable to the position for which certification is being sought," or the employer can show that "it is no longer feasible to train a worker to qualify for the position."
Paragraph (i)(5)(ii) defines a substantially comparable job or position as one "requiring performance of the same job duties more than 50 percent of the time."
The AAO applied the rule in an EB-2 case decided on December 2, 2019 (case 6221755). The job was database administrator. The labor certification required a U.S. master's degree or foreign equivalent in computer science or mechanical engineering and 12 months in the job offered or as a programmer analyst, including 12 months using Teradata and Informatica. The only experience letter, dated January 24, 2017, confirmed the worker's employment with the petitioner as a programmer analyst from August 20, 2015.
The AAO found that both positions appeared responsible for the petitioner's database work with Teradata and Informatica, so the earlier job looked substantially comparable and the petitioner could not rely on it. The record held no other evidence of prior experience. The AAO remanded the case and told the Director to request more evidence of the worker's qualifications.
What happens when the letters contradict each other?
The petitioner has to resolve the conflict with independent, objective evidence. Statements by counsel in a brief carry no evidentiary weight, so the explanation has to come with documents.
In a footnote to the 2024 decision the AAO noted that the beneficiary's claimed work in Ukraine, which ran through April 2013, "overlaps with his claimed employment on the labor certification" in Gabon from March 2013. The AAO said the overlap was not a basis for its decision and that the petitioner must resolve it in any further filings. The decision cites Matter of Ho, 19 I&N Dec. 582 (BIA 1988), for the rule: "The Petitioner must resolve inconsistencies with independent, objective evidence pointing to where the truth lies."
Arguments on appeal do not replace that evidence. Counsel's brief argued that each letter writer was a former employer because the writers had employed the beneficiary in their own earlier positions. The AAO rejected the argument as unsupported and cited Matter of S-M-, 22 I&N Dec. 49 (BIA 1998): "statements in a brief, motion, or Notice of Appeal are not evidence and thus are not entitled to any evidentiary weight."
An overlap between two full-time jobs has to be explained with the dates and the schedule of each job. The letters are where that information appears, and the 2020 decision treated a missing schedule as a defect in its own right.
What should be checked in experience letters before filing?
The writer's name, address and title, a specific description of duties, exact dates, full-time or part-time status, consistency with the labor certification, the cut-off at the priority date and third-party records for any gap.
Each point below comes from 8 CFR 204.5(g)(1), 20 CFR 656.17(i) or a gap that the AAO named in the 2019, 2020 and 2024 decisions.
- Each letter gives the name, address and title of the writer, and the writer worked at the company during the period the letter covers.
- Each letter describes the duties in enough detail to compare them with the job offered or with the alternative occupation accepted on the labor certification.
- Each letter gives the start and end date of every position, and the dates match the work history on the labor certification to the day.
- Each letter states whether the work was full-time or part-time.
- The months counted end on or before the priority date and add up to the experience the labor certification requires.
- Experience with the sponsoring employer is counted only if the earlier position was not substantially comparable to the job offered under 20 CFR 656.17(i)(5)(ii).
- No two claimed full-time jobs overlap unless records explain the overlap.
- Where an employer letter cannot be obtained, the file says why and adds records kept by a third party, such as tax, payroll or pension records, before it relies on statements from coworkers.
- A letter or certificate in a foreign language carries a full English translation certified under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(3).
What does IAE check in an experience evaluation?
A reviewer from the IAE registry checks the methodology, the evaluator's authority and the weak points of a degree or experience evaluation, and returns a signed 3-5 page review with a verdict: file, revise or redo.
The IAE expert letter review covers expert opinion letters and credential evaluations. The service page lists four situations: a check before filing, a diagnosis after an RFE, a comparison of two providers and the review of a degree or experience evaluation. For an evaluation, the reviewer assesses the methodology, the evaluator's authority and the weak points.
An evaluation that counts years of work relies on employer letters. The review lists the weak points of the evaluation with a way to strengthen each and ends with one of three verdicts, each with reasoning: file, revise or redo. After an RFE, the review diagnoses whether the officer's findings stem from the expert letter or evaluation and what to strengthen.
The review runs to 3-5 pages and is signed by a reviewer from the IAE registry in the relevant field. The reviewer is independent of the provider of the document under review and confirms this in writing. The materials are kept confidential.
To order, send the document and a short description of the petition. The secretariat confirms the fee, the turnaround and the reviewer within one business day, and the fee depends on the visa category and the volume of materials. The standard turnaround is 3 business days from payment and receipt of all materials, or 1 business day on the rush option. IAE is not a law firm, and USCIS decides the petition.
Sources
- 8 CFR 204.5, Petitions for employment-based immigrants (LII)
- 8 CFR 103.2, Submission and adjudication of benefit requests (govinfo, 2023 edition)
- 20 CFR 656.17, Basic labor certification process (LII)
- AAO non-precedent decision, In Re: 32462814 (May 2, 2024)
- AAO non-precedent decision, In Re: 9502551 (November 23, 2020)
- AAO non-precedent decision, In Re: 11105889 (October 1, 2020)
- AAO non-precedent decision, case 6221755 (December 2, 2019)
Read also
All articles
Indian three-year bachelor's plus two-year master's: does USCIS count it as an advanced degree for EB-2?
In AAO decisions of 2017 and 2019 an Indian master's degree was placed at the level of a U.S. bachelor's degree. In 2017 the AAO cited EDGE. In 2019
Foreign medical degree (MBBS or MD) for USCIS: when is it an advanced degree, and what must the evaluation show?
A U.S. medical degree is an advanced degree for USCIS because U.S. medical schools admit students after a bachelor's. Many foreign schools admit them
USCIS cited AACRAO EDGE against your credential evaluation: what happens next?
When a credential evaluation and the AACRAO EDGE database disagree, USCIS may follow EDGE. In Viraj v. U.S. Attorney General (11th Cir. 2014)Expert letter review
Check the letter before the officer does
The standard turnaround is 3 business days, the rush option 1 business day. The fee depends on the visa category and the volume of materials; we confirm the fee, the turnaround and the reviewer within one business day.

