Expert witnesses

What happens if your expert witness dies or withdraws before trial?

When a disclosed expert dies, falls ill or withdraws after the disclosure deadline, the party has to ask the court to change the scheduling order, which under Rule 16(b)(4) needs good cause. Federal courts granted substitution in Shipp v. Hoffman (2019) and Vincent v. Omniflight (2009) but limited the new expert to the subject and opinions of the old one. In Dennis v. Sherman (2010) a substitute who went further was excluded.

A coat and a closed report rest on an empty courtroom bench, a person leaving through the door

Can you replace an expert witness after the disclosure deadline?

Yes, with the court's permission. The party moves to modify the scheduling order, which under Rule 16(b)(4) may be changed only for good cause and with the judge's consent.

Under Rule 16(b)(3)(A), "the scheduling order must limit the time to join other parties, amend the pleadings, complete discovery, and file motions." Expert disclosure dates are part of that order. Rule 16(b)(4) states: "A schedule may be modified only for good cause and with the judge's consent."

A new expert named after the deadline without a court order is a late disclosure, and the other side can move to exclude the new expert. The motion to substitute is therefore the first step, filed as soon as the party learns that its expert cannot testify.

In the orders discussed below, the reason for the change decided the first question. Death is outside the party's control. A withdrawal that follows a false entry in the expert's CV, as in Vincent v. Omniflight, came with a condition attached.

What counts as good cause when an expert dies?

The death itself, if the party then acts promptly. In Shipp v. Hoffman (W.D. Ark. 2019) the court found that the expert's death could not have been foreseen and that the plaintiff was diligent.

In Shipp v. Hoffman, No. 4:18-cv-04017 (W.D. Ark. Aug. 27, 2019), the plaintiff's jail medicine expert was deposed on June 7, 2019. On July 25 counsel learned that he had "passed away shortly after the date of his deposition." On August 1 the plaintiff moved under Rule 16(b) to designate a substitute.

Judge Susan O. Hickey asked first whether there was good cause, quoting the Eighth Circuit: "The primary measure of good cause is the movant's diligence." She found that the death "could not have been foreseen by Plaintiff and was not within his control," and that the plaintiff had notified the parties and the court promptly. Only then did she consider prejudice to the defendants.

The defendants argued that trial was set for October 21, 2019, and that they had built their strategy around the deceased expert. The court answered that a continuance could be requested if the substitution could not be completed in time.

What limits do courts put on the substitute expert?

The new expert usually stays within the subject matter and theories of the original. In Shipp the opinions had to be substantively similar and could not be contrary to or inconsistent with the original expert's opinions.

The Shipp order stated the purpose of substitution: "to put the movant in the same position it would have been in but for the need to change experts." A party that loses its expert does not get a better one through the substitution.

The substitute's testimony was limited to the original expert's subject matter and theories. The opinions had to be "substantively similar" and "cannot be contrary to or inconsistent with" the original opinions. The court added that the substitute did not have to adopt the original conclusions "verbatim," and that the defendants could move to exclude any new theory.

The defendants also had to be given an opportunity to depose the substitute. That deposition is where the comparison with the original report and deposition is made.

What happens if the substitute expert goes further than the original?

The court can exclude the new opinions. In Dennis v. Sherman (W.D. Tenn. 2010) the court excluded the substitute because her opinions contradicted the deceased expert on who should have treated the patient and on the standard of care.

Dennis v. Sherman, No. 1:08-cv-01055 (W.D. Tenn. Oct. 4, 2010) was a medical malpractice case brought by a patient's widow. The plaintiff's expert died after his deposition and before trial, and the court allowed a substitute under an earlier order that limited her to the scope of the original testimony.

The defendant moved in limine to exclude the substitute. Judge J. Daniel Breen compared the two experts and found contradictions on which doctor should have treated the patient, on another physician's diagnosis and on whether that physician met the standard of care. He granted the motion and found that the substitute's opinions "unfairly prejudice[] the Defendant."

In Dennis the checks came in two stages. On March 9, 2010 the court granted a substitute under an order that limited her to the subject matter and opinions in the original expert's deposition. After the defendant's motion in limine, the court compared her opinions with that deposition point by point and found contradictions on the type of doctor, the other physician's diagnosis and the standard of care, but no clear contradiction on when surgery was last viable.

What if the expert withdraws instead of dying?

Courts weigh the reason for the change, the importance of the testimony, the prejudice and whether a continuance can cure it. In Vincent v. Omniflight (2009) the plaintiff's side had to reimburse the defense's deposition costs.

In Vincent v. Omniflight Helicopters, No. 1:08-cv-00572 (E.D. Wis. Nov. 24, 2009), the plaintiff's expert on FAA certification withdrew three days after a six-hour deposition. Defense counsel had shown at the deposition that his qualifications profile listed memberships and degrees he could not substantiate.

Judge William C. Griesbach applied four factors from Betzel v. State Farm Lloyds (5th Cir. 2007): the explanation for failing to identify the witness on time, the importance of the testimony, the potential prejudice, and the availability of a continuance to cure it. He granted the substitution "conditioned upon plaintiff reimbursing the defendants" for the cost of preparing for and taking the withdrawn expert's deposition.

In Vincent the plaintiff kept its claim, but its side had to reimburse the defense's work on the first expert, a cost the court presumed counsel would bear, and had to retain a second expert. A conflict and credential check before retention addresses that risk before the disclosure deadline.

Can the parties agree on a substitute without a contested motion?

Yes. In Stewart v. Cassidy (E.D. Cal. 2015) the parties stipulated after the defense expert died, and the court set a date for the new expert, an immediate deposition and a new trial date.

In Stewart v. Cassidy, No. 2:14-cv-00326 (E.D. Cal. Apr. 14, 2015), the defendant's dental expert died before trial. The parties filed a stipulation, and Magistrate Judge Carolyn K. Delaney accepted it, "good cause appearing."

The order allowed the defendant to substitute a new expert by April 30, 2015 and required the defendant to produce the expert "promptly for immediate deposition." Discovery motions about the new expert were due by May 13. The plaintiff agreed not to use the fact that the new expert had not examined the plaintiff for impeachment. Both sides reserved the right to ask for a jury instruction about the death. The final pretrial conference moved to May 27 and the jury trial to June 15, 2015.

Can the deceased expert's deposition be read at trial instead?

It can be used under Rule 32(a)(4)(A) if the witness is dead and the Rule 32(a)(1) conditions are met. Former testimony is also a hearsay exception under Evidence Rule 804(b)(1).

Rule 32(a)(4) lets a party use the deposition of a witness who is unavailable, and the first ground is "that the witness is dead." Rule 32(a)(1) adds three conditions: the party against whom it is used "was present or represented at the taking of the deposition or had reasonable notice of it," the use is to the extent the testimony would be admissible "if the deponent were present and testifying," and the use is allowed by Rule 32(a)(2) through (8).

Under Federal Rule of Evidence 804(a)(4), a declarant is unavailable if he or she "cannot be present or testify at the trial or hearing because of death or a then-existing infirmity, physical illness, or mental illness." Rule 804(b)(1) admits former testimony given at a lawful deposition if the party against whom it is offered had "an opportunity and similar motive to develop it" by examination.

When the other side took the deposition, the questions were its own, and the transcript may lack the direct testimony the party needs. In Shipp the court declined to require the plaintiff to rely on the deceased expert's deposition and noted that "oral testimony is the preferred form of testimonial evidence."

What should counsel do when an expert drops out?

Notify the court and the other side at once, move to modify the scheduling order, retain a substitute in the same field, and give the substitute the original report and deposition to stay within their scope.

The cases above reward speed. In Shipp the motion was filed a week after counsel learned of the death, and the court counted that diligence as good cause.

The steps follow from the orders:

  • Tell the court and opposing counsel in writing on the day the party learns that the expert cannot testify.
  • File a motion to modify the scheduling order under Rule 16(b)(4), with the facts of the death, illness or withdrawal and the dates.
  • Retain a substitute in the same specialty who can work from the original report, its data and the deposition transcript.
  • Have the substitute state where his or her opinions match the original and list any point that differs, so the court can decide on it before trial.
  • Offer the other side a deposition of the substitute and ask the court for a continuance if the trial date cannot hold.

How does IAE find a replacement expert?

Within 1 business day IAE replies whether it can search by the deadline, and within 5 business days it sends 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates, 4 years of testimony and 10 years of publications.

The request form on the IAE expert witness page asks for the field of expertise, the case type, the state and court, the firm's side, the expert disclosure deadline, the parties and their counsel for the conflict check and a short description of the case. For a substitution, the description names the original expert's field and the dates set by the court. The search costs $2,000 per case, paid in advance, and candidate names and CVs come after payment.

Each candidate confirms in writing that he or she has no ties to the parties or their counsel. If no candidate fits, the second search is free, and if no candidates are found, the fee is refunded.

The firm chooses the expert, who bills the firm directly or through IAE under the agency option. The expert's hourly rate never depends on the outcome of the case or on the content of testimony. IAE is not a law firm: whether to move for substitution and how to present the case stay with the attorney.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert witnesses

Need an expert witness for your case?

Describe the question, the case type and the court. Within 5 business days you receive 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

Expert request

Received

Candidates, rates and prior testimony within 5 business days

Candidates2-3 with CVs
Timeline5 business days
Search$2,000 per case