Awards

Awards you pay to enter: what does USCIS check in a prize for EB-1A?

Neither 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(i) nor Chapter 2 of the USCIS Policy Manual says that an entry fee disqualifies an award. USCIS asks whether the applicant personally received the award and whether the field recognizes it nationally or internationally for excellence. The AAO weighs the selection criteria, the number of winners, limits on competitors and recognition outside the organizer. A fabricated certificate leads to a finding of willful misrepresentation.

A person from behind holds a blank trophy in a shop of glossy awards, tags out of focus

What does USCIS check in an award for the EB-1A prizes criterion?

Two things. First, that the applicant personally received the prize or award. Second, that the award is a lesser nationally or internationally recognized prize for excellence in the field. An entry fee is not part of either step.

The criterion is the first of ten in 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3): "Documentation of the alien's receipt of lesser nationally or internationally recognized prizes or awards for excellence in the field of endeavor." The Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2 applies it in two steps. "First, USCIS determines if the person was the recipient of prizes or awards." Second, USCIS determines "whether the award is a lesser nationally or internationally recognized prize or award which the person received for excellence in the field of endeavor."

The AAO reads three conditions into the same sentence. In its decision of September 27, 2023 on a professional surfer (In Re: 28154174) it wrote that "the evidence must establish that the Petitioner is the recipient of prizes or awards, that the awards are nationally or internationally recognized, and that each prize or award is one for excellence in the field of endeavor."

The name of the organizer does not settle the second step. In a decision of December 18, 2024 (In Re: 33756110) the AAO wrote that "while the prestige of an awarding entity may help establish the recognition level of a prize or award, the plain language of the regulation requires a showing that the prize itself is nationally or internationally recognized" as a mark of excellence in the person's field.

The bar sits below the Nobel Prize. Chapter 2 says that "this criterion does not require an award or prize to have the same level of recognition and prestige associated with the Nobel Prize or another award that would qualify as a one-time achievement." A Nobel-level award is a separate route to EB-1A, and for that route the chapter says: "There is no comparable evidence for the one-time achievement of a major, international recognized award."

Does an entry fee disqualify an award?

Not under the written rules: 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(i) and Chapter 2 of the Policy Manual do not mention fees. In 2015 the AAO recorded a competition's entry fees, drew no conclusion from them and rejected the awards on other grounds.

Chapter 2 introduces its list of considerations for the second step with the words "include, but are not limited to." The AAO repeats the list in its decisions. In the decision of February 5, 2024 on a veterinary researcher (In Re: 28282807) the factors read: "the criteria used to grant the award; its national or international significance in the field;" and "the number of awardees; and any limitations on competitors." A fee paid by the entrant is not on that list.

On March 16, 2015 the AAO decided the appeal of a branding and design agency that had petitioned for an art director and designer as an alien of extraordinary ability in the arts (Texas Service Center appeal, March 16, 2015). The record included a Gold award in the Real Estate category, a Bronze award in the Computer-Generated Character category, material about a design awards gala and a Silver award for a magazine redesign.

The AAO quoted the organizer of the Gold award: "up to 1,000 Platinum, Gold, Silver and Merit awards will be honored and archived on the website annually." The AAO also quoted the organizer's statements that "winners can order certificates for $25 each" and that trophies "are available to all winners for $250 each." In footnote 4 the AAO noted that the organizer of one competition "charges a $250 fee for the first entry and $195 fee for each additional entry." The AAO described these payments and drew no conclusion from them.

The awards failed on other grounds. The record did not say how many entries competed in the Real Estate category. The AAO pointed to the number of awards the competition confers each year and found no documentary evidence that the Gold award was recognized beyond its organizer. At the gala only the six top "of the Year" awards would be "called on stage to receive their trophy." The Silver award was presented to a magazine, not to the beneficiary. The conclusion reads: "Accordingly, the petitioner has not established that the beneficiary meets this regulatory criterion."

Why does an award with hundreds of winners fail the criterion?

The number of awardees is one of the factors USCIS weighs. In 2023 the AAO wrote that a competition's large number of winners each year suggested that selection was not based on excellence in the field.

The petitioner in the decision of October 12, 2023 (In Re: 28403260) was a DJ and sound producer. He relied on a "Playlist honor" from a competition for artists who wanted their music played in a park or a skating rink. The AAO noted evidence of "500 winning tracks" among 20 to 30 winning participants each year and wrote: "The competition's large number of winners each year further suggests that selection is not based on excellence in the field."

The AAO also held that the honor "is neither an award or prize, nor is it granted for excellence in the field of DJ'ing or sound producing." Material about earlier winners did not change the result. The petitioner "provided little evidence to establish that these past winners enjoy national or international acclaim such that it would suggest the honor is nationally or internationally recognized."

On appeal he stressed that the competition was open to artists from many countries. The AAO answered: "While we acknowledge the international nature of the competitors, the Petitioner has not provided sufficient evidence showing that winning the competition is a prize or award, that it is for excellence in DJ'ing or sound production, or that it is nationally or internationally recognized in the field." The appeal was dismissed.

Do awards from an employer, a school or a city count?

Chapter 2 of the Policy Manual says an award available only within one locality, employer or school may have little national or international recognition. An award open to members of a professional organization may be nationally recognized.

The full sentence in Chapter 2 reads: "For example, an award available only to persons within a single locality, employer, or school may have little national or international recognition, while an award open to members of a well-known national institution (including an R1 or R2 doctoral university) or professional organization may be nationally recognized."

In the decision of December 18, 2024 the petitioner was a hospital that had filed for a rehabilitation therapist working in art therapy. One prize was limited to students of ceramics in a college art department. A scholarship was limited to fine arts students at a named college or two other colleges in the local area. The AAO wrote: "The certificate of excellence in ceramics and the art department scholarship, which are awarded to art students rather than practicing art therapists, are therefore not prizes in her field." It added that prizes open to members of well-known national institutions such as high-level research universities may qualify, while prizes limited to competitors within a certain locality or school generally lack a national or international level of recognition. The record had no documentation of either award being recognized by anyone outside the awarding entities.

In the February 2024 decision the veterinary researcher's awards "honored only students and excluded more educated and experienced competitors in the field," and "the record lacks sufficient evidence of the awards' national or international recognition beyond organization members."

A limit on competitors does not end the inquiry. Chapter 2 calls it "a relevant factor" and says that an award limited to youth, amateur competitors or early-career professionals can still be shown to have national or international recognition. Its example: awards presented to new players or "rookies" in major sports leagues "may garner national or even international media coverage."

Is a letter from the award organizer enough?

No. In November 2023 the AAO wrote that letters from the awarding entities alone are not direct evidence of recognition of the awards beyond those entities. Recognition has to be documented outside the organizer.

The decision of November 15, 2023 (In Re: 27693286) concerned a writer. The AAO wrote: "The Petitioner must establish the recognition of the awards she received. Information about the awarding entities, or the events where she received the awards, do not suffice in this regard. Letters from the awarding entities alone are not direct evidence of recognition of the awards beyond those entities."

The decision of December 7, 2023 (In Re: 28980948) concerned a project manager in augmented and virtual reality who relied on a Certificate of Merit. In response to a request for evidence, the petitioner filed a letter about the certificate from a director, K-M-S-. The AAO wrote: "The letter does not discuss the field's view of the Certificate of Merit or explain why the award is considered to be nationally or internationally recognized for excellence."

On material published by organizers, the AAO wrote in the 2015 decision: "USCIS need not rely on self-promotional material." It cited Braga v. Poulos, No. CV 06 5105 SJO, aff'd 317 Fed. Appx. 680 (C.A.9), "concluding that USCIS did not have to rely on self-serving assertions on the cover of a magazine as to the magazine's status as major media."

Which documents prove that an award is nationally or internationally recognized?

Evidence from outside the organizer: the selection criteria, the reputation of the jury, the geographic scope, the number of entrants and winners, earlier winners and their standing, and coverage of the results in national or international media.

In the surfing case the Director listed what the evidence should cover: "the criteria used to grant the awards, their significance (including the national or international recognition associated with the awards), the reputation of the organization or panel granting the awards, the geographic scope of the awards and any limitations on competitors, the number of awards or prizes granted, evidence related to previous award winners, and public announcements of the awards."

The surfer also relied on 9th place finishes in WQS competitions. The Director observed that no publications or news outlets with a national or international audience had reported on those finishes. The AAO agreed and wrote: "For these reasons, this criterion has not been met."

Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(3), "Any document containing foreign language submitted to USCIS shall be accompanied by a full English language translation which the translator has certified as complete and accurate." A certificate in another language without such a translation is not usable evidence of the award.

  • Obtain the official rules of the award: who may enter, how entries are judged and who sits on the jury.
  • State the number of entries and the number of winners in the applicant's category for the year of the award, with the source of each figure.
  • Attach the organizer's published announcement of the results in which the applicant's name appears.
  • Add coverage of the results by national or international media that the organizer did not publish itself.
  • Add information on earlier winners of the same award and their standing in the field.
  • Attach certified English translations of every document in another language.

How do USCIS and the AAO check whether an award is genuine?

They compare certificates with the organizer's public records, follow web links printed on submitted articles, ask for originals and for information about the organizer, and issue notices of intent to deny when the evidence conflicts.

Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(5), "USCIS may, at any time, request submission of an original document for review." The request sets a deadline, and "Failure to submit the requested original document by the deadline may result in denial or revocation of the underlying benefit request."

In the surfing case the petitioner claimed a bronze medal at a 2006 junior event. The AAO checked the online ranking data of the organizer, ISA: for that under-18 event it credited 3rd place among U18 women to another Brazilian surfer, D-S-, not to the petitioner. A photograph of the petitioner with an award did not settle it, and the AAO wrote: "The Petitioner must resolve this inconsistency and ambiguity in the record with independent, objective evidence pointing to where the truth lies." It cited Matter of Ho, 19 I&N Dec. 582, 591-92 (BIA 1988).

In the writer's case, "Efforts to verify the Petitioner's evidence, by following the web links printed on the submitted articles, showed that at least three of these articles were falsified, with the Petitioner's name, photograph, and other information inserted into existing articles that were actually about other people." The authentic article at the link provided named a different author as the winner of the award. The AAO also noted: "The certificate purporting to show the Petitioner's receipt of the 2019 Award is dated 2009."

In the decision of December 14, 2023 (In Re: 27007829) a singer and composer filed cell phone pictures of himself holding what appeared to be an award certificate. The Director questioned the award because the record lacked information about it. The AAO described the picture as appearing staged, with the caption "first time in New York." Other photos showed certificates and statuettes with untranslated or illegible text. The Director's notice of intent to deny asked about the organizations that gave the awards. The petitioner answered the notice without that evidence, and the AAO issued its own notice in November 2023.

Two rules govern such requests. Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(14), "Failure to submit requested evidence which precludes a material line of inquiry shall be grounds for denying" the request. Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(16)(i), a decision based on derogatory information requires that the petitioner be told of it and given a chance to rebut it before the decision.

What happens if an award certificate turns out to be fabricated?

The AAO enters a finding that the petitioner willfully misrepresented material facts. Under INA 212(a)(6)(C)(i) the finding can make the person inadmissible later. 18 U.S.C. 1546(a) sets criminal penalties for knowingly false statements.

The AAO quoted the statute in the singer's case: "Any noncitizen who, by fraud or willfully misrepresenting a material fact, seeks to procure (or has sought to procure or has procured) a visa, other documentation, or admission into the United States or other benefit provided under the Act is inadmissible. Section 212(a)(6)(C)(i) of the Act, 8 U.S.C. § 1182(a)(6)(C)(i)." The text is on the U.S. Code site under 8 U.S.C. 1182(a)(6)(C)(i).

The same decision defines the terms. "Material misrepresentation requires only a false statement that is material and willfully made." "The term "willfully" means knowing and intentionally, as distinguished from accidentally, inadvertently, or in an honest belief that the facts are otherwise," citing Matter of Healy and Goodchild, 17 I&N Dec. 22, 28 (BIA 1979).

The finding followed: "we find that the Petitioner willfully misrepresented material facts in seeking to procure a benefit under the Act." The AAO explained that "The information in the falsified awards is material to the petition because it relates to eligibility for the criteria" and warned: "Our finding may render him inadmissible in future proceedings where admissibility is an issue." The order reads: "ORDER: The appeal is dismissed."

In the writer's case the AAO held the falsification willful because the petitioner's name and image had been substituted for the names and images of other people. It made the same finding.

The Policy Manual, Volume 8, Part J, Chapter 1 states that "an alien could be found inadmissible for using fraud or willful misrepresentation when seeking any benefit under the INA." It also says that "There are exceptions and waivers to inadmissibility due to fraud or willful misrepresentation" available under certain circumstances. The waiver under INA 212(i) is covered in Volume 9, Part F.

Criminal liability sits in 18 U.S.C. 1546(a). It reaches anyone who, under oath or under penalty of perjury, "knowingly subscribes as true, any false statement with respect to a material fact in any application, affidavit, or other document required by the immigration laws." Outside terrorism and drug trafficking cases, the maximum prison term is 10 years for a first or second offense and 15 years for any other offense.

Does one doubtful award affect the rest of the petition?

It can. In November 2023 the AAO wrote that falsified articles raised doubts about the letters and certificates for the claimed awards. Inconsistencies must be resolved with independent, objective evidence, and an explanation alone does not suffice.

In the writer's case the AAO wrote: "The falsified articles also raise doubts about the authenticity of the letters and certificates attesting to the Petitioner's receipt of the claimed awards." The online articles were the only evidence of wider recognition of the awards, and the AAO held that they "have no credibility or weight in this proceeding." The petitioner did not establish receipt of nationally or internationally recognized prizes.

The AAO found the falsified articles material to two criteria, 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(i) and (ix): prizes and high remuneration. It entered a separate misrepresentation finding about claimed news articles from 2019.

In the singer's case the AAO set the burden: "It is the petitioner's responsibility and burden to resolve any inconsistencies in the record with independent objective evidence and attempts to explain or reconcile such inconsistencies will not suffice without competent objective evidence pointing to where the truth, in fact, lies." It added: "A mere explanation is not the independent objective evidence contemplated by Matter of Ho."

A petition also has to be complete on the day it is filed. Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(1) the petitioner "must establish that he or she is eligible for the requested benefit at the time of filing." An award received after the filing date was not received on that date and does not count for that petition. Evidence about authorship and paid journals is covered in Predatory journals and EB-1A, and shared prizes in Team awards in EB-1A.

How does the IAE Award choose its laureates?

Active IAE members at Senior Member, CIE or Fellow level nominate a colleague, and self-nomination is not considered. The secretariat checks every stated achievement against the registry and primary sources, and the Council votes in a closed session.

The IAE Award is the annual award of the International Association of Experts for contribution to the expert profession and its standards. It has five nominations: Methodological Innovation, Expert Practice, Academic Excellence, Rising Expert and the Grand Prix. The Council initiates consideration of the Grand Prix without nominations, and the Grand Prix has not yet been awarded.

A nomination comes from an active member at Senior Member, CIE or Fellow of the Association level who is personally familiar with the candidate's work. The candidate is an active IAE member of any level with a record in the registry. In the form the nominator confirms that the candidate is neither the nominator nor a relative, and that the information is supported by the sources listed. The nomination gives the candidate's full name and Member ID, the category, a description of achievements of 500-1,000 words and links to verifiable sources.

Nominations are accepted between September 1 and October 31. In November the secretariat checks the stated achievements against the registry and primary sources, and anything it cannot verify is excluded. The Council votes in a closed session in the first week of December, with written reasoning for each decision. The rules on the award page state: "No quotas and no commercial factors: the award procedure is independent of the application process and IAE services." In December the laureates' names are published, and each laureate is entered in the public registry and receives the Council's certificate.

Nominations for 2026 closed on October 31, and later nominations move to the 2027 cycle. Only active members nominate colleagues and receive awards, so taking part starts with an application for membership; the decision comes within 30 days. Members at Senior Member, CIE or Fellow level can submit a nomination when nominations open on September 1. USCIS decides in each petition whether any award, the IAE Award included, meets the prizes criterion.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Awards

Become part of the IAE community

IAE membership is the first step to taking part in the award: only active members nominate colleagues and receive awards. A decision on the application within 30 days.

Nomination

Accepted

IAE Award 2026 season

CategoryExpert practice
CandidateIAE registry member
LaureatesIn December