Journal

Predatory journals and EB-1A: what makes an article count as a scholarly article?

The EB-1A criterion in 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(vi) asks for authorship of scholarly articles in professional or major trade publications or other major media. The USCIS Policy Manual describes a scholarly article as a report on original research that is generally peer reviewed by other experts. In 2019 a federal court in Nevada imposed a judgment of more than $50.1 million on OMICS Group, a publisher that claimed rigorous peer review for articles published with little or none.

A scientist in a library looks doubtfully through journals with blank covers.

What does USCIS count as a scholarly article for EB-1A?

A report on original research, experimentation or philosophical discourse, written by a researcher or expert in the field, generally peer reviewed by other experts, and usually with footnotes, endnotes or a bibliography, according to the Policy Manual.

The text of 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(vi) is short: "Evidence of the alien's authorship of scholarly articles in the field, in professional or major trade publications or other major media." The definition of a scholarly article comes from the USCIS Policy Manual, volume 6, part F, chapter 2.

The chapter starts with the academic meaning: "a scholarly article reports on original research, experimentation, or philosophical discourse." It is "written by a researcher or expert in the field who is often affiliated with a college, university, or research institution." The chapter adds: "Scholarly articles are also generally peer reviewed by other experts in the field of specialization." In general such an article has footnotes, endnotes or a bibliography and may include graphs, charts, videos or pictures.

Outside academia the test changes: "For other fields, a scholarly article should be written for learned persons in that field." An engineer's article in an industry journal can meet the criterion if its readers are specialists of that industry.

Does the journal itself have to qualify?

Yes. In the second part of the criterion USCIS decides whether the venue is a professional publication, a major trade publication or major media, looking at the intended audience of professional journals and at relative circulation for major media.

The Policy Manual reads: "Second, USCIS determines whether the publication qualifies as a professional publication, major trade publication, or major media publication." Relevant factors "include the intended audience (for professional journals) and the circulation or readership relative to other media in the field (for major media)."

The word "major" does not attach to professional publications. In a May 24, 2019 decision on the published material criterion, whose text uses the same phrase, the Nebraska Service Center director had required comparative circulation data. The AAO agreed with the petitioner, an international legal consultant, that "major" does not apply to professional publications. For Commercial Dispute Resolution it relied on the cover, the title page and the table of contents, which showed a publication "intended to be read by legal and business professionals engaged or interested in this field." The appeal was sustained.

For a journal, then, the record shows who it is written for: its scope, its editorial board and its readers. A journal that accepts papers on any subject from anyone has no defined professional audience to show.

What did the FTC prove against the predatory publisher OMICS?

In 2019 the U.S. District Court for the District of Nevada found that OMICS Group made deceptive claims about peer review, editors and indexing and did not adequately disclose publishing fees. The judgment exceeded $50.1 million.

The Federal Trade Commission filed its complaint in the OMICS Group case in August 2016. The FTC alleged that the defendants "falsely advertised online scientific and medical academic journals and international conferences" and claimed "editorial boards comprised of prominent academics."

The court granted the FTC summary judgment in an order of March 29, 2019. It found that the defendants' peer review "often took a matter of days and contained no comments or substantive feedback," although they represented standard peer review to authors. The defendants could not show that most of the people listed as editors had agreed to be listed. By their own admissions none of their journals was indexed in Medline or PubMed Central, and the National Library of Medicine had refused to index them and asked them to stop indicating any affiliation. Publishing fees were not adequately disclosed in solicitation emails or on article submission pages. In its press release of April 3, 2019, the FTC also listed its allegation that the defendants did not allow authors to withdraw their articles from submission.

The court ordered Srinubabu Gedela and his companies to pay more than $50.1 million.

Can an article in a predatory journal still meet the criterion?

At the first step it can, if the venue qualifies: the Policy Manual says publishing in qualifying publications alone, "regardless of the caliber," should satisfy the criterion. The caliber of the journal returns in the final merits determination.

The Policy Manual uses a two-step analysis, described in the guide on the Kazarian two-step review. On the first step it says: "Publishing scholarly articles in professional or major trade publications or other major media alone, regardless of the caliber, should satisfy the regulatory criteria in the first step of the analysis."

Two conditions stay in that sentence. The article must be a scholarly article, and the venue must be a professional publication, a major trade publication or major media. A journal that performs no review and has no defined audience gives the officer grounds to doubt both.

In the final merits determination the chapter names, as an example of strong evidence, articles "in particularly highly-ranked journals (including published conference proceedings) relative to other journals in the field," for example through the journal's impact factor. Articles in journals with no standing in the field add little at that step, even when they counted toward the three criteria.

Does a high impact factor prove that an article matters?

No. In a July 23, 2020 decision the AAO wrote that a journal's high ranking or impact factor concerns its citation rate as a whole and "does not show an author's influence or the impact of research in the field."

In In Re: 8523716, a postdoctoral research associate in a department of civil and environmental engineering argued that "publications in top journals" met the criterion of original contributions of major significance, 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(v). The Nebraska Service Center director denied the petition.

The AAO found that the petitioner had not shown that every article published in a highly ranked journal "automatically indicates a contribution of major significance." A reference letter calling the journals "high demanding journals in the field of hydrological sciences" did not change that. The appeal was dismissed.

Journal rank and article significance are separate questions. Rank speaks to the venue under criterion (vi) and to the final merits. Significance of a particular article is proved through its own reception: citations, use by others and commentary.

How does USCIS weigh citations of published articles?

Against others in the same field. The Policy Manual names a total citation rate that is high relative to others in the field, such as a high h-index, and research "highly cited relative to others' work in that field."

Under criterion (v), the chapter says that published research that has provoked widespread commentary on its importance from others working in the field, "and documentation that it has been highly cited relative to others' work in that field, may be probative of the significance of the person's contributions to the field of endeavor."

In the 2020 decision the petitioner's Google Scholar evidence showed six articles or conference papers with 45, 27, 10, 5, 4 and 1 citations, and the response to the request for evidence updated this to seven papers with 52, 34, 10, 7, 5, 4 and 2. The AAO wrote that "citations can serve as an indication that the field has taken interest in a petitioner's research," but found the counts not commensurate with contributions of major significance. The petitioner also "did not articulate the significance or relevance of the citations" to her articles.

A comparison needs a baseline: citation figures for researchers at a similar career stage in the same subfield, from the same database.

Does a publication fee disqualify an article?

The regulation and the Policy Manual text on scholarly articles say nothing about fees. In the OMICS case the fees mattered because they were hidden. For published material about the applicant, paid content is a separate question.

An open-access journal may charge authors an article processing charge (APC). Criterion (vi) and its description in the Policy Manual name the type of article and the type of venue, not the business model of the journal.

In the OMICS case the court found that the fees were not adequately disclosed before submission, and the FTC also alleged that authors could not withdraw their articles. A fee stated up front, before submission, is a different situation.

Criterion (iii), published material about the applicant, has a rule of its own. Under the Policy Manual, marketing material created to sell the person's products or promote the person's services generally does not count, and this includes seemingly objective content that the person or the employer paid for. A paid profile in a magazine belongs to that rule, not to authorship.

Do conference papers and proceedings count as scholarly articles?

Some do. The Policy Manual notes that many conference presentations are never published, but conferences that peer review and publish accepted presentations, sometimes as proceedings, can produce scholarly articles under the criterion.

Footnote 27 of the chapter reads: "While many articles accepted for presentation at conferences do not result in publication, there are conferences that peer review and publish accepted presentations in professional journals (sometimes called proceedings), such that they may qualify as scholarly articles under this criterion."

Two facts go into the record for a conference paper: that the conference reviewed submissions, and that the paper appeared in a publication. A slide deck or an abstract in a program book proves neither.

The final merits example in the same chapter puts published conference proceedings next to journals: articles in particularly highly ranked journals "(including published conference proceedings) relative to other journals in the field."

Do the same questions arise in an NIW petition?

In a different form. For the second Dhanasar prong, the Policy Manual lists published articles and a strong citation history among possible evidence and states that "This list is not meant to be a checklist."

Chapter 5 of the Policy Manual, on advanced degree and exceptional ability petitions, asks whether the person is well positioned to advance the proposed endeavor. Its examples include "Published articles or media reports about the person's achievements" and documentation of a strong citation history of the person's work.

No criterion for the venue is written into that prong. An article is evidence of the person's record of success, and its weight depends on what the officer can learn about the article and the journal.

The article Do you need publications or citations for an NIW? covers petitions with few or no papers.

Is the authorship criterion read the same way for an O-1A visa?

Largely. Under the Policy Manual chapter on O-1, authorship "alone, regardless of caliber, would satisfy the criterion," and the quality of the articles is weighed in the review of the totality of the evidence.

The USCIS Policy Manual, volume 2, part M, chapter 4 covers O-1 petitions. In a footnote on the authorship criterion it states that authorship "alone, regardless of caliber, would satisfy the criterion." The chapter adds that publication in highly ranked journals may carry particular prestige, especially if the beneficiary made the largest contribution to the publication, was a senior author or was the sole author.

The chapter then moves to the whole record: "Providing required evidence does not, in itself, establish that the beneficiary meets the standard for classification." If the officer finds the standard is not met, "the officer should articulate the specific reasons." An article in a journal that misstates its review and its editors meets the criterion on paper and then carries little weight in that review, as in EB-1A.

How can an author check a journal before submitting?

By testing each claim that was found false in OMICS: peer review, editors, indexing and fees. Editors and indexing are checked outside the journal's own website, and the review policy and fees are read before a manuscript is sent.

The four claims from the OMICS case give four checks, and the Policy Manual description of a scholarly article gives a fifth.

  • Read the journal's peer review policy and check that it names the type of review, the number of reviewers and the possible decisions.
  • Check two or three members of the editorial board on their own university or employer pages to confirm that they list the journal.
  • Check any claimed indexing in the index itself, such as PubMed Central, because the journal's own site is not proof of it.
  • Find the fee schedule before submission and check whether authors may withdraw a manuscript and on what terms.
  • Read several published articles in the field to see whether they have references, methods and a subject that matches the journal's stated scope.

How does IAE Review handle manuscripts?

Each research manuscript goes through double-anonymous review by at least two independent reviewers after plagiarism screening. IAE Review charges no article-processing fee, and the initial decision comes within 7 business days.

Under the editorial policy, original research articles, analytical reviews, practical case studies and methodological developments receive independent review by two reviewers, who see the manuscript in anonymized form. Every manuscript is screened for improper borrowing, with a similarity threshold of 15%. Reviewer competence and conflicts of interest are checked before assignment, and a reviewer who is a co-author, supervisor or colleague in the same organization must decline.

The decision after review is one of four: accept, accept with minor revisions, return for revision and further review, or reject. It comes within 60 calendar days of submission. A manuscript based on a published conference paper must say so in the cover letter and contain at least 30% new material.

Articles are published in open access under CC BY 4.0, each with a permanent page and a PDF in English and Russian, as soon as they are ready, without fixed issues. Authors keep copyright. The journal follows COPE recommendations as guidance and is not a COPE member, and it will announce external indexing only after such indexing has been obtained.

IAE membership is not required and does not affect editorial decisions. Manuscripts in Russian or English go through the submission form as DOCX, PDF or LaTeX. Whether an article counts toward a criterion in a petition is decided by USCIS.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Journal

Want to publish in IAE Review?

Submit your manuscript in Russian or English as DOCX, PDF or LaTeX through the submission form. Initial decision within 7 business days.

Manuscript

Received

Initial decision within 7 business days

Article typeOriginal research
Reviewers2, double-anonymous
DOI10.68034 via Crossref