Expert report review
Errors in forensic accounting damages reports: what does a reviewer look for?
A reviewer of an opposing damages report looks first for errors that courts have already used to exclude or limit accountants. In Comcast v. Behrend (2013) the Supreme Court required a damages model to measure only the damages attributable to the liability theory in the case. District courts have excluded profits computed for products outside the claim and projections the expert never tested, and the Third Circuit has restated that lost profits are measured net of avoided costs.

Does the damages model measure the harm the case is about?
It must. In Comcast v. Behrend the Supreme Court held that a model offered as evidence of damages must measure only those damages attributable to the theory of liability that remains in the case.
Comcast Corp. v. Behrend, No. 11-864, 569 U.S. 27, was argued on November 5, 2012 and decided on March 27, 2013. The plaintiffs sought class certification in an antitrust case. The plaintiffs alleged four theories of antitrust impact, and the District Court accepted only one of them, the overbuilder theory, as capable of classwide proof (p. 31). Their expert's model used a "but for" baseline and assumed the validity of all four theories (p. 36).
The Court held that a model purporting to serve as evidence of damages "must measure only those damages attributable to that theory" (p. 35). If the model does not even try, "it cannot possibly establish that damages are susceptible of measurement across the entire class." The Court added that "Calculations need not be exact," but the court must still conduct a "rigorous analysis."
On page 38 the Court quoted the Federal Judicial Center's Reference Manual on Scientific Evidence (3d ed. 2011, p. 432): "The first step in a damages study is the translation of the legal theory of the harmful event" into an analysis of its economic impact. The lower courts, the Court wrote, "ignored that first step entirely."
Comcast arose under Rule 23(b)(3), but the reviewer applies its first step to any damages report. The reviewer lists the liability theories that survive, then reads the but-for world of the opposing model and marks every assumption that rests on a theory the court has dismissed or the plaintiff has dropped.
Does the calculation include products or periods outside the claim?
It should not. In Shure v. ClearOne the District of Delaware upheld the exclusion of a total profits figure computed for a bundle of products because it included profits attributable to items other than the one at issue.
Shure Inc. v. ClearOne, Inc., Civil Action No. 19-1343-RGA, was decided by the District of Delaware on October 26, 2021. The plaintiffs claimed total profits under 35 U.S.C. § 289 for a design patent. Their damages expert, Dr. Vander Veen, calculated profits for a bundle of products rather than for the BMA CTH product alone.
The court overruled Shure's objections to the magistrate judge's order excluding the calculation: "Dr. Vander Veen's report erred in calculating lost profits for the bundle rather than the BMA CTH product," and the calculation "includes profits attributable to other items in the bundle and therefore must be excluded." The court also refused a request to supplement the report, which would have come less than three weeks before trial.
The review check is mechanical. Each revenue line in the opposing schedule is matched to the product, the customer and the period in the complaint. Sales of other products, sales to customers outside the claim and months outside the damages period are listed separately with their amounts, so the court sees how much of the figure falls outside the case.
Are lost profits computed net of costs?
They should be. In Roberts Technology Group v. Curwood the Third Circuit quoted the rule that lost profits are measured net, not gross, and described the recovery as lost revenue minus the costs the breach avoided.
Roberts Technology Group, Inc. v. Curwood, Inc., No. 16-3079, was decided by the Third Circuit on June 16, 2017 in a non-precedential opinion. The jury had awarded $3 million on a contract claim. The court quoted the district court for the rule that "the proper measure of lost profits is net profits, not gross." Under Pennsylvania law, the Third Circuit wrote, the plaintiff was "entitled to recover the net lost profits caused by the breach": the lost revenue "minus the costs avoided as a result of the same breach."
The Third Circuit reinstated the verdict because the record contained enough evidence for a jury to accept the estimate of lost net profits by the plaintiff's expert, John Maloney. It stressed that its ruling "does not amount to an endorsement of Maloney's analytical approach."
For the reviewer the cost side of the model is a separate part of the review. It covers which costs the plaintiff would have incurred to earn the lost revenue, which of them the plaintiff avoided because the contract ended, and whether the opposing model deducted them at all. Each deduction the reviewer adds is tied to a ledger account or to the plaintiff's own cost records.
Can a damages model rest on projections nobody tested?
Courts have excluded such models. In Jacked Up v. Sara Lee the court affirmed exclusion of a lost profits opinion built on a pro forma projection because the expert failed to test its validity and reasonableness.
In Jacked Up, LLC v. Sara Lee Corp., No. 3:11-cv-3296-L (N.D. Tex.), Judge Sam A. Lindsay on May 2, 2018 affirmed Magistrate Judge David Horan's order of February 15, 2018 excluding the lost profits testimony of the plaintiff's expert, E.J. Janik, under Rule 702.
Janik's model rested on the Sara Lee Pro Forma, which the magistrate judge described as the "'gangbusters' scenario created for a Jacked Up branded dispensed energy ice tea." The court agreed that Janik "failed to test the validity and reasonableness of the Sara Lee Pro Forma." Experts may rely on assumptions, but "Those assumptions, however, must have some factual basis in the record and an underlying rationale." The projections for coffee and cappuccino were held "unsupported and too speculative to be admissible under Rule 702."
The order also quoted General Electric Co. v. Joiner: a court may find "too great an analytical gap between the data and the opinion offered." On expenses, the magistrate judge noted that Janik deducted them while "noting that he has not been able to fully evaluate these deductions"; the district court did not rest its ruling on that point.
A reviewer asks three things about each projection in the opposing model: who prepared it and when, whether the plaintiff ever reached the projected volumes in its actual history, and whether the expert compared the projection with any outside data. The answers go into the rebuttal with the documents behind them.
Are future losses discounted to present value?
A lump sum paid today earns money once invested. In Jones & Laughlin Steel v. Pfeifer the Supreme Court held for that reason that future benefits ought to be discounted in making up the award.
Jones & Laughlin Steel Corp. v. Pfeifer, 462 U.S. 523, was decided on June 15, 1983; the opinion was written by Justice Stevens. The case concerned the lost future earnings of an injured worker. The Court explained that the award cannot be computed simply by totaling up the periodic payments, because when the lump sum "or even a part of it" is invested, "it will earn additional money."
The Court then repeated the rule from Chesapeake & Ohio R. Co. v. Kelly: "the ascertained future benefits ought to be discounted in the making up of the award."
The arithmetic is the same in a commercial lost profits report that projects losses past the trial date. The reviewer checks three inputs: the discount rate and its source, the date to which the future stream is discounted, and whether the same rate is applied to every year of the projection. A report that adds future years at face value overstates the award by the amount of the omitted discount, and the reviewer computes that amount.
Did the expert account for other causes of the loss?
Rule 702's 2000 committee note lists, as a reliability factor, whether the expert adequately accounted for obvious alternative explanations. The reviewer lists the other events of the loss period and checks whether the model separated them.
The 2000 committee note to Rule 702 sets out factors that courts have used to test reliability. Factor (3) asks "Whether the expert has adequately accounted for obvious alternative explanations." Factor (4) asks whether the expert "is being as careful as he would be in his regular professional work outside his paid litigation consulting," quoting Sheehan v. Daily Racing Form, Inc.
In a lost profits case the alternative explanations are concrete events in the plaintiff's records: a price change, the loss of a customer unrelated to the defendant, a supply interruption, a new competitor, a change in the plaintiff's own sales staff. The Comcast reasoning points the same way, since a but-for world that removes the defendant's conduct should leave the other events in place.
The reviewer lists each such event with its date and its documented effect on sales, then checks whether the opposing model adjusted for it. Where the model assigns the whole decline to the defendant, the rebuttal shows the share of the decline that falls in months with another documented cause.
Which errors lead to exclusion and which go to cross-examination?
Since the 2023 amendment of Rule 702, sufficiency of the basis and reliable application of the method are admissibility questions for the court. Errors a jury can weigh are tested on cross-examination and by the rebuttal expert.
Rule 702 admits expert testimony if the proponent persuades the court that it is more likely than not that the testimony rests on sufficient facts or data and that the opinion applies reliable principles and methods reliably to the facts of the case. The 2023 committee note calls this "the preponderance of the evidence standard that applies to most of the admissibility requirements."
The same note states that "many courts have held that the critical questions of the sufficiency of an expert's basis, and the application of the expert's methodology, are questions of weight and not admissibility," and the amendment wrote the preponderance standard into the text of the rule. A model built for the wrong liability theory, or for products outside the claim, goes to the basis and the application and is argued in a motion.
Timing decides how far the argument goes. In Roberts Technology the Third Circuit wrote that "the proper way to challenge improper expert testimony is through a Daubert motion filed before trial" or a contemporaneous objection, and it reinstated the verdict that rested on the expert's estimate. The reviewer's findings therefore reach counsel early enough for a pretrial motion.
Errors in individual inputs, such as a disputed growth rate or a contested cost allocation, are often left for the jury. For these the rebuttal report gives the corrected figure and the source, and counsel uses it on cross-examination.
Can the opposing accountant tell the court that the defendant committed fraud?
A CPA bound by AICPA Statement on Standards for Forensic Services No. 1 may not opine on whether fraud occurred. A reviewer marks such statements as outside the standard.
The Journal of Accountancy reported on September 1, 2019 that SSFS No. 1 applies to AICPA members, member firms and their employees for engagements accepted on or after January 1, 2020. The standard covers litigation, defined as "an actual or potential legal or regulatory proceeding before a trier of fact or a regulatory body," and investigations, defined as services "performed in response to concerns of wrongdoing."
Under the standard, members may not opine on whether fraud occurred, and certain forensic services may not be performed for a contingent fee. A damages report by a CPA that calls a transfer fraudulent, or that labels the defendant's intent, goes beyond what the standard permits.
The reviewer separates the two parts of such a report. The amounts, dates and accounts of each transfer are facts the accountant may state from the records. The characterization of those facts as fraud is listed in the review as an opinion the standard bars, with the page of the report where it appears.
What does IAE do when a party needs a review of an opposing damages report?
A forensic accountant from the IAE registry reviews the opposing damages report or writes an expert report on the party's questions. The signed document is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.
The IAE forensic accounting page describes the work in three areas. The expert rebuilds lost profits from ledgers and tax returns, measures value received against value given and tests solvency on each transfer date, and follows funds between accounts through bank statements and ledgers. Assumptions that counsel supplied and the expert relied on are discoverable under FRCP 26(b)(4)(C)(iii).
The questions are framed from the ledgers, tax returns and bank statements in the record and confirmed before work starts. A review answers six questions about the opposing report: the method, the completeness of the examination, the soundness of the conclusions, the expert's competence, the form and procedure, and whether the report can be relied on.
The client sends the report or the case materials and describes the task. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day; within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist, and the client approves the candidate and the CV. The draft is checked for facts, and the signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days. Cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.
Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and passed the council's attestation under the published Criteria Matrix; the Member ID or QR code in the document opens the specialist's record. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. A review is evidence that the court weighs with the other materials, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.
Sources
- Comcast Corp. v. Behrend, 569 U.S. 27 (2013), U.S. Reports (GovInfo)
- Shure Inc. v. ClearOne, Inc., Civil Action No. 19-1343-RGA, U.S. District Court for the District of Delaware, opinion of October 26, 2021
- Roberts Technology Group, Inc. v. Curwood, Inc., No. 16-3079, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, opinion of June 16, 2017 (not precedential)
- Jacked Up, LLC v. Sara Lee Corp., No. 3:11-cv-3296-L (N.D. Tex.), Memorandum Opinion and Order of May 2, 2018, Document 208 (Justia)
- Jones & Laughlin Steel Corp. v. Pfeifer, 462 U.S. 523 (1983) (LII)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702, Testimony by Expert Witnesses, with Committee Notes of 2000 and 2023 (LII)
- Journal of Accountancy, September 1, 2019: AICPA issues forensic accounting standards (SSFS No. 1)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26, Duty to Disclose; General Provisions Governing Discovery (LII)
Read also
All articles
SEC disgorgement: how is the amount calculated, and how does a defense forensic accountant review the SEC's number?
In an SEC enforcement case disgorgement is the gain the defendant is ordered to give up. Since Liu v. SEC in 2020 that number is limited to net
Loss calculation in federal fraud sentencing: how does a defense forensic accountant review the government's number?
In a federal fraud case the loss figure moves the guideline range more than any other number. Since November 1, 2026, the loss table in USSG 2B1.1
Prejudgment interest calculation: how do you check the other side's numbers?
Prejudgment interest can add a large figure to a damages award, and each input of the calculation is set by a statute, a contract or a court'sExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

