Examinations

Forensic psychologist or psychiatrist: who evaluates what in family and civil cases?

Courts decide who may evaluate a person by the question in the case and the examiner's license and training. California lets a psychiatrist, a psychologist, a marriage and family therapist, a clinical social worker or a professional clinical counselor perform a custody evaluation if the training rules are met. Under federal Rule 35, any suitably licensed or certified examiner may conduct a mental examination. The two professions differ most where a case needs medical diagnosis or standardized testing.

Two chairs: a psychologist's notebook on one, a physician's bag on the other

What is the difference between a forensic psychologist and a forensic psychiatrist?

A psychiatrist is a physician with a psychiatry residency or board certification in psychiatry. A psychologist is licensed in psychology. Both can evaluate mental condition for a court, which checks each one's suitability.

California's rule 5.225(c) describes the psychiatrist as a licensed physician who is a board-certified psychiatrist or has completed a residency in psychiatry. The same rule lists the licensed psychologist as a separate category. The professional difference therefore starts with training and license: a medical license with psychiatric residency or board certification for one, a psychology license for the other.

In court the question is whether the expert fits the issue. Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence qualifies a witness by knowledge, skill, experience, training or education, and requires the proponent to show the court that it is more likely than not that the testimony rests on sufficient facts or data and reliable methods reliably applied.

Rule 35 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure adds a specific check for examinations. The examiner must be suitably licensed or certified, and the committee note explains that the word suitably lets the court assess an examiner's credentials, even when the examiner is a physician.

Who may perform a child custody evaluation in California?

Under rule 5.225(c): a psychiatrist, a licensed psychologist, a marriage and family therapist, a clinical social worker or a professional clinical counselor qualified to assess couples and families. Court-connected evaluators may be unlicensed under subdivision (j).

Rule 5.225 of the California Rules of Court, last amended effective January 1, 2020, sets education, experience and training standards for court-appointed child custody evaluators. Subdivision (c) lists the licensed professionals: a physician who is a board-certified psychiatrist or has completed a psychiatry residency, a psychologist, a marriage and family therapist, a clinical social worker, or a professional clinical counselor qualified to assess couples and families.

Two exceptions allow an unlicensed evaluator. One is a court-connected evaluator who meets the requirements of subdivision (j). The other applies when no licensed evaluator is available within a reasonable time, the parties stipulate to the person and the court approves.

A psychiatrist and a psychologist therefore stand in the same list. For a custody evaluation the rule does not prefer one profession over the other; it requires each evaluator to meet the training and experience standards described below.

What training and experience must a custody evaluator have?

Forty hours of basic training on 21 listed subjects, domestic violence training, eight hours of update training each year and participation in at least four court-appointed evaluations within the preceding three years.

Under rule 5.225(d), before appointment an evaluator completes 40 hours of education and training on the subjects the rule lists, including child development, family dynamics, child abuse and child sexual abuse, cultural and religious factors and testifying in court. Court-connected evaluators may start with 20 hours and complete the rest within 12 months of their first evaluation (subdivision (j)).

Rule 5.225(e) requires basic and advanced domestic violence training under rule 5.230 before appointment. Under subdivision (i), each year the evaluator completes eight hours of update training on the subjects in subdivision (d), together with domestic violence update training.

Subdivision (g) requires experience: participation in at least four partial or full court-appointed custody evaluations within the preceding three years, each resulting in a written or oral report, either by conducting the evaluation or by materially assisting another qualified evaluator. The court may waive this when no experienced evaluator is available and the parties stipulate.

The evaluator documents all of this in a declaration. Court-connected evaluators complete form FL-325, and private evaluators file form FL-326 no later than 10 days after notification of each appointment and before any work on the evaluation begins (subdivision (l)). A reviewing psychologist checks the declaration against the evaluator's CV.

Who may examine a party's mental condition in a federal civil case?

A suitably licensed or certified examiner. Under Rule 35 the court, on motion for good cause, may order a party whose mental condition is in controversy to be examined, and the order names the examiner.

Rule 35(a)(1) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure lets the court order a party whose mental or physical condition is in controversy to submit to a physical or mental examination by a suitably licensed or certified examiner. Under Rule 35(a)(2) the order may be made only on motion for good cause and on notice to all parties and the person to be examined, and it specifies the time, place, manner, conditions and scope of the examination and the person who will perform it.

The wording has a history. The committee note to the 1991 amendment explains that in 1988 Congress amended the rule to permit mental examinations by licensed clinical psychologists, and that the 1991 amendment extended the rule to any suitably licensed or certified examiner. The note gives dentists and occupational therapists as examples of professionals who are neither physicians nor clinical psychologists but may give valuable testimony.

The note also explains the word suitably. The court may consider whether the proposed examiner has the needed expertise, so that a party is not subjected to an intrusive examination by a person whose testimony would be of limited value. That check applies to physicians as well.

What must the examiner's report contain?

Under Rule 35(b)(2), the examiner's findings in detail, including diagnoses, conclusions and the results of any tests. The examined party may request the report and reports of earlier examinations of the same condition.

Rule 35(b)(1) requires the party who moved for the examination, on request, to deliver a copy of the examiner's report to the person examined or the opposing party, together with like reports of all earlier examinations of the same condition. Rule 35(b)(2) requires the report to be in writing and to set out in detail the examiner's findings, including diagnoses, conclusions and the results of any tests.

Under Rule 35(b)(4), by requesting and obtaining the report, or by deposing the examiner, the party examined waives any privilege it may have in that action or any other action involving the same controversy concerning testimony about all examinations of the same condition.

For the choice between professions, the report requirement is practical. The report shows which findings the examiner relied on: medical findings, interview data or standardized test results. Under the suitability check of Rule 35(a)(1), the court compares those findings with the examiner's license and training.

Does every custody evaluation include psychological testing?

No. Rule 5.220 requires the evaluator to explain in writing the role of any psychological test results, and the Calaveras County court states that its set-fee evaluations do not include psychological testing.

Rule 5.220(e)(1) of the California Rules of Court requires a written explanation of the procedures used and the time required, including the role of any psychological test results. The rule leaves testing to the evaluator's method; it does not require testing in every evaluation.

The Superior Court of California, County of Calaveras, states on its Family Court Services page that the court's evaluations "are limited and do not include psychological testing." An evaluation without testing relies on the other methods of rule 5.220(e)(2): document review, observation of parent-child interaction, interviews of parents, children and household members, and collateral information.

Counsel therefore match the expert to the findings the case needs. Standardized test results call for an examiner trained in those instruments, and questions about a psychiatric disorder, its treatment and medication call for a physician trained in psychiatry.

Can a psychologist and a psychiatrist work on the same case?

Yes. Under rule 5.220(e)(2) the custody evaluator may consult other experts on matters outside the evaluator's expertise, so a psychologist evaluator can consult a psychiatrist and the reverse.

Among the methods listed in rule 5.220(e)(2) is consulting with other experts, when necessary, about matters outside the evaluator's expertise. A psychologist who evaluates a parent with a treated psychiatric illness can consult a psychiatrist about the diagnosis and its treatment, and a psychiatrist evaluator can rely on a psychologist for standardized testing.

In civil damages cases each side may also retain its own expert. A plaintiff examined by a defense psychiatrist under Rule 35 can retain a psychologist to review the report, and the review compares the findings in the report with the records and the tests actually given.

Can either expert tell a criminal jury whether the defendant had the required mental state?

No. Rule 704(b) bars an expert in a criminal case from stating an opinion about whether the defendant did or did not have a mental state or condition that is an element of the crime or of a defense.

Rule 704(a) of the Federal Rules of Evidence lets experts give opinions on ultimate issues. Rule 704(b) carves out criminal cases: an expert witness must not state an opinion about whether the defendant did or did not have a mental state or condition that constitutes an element of the crime charged or of a defense, and those matters are for the trier of fact alone.

The rule applies to psychologists and psychiatrists alike. Each may describe the diagnosis, the test results and the characteristics of a condition, and the jury draws the conclusion about the defendant's mental state.

What does IAE do when a case needs a psychological evaluation or review?

A psychologist from the IAE registry writes an expert report on the client's questions or a review of the opposing psychologist's evaluation. Delivery takes up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.

The IAE forensic psychological evaluation page covers child custody and parenting time, decision-making capacity in contract and will disputes, and emotional distress claims in civil cases. For emotional distress, the page notes that when a party's mental condition is in controversy, the court may order an examination under FRCP 35, and the examiner's report sets out findings, diagnoses, conclusions and test results.

The page names the standards the review uses, including the APA Specialty Guidelines for Forensic Psychology, adopted by the APA Council of Representatives on August 3, 2011: corroboration from more than one source (9.02), instruments with established validity and reliability (10.02) and stated limits for persons not examined (9.03). A rebuttal is due within 30 days of the other side's disclosure under FRCP 26(a)(2)(D)(ii), absent a stipulation or court order.

The client sends the report under review, the court order and the case materials and describes the task. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. Delivery takes up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, with a 48-hour rush for tight deadlines.

Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry, can be verified by Member ID or QR code and confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. Materials are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. Neither IAE nor the psychologist guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert examinations

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member