Expert report review

Supplementing a forensic accounting report after the rebuttal: what does Rule 26(e) allow, and when is it too late?

After a rebuttal points out errors in a damages report, the expert who wrote it often wants to answer with a supplemental report. Rule 26(e) requires a supplement when a report is incomplete or incorrect in a material respect, and the duty runs until pretrial disclosures, at least 30 days before trial unless the court orders otherwise. Courts read the rule narrowly: a supplement corrects and completes, it does not rebuild an opinion with data the expert already had.

An accountant from behind clips a slim addendum onto a thick report, an empty chair and a second binder across the table.

What does Rule 26(e) require after an expert report is served?

A party must supplement or correct a disclosure in a timely manner if it learns that the disclosure is incomplete or incorrect in a material respect and the other parties do not already know the corrective information.

Rule 26(e)(1) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure states that a party who has made a disclosure under Rule 26(a) "must supplement or correct its disclosure or response: (A) in a timely manner if the party learns that in some material respect the disclosure or response is incomplete or incorrect, and if the additional or corrective information has not otherwise been made known to the other parties during the discovery process or in writing; or (B) as ordered by the court."

For experts the rule adds a second paragraph. Under Rule 26(e)(2), "for an expert whose report must be disclosed under Rule 26(a)(2)(B), the party's duty to supplement extends both to information included in the report and to information given during the expert's deposition." Rule 26(a)(2)(E) repeats the point in the disclosure rule itself: "The parties must supplement these disclosures when required under Rule 26(e)."

The 1993 committee note ties the duty to the opinions. It states that "changes in the opinions expressed by the expert whether in the report or at a subsequent deposition" are subject to the duty of supplemental disclosure. The same note describes the report as one "intended to set forth the substance of the direct examination."

Read together, the provisions put two limits on a forensic accountant who wants to change his numbers. The change must answer a real gap or error in a material respect, and it must be disclosed in time. Everything else is a new opinion, and a new opinion has its own deadline under Rule 26(a)(2)(D).

When is the last day to supplement an expert report?

By the time pretrial disclosures under Rule 26(a)(3) are due, which is at least 30 days before trial unless the court orders otherwise. Many scheduling orders set an earlier date, and that date controls.

The outer limit is in Rule 26(e)(2): "Any additions or changes to this information must be disclosed by the time the party's pretrial disclosures under Rule 26(a)(3) are due." Rule 26(a)(3)(B) fixes those disclosures: "Unless the court orders otherwise, these disclosures must be made at least 30 days before trial."

The scheduling order usually comes first. In Koel v. Citizens Medical Center, Inc., No. 21-cv-2166 (D. Kan.), Magistrate Judge Teresa J. James applied a scheduling order that required that "final supplemental disclosures must be served no later than 40 days before the deadline for completion of all discovery." The rule's 30-day default never came into play.

The phrase "in a timely manner" in Rule 26(e)(1)(A) adds a second limit. A correction held for months after the party learned of the error invites the argument that it was not made in a timely manner. A reviewing accountant who receives a supplement shortly before trial checks two dates: when the information behind the supplement became available, and when the supplement was served.

What counts as a true supplement?

A correction of inaccuracies or a completion of an incomplete report, based on information that was not available when the expert wrote it. Courts have repeated that supplementation is not a second chance to write the report.

In CrossFit, Inc. v. National Strength and Conditioning Association, No. 14cv1191 (S.D. Cal.), Magistrate Judge Karen S. Crawford described supplementation in her order of July 18, 2018 as "correcting inaccuracies, or filling the interstices of an incomplete report."

In Young v. Sequoyah Fuels Corp., No. 22-cv-280 (E.D. Okla.), Magistrate Judge Gerald L. Jackson wrote on June 2, 2025 that "the purpose of supplementation is to allow for correction of inadvertent errors in timely filed reports." Quoting a decision from the District of Kansas, the court added that supplementation "may only be based upon additional or corrective information that was unavailable when the expert made his or her initial report."

For a forensic accountant the test has a practical form. A supplement that adds a bank statement produced after the report, corrects a transposed figure, or rolls the damages period forward with actual results that did not exist when the report was written fits the rule. A supplement that adopts a new benchmark, a new discount rate or a new method, built on documents that were in the production all along, looks like the new opinion that the rule does not cover.

Can the expert use a supplement to answer the rebuttal?

Not if the answer rests on data the expert already had. In Young v. Sequoyah Fuels (E.D. Okla. 2025) the court struck a supplement written to answer the rebuttal expert's criticisms.

The Young schedule is typical. The plaintiffs' expert, Dr. Clark, served his report on December 6, 2024. The defense rebuttal expert, Dr. Fellman, served a rebuttal on February 3, 2025, after the rebuttal deadline was extended from January 22. On March 6, 2025, Dr. Clark served a report titled "Supplemental Opinions" with a new calculation. A scheduling order of March 13 extended discovery to June 13, 2025, but did not change the expert disclosure deadlines.

The plaintiffs conceded that the new quantification was "directly responsive to Defendants' rebuttal expert, Dr. Fellman." The court found that the comparative studies on which the new calculation rested were available when Dr. Clark wrote the December report. It held that the report "exceeds the bounds of permissible supplementation" and that Rule 26(e) "is not an invitation to substantially change or bolster opinions with information that should have been included in the original report."

One sentence of the order answers the question in this section's heading: "Responding to criticism in Dr. Fellman's Report is not relying on new information." The court also noted that Dr. Clark was "making calculations that he could have made in the December Report." It found the violations "neither justified nor harmless" and held that "the appropriate remedy is to strike Dr. Clark's March Report."

The case concerned radiation exposure, not damages, but the reasoning carries over directly to accounting. A damages expert who learns from the rebuttal that his model omitted avoided costs, and then adds them from ledgers produced a year earlier, is doing what Dr. Clark did: strengthening the opinion with information he already had.

Does calling a report a supplement change its deadline?

No. Courts look at what the report does. In City of Las Cruces (D.N.M. 2022) a report labeled supplemental was treated as a rebuttal served 24 days late, and in Hansen (N.D. Ill. 2022) late reports were struck.

In City of Las Cruces v. United States, No. 2:17-cv-00809 (D.N.M.), Senior District Judge Judith C. Herrera ruled on August 2, 2022 on the second report of James Bearzi, which the defendant American Linen called a supplemental report. American Linen admitted it needed the report to rebut another expert, Helgen, after the United States settled and two other experts, Johnson and Kool, became unavailable.

The court wrote: "Thus, the second Bearzi report was a rebuttal report." Measured against the 30-day period of Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii), it was late: "Excluding the time the case was stayed, American Linen served Bearzi's second report 24 days after the 30-day deadline." A change in the party's litigation position was "not the type" of new information "that justifies a supplemental expert report." The court granted the motion in part and referred the remedy to the magistrate judge.

In Hansen v. Country Mutual Insurance Co., No. 18 CV 244 (N.D. Ill.), Magistrate Judge Jeffrey I. Cummings ruled on January 13, 2022 on reports the plaintiffs offered as supplemental or rebuttal opinions. The court held that "under the plain application of Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii)," the defendant's expert disclosures "triggered the thirty-day deadline," and it rejected the view that the period runs only after the expert is deposed. The plaintiffs did not develop an argument that the reports were supplements under Rule 26(e)(2), and the court did not address it. Leave to disclose was denied and the reports were struck.

Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii) defines rebuttal evidence as evidence "intended solely to contradict or rebut evidence on the same subject matter identified by another party," due "within 30 days after the other party's disclosure" absent a stipulation or court order. A party that misses that period cannot recover it by changing the title of the document.

What happens when the damages expert updates the number?

The court may accept part of the update as a supplement, treat the rest as untimely, and give the other side time to depose the expert and rebut the new figure, as in CrossFit (S.D. Cal. 2018).

In CrossFit the plaintiff's damages expert, Dr. Michael R. Solomon, served an initial report on April 1, 2016 and a second report, called an update, on December 29, 2016. His estimate of corrective advertising damages was about $3.5 million in the first report and $18,018,413 in the second. The court observed that "this new estimate of total corrective damages represents a significant increase."

The court found that the second report "is, in part, a timely Rule 26(e) supplement and, in part, an untimely report under Rule 37(c)(1)." It did not strike it. Instead it allowed the defendant to depose Dr. Solomon, to serve a rebuttal to the second report and to designate a further rebuttal expert, Dr. Itamar Simonson, whom the plaintiff could depose. The court added that if the second report were treated as an untimely disclosure it would "reach the same result," finding the disclosure not harmless and allowing the defendant time to respond.

The order denied the defendant's broader requests: to reopen expert discovery on new allegations, which the court found lacked good cause, and to counter the expert's initial report.

For the side receiving an updated damages figure, CrossFit marks what to ask for. The motion seeks a ruling on which parts of the update are supplementation and which are new, and in the alternative a deposition limited to the update and a date for a rebuttal limited to it.

What does the court do with an improper supplement?

Rule 37(c)(1) bars the party from using it on a motion, at a hearing or at trial unless the failure was substantially justified or harmless. Courts weigh surprise, cure, disruption of trial and bad faith.

The court in Young quoted Rule 37(c)(1): "the party is not allowed to use that information or witness to supply evidence on a motion, at a hearing, or at a trial unless the failure was substantially justified or is harmless." It then applied the factors from Woodworker's Supply, Inc. v. Principal Mutual Life Insurance Co., 170 F.3d 985 (10th Cir. 1999): "the prejudice or surprise to the party against whom the testimony is offered," "the ability of the party to cure the prejudice," "the extent to which introducing such testimony would disrupt the trial," and "the moving party's bad faith or willfulness." The March report was struck.

The Hansen court applied the four factors from the Westefer and David decisions: surprise and prejudice, ability to cure, likelihood of disruption at trial, and bad faith or willfulness. It found the delay neither substantially justified nor harmless, although it found no bad faith.

Koel shows the other outcome. The defense had disclosed a new causation opinion late. Magistrate Judge James, in a memorandum and order of May 12, 2023, found the late disclosure unjustified but harmless because the prejudice could be cured. The court allowed a supplemental report limited to the new theory by June 12, 2023 and rebuttal reports limited to that theory by July 12, 2023, allowed no further depositions or discovery, kept the trial date of January 22, 2024, and declined to shift the cost of the plaintiff's rebuttal reports to the defendants.

For a forensic accountant on the receiving side, the factors point to what the review should document. Surprise is shown by comparing the supplement with the original report line by line. The ability to cure depends on how much time remains before trial and whether the rebuttal expert can answer within it. A list of every new input, with the date it became available, answers the question of justification.

Can the court hold the expert to the original reports?

Yes. In Perez v. Century Asphalt (D. Neb. 2022) the court declined to exclude an expert whose timely reports were deficient but limited him to their contents and barred amendments and new supporting material.

In Perez v. Century Asphalt Company, No. 8:20-cv-210 (D. Neb.), Magistrate Judge Susan M. Bazis ruled on November 29, 2022 on the plaintiff's expert, Dr. Joseph Wu. The court found that his three initial reports did not fully satisfy Rule 26(a), but it noted that "Dr. Wu's initial reports, though deficient, were timely disclosed," and declined to exclude his testimony entirely.

It chose a narrower remedy. Dr. Wu was limited to the contents of his initial reports. In the court's words, he "will not be permitted to amend his reports or supplement his opinion" by giving a "clinical correlation" or an additional opinion on causation, and he could not rely on facts, data or exhibits not in those reports. A supplemental designation served on September 27, 2022, after the motion to strike was filed, did not cure the deficiencies, the court found. Separately, the court found good cause to extend the rebuttal expert deadline to January 6, 2023.

The same remedy is open in a damages case. A defendant who has already built its rebuttal around the plaintiff's original model asks the court to hold the plaintiff's accountant to that model. The rebuttal then answers a fixed target, and the trial covers the opinions both sides saw during discovery.

Can a report be corrected after the other side finds an error?

Yes, when the correction rests on information the expert did not have before. In Keystone (W.D. Va. 2019) the court admitted a rebuttal that revised the date of harm after the opposing expert found a mathematical error.

In Keystone Transportation Solutions, LLC v. Northwest Hardwoods, Inc., No. 5:18-cv-00039 (W.D. Va.), Judge Elizabeth K. Dillon ruled on April 22, 2019 on the rebuttal report of the plaintiff's damages expert, Brian Burns. Citing an earlier decision, the court noted that a rebuttal report does not "permit an expert to correct mistakes based on information that was available" to the expert earlier.

It then found that Burns's report "makes changes based on information that was not available to him at the time of his initial report." The only new conclusion was a revised date of harm, which Burns explained was prompted by the defense expert's identification of a mathematical error, and Burns identified the new information he relied on. The motions to exclude Burns and to strike the rebuttal were denied.

Keystone and Young draw the same line from opposite sides. Information that was available earlier cannot support a late change; information that was not available can. An expert who corrects an error the other side found should state in the corrected report what the new information is and when he received it.

What does the reviewing accountant check when a supplement arrives?

Each change against the original report, the source and date of every new input, whether the change answers the rebuttal or reports new facts, and the time left under the scheduling order.

The review starts with a redline. The accountant lists every figure, assumption and conclusion that differs from the original report and marks for each whether it corrects an error, adds data, changes the method or adds an opinion.

Each new input is traced to a document and a production date. If the document was produced before the original report, the change is the kind of bolstering the Young court struck. If it arrived later, the reviewer checks whether the supplement was served in a timely manner after it arrived, as Rule 26(e)(1)(A) requires.

The reviewer then measures the effect. A correction that moves damages by a small amount and a new model that multiplies them, as the update in CrossFit did, call for different responses: a short rebuttal in the first case, a motion to strike or a request for a deposition and a new rebuttal date in the second. Rule 26(b)(4)(A) permits the deposition once the report is provided.

Finally the reviewer prepares counsel's record for Rule 37(c)(1): what is new, when it was available, how much time the defense needs to answer, and whether the trial date can hold. These are the factors the courts in Young, Hansen and Koel weighed.

What does IAE do when the opposing damages expert serves a supplement?

A forensic accountant from the IAE registry reviews the supplement against the original report and the record and writes a rebuttal or deposition questions, in up to 5 business days or a 48-hour rush.

The IAE page on forensic accounting reviews is written for attorneys facing the other side's damages, solvency or tracing report. The reviewer rebuilds the opposing calculation from the record, marks each figure without a source and writes a rebuttal report within the Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii) period or the court's schedule. The page also lists deposition questions among the products.

The client sends the original report, the supplement and the scheduling order. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day, and within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry; the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. Delivery takes up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, and cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.

Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code. Whether to move to strike a supplement is a decision for the client's attorney: IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy. A review is evidence that the court weighs with the other materials, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member