Expert report review

Ghostwritten expert report: how much may a lawyer write, and what happens when the expert did not write it?

Under Rule 26(a)(2)(B) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, a retained expert's report must be prepared and signed by the expert. Counsel may help, and the 1993 Advisory Committee Note says so. When the substance comes from someone else, federal courts exclude the report: in Batiste v. Lewis the plaintiff supplied the analysis, and in Fox v. Makin the plaintiff's former attorney drafted the expert's report.

A yellow pad and a second pen rest beside a thick report on an empty chair

What does Rule 26 require of the person who writes an expert report?

A retained expert must give a written report prepared and signed by the witness. It states all opinions with their basis and reasons, the facts or data considered, exhibits, qualifications, prior testimony and compensation.

Rule 26(a)(2)(B) applies to a witness "retained or specially employed to provide expert testimony in the case" and to an employee whose duties regularly involve giving expert testimony. Unless the parties stipulate or the court orders otherwise, the disclosure of such a witness must be accompanied by a written report, "prepared and signed by the witness."

The 1993 Advisory Committee Note describes what the report is for. Such a witness "must prepare a detailed and complete written report, stating the testimony the witness is expected to present," and the report "is intended to set forth the substance of the direct examination."

The signature therefore carries a claim: the opinions in the report are the witness's own and he will give them from the stand. A report that the witness cannot explain at deposition fails that claim even if every sentence in it is accurate.

How much may a lawyer help draft the expert's report?

Counsel may assist, and the 1993 note names experts such as automobile mechanics who may need it. Courts require that the expert substantially participate in preparing the report and supply its substance himself.

The 1993 note states that the rule "does not preclude counsel from providing assistance" when experts prepare their reports, "and indeed, with experts such as automobile mechanics, this assistance may be needed." It goes on: "Nevertheless, the report, which is intended to set forth the substance of the direct examination, should be written in a manner" that matches the testimony to be given by the witness, "and it must be signed by the witness."

District courts have turned that sentence into a test. In Batiste v. Lewis the Eastern District of Louisiana stated: "To prove ghostwriting, the party seeking exclusion must use the available documents to show that the non-moving party provided the substance of the opinions of the testifying expert," as opposed to editorial assistance. The court added that "although an expert may receive some assistance in preparing his or her report, the expert must 'substantially participate[] in the preparation.'" It cited earlier decisions of district courts in Louisiana, Texas and Mississippi.

The District of Maine used the same standard in Fox v. Makin: "the expert must also substantially participate in the preparation of the report." It also drew the line in one sentence: "the assistance of counsel contemplated by Rule 26(a)(2)(B) is not synonymous with ghost-writing."

Batiste set the substance of the opinions against editorial assistance. In both cases below the court looked at who ran the analysis and who supplied the content of the report.

What happened in Batiste v. Lewis?

A New Orleans jazz musician sued Macklemore and Ryan Lewis for copyright infringement. His musicologist could not identify analysis he had created himself, and on April 10, 2019 the court excluded the report and his testimony.

Paul Batiste, a member of The Batiste Brothers Band, alleged that eleven of his songs were infringed through unauthorized samples and copied elements in "Thrift Shop," "Can't Hold Us," "Need to Know," "Same Love" and "Neon Cathedral." The defendants included Ryan Lewis and Ben Haggerty, who perform as Macklemore and Ryan Lewis. Batiste offered Archie Milton, whom the court called "a purported expert musicologist," with a 68-page report on copying and digital sampling prepared with computer software.

At deposition Milton was asked about the analysis. "That's not my wording," he said of one passage. Asked whether none of the analysis was independently created by him, he answered: "Correct." He could not verify the comparisons because, in his words, "I don't have those programs." Batiste conceded that he had "collaborated" with Milton but denied writing the report.

Judge Martin L. C. Feldman found that Batiste "provided the actual substantive content" and assistance going beyond editorial help, so the report was not prepared by Milton as Rule 26 requires. The report and the proffered testimony were excluded under Rule 37(c)(1) and Federal Rule of Evidence 702. In this case the ghostwriter was the party himself, not his lawyer, and the rule applied the same way.

What happened in Fox v. Makin?

A challenge to Maine's school vaccination policy. The plaintiff's expert testified that the plaintiff's former attorney drafted the report and supplied the attached articles, and on March 10, 2025 the court excluded his testimony.

Dr. Gregory Fox challenged the vaccination policy applied in a Maine school district, and Commissioner Pender Makin moved to exclude his expert, Dr. Stephen Paulding. The report addressed transmission risk: it opined that a new student who attends school for 90 days without the required vaccinations poses the same risk as a student unvaccinated for the same period because of a religious objection.

At deposition Dr. Paulding testified that the plaintiff's former attorney, Stephen Whiting, drafted the report and supplied the articles attached to it, that he agreed with the report after it was presented to him, and that he had not reviewed the attached articles in detail.

Judge John A. Woodcock, Jr. held that the report did not comply with Rule 26(a)(2)(B): "Dr. Paulding did not prepare it as the Rule requires." The motion to exclude was granted. The court also rejected the argument that the challenge came too late, holding that a Rule 26 objection could be raised together with the Rule 702 challenge.

What happens to a report the expert did not prepare?

The report and the testimony can be excluded. Rule 37(c)(1) bars a party from using a witness or information not disclosed as Rule 26(a) requires, unless the failure was substantially justified or is harmless.

Rule 37(c)(1) reads: "If a party fails to provide information or identify a witness as required by Rule 26(a) or (e), the party is not allowed to use that information or witness to supply evidence on a motion, at a hearing, or at a trial, unless the failure was substantially justified or is harmless." Instead of or in addition to exclusion, the court may order payment of reasonable expenses, including attorney's fees, inform the jury of the failure, or impose other sanctions listed in Rule 37(b)(2)(A).

In Batiste the court relied on Rule 37(c)(1) and on Rule 702 together. In Fox the court held that a report the expert did not prepare does not satisfy Rule 26(a)(2)(B). In both cases the party lost the expert's opinions at the stage of the case where they were needed.

The timing matters for the other side as well. In Fox the court held that a challenge raised with the Rule 702 motion was timely, and in both cases the facts behind the challenge came from the expert's own deposition.

Can the other side see the drafts and the lawyer's emails to the expert?

Drafts are protected, and so are most attorney-expert communications. Three kinds are discoverable: those about compensation, facts or data counsel provided and the expert considered, and assumptions counsel provided and the expert relied on.

Since the 2010 amendments, Rule 26(b)(4)(B) protects "drafts of any report or disclosure required under Rule 26(a)(2), regardless of the form in which the draft is recorded." Rule 26(b)(4)(C) protects communications between the party's attorney and a witness required to provide a report, except to the extent that they relate to compensation for the expert's study or testimony, identify facts or data that the attorney provided and the expert considered, or identify assumptions that the attorney provided and the expert relied on.

The 2010 Committee Note keeps the expert's own work open to questioning. The protections do not impede discovery about the opinions to be offered or "the development, foundation, or basis of those opinions," and the expert may be asked about "alternative analyses, testing methods, or approaches" to the issues, whether or not he considered them.

So the drafts themselves usually stay out of reach, and authorship is tested through the expert. The questions that ended the reports in Batiste and Fox were questions about development and basis, which the 2010 note leaves open.

How does a reviewer spot a report the expert did not write?

By setting the report against the expert's own record and testimony: whether he can explain each analysis, whether he ran the software or tests, whether he read the cited sources, and what counsel supplied.

Both excluded reports failed on facts the expert could check himself. Milton did not have the programs used for the comparisons. Paulding had not read the attached articles in detail. A reviewer reads the opposing report for the same gaps: analyses that need tools or data the expert does not list, sources cited without any discussion of their content, and sections whose terminology or method differ from the expert's publications listed under Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(iv).

The reviewer then turns those gaps into deposition questions. The questions are short and factual, because under the 2010 note the development and basis of the opinions remain open to discovery.

  • Which sections of the report did you write yourself, and which were drafted by someone else?
  • Which tests, measurements or software runs did you perform personally, and where are the outputs?
  • Which documents did counsel send you, and which of them did you consider? (Rule 26(b)(4)(C)(ii))
  • Which facts were you told to assume, and did you rely on them? (Rule 26(b)(4)(C)(iii))
  • Which of the cited sources did you read in full before signing?
  • How many hours did you spend on the report, and how were you paid? (Rule 26(b)(4)(C)(i))

Does the same rule bind the reviewer's own rebuttal report?

Yes. A retained rebuttal expert also gives a Rule 26(a)(2)(B) report, so the reviewer writes the critique himself, keeps the analysis files and records what counsel sent him.

Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii) sets the default deadline for evidence "intended solely to contradict or rebut evidence on the same subject matter identified by another party," 30 days after the other party's disclosure. A rebuttal witness retained for the case still falls under Rule 26(a)(2)(B), so his report must be prepared and signed by him.

The reviewer who points to ghostwriting in the opposing report will face the same questions. He keeps his working files, his calculations and the list of documents received from counsel, so that he can answer at deposition which analysis is his and where it came from.

What does IAE do when the authorship of an opposing report is in question?

An IAE specialist reviews the opposing report, including whether its method, data and conclusions hold together, and prepares deposition questions. The specialist writes and signs his own document and confirms he has no interest in the outcome.

The client sends the report and the case materials and describes the task. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day, and within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its public registry. The client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts.

The review checks the method and whether it was followed at each stage, the completeness of the examination, whether the conclusions follow from it, the expert's competence for the subject, and the form and procedure of the report. Questions for the deposition of the opposing expert can be ordered with the review. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, with a 48-hour rush for tight deadlines.

The specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code. IAE is not a law firm; whether to move to exclude a report is a decision for the client's attorney, and a review is evidence the court weighs with the rest of the record.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member