Expert report review

Must a rebuttal expert offer an alternative opinion, or is a critique of the other report enough?

A rebuttal expert does not have to build a competing model. In Medidata v. Veeva (S.D.N.Y. 2022) the court repeated that "there is no requirement that a rebuttal expert himself offer a competing analysis." The limits run the other way: a rebuttal expert who presents a new affirmative theory can be struck, as in Wang v. Injective Labs (D. Del. 2025), and criticism of logic alone may belong to cross-examination, as in Avila v. Ford (N.D. Cal. 2025).

An empty witness chair holds a pencil and a blank pad, a thick report on the opposite table

Does a rebuttal expert have to offer an opinion of his own?

No. Federal courts hold that a rebuttal expert may confine the testimony to criticizing the methodology and opinions of the other side's expert, without offering a competing analysis or calculation.

In Medidata Solutions, Inc. v. Veeva Systems Inc., No. 1:17-cv-00589 (S.D.N.Y. Feb. 24, 2022), Judge Lorna G. Schofield quoted In re Aluminum Warehousing Antitrust Litigation, 336 F.R.D. 5 (S.D.N.Y. 2020): "A rebuttal expert, by nature, criticizes the methodology and/or opinions of another." The court continued: "There is no requirement that a rebuttal expert himself offer a competing analysis." The expert "need only attack those of plaintiffs' expert."

A rebuttal confined to the opposing report leaves the proof of that report with the party that offered it. The rebuttal expert's task in that setting is to show the court and the jury where the report fails, with the knowledge of the field.

What does Rule 26 say a rebuttal report is for?

Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii) describes rebuttal evidence as evidence intended solely to contradict or rebut evidence on the same subject matter identified by another party. The rule does not require a rebuttal expert to propose an answer of his own.

Under Rule 26 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, a rebuttal disclosure covers evidence "intended solely to contradict or rebut evidence on the same subject matter identified by another party." A rebuttal expert who is retained to testify still writes a report under Rule 26(a)(2)(B): "a complete statement of all opinions the witness will express and the basis and reasons for them," "the facts or data considered by the witness in forming them," the exhibits, the qualifications, the list of prior testimony and the compensation.

The rule speaks of contradicting or rebutting, which a critique of the opposing method does. In Trustees of Boston University v. Everlight Electronics, No. 12-cv-11935 (D. Mass. Oct. 20, 2015), Chief Judge Patti B. Saris held that a rebuttal report need address only the same subject matter and may use different methods or data. Quoting TC Systems Inc. v. Town of Colonie, she wrote that requiring the same methodology or data would "impose an additional restriction on the parties that is not included in the Rules."

What did the court decide about the rebuttal damages expert in Medidata?

It denied motions to exclude parts of the rebuttal reports of Veeva's damages expert, who had not built his own model for three of the opposing expert's opinions, and limited him at trial to the analyses in his reports.

Veeva's damages expert, Daniel Ingberman, answered the damages opinions of Medidata's expert, David Hall. His reports contained a corrected running royalty calculation in response to one of Hall's opinions, and no quantitative analysis of Hall's other three opinions.

Medidata moved in limine to exclude parts of the rebuttal reports, including a supplemental rebuttal report. The court denied the motions: because Ingberman offered rebuttal opinions, he did not need to produce his own competing model. The court limited his trial testimony to the analyses in his reports.

A rebuttal expert who stays within the critique cannot add a new calculation at trial that the reports did not contain.

Where does a critique end and a new theory begin?

At the point where the rebuttal stops engaging with the opposing report. In Wang v. Injective Labs (D. Del. 2025) the court struck the paragraphs presenting an alternative damages theory and kept those that answered the opposing theory.

In Wang v. Injective Labs Inc., No. 22-943 (D. Del. Mar. 11, 2025), Judge William C. Bryson wrote that "the report must contradict or rebut the actual contents of the initial report." The rebuttal expert could "rebut Dr. Risler's damages theory by offering a different perspective on that theory, but not by presenting an unrelated affirmative theory of damages."

The court granted the motion in part. It struck paragraphs 11-14, 25-43, 52-55, 61-70 and 72, which set out an alternative damages theory, and any trial testimony based on them. The paragraphs that engaged with the opposing report, 44-51, 56-60 and 71, stayed in.

Is every criticism proper rebuttal testimony?

Not always. In Avila v. Ford (N.D. Cal. 2025) the court kept opinions that raised genuine methodological challenges but struck those that only pointed to logical flaws and disputed conclusions, which it said belong to cross-examination or closing argument.

In Avila v. Ford Motor Co., No. 5:22-cv-00542 (N.D. Cal. Aug. 22, 2025), Judge P. Casey Pitts reviewed a rebuttal report by Dan Calef. Opinions that "present genuine methodological challenges to the opinions set forth in Ford's experts' reports" were proper rebuttal.

Other parts repeated another expert's analysis, argued the case, or pointed out logical flaws in Ford's experts' reports and disputed their conclusions. The court wrote that such critiques are "more appropriate for cross examination or closing argument, rather than being within the purview of a rebuttal expert." It granted the motion to strike in part, keeping three sections of the report and striking the rest.

Read together, Medidata and Avila give the shape of a rebuttal that survives: it uses the expert's own knowledge to test the opposing method, data and application. What a lawyer could say from the transcript, without expertise, does not need an expert.

What should a critique-only rebuttal report test?

The opposing method, the data it used, how the method was applied, and whether the conclusions follow from the analysis, each with the specialist knowledge that a lawyer cannot supply.

A rebuttal confined to critique still needs substance. The questions follow from what the opposing expert must show and from the limits in Avila:

  • Is the method recognized in the field for this kind of question, and is there literature or a standard the expert departed from?
  • Were the data sufficient and correct, and were data that cut the other way left out?
  • Was the method applied as described, at every step, with the inputs the report lists?
  • Do the conclusions follow from the analysis, or does the report state a result that its own calculations do not produce?
  • For each point, what specialist knowledge does the critique rest on, so that it is expert testimony and not argument?

When is it worth offering an alternative opinion anyway?

When the party bears the burden on the point, or when the factfinder will need a number or a cause to choose. Then the alternative is an affirmative opinion and goes in an initial report, not in rebuttal.

Wang draws the procedural consequence. An affirmative theory has to be disclosed as one, by the deadline for affirmative reports. Putting it into a rebuttal report risks having it struck.

A party that wants the jury to have its own damages figure or its own cause of failure therefore decides early whether it needs an affirmative expert. If the decision is made after the opposing report arrives, the rebuttal can still test that report, and a corrected calculation that answers a specific opinion, as in Medidata, stays within rebuttal.

Does a Russian reviewer have to give his own answer to the expert's questions?

No. A review tests whether the opinion can be checked and is sound; a new answer to the questions comes from an additional or repeat examination that the court orders under Article 87 of the Arbitration Procedure Code.

Under Article 8 of Federal Law No. 73-FZ, an expert opinion must rest on provisions that make it possible to verify the soundness and reliability of its conclusions on the basis of generally accepted scientific and practical data. A Russian review checks that point by point. Under Part 2 of Article 87 of the Arbitration Procedure Code, doubts about the soundness of an opinion are a ground for a repeat examination by another expert or commission of experts.

What does IAE prepare when a rebuttal is limited to the opposing report?

IAE reviews the opposing expert's report on six questions and prepares deposition or hearing questions on request. The format, cost, deadline and specialist are confirmed within one business day; the signed PDF follows in up to 5 business days.

The review answers six questions about the report: whether the method fits the object and the questions and was followed at every stage; whether all objects, materials and questions were examined, with no substituted questions or gaps; whether the conclusions follow from the examination, with no contradictions or inadmissible assumptions; whether the expert's education, specialty and experience match the subject; whether the report meets the formal requirements and procedure of the jurisdiction; and whether it can be relied on.

The client sends the opposing report with its exhibits and data and describes the task: a review, questions for the deposition, or both. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day, and within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry. The client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. A 48-hour rush is available for tight deadlines.

Every reviewer is a member of the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code, and confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy; whether to serve an affirmative or a rebuttal report is a decision for the client's attorney. Neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member