Examinations
Goods do not match the sample or the description: what does the buyer have to prove, and what does the expert compare?
A description of the goods, or a sample or model, that is part of the basis of the bargain creates an express warranty under UCC 2-313. Described goods must conform to the description, and the whole of the goods to the sample or model. No formal words are needed. In a lawsuit the buyer proves the warranty, the nonconformity and timely notice, and an expert compares the delivered goods with the sample or description.

When does a sample or a description become a warranty?
When it is made part of the basis of the bargain. UCC 2-313(1)(b) and (1)(c) then create an express warranty: the goods must conform to the description, and the whole of the goods to the sample or model.
Section 2-313(1) of the Uniform Commercial Code names three ways a seller creates an express warranty. Paragraph (a) covers "any affirmation of fact or promise made by the seller to the buyer which relates to the goods and becomes part of the basis of the bargain". Paragraph (b) reads: "Any description of the goods which is made part of the basis of the bargain creates an express warranty that the goods shall conform to the description." Paragraph (c) reads: "Any sample or model which is made part of the basis of the bargain creates an express warranty that the whole of the goods shall conform to the sample or model."
Subsection (2) removes the formalities. It is not necessary "that the seller use formal words such as 'warrant' or 'guarantee' or that he have a specific intention to make a warranty." The same subsection draws the line on the other side: "an affirmation merely of the value of the goods or a statement purporting to be merely the seller's opinion or commendation of the goods does not create a warranty."
The words "the whole of the goods" in paragraph (c) matter for a lot of goods. A sample stands for every unit delivered under the contract. In Alafoss the district court counted the units that failed the sample and found at least 3,736 nonconforming coats out of two purchase orders for 7,200 and 1,025 coats.
Every state enacts Article 2 in its own code under its own numbering. The Minnesota version, Minn. Stat. 336.2-714, appears in the Alafoss case discussed below. Hawaii prints the official comments next to its section 490:2-313, and those comments are quoted in this article.
Does the buyer have to prove reliance on the sample or the description?
Not as a separate element. Official comment 3 to 2-313 says no particular reliance on such statements need be shown; the question is whether the sample or description became part of the basis of the bargain.
Official comment 3 states: "No specific intention to make a warranty is necessary if any of these factors is made part of the basis of the bargain." It goes on: "no particular reliance on such statements need be shown in order to weave them into the fabric of the agreement."
Model jury instructions put the question the same way. New Jersey Model Civil Jury Charge 4.21, Breach of Express Warranty on Sale of Goods, asks whether the affirmation "became part of the basis of the bargain" and does not use the word reliance. Its commentary says that whether affirmations were woven into the agreement "requires clear affirmative proof and is usually a fact issue." North Carolina Pattern Jury Instruction 741.10 asks whether the goods do not conform "to the sample or model which was made part of the basis of the bargain between the buyer and the seller."
Courts still record reliance when the evidence supports it. In Alafoss the District of Minnesota found: "The sample was part of the basis of the bargain, was relied upon by PCA." The buyer had approved sample coats before it placed its purchase orders.
For the expert this question fixes the reference object. Before any measurement the report names the sample, the catalog page or the specification sheet that the parties used, with the date it was shown or sent. A comparison against a later catalog or a different sample answers a question nobody in the case asked.
What is the difference between a sample and a model?
A sample is drawn from the bulk being sold; a model is shown when the goods are not at hand. Official comment 6 treats a sample from an existing bulk as describing the goods unless the seller clearly disclaims that.
Official comment 6 to 2-313 starts from a presumption: "In general, the presumption is that any sample or model" is intended to become a basis of the bargain. Whether a particular display was meant to describe the goods or only to suggest their type remains a question of fact, and the comment says the circumstances help answer it.
For a sample the comment is firm: "If the sample has been drawn from an existing bulk, it must be regarded as describing values of the goods contracted for" unless the seller clearly disclaims that responsibility. The comment also requires that a sample drawn from an existing bulk be fairly drawn.
A model gets weaker treatment. When the seller shows a model of goods that are not on hand, the presumption that the model literally describes the goods is weaker, and the comment notes the case where the buyer's own changes to the model impair a feature.
The expert therefore records the history of the reference item: who kept it after the contract was signed, whether it was sealed, whether it came from the production lot or was made separately as a showroom piece. A model built before production and a sample taken from the lot support different conclusions about what the buyer was promised.
What if the sample and the written specifications disagree?
UCC 2-317 reads warranties as consistent and cumulative where that is reasonable. If they cannot be reconciled, exact or technical specifications displace an inconsistent sample or model, and a sample from an existing bulk displaces general descriptive language.
Section 2-317 opens with the rule that "Warranties whether express or implied shall be construed as consistent with each other and as cumulative". If that reading is unreasonable, the intention of the parties decides which warranty is dominant, and the section gives three rules for finding it.
Rule (a): "Exact or technical specifications displace an inconsistent sample or model or general language of description." Rule (b): "A sample from an existing bulk displaces inconsistent general language of description." Rule (c): "Express warranties displace inconsistent implied warranties" other than the implied warranty of fitness for a particular purpose.
Official comment 5 to 2-313 widens what counts as a description. It says: "A description need not be by words." It adds that "Technical specifications, blueprints and the like can afford more exact description than mere language", and that "Past deliveries may set the description of quality, either expressly or impliedly by course of dealing."
These rules set the order of the expert's comparison. Drawings, tolerances and test values in the contract come first. The sample is checked next for features the specifications do not address, such as color or texture. General catalog words come last. When the contract gives a dimension with a tolerance, the expert measures against the tolerance, not against the dimension of the sample.
Can a general disclaimer cancel the description?
Not as to the description itself. Official comment 4 to 2-313 says a clause generally disclaiming all warranties, express or implied, cannot reduce the seller's obligation with respect to the description of the goods.
Comment 4 starts from the nature of the contract: "a contract is normally a contract for a sale of something describable and described." It then states: "A clause generally disclaiming 'all warranties, express or implied' cannot reduce the seller's obligation with respect to such description".
Timing does not defeat the warranty either. Comment 7 says: "The precise time when words of description or affirmation are made or samples are shown is not material." If the seller adds descriptive language after the deal is closed, the comment says that "the warranty becomes a modification, and need not be supported by consideration", provided the modification is otherwise reasonable and in order under section 2-209.
Sales talk stays outside. Comment 8 says that all of the seller's statements generally become part of the basis of the bargain unless there is good reason to think otherwise, and that subsection (2) exists for opinions, commendations and similar statements. New Mexico's Uniform Jury Instruction 13-1428 makes the same cut: sales talk that a reasonably prudent buyer would interpret as merely a salesperson's recommendation or opinion does not create a warranty.
For the expert, the line between a description and sales talk decides which statements become test items. A stated fiber content, weight, capacity or dimension can be measured. A phrase such as premium quality cannot, and the report says so rather than inventing a test for it.
What does the buyer have to prove at trial?
That the sample or description became part of the basis of the bargain, that the goods did not conform, that notice was given within a reasonable time, and the damages. Model jury charges put these questions to the jury.
The commentary to New Jersey Model Civil Jury Charge 4.21 quotes the statute for both sources of warranty, "Any description of the goods which is made part of the basis of the bargain" and "Any sample or model which is made part of the basis of the bargain", and the rule that it is "not necessary to the creation of an express warranty that the seller use formal words". The charge asks the jury whether the goods conformed and "whether plaintiff-buyer gave notice of that fact to defendant-seller within a reasonable time."
North Carolina Pattern Jury Instruction 741.10 frames the breach issue separately for each source. For a description it asks whether the goods do not conform "to the description of the (name good) which was made part of the basis of the bargain"; for a sample it asks the parallel question about the sample or model.
New Mexico's Uniform Jury Instruction 13-1428, Creation and breach of express warranty, has a paragraph for a sample or model. Its use note says the paragraph is used "where the warranty was allegedly created by exhibiting a sample or model of the product." A supplier breaches the warranty when the goods do not conform to the description or the promised performance.
The expert's report goes to the second element, nonconformity, and supplies the measurements that damages experts use. It does not decide whether notice was timely or whether a statement was part of the bargain: those are questions for the jury on the instructions above.
How did the courts decide the Alafoss wool coat case?
The District of Minnesota held in 1978 that coats with yellowed fur collars breached an express warranty by sample. In 1979 the Eighth Circuit affirmed that liability but reversed the damage award and sent it back for recalculation.
Alafoss, an Icelandic exporter, supplied women's wrap coats with an all-white wool body and a detachable white fur collar made from Icelandic sheep fur. Premium Corporation of America (PCA) resold the coats by direct mail to American Express cardholders. In about July 1972 PCA approved sample coats in sizes 8 through 16. The samples had full, solid white collars with no perceptible yellowing. PCA then issued purchase orders for 7,200 and 1,025 coats.
In October 1973 PCA found "a significant yellow discoloration" in many collars, and loosely sewn pockets on about 1,400 coats. A New York furrier, Mademoiselle Furs, "purported to have a process" to improve the collars. PCA paid $5.55 per collar, $24,186.90 in total for about 4,350 collars, and used the treated collars to fill orders. Customers returned coats with "yellow and ragged collars" in early 1974. The court found that the treatment "did not change the color of the fur but only temporarily improved its appearance."
In June 1974 PCA detached the collars from the coats in inventory and "drew a random sample of 112 collars." The court found that this sample "does not conform in color or quality to the sample coats approved by PCA in 1972." Judge MacLaughlin held that the samples "were made a part of the basis of the bargain" and created an express warranty that the whole of the goods would conform to them, and that Alafoss delivered at least 3,736 coats that did not conform.
The district court measured damages under the Minnesota version of 2-714, the difference in value at the time and place of acceptance. It valued the 3,736 coats as warranted at $88.11 each, $329,178.96 in total. PCA had sold them to Aldens, Inc. for a net $71,740; the court found $25 per coat a fair price, set the value of the coats as delivered at $90,420 and arrived at a difference of $238,758.96. Incidental damages were $26,986.90: the collar treatment plus $2,800 for pocket repairs. After an offset of $132,470 that PCA owed Alafoss for unpaid coats, the district court entered judgment for PCA of $133,275.86 plus costs and interest. Lost profits were denied.
The damage figure did not survive the appeal. In Alafoss, h.f. v. Premium Corp. of America, 599 F.2d 232 (8th Cir. 1979), Judge Bright wrote for the panel: "we affirm the district court's determination of Alafoss' liability for breach of warranties". The panel reversed the damage award. PCA had expected that it could not sell "somewhere between twenty-five and fifty percent of the coats" even if every coat conformed, and the 3,736 coats sold to Aldens were about 44 percent of the total ordered. The district court "should have distinguished between the number of coats that would normally have been left over and the number of additional coats left over due to the nonconformities." The Eighth Circuit concluded that the award "should be substantially reduced" to the actual loss PCA sustained and remanded the case.
The district court's opinion names no expert or laboratory for the comparison. It relied on PCA's findings of discoloration, the customer returns, PCA's letter of June 12, 1974 and the random sample of 112 collars set against the approved sample coats. On appeal Alafoss argued that the customers' letters showed dissatisfaction with size, not with the collars or pockets, and the Eighth Circuit found the letters "highly relevant to whether PCA adequately proved its damages."
How does an expert compare the goods with the sample or the description?
The expert first fixes the reference: the approved sample, the specification or the catalog text in force at contracting. Then the expert inspects or tests the delivered goods for each stated feature and records how units were selected.
Access to the goods comes from 2-515. Under subsection (a) either party, "on reasonable notification to the other and for the purpose of ascertaining the facts and preserving evidence has the right to inspect, test and sample the goods including such of them as may be in the possession or control of the other". Under subsection (b) the parties "may agree to a third party inspection or survey to determine the conformity or condition of the goods" and may agree that the findings "shall be binding upon them in any subsequent litigation or adjustment."
The work then runs in four steps.
Because the warranty covers "the whole of the goods", selection is part of the method. In Alafoss the court relied on PCA's random sample of 112 collars detached from the coats in inventory. A report that examines the three worst units chosen by the buyer tells the court about those three units only.
Section 2-515(a) requires reasonable notification to the other side for testing and sampling as well as for inspection, so the other side can attend or send its own expert when a unit is cut, washed or loaded to failure. The report lists who was present and what happened to each tested unit.
- The expert identifies the reference: the sample with its chain of custody, or the specification or catalog page with its date, and explains under 2-317 which one controls if they differ.
- The expert lists every feature the reference states: dimensions, weight, material, color, finish, capacity, performance values.
- The expert selects units from the delivered goods by a stated method, such as random selection by lot number, and records how many units were examined out of how many delivered.
- The expert measures or tests each unit for each feature, photographs it beside the sample under the same lighting and states for each feature whether the unit conforms.
What does IAE do when goods do not match the sample or the description?
IAE prepares an expert report on the client's questions or a review of the opposing expert's report. The format, cost, deadline and specialist are confirmed within one business day, and the signed PDF follows in up to 5 business days.
The client sends the request and describes the goods and the dispute: what was delivered, what the sample or the description promised, whether a warranty period applies, and what is attached, such as the contract or purchase order, the catalog page or specification, photographs of the approved sample, delivery documents, notice letters and any inspection report or expert report from the other side. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The questions are confirmed with the client before work starts.
The specialist prepares the report, and the draft is checked for facts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days, depending on the volume of materials. For cases with tight deadlines there is a 48-hour rush.
Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy; whether to reject the goods, revoke acceptance or sue for damages is a question for the client's attorney. An expert report is evidence that the court weighs with the rest of the record, and neither IAE nor the expert guarantees the outcome.
Sources
- UCC 2-313, Express Warranties by Affirmation, Promise, Description, Sample (LII, Cornell Law School)
- UCC 2-317, Cumulation and Conflict of Warranties Express or Implied (LII, Cornell Law School)
- UCC 2-515, Preserving Evidence of Goods in Dispute (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Hawaii Revised Statutes 490:2-313, Comments to Official Text (Hawaii State Legislature)
- Alafoss, h.f. v. Premium Corporation of America, Inc., 448 F. Supp. 95 (D. Minn. 1978) (Justia)
- New Jersey Model Civil Jury Charge 4.21, Breach of Express Warranty on Sale of Goods (New Jersey Courts)
- North Carolina Pattern Jury Instruction Civil 741.10, Warranties in Sales of Goods, Issue of Breach of Express Warranty, General Civil Volume, May 1999 (UNC School of Government)
- New Mexico Uniform Jury Instruction 13-1428, Creation and breach of express warranty (New Mexico Supreme Court)
- Alafoss, h.f. v. Premium Corporation of America, Inc., 599 F.2d 232 (8th Cir. 1979) (Justia)
Read also
All articles
Goods damaged in a warehouse: who is liable, and what does the goods expert establish?
Goods go into a warehouse sound and come out wet, crushed, spoiled or short. Under UCC 7-204 the warehouse answers for damage caused by its failure
How do you prove goods are counterfeit, and what does the product expert compare?
Under the Lanham Act a counterfeit is a spurious mark that is identical with, or substantially indistinguishable from, a registered mark. Whether
Goods damaged in shipping: who bears the loss, and what does the expert establish?
When goods arrive damaged, three questions decide who pays: when the risk of loss passed to the buyer under UCC 2-509, whether the goods were alreadyExpert examinations
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

