Expert report review

Hiring an expert to review the opposing expert's report: what may the reviewer see and do?

A party or its lawyer can hire an expert to review the other side's expert report as soon as that report is served. The reviewer works from the written report, its exhibits and the facts or data the opposing expert considered. Confidential documents reach the reviewer through the protective order in the case, and questions for the opposing expert go through a deposition, not a private call.

A hand opens a sealed envelope beside a thick expert report on a counsel table

Who can hire an expert to review the opposing expert's report?

The party or its attorney. A reviewer who will not testify works as a consulting expert, and Rule 26(b)(4)(D) ordinarily keeps a consultant's facts and opinions out of the other side's discovery.

Rule 26(b)(4)(D) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure reads: "Ordinarily, a party may not, by interrogatories or deposition, discover facts known or opinions held by an expert who has been retained or specially employed by another party in anticipation of litigation or to prepare for trial and who is not expected to be called as a witness at trial." There are two exceptions: an examination report under Rule 35(b), and a showing of exceptional circumstances under which it is impracticable for the party to obtain facts or opinions on the same subject by other means.

The model stipulated protective order of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California treats the consultant and the testifying expert alike. It defines an Expert as "a person with specialized knowledge or experience in a matter pertinent to the litigation who has been retained by a Party or its counsel to serve as an expert witness or as a consultant in this action." A reviewer hired only to read and critique the report falls within that definition.

The role changes when the party decides to call the reviewer at trial. Rule 26(a)(2)(A) then requires the party to disclose the identity of the witness, and a retained witness must give a written report. Absent a stipulation or court order, evidence intended solely to contradict or rebut the other side's expert evidence on the same subject is due within 30 days after the other side's disclosure, under Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii). Rule 26(a)(2)(D) puts the court's schedule first, so the reviewer starts by reading the scheduling order.

What does the opposing expert's disclosure give the reviewer?

A report prepared and signed by the expert, with every opinion and its basis, the facts or data considered, exhibits, qualifications and publications for ten years, testimony for four years, and compensation.

Rule 26(a)(2)(B) requires a written report, prepared and signed by the witness, from a witness retained or specially employed to give expert testimony. The report must contain six items, and each one gives the reviewer something to check.

The 1993 Advisory Committee Note explains why the rule asks for so much. Under the former rule, answers about the substance of expert testimony were "frequently so sketchy and vague that it rarely dispensed with the need to depose the expert." With a full report, the note says, in many cases the report may eliminate the need for a deposition.

The reviewer reads the six items against each other. An opinion in item (i) that rests on a document missing from item (ii) is a question for deposition. A publication list in item (iv) can show whether the expert has written about the method he applied. Item (v) gives case names for the last four years, and transcripts from those cases can show whether the expert took a different position on the same method before.

  • A complete statement of all opinions the witness will express and the basis and reasons for them.
  • The facts or data considered by the witness in forming them.
  • Any exhibits that will be used to summarize or support them.
  • The witness's qualifications, including a list of all publications authored in the previous 10 years.
  • A list of all other cases in which, during the previous 4 years, the witness testified as an expert at trial or by deposition.
  • A statement of the compensation to be paid for the study and testimony in the case.

Can the reviewer see documents produced under a protective order?

Usually yes, on the order's terms. In the Northern District of California model order, confidential material may go to a retained expert or consultant if disclosure is reasonably necessary and the expert signs an acknowledgment.

Under Rule 26(c)(1)(G) a court may, for good cause, order "that a trade secret or other confidential research, development, or commercial information not be revealed or be revealed only in a specified way." The documents behind the opposing report may carry a designation under such an order, and then the order decides who may read them.

Section 7.2(c) of the Northern District of California standard model order permits disclosure of material designated CONFIDENTIAL to "Experts (as defined in this Order) of the Receiving Party to whom disclosure is reasonably necessary for this litigation and who have signed the 'Acknowledgment and Agreement to Be Bound' (Exhibit A)." In Exhibit A the expert declares under penalty of perjury that he has read and understood the order, agrees to be bound by it, submits to the jurisdiction of the court and appoints an agent for service of process in California.

The obligations last after the case ends. Under Section 4, confidentiality remains in effect until the designating party agrees otherwise in writing or a court orders otherwise. Under Section 13, within 60 days after final disposition of the action each receiving party must return all protected material to the producing party or destroy it, and certify this in writing. Counsel should keep track of every file the reviewer received, because the reviewer's copies count.

Will the other side learn who the reviewer is before he sees the files?

Under the standard model order, no advance notice is required. Under the model order for highly sensitive patent and trade secret material, the reviewer's name, CV, employer, funding sources and five years of testimony go to the designating party first.

The Northern District of California has a separate model order for litigation involving patents, highly sensitive confidential information and trade secrets. Section 7.4(a)(2) requires a party that wants to show material designated highly confidential for attorneys' eyes only to an expert to send a written request first. The request identifies the general categories of information, gives the expert's full name and the city and state of his primary residence, attaches a current resume and names his current employers.

The request also identifies each person or entity from whom the expert received compensation or funding for work in his areas of expertise, or to whom he provided professional services, during the preceding five years. It also lists each case in which he gave expert testimony during the preceding five years, including through a declaration, report, deposition or trial testimony, by case name and number, filing date and court location.

The designating party may object in writing within 14 days of delivery, with detailed grounds. The parties must then meet and confer by direct voice-to-voice dialogue within seven days of the objection. If they do not agree, the requesting party may file a motion under Civil Local Rule 7, and the party opposing disclosure bears the burden of proving that the risk of harm outweighs the receiving party's need.

Two consequences follow for a review. A consultant whose identity would otherwise stay private becomes known to the other side once he needs that tier of documents. And 14 days for an objection plus seven days to confer use three weeks of a 30-day rebuttal period, so the request goes out on the day the reviewer is chosen.

Can the reviewer or counsel call the opposing expert directly?

Not without risk. In Campbell Industries v. M/V Gemini the Ninth Circuit upheld an order that barred an expert's testimony after the other side's counsel contacted him ex parte. Rule 26(b)(4)(A) provides a deposition instead.

In Campbell Industries v. M/V Gemini, 619 F.2d 24 (9th Cir. 1980), Campbell had retained Nathaniel Torbert in 1974 to inspect a ship and listed him as its expert witness. Counsel for Gemini contacted Torbert ex parte several times while he was still working for Campbell. When the contacts came to light, the district court barred Torbert from testifying at trial. Gemini conceded on appeal that the contacts violated Rule 26(b)(4).

The Ninth Circuit affirmed on April 30, 1980. It held that the ruling, "carefully fashioned to deny Gemini the fruits of its misconduct yet not interfere with Gemini's right to produce other relevant expert testimony," was not an abuse of discretion, and that exclusion was within the court's inherent power even though no court order had been violated. Gemini had three other experts who inspected the ship at the same time, and one of them testified on the same issues.

Ethics opinions do not settle the procedural question. In Opinion 577 of October 29, 1986, the New York State Bar Association Committee on Professional Ethics found ex parte communication with an adversary's retained expert ethically permissible, but said a lawyer may not use it to learn matters protected by an evidentiary or work product privilege. The Committee expressly declined to say whether CPLR 3101(d)(1) or Federal Rule 26(b)(4) would bar the contact.

The safe route is the rule itself. Under Rule 26(b)(4)(A) a party may depose any person identified as an expert whose opinions may be presented at trial, and if a report is required, only after the report is provided. Under Rule 26(b)(4)(E), unless manifest injustice would result, the party seeking that discovery pays the expert a reasonable fee for the time spent responding. The reviewer's part is to write the questions.

Can the reviewer examine or test the physical evidence himself?

Yes, through a Rule 34 request. A party may ask to inspect, copy, test or sample documents and tangible things, or to enter property to inspect, measure, photograph, test or sample it, at a reasonable time, place and manner.

A report built on testing often cannot be checked from paper alone. Rule 34(a)(1) lets a party request the other side to produce and permit it or its representative "to inspect, copy, test, or sample" designated documents, electronically stored information and tangible things in the responding party's possession, custody or control.

Rule 34(a)(2) covers premises: entry onto designated land or other property so that the requesting party may "inspect, measure, survey, photograph, test, or sample the property or any designated object or operation on it." Under Rule 34(b)(1)(B), the request must specify a reasonable time, place and manner for the inspection, and under Rule 34(b)(2)(A) the other side responds in writing within 30 days after being served.

The reviewer drafts the technical part of the request: which object, which measurement, which test and what equipment. If the test would alter or consume the object, the request says so, and the other side can object or propose conditions in its written response before anyone touches the evidence.

What does the reviewer hand back, and what can the other side see?

A consulting reviewer gives counsel a written critique and questions for deposition. If he later testifies, his drafts stay protected, but facts, data and assumptions counsel gave him, and his compensation, become discoverable.

While the reviewer consults, his work stays with counsel under Rule 26(b)(4)(D). Once he is disclosed as a testifying rebuttal expert, Rule 26(b)(4)(B) protects drafts of his report regardless of form, and Rule 26(b)(4)(C) protects his communications with the party's attorney with three exceptions: communications that relate to his compensation, that identify facts or data the attorney provided and he considered, or that identify assumptions the attorney provided and he relied on.

The 2010 Committee Note sets the outer limit of that protection. It does not impede discovery about the expert's opinions or "the development, foundation, or basis of those opinions," and the expert may be questioned about "alternative analyses, testing methods, or approaches" to the issues, whether or not he considered them in forming his opinions.

For that reason a reviewer who may testify keeps a clean list of every document he received and from whom. The same list later answers item (ii) of his own Rule 26(a)(2)(B) report.

What does IAE do when a party needs the opposing expert's report reviewed?

IAE assigns a specialist from its public registry who checks the method, completeness, reasoning, competence, form and procedure of the report. Format, cost, deadline and specialist are confirmed within one business day.

The client sends the report or the case materials and describes the task. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. Reviews cover 16 fields of expertise in civil, commercial and criminal cases.

The reviewer answers six questions about the report: whether the method fits the object and the questions and was followed at each stage, whether all objects, materials and questions were examined, whether the conclusions follow from the examination, whether the expert's education and experience match the subject, whether the report meets the form and procedure of the jurisdiction, and whether it can be relied on. The client can also order questions for the deposition of the opposing expert.

The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, depending on the volume of materials; a 48-hour rush is available for tight deadlines. The specialist confirms in the document that he has no interest in the outcome, materials are not passed to third parties without the client's consent, and the specialist can be verified in the registry by Member ID or QR code. IAE is not a law firm, and a review is evidence that the court weighs with the rest of the record.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member