Examinations

Hospital-acquired infection lawsuit: what does the medical expert have to prove?

An infection caught in a hospital is grounds for a malpractice claim only if a physician expert links it to a breach of the standard of care or establishes that it was recognized or treated too late. In an unpublished January 2025 opinion, a New Jersey appeals court affirmed summary judgment against a patient with MRSA after a knee replacement: no expert said such an infection does not ordinarily occur without negligence.

A clinician from behind pulls on gloves beside an empty bed and a folded isolation gown

Can you sue a hospital for an infection you caught there?

Yes, as a negligence or malpractice claim. The patient has to prove a breach of the standard of care and that the breach caused the infection or its harm, and courts generally require expert testimony on both.

The infection itself is not the claim. The claim is that someone at the hospital did or failed to do something the standard of care required, and that this act or omission caused the infection, or made it worse by delaying its recognition or treatment.

Courts treat both points as medical questions. In Spille v. Virtua Health, Inc., No. A-2743-22, an unpublished opinion decided on January 3, 2025, the Appellate Division of the Superior Court of New Jersey restated the rule that medical malpractice generally requires expert proof of the standard of care, the deviation from it and proximate cause. In Koeniguer, 422 N.W.2d 600, a malpractice case over a patient's death decided on April 27, 1988, the Supreme Court of South Dakota quoted the rule that the plaintiff has the burden of proving causation in a malpractice action and generally must present expert testimony to meet it.

Two theories recur in these cases. One concerns how the infection started: sterile technique, equipment, hand hygiene, the environment. The other concerns what happened once it appeared: whether the signs of infection were recognized and treated in time. The expert's work differs between them, and so do the records the expert needs.

What do federal rules require hospitals to do about infections?

Under 42 CFR 482.42, a Medicare-participating hospital must run active hospital-wide programs for surveillance, prevention and control of healthcare-associated infections, with an appointed infection preventionist and an antibiotic stewardship program.

Section 482.42 is one of the conditions of participation for hospitals in Part 482 of Title 42. Its introduction states: "The hospital must have active hospital-wide programs for the surveillance, prevention, and control of HAIs" and other infectious diseases, and for optimizing the use of antibiotics through stewardship. The programs follow nationally recognized guidelines and are coordinated with the hospital's quality assessment and performance improvement (QAPI) program.

Paragraph (a)(1) requires the governing body to appoint a qualified infection preventionist or infection control professional, on the recommendation of medical staff and nursing leadership. Under paragraph (a)(2) the program has documented policies and procedures and "employs methods for preventing and controlling the transmission of infections within the hospital" and between the hospital and other settings. Paragraph (a)(3) covers surveillance, prevention and control of HAIs, including "maintaining a clean and sanitary environment to avoid sources and transmission of infection," and issues identified by public health authorities.

Paragraph (b) requires an antibiotic stewardship program led by one or more persons with training or experience in infectious diseases or stewardship. The program documents the evidence-based use of antibiotics in all departments and services and records improvements.

Paragraph (c) assigns duties. The infection preventionist develops and implements policies, documents the program, works with the QAPI and stewardship programs, trains staff and audits adherence to the policies. Under paragraph (d), a system that runs two or more separately certified hospitals may operate unified programs where state and local law permit, with a designated qualified individual at each hospital.

Does a hospital infection-control rule set the standard of care for the doctors?

Not by itself. In Spille the New Jersey court held that the state MRSA statute does not impose a standard of care and, because it applies only to hospitals, cannot set the standard for individual medical defendants.

New Jersey has a statute on MRSA in hospitals, N.J.S.A. 26:2H-12.35. The plaintiffs in Spille relied on it. The Appellate Division held that the statute does not impose a standard of care and did not create a per se cause of action for negligence, and that, because it applies only to hospitals, it could not establish the standard of care for the individual medical defendants. The court noted that the statute calls such infections preventable, while the studies behind it confirmed that the infection can occur without any negligent action or inaction.

Section 482.42 describes programs, policies and records the hospital must keep. It does not describe what an individual physician must do for a particular patient. Whether a nurse, an anesthesiologist or a surgeon fell below the standard of care with a particular patient is still a question for an expert in that field, who explains what a reasonable practitioner would have done.

The program records still matter. A hospital that must document its surveillance, its policies and its audits of adherence under 42 CFR 482.42 has documents that the expert can ask for: the unit's infection surveillance data for the period, the policies on sterile technique in force on the date of the procedure, and audit results for that unit.

What happened in the New Jersey MRSA case after a knee replacement?

James Spille developed MRSA bacteremia and an epidural abscess after a knee replacement under spinal anesthesia. The court affirmed summary judgment for the defendants because his experts did not address whether such an infection occurs without negligence.

Spille had a total left knee replacement at Virtua Voorhees Hospital on January 10, 2019, with a single spinal anesthesia block given through a BD needle. He had tested negative for MRSA on December 3, 2018. On January 28, 2019 he was readmitted with MRSA bacteremia, L4-L5 discitis and an epidural abscess. A knee infection followed in April 2019.

Two experts supported the claim. An anesthesiologist, in the affidavit of merit, wrote that the infection "appears to have been causally related to the neuraxial block procedure, secondary to improper sterile technique, faulty equipment, improper oversight." An infectious disease specialist concluded that Spille "obtained the MRSA epidural abscess and bacteremia from the epidural anesthesia." Neither addressed the view of the medical community on whether a MRSA infection of this kind occurs without negligence.

The defense attacked the timeline. It argued that his last bloodwork was five weeks before the surgery, so it was unknown whether the infection developed just before, during or after the procedure, and that he began physical therapy on January 14, before his readmission on January 28. The trial judge said the expert report "does little to explain anything dealing with MRSA" beyond the timing.

The Appellate Division affirmed. Res ipsa loquitur did not apply, because neither expert testified that the medical community recognizes that a MRSA infection of this kind does not ordinarily occur without negligence. The narrow burden-shifting exception the plaintiffs also invoked did not fit the case. The common knowledge exception did not apply either, and the court noted that Spille had acknowledged in the consent form that infection is a recognized and foreseeable risk of surgery. The court recorded that the plaintiffs conceded their expert report was not sufficient to establish a prima facie negligence case. The opinion is unpublished and under New Jersey Rule 1:36-3 does not constitute precedent.

Can the jury infer negligence just because the infection happened?

Only with expert support. In Spille, an unpublished New Jersey decision, res ipsa loquitur required expert testimony that the medical community recognizes such an infection does not ordinarily occur without negligence, and the plaintiffs had none.

Res ipsa loquitur lets a jury infer negligence when an injury of that kind does not ordinarily happen without someone's negligence. For a hospital infection, whether that is true is itself a medical question, and the New Jersey court required an expert to say so. The court also repeated that res ipsa does not shift the burden of proof: it requires of the defendant an explanation, not exculpation.

The consent form came up in the same opinion. Spille had signed a consent that listed infection among the risks of the operation, and the court cited that acknowledgment when it held the common knowledge exception inapplicable.

For the expert, the practical consequence is specific. A report that traces the infection to a procedure and names the possible lapses is not enough in a jurisdiction that follows Spille's reasoning. The report also has to explain, with literature or the expert's own basis, why this infection, in this patient, with this organism and this timing, points to a breach rather than to a risk that materializes with correct care.

Can the claim be about late treatment of the infection rather than how it started?

Yes. In Koeniguer, a 1988 sepsis case, the South Dakota Supreme Court reversed summary judgment for a hospital, holding that a jury could infer from the record that the delay in treatment led to the patient's readmission.

Winnifred Scoblic had surgery on January 5, 1983 and was discharged on January 16 with a temperature of 100.2 degrees that morning. She was readmitted on January 19 with severe abdominal pain, fever and sepsis, was transferred to the University of Minnesota Hospital and died on March 6, 1983. In the suit that followed, the trial court granted summary judgment to Dakota Midland Hospital. The Supreme Court of South Dakota reversed on April 27, 1988 (No. 15869) and remanded for trial.

The majority found that "It can reasonably be inferred from evidence in the record that the delay in treatment resulted in Scoblic being readmitted," and that the hospital had not shown that the physician's negligence was the "sole proximate cause" of her death. It concluded: "A jury will have to make that factual determination." A special concurrence by Justice Henderson noted that "A perforated colon and leaking urine appears to have been the cause of infection."

Chief Justice Wuest dissented. In his view expert testimony on causation was required and "plaintiff has not offered any testimony, expert or otherwise, substantiating a causal relation." For the expert in a delayed-treatment case, the split means that the report has to connect the hours or days of delay to the outcome, so the court does not have to infer the connection on its own.

How does the medical expert link the infection to the hospital stay?

By building a timeline: the last negative test before admission, each procedure and device, the first signs of infection, the cultures and the organism, the antibiotic orders and the alternative sources the defense will raise.

Timing comes first. In Spille the negative MRSA test was dated December 3, 2018 and the operation January 10, 2019, five weeks apart. The defense used that gap and the physical therapy that began on January 14 to argue that it was unknown whether the infection developed before, during or after the procedure. An expert who expects that argument addresses it in the report, with the dates and the incubation and presentation pattern the expert relies on.

Each entry route is then examined. For a surgical site infection, the expert reviews the operative record, skin preparation, the timing of prophylactic antibiotics and the dressing care. For an infection traced to an epidural or a central line, the expert reviews the insertion record, who placed the device, how long it stayed and how it was maintained. In Spille the plaintiffs' experts tied the epidural abscess to the spinal block, and summary judgment was still affirmed: neither expert addressed whether the medical community recognizes that such an infection does not ordinarily occur without negligence.

Recognition and treatment form the second half of the timeline. The expert reads the vital signs, nursing notes, laboratory values and physician notes around the onset and identifies when the signs of infection were present, when a physician was told and when cultures and antibiotics were ordered. In Koeniguer the dispute concerned the 100.2-degree temperature on the morning of discharge and whether the nurses charted it and reported it to the physician.

The work can call for two experts. In Spille the plaintiffs had an anesthesiologist on the spinal block and an infectious disease specialist on the source of the infection.

Which records does the expert need in a hospital infection case?

The complete chart with nursing notes, the operative and anesthesia records, the medication administration record, microbiology results, and the hospital's infection control records for the unit and period, including policies and adherence audits.

From the chart: admission screening results, the operative report and anesthesia record, device insertion and maintenance notes, nursing flow sheets with vital signs, laboratory and microbiology results with collection times, the medication administration record showing when each antibiotic dose was given, and the discharge summary. Readmission records are part of the set, because the infection is often diagnosed there.

From the hospital's program under 42 CFR 482.42: the infection prevention and control policies in force on the date of the procedure, surveillance data for the unit, the infection preventionist's audits of adherence for that period and the stewardship program's documentation of antibiotic use. Requests for these records go through discovery, and the expert can tell counsel which ones the opinion needs.

The consent form belongs in the file as well. In Spille the court cited it when it rejected the common knowledge exception.

What does IAE do in a hospital-acquired infection case?

A physician in the relevant specialty from the IAE registry writes an expert report on the client's questions or a review of the opposing expert's report, within up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.

The IAE medical expert report page covers standard of care, causation and the medical record in malpractice, wrongful death and personal injury cases. The physician builds a timeline of the chart, separates general and specific causation and checks the record set for missing notes and gaps in orders. For an infection case the client sends the chart with the operative and anesthesia records, the microbiology results, the readmission records and, where there is one, the opposing expert's report, and describes the task.

The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. Delivery takes up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, with a 48-hour rush for tight deadlines.

Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry, can be verified by Member ID or QR code and confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. Materials are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. A report is evidence that the court weighs with the rest of the record. Neither IAE nor the physician guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert examinations

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member