Journal

How long does peer review take, and what decides the wait?

Authors who reported 3,500 review experiences to the SciRev site waited 13 weeks on average for the first decision, and accepted papers spent 17 weeks at the journal in total. A reviewer needs a median of 16.4 days for one report. The rest of the wait is screening, finding reviewers and revision rounds. IAE Review gives its initial decision within 7 business days and its decision after review within 60 calendar days of submission.

An editor from behind faces a wall calendar whose dates are out of focus, manuscripts stacked nearby

How long does peer review usually take?

In 3,500 author reports collected by SciRev, the first decision came after 13 weeks on average, and accepted papers spent 17 weeks at the journal in total. In only 19% of cases the answer came in less than a month.

The figures are published in J. Huisman and J. Smits, "Duration and quality of the peer review process: the author's perspective," Scientometrics, volume 113, pages 633-650 (2017). The authors analysed 3,500 review experiences that researchers reported to the SciRev website between 2013 and 2016.

The reported first response time was 13 weeks on average. In 19% of cases the author knew the outcome in less than a month, and in about one third of cases (32%) the wait was three months or more. For manuscripts that were accepted, total review duration was 17 weeks on average, over 2.03 review rounds. The paper defines that measure as the time a manuscript is under the responsibility of the journal.

The study states its own limit. The authors write that "the data are not based on a representative sample of author experiences." Authors reported by filling in a questionnaire on the site, so the numbers describe those reports and not every journal.

Does the wait depend on the field?

Yes. In the SciRev data the first response took 8-9 weeks in medicine and public health and 16-18 weeks in economics, the social sciences and the humanities. Total review duration for accepted papers in economics and business was 25 weeks.

Huisman and Smits report the first response time by field. Medicine and public health came first at 8-9 weeks. Natural sciences and general journals followed at 11 weeks and psychology at 14. In the social sciences, the humanities, mathematics and computer sciences, and economics and business the first response took 16-18 weeks.

The paper also gives total review duration for accepted papers by field. "With 12-14 weeks, average total review duration is shortest in Medicine, Public health, and the Natural sciences," the authors write. It was 22-23 weeks in the social sciences, the humanities, and mathematics and computer sciences, and 25 weeks in economics and business.

B.-C. Björk and D. Solomon measured the longer path that ends in print. In "The publishing delay in scholarly peer-reviewed journals" (Journal of Informetrics, 2013) they sampled 2,700 papers in 135 journals indexed in Scopus. Their abstract reports: "Business/economics with a delay of 18 months took twice as long as chemistry with a 9 month average delay." The same abstract attributes long publishing delays in part to the length of the peer review process and in part to the tradition of publication in issues.

How long does a reviewer take to write a report?

A median of 16.4 days after agreeing to review, according to the Publons report Global State of Peer Review (2018). The mean is 19.1 days, and the average report is 477 words long.

Publons, with ScholarOne and Web of Science, published Global State of Peer Review in 2018. It states: "It takes reviewers a median of 16.4 days to complete a review after agreeing to the assignment (the mean is 19.1 days)." The average review report in Publons data is 477 words long.

Journals set their own deadlines for reviewers. PLOS ONE tells authors: "After agreeing to review, external peer reviewers typically have 10 days to submit their review." The journal office follows up with late reviewers and informs the author of delays.

Reviewers have duties on timing too. The ICMJE Recommendations say reviewers "are expected to respond promptly to requests to review and to submit reviews within the time agreed." The COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers (version 2, September 2017) tell a reviewer to agree only when able to return the review within the proposed or mutually agreed time frame, and to inform the journal promptly when an extension is needed.

Where does the rest of the time go?

Into the steps around the report: editorial screening, inviting reviewers, waiting for the last report and revision rounds. By the end of 2017 an editor sent 2.4 invitations on average for every completed review.

A report takes a median of 16.4 days, and the first decision in the SciRev data takes 13 weeks on average. Huisman and Smits define first response time as the journal's first evaluation of the manuscript, the search for reviewers, the reviewers' own work and the time the editor needs to weigh the reports and inform the authors.

Finding reviewers has become slower. The Publons report states: "In 2013, an editor had to invite an average of 1.9 reviewers to get one review done." By the end of 2017 the figure had risen to 2.4 invitations for every completed review. Each declined or unanswered invitation adds days before a reviewer opens the manuscript.

Accepted manuscripts in the SciRev reports went through 2.03 review rounds on average. The 17-week total counts only the time at the journal. The paper states: "Total review duration does not include the time taken by authors to revise and resubmit their manuscript." The calendar time between submission and acceptance is therefore longer than 17 weeks by the weeks the author spends on revision.

Journals that print in issues add a queue after acceptance. Björk and Solomon found that the time between acceptance and publication differed mainly between journals, while the time between submission and acceptance differed mainly among articles within one journal.

How fast is a rejection without review?

Half of the desk rejections reported to SciRev arrived within one week. One third of journals took more than two weeks for an immediate rejection, and one sixth took more than four weeks.

Of the 3,500 experiences in the study, 572 (16.3%) were immediate rejections by the editor, without external review. In half of those cases the editor informed the authors within one week. The abstract adds: "One-third of journals take more than 2 weeks for an immediate (desk) rejection and one sixth even more than 4 weeks."

Average desk rejection time was 10 days in medicine, 11-12 days in the natural sciences, public health and engineering, and 15-17 days in psychology, the social sciences, and mathematics and computer sciences.

The ICMJE Recommendations address this step: "If a journal has no intention of proceeding with a manuscript, editors should endeavor to reject the manuscript as soon as possible to allow authors to submit to a different journal." The reason is in the sentence itself: until the journal answers, the author cannot offer the paper elsewhere.

Where do you find a journal's own numbers?

On the journal's information or metrics page. PLOS ONE reports a median of 45 days to first decision for January-June 2023, and Leukemia reports a median of 3 days to the first editorial decision.

PLOS ONE publishes medians in days for each half-year. Time to first decision was 44 days in January-June 2020, rose to 62 days in January-June 2022 and stood at 45 days in January-June 2023. For that last period the journal reports 188 days as time to acceptance and 204 days as time to publication.

Leukemia, a Springer Nature journal, lists two speed metrics on its journal information page: "Submission to first editorial decision (median days): 3" and "Submission to acceptance (median days): 119."

The labels differ between publishers. PLOS ONE keeps two separate lines in its table: "Time to First Editorial Decision (Rejection or Peer Review)", 17 days in January-June 2023, and "Time to First Decision", 45 days in the same period. The Leukemia page gives no definition and no period for its two speed metrics. A median of 3 days to the first editorial decision and a median of 45 days to first decision are therefore not measurements of the same step. A comparison between journals holds only for metrics with the same name over a stated period.

What can you ask the journal while the paper is under review?

The status of the manuscript. The ICMJE Recommendations say journals should answer such requests in a timely manner, and they describe what an author may assume after asking to withdraw a paper in good faith.

The sentence in the ICMJE Recommendations is short: "Journals should respond to authors' requests about the status of their manuscript in a timely manner."

ICMJE also covers withdrawal. When authors submit a request to withdraw their manuscript in good faith, they "should consider the manuscript withdrawn even if they don't receive a confirmation from the journal."

Editors carry the timing duty on their side. ICMJE asks them to do all they can to process manuscripts on time with the resources available, and to negotiate any planned delay in publication with the authors. For reviewers the COPE guidelines add: "Do not intentionally prolong the review process."

Do authors rate a fast review higher?

Yes, in the SciRev data. Authors of accepted papers rated the process 4 on a scale of 0 to 5 and authors of rejected papers 2.2, and ratings fell as the total duration grew.

Huisman and Smits asked how authors rated the process. Accepted papers received an average rating of 4 and rejected papers 2.2, on a scale that runs between 0 (very bad) and 5 (excellent). The authors write that "the rating of the peer review process is negatively related to total review duration." In their multivariate analysis a shorter first review round and fewer review rounds went with higher ratings.

The study measures the author's view and does not measure the quality of the reports. Citing Azar's study of economics journals, the authors write that a longer first response time "is in itself not necessarily negative": economics manuscripts have become longer and carry more mathematical content, so they take more time to evaluate.

They are less tolerant of slow immediate rejections. In 17% of those cases authors waited more than 4 weeks for the rejection, and several waited more than 3 months or withdrew the manuscript after hearing nothing. "These are clearly unacceptable practices," the paper says.

Does a paper under review count in an EB-1A or O-1 petition?

The criteria ask for authorship of scholarly articles, and 8 CFR 103.2(b)(1) requires eligibility at the time of filing. A manuscript still under review on the filing date is not yet a published article.

For O-1A, 8 CFR 214.2(o)(3)(iii)(B)(6) lists "Evidence of the alien's authorship of scholarly articles in the field, in professional journals, or other major media." For EB-1A, 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(vi) lists "Evidence of the alien's authorship of scholarly articles in the field, in professional or major trade publications or other major media."

The USCIS chart of examples for the O-1A criteria, which USCIS reproduces on its page about STEM employment pathways, says "the beneficiary must be a listed author of the submitted article(s) but need not be the sole or first author." It adds: "In the academic arena, a scholarly article reports on original research, experimentation, or philosophical discourse," and "the article is normally peer-reviewed."

Timing is set by 8 CFR 103.2(b)(1): "An applicant or petitioner must establish that he or she is eligible for the requested benefit at the time of filing the benefit request and must continue to be eligible through adjudication." Paragraph (b)(12) applies the same date to evidence sent in response to a request for evidence: "A benefit request shall be denied where evidence submitted in response to a request for evidence does not establish filing eligibility at the time the benefit request was filed." An author who plans a petition therefore counts back: the journal's time to acceptance and publication has to fit before the filing date. No journal's metrics promise a date, and USCIS decides what weight each article carries.

How long does IAE Review take to decide?

IAE Review gives the initial decision within 7 business days and the decision after peer review within 60 calendar days of submission. The target period for the two reviewers is 21 business days.

IAE Review is the peer-reviewed open-access journal of the International Association of Experts. Under its editorial policy, the Editor-in-Chief or handling editor screens each manuscript for scope, formatting, word limits and basic quality, and manuscripts that do not pass are rejected without external review within seven business days.

A manuscript that passes goes to two independent reviewers under double-anonymous review. The target peer-review period is 21 business days and may be extended in consultation with the reviewer. The editorial decision is one of four: accept without changes, accept subject to minor revisions, return for revision and further peer review, or reject. The decision after review comes within 60 calendar days of submission, and revisions requested by reviewers extend the term. The policy calls these deadlines approximate: they may vary with reviewer workload and manuscript complexity.

Articles are published on a rolling basis as soon as review, revision and technical preparation are complete, without waiting for an issue. Status enquiries that quote the manuscript number are answered within 3 business days. An author may appeal a rejection in writing within 30 days, and the Editor-in-Chief normally responds within 21 business days.

IAE membership is not required and does not affect the editorial decision, and the journal imposes no article-processing charge. Manuscripts are accepted in Russian or English as DOCX, PDF or LaTeX through the submission form.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Journal

Want to publish in IAE Review?

Submit your manuscript in Russian or English as DOCX, PDF or LaTeX through the submission form. Initial decision within 7 business days.

Manuscript

Received

Initial decision within 7 business days

Article typeOriginal research
Reviewers2, double-anonymous
DOI10.68034 via Crossref