Journal

Can you submit a paper to two journals at the same time?

In most fields the answer is no. The ICMJE Recommendations state that authors should not submit the same manuscript, in the same or different languages, to more than one journal at once, and IAE Review prohibits it in its editorial policy. Student-edited law reviews work the other way. A paper moves to a new journal after a rejection or a confirmed withdrawal.

Hands hold one manuscript above two open envelopes and lower it into only one of them

Can you send one manuscript to two journals at once?

Not in medicine, the sciences and most social sciences. The ICMJE Recommendations say authors should not submit the same manuscript simultaneously to more than one journal, in the same or a different language.

The ICMJE Recommendations, section Overlapping Publications, open with the rule on duplicate submission: "Authors should not submit the same manuscript, in the same or different languages, simultaneously to more than one journal." A journal that states it follows the ICMJE Recommendations applies this rule to every manuscript it receives.

Journals check the rule at submission. The author confirms in the submission form that the manuscript is not under consideration elsewhere. The submission form of IAE Review contains this declaration: "The manuscript is original, has not been previously published to a substantial extent and is not under consideration elsewhere; any preprint posting is disclosed in the cover letter."

A false declaration is the first problem an editor finds when the same paper turns up at two journals. The second is the waste of review work: two sets of editors and reviewers read one paper, and only one journal can publish it.

What counts as simultaneous or duplicate submission?

Sending a paper with identical or near identical content to more than one journal without telling the editors. A translation of the same paper counts too.

The Office of Research Integrity of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services describes duplicate publication as "submitting a paper with identical or near identical content to more than one journal" without alerting editors or readers to the earlier version.

The ICMJE rule names languages directly: the same manuscript "in the same or different languages." An author who sends an English version to an international journal and a Russian version to a national journal at the same time has made a duplicate submission under this rule.

Duplicate publication, the result of a duplicate submission that succeeds, is defined by ICMJE as "publication of a paper that overlaps substantially with one already published." Two articles that use the same data set to answer different questions are a different matter, and the author explains the relation between them in the cover letter.

Why do journals forbid simultaneous submission?

Because review costs editors and reviewers weeks of work, because two journals cannot publish the same original article, and because publishing agreements grant rights that an author cannot give twice.

Peer review takes weeks of editors' and reviewers' time. At IAE Review, for example, the target peer-review period is 21 business days and the decision after review comes within 60 calendar days of submission. A second journal reviewing the same paper doubles that work for one possible article.

When two journals hold overlapping manuscripts, the ICMJE Recommendations say it "may be reasonable although not mandatory for editors to give preference to the manuscript submitted first." An author who submits the same paper twice gives neither journal a clear first claim.

Rights are the third reason. Under 17 U.S.C. 204(a), a transfer of copyright ownership "is not valid unless an instrument of conveyance, or a note or memorandum of the transfer, is in writing and signed by the owner of the rights conveyed." An author who signs copyright transfers with two journals for one paper has signed away the same rights twice.

What happens if both journals accept the paper?

The author has to withdraw from one of them, and if both have published, the later article is treated as duplicate publication. Journal policies, IAE Review's among them, list a serious breach of publication ethics among the grounds for retraction.

The ORI page treats duplicate publication as one of "the problems of duplicate publication and of other forms of redundancy" and links the pressure behind it to tenure and promotion systems.

Journal policies describe what follows. The editorial policy of IAE Review lists a serious breach of publication ethics among the grounds for retraction, and states that a retracted article stays in the archive with a prominent Retracted notice, the date and a separate notice giving the reasons. Fabrication or falsification discovered at any stage leads to rejection or retraction, and the information is forwarded to the author's employing organization.

Withdrawing after acceptance is possible before publication, but the editors who accepted the paper learn that it was under review elsewhere.

Is a translated version of the same paper allowed?

Only as a secondary publication with the approval of both editors, a publication interval they agree, a different readership and a clear label that it is a secondary publication.

The ICMJE Recommendations treat secondary publication in another language as possibly "justifiable and beneficial" and list the conditions: "The authors have received approval from the editors of both journals"; the priority of the primary publication is respected by a publication interval negotiated by both editors; the paper is intended for a different group of readers; the secondary version keeps the authors, data and interpretations of the primary version; it informs readers that it has been published in whole or in part elsewhere; and its title indicates that it is a secondary publication.

The ORI page gives translation as an example of acceptable dual publication when both editors agree and "the new version must clearly indicate that it is a duplicate of an existing version."

The order matters. The first journal publishes, and the translation follows with both editors' consent. Sending the original and the translation out together breaks the duplicate submission rule.

Does posting a preprint count as a prior submission?

No, a preprint is not a journal submission, but journals want to know about it. ICMJE asks authors to inform the journal when the work has been posted on a preprint server.

The ICMJE Recommendations state that posting of work as a preprint "may influence a journal's interest in or priority for peer review" and that "Authors should inform a journal if the work submitted to the journal has been posted on a preprint server."

Journals differ on what they accept. The editorial policy of IAE Review says a manuscript must not have been previously published to a substantial extent, "This includes publication as a preprint unless the Editorial Office has been expressly informed." The disclosure goes in the cover letter.

A preprint and a journal submission can run in parallel. Two journal submissions cannot.

Can a conference paper be submitted to a journal?

Often yes, if the journal's policy permits it and the author discloses the conference version. IAE Review requires disclosure in the cover letter and at least 30% new material.

Journals set their own thresholds for papers that first appeared in conference proceedings. The IAE Review editorial policy states that when a manuscript is based on a previously published conference paper, the fact must be disclosed in the cover letter and the revised work must contain substantial changes, with at least 30% of the material new.

The ICMJE definition of duplicate publication turns on substantial overlap with a paper "already published." A journal version that adds new data, a new analysis or a full methods section is a new paper in that sense. A copy of the proceedings text with a new title is not.

The conference paper and the journal manuscript can still not be under review at two journals at once.

Do any fields allow submitting to several journals at once?

Yes. Student-edited U.S. law reviews work with authors who submit to several journals. Harvard Law Review and peer journals commit to give authors at least seven days to decide on an offer.

The submissions page of the Harvard Law Review recommends that an author who prefers the Review consider "submitting the manuscript to us exclusively at least two weeks before submitting it to other journals." It accepts requests for expedited review and states that "we do not omit any of our review stages in response to such requests."

Both the Harvard Law Review and the Yale Law Journal state that they and several peer journals have committed to give every author "at least seven days to decide whether to accept any offer of publication." The Yale Law Journal dates the joint letter to April 2011. The Harvard Law Review page also refers to the date on which an author plans to send the manuscript to other journals.

This practice belongs to student-edited law journals. A legal scholar who writes for a peer-reviewed journal in criminology, economics or forensic science follows that journal's rule, which in most cases is one journal at a time.

How do you move a paper to another journal correctly?

Wait for a decision or withdraw in writing and get confirmation, then submit to the next journal. A rejected manuscript can be revised before it goes out again.

The duplicate submission rule ends when the first journal's process ends. That happens with a rejection or with a withdrawal confirmed by the editorial office. An author who withdraws keeps the confirmation email, because the next journal's declaration asks whether the paper is under consideration elsewhere.

After a rejection, an author can also appeal, if the journal provides for it. At IAE Review a written appeal goes to the Editor-in-Chief within 30 days of the rejection, must contain specific arguments, and gets a written response normally within 21 business days. The policy states that resubmission of a revised manuscript is treated as a new submission, not as an appeal.

How should related or duplicate papers appear on a CV?

Each paper is listed once, and a secondary publication or translation is marked as such. ORI expects authors to show on CVs that duplicate papers are identical.

The ORI page states that when authors list publications on CVs or profiles, they are expected to show that duplicate papers are identical. A translated secondary publication appears as a translation of the primary article, with both references.

The APA Ethics Code, Standard 8.13, states: "Psychologists do not publish, as original data, data that have been previously published." It adds that this "does not preclude republishing data when they are accompanied by proper acknowledgment." The current code includes amendments that took effect on January 1, 2017.

The same discipline applies to a CV prepared for an academic job, a grant or an immigration petition. Two entries for one study, one in English and one in Russian, without a note, look like two papers to a reader who does not open them, and an expert who does open them sees the duplication.

What does IAE Review require on originality and parallel submission?

Originality, no substantial prior publication, disclosure of any preprint and no simultaneous submission. The initial editorial decision comes within 7 business days, so authors know early whether review will start.

IAE Review is the peer-reviewed open-access journal of the International Association of Experts. Its editorial policy states: "A manuscript must be original and must not have been previously published to a substantial extent in another publication. This includes publication as a preprint unless the Editorial Office has been expressly informed. Simultaneous submission to another publication is prohibited."

The initial editorial screening takes up to 7 business days. The manuscript then goes to two independent reviewers, with a target peer-review period of 21 business days, and the decision after review comes within 60 calendar days of submission. The acceptable similarity level should not exceed 15% of the manuscript, excluding properly formatted quotations.

Authors retain copyright and grant IAE a non-exclusive licence, and articles are published under CC BY 4.0. IAE membership is not required. Manuscripts are accepted in Russian or English, in DOCX or PDF and in LaTeX for manuscripts with mathematical formulas, through the submission form.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Journal

Want to publish in IAE Review?

Submit your manuscript in Russian or English as DOCX, PDF or LaTeX through the submission form. Initial decision within 7 business days.

Manuscript

Received

Initial decision within 7 business days

Article typeOriginal research
Reviewers2, double-anonymous
DOI10.68034 via Crossref