Journal

Can you publish a research paper without a university affiliation?

A university affiliation is not a condition of authorship. The ICMJE Recommendations define an author by four criteria of contribution and accountability, and none of them is an employer. Unaffiliated authors publish as independent researchers, describe their part in the work with the CRediT roles and identify themselves with an ORCID iD. The editorial policy of IAE Review admits authors regardless of citizenship or place of employment.

An independent researcher from behind writes at a kitchen table, the manuscript face down

Can you publish without a university affiliation?

Yes. Authorship rests on what a person did for the work, not on where the person works. The four ICMJE criteria cover contribution, drafting, approval and accountability, and affiliation is not one of them.

The International Committee of Medical Journal Editors sets out who is an author in its Recommendations, in the section on defining the role of authors and contributors. Each author meets all four criteria: substantial contributions to the conception or design of the work, or to the acquisition, analysis or interpretation of data; drafting the work or reviewing it critically for important intellectual content; final approval of the version to be published; and agreement to be accountable for all aspects of the work, including questions about its accuracy or integrity.

The Recommendations add that all those designated as authors should meet all four criteria and that all who meet them should be listed as authors. The criteria say nothing about a university, a laboratory or a job title. A practitioner who designed a study, analyzed the data, wrote the paper and accepts responsibility for it meets them in the same way as a professor.

The question for an independent author is therefore practical, not one of eligibility: what to write in the affiliation field, how to show what he or she did, and how a journal can contact and identify the author over time.

What do unaffiliated authors write in the affiliation field?

One established form is "Independent researcher" in place of an institution. In 2017 E. ElSabry studied publications whose authors list independent researcher instead of an institutional affiliation, to explore what it called an apparently rising trend of unaffiliated researchers.

The affiliation line tells readers where the work was done and who stands behind it. When there is no institution, the line still has to say something true, and the form that has entered the literature is "Independent researcher".

ElHassan ElSabry's paper Unaffiliated Researchers: A Preliminary Study, published in the journal Challenges in 2017 (volume 8, issue 2, article 20), set out to explore the apparently rising trend of unaffiliated researchers by analyzing scholarly publications whose authors list independent researcher instead of an institutional affiliation. According to the abstract, the paper explains some characteristics of this set of publications and gives directions on how to expand research on the topic.

The affiliation also has a procedural role. The ICMJE Recommendations say that when authors disagree about authorship, the institution where the work was performed, not the journal editor, should be asked to investigate. An independent author has no such institution, so clear agreements on authorship among co-authors before submission matter more for him than for a staff researcher.

How can an independent author show what he or she contributed?

With a contribution statement in CRediT roles. ANSI/NISO Z39.104-2022, the Contributor Roles Taxonomy, names 14 roles, among them conceptualization, methodology and writing, review and editing.

CRediT, the Contributor Roles Taxonomy, was approved in 2022 as the standard ANSI/NISO Z39.104-2022. It lists 14 roles: conceptualization, data curation, formal analysis, funding acquisition, investigation, methodology, project administration, resources, software, supervision, validation, visualization, writing of the original draft, and writing, review and editing.

One contributor can be assigned more than one role, and the same role can be assigned to several people. Where several people share a role, the degree of contribution can optionally be specified as lead, equal or supporting; NISO notes that the degree is not currently part of the standard. For a sole independent author the statement lists every role he or she performed; for a team that includes an independent researcher, it shows the reader exactly which part of the work that person did.

A contribution statement does for an independent author part of what an institutional affiliation does for an employee: it gives the editor, the reviewers and the readers a stated basis for the author's part in the work, role by role.

Why do independent researchers use an ORCID iD?

ORCID gives each researcher a unique, persistent identifier at no cost to the researcher. It connects the person with contributions and affiliations, and the researcher creates and maintains the record free of charge.

ORCID describes itself as a global, not-for-profit organization sustained by fees from its member organizations. It issues a unique, persistent identifier for individuals, the ORCID iD, and a record that the researcher creates and maintains at no cost.

The iD stays with the person when jobs change or when there is no job at all, so publications by the same author under different addresses, or with and without an affiliation, are linked to one record. For an independent researcher whose name may be shared by others in the field, the iD is a stable way for editors and readers to tell who wrote the work.

The editorial policy of IAE Review strongly encourages authors to include their ORCID iD on the title page.

Who should be a co-author, and who goes in the acknowledgments?

A contributor who meets fewer than all four ICMJE criteria is acknowledged, not listed as an author. Funding, general supervision, administrative support and language editing alone do not qualify for authorship.

Independent researchers often work with help: a colleague who reads the draft, a friend who checks the statistics, an editor who polishes the English. The ICMJE Recommendations say that contributors who meet fewer than all four criteria should not be listed as authors but should be acknowledged, individually or together under a single heading, with their specific contributions stated.

The Recommendations name activities that alone do not qualify for authorship: acquisition of funding, general supervision of a research group or general administrative support, and writing assistance, technical editing, language editing and proofreading. Because an acknowledgment may imply endorsement of the data and conclusions, the corresponding author obtains written permission from everyone acknowledged.

The rule protects the independent author as well. A paper with one real author and three honorary co-authors from a university does not become stronger for the added names; the editorial policy of IAE Review, for example, prohibits guest or honorary authorship and ghost authorship.

What does the corresponding author have to do?

Communicate with the journal during submission, review and publication, complete the administrative requirements, answer editorial queries promptly and remain available after publication to respond to critiques and provide data.

Under the ICMJE Recommendations the corresponding author is the one individual who takes primary responsibility for communication with the journal during submission, peer review and publication. That person sees to the administrative requirements, such as details of authorship, ethics committee approval, registration documentation and disclosures of relationships and activities, although these tasks may be delegated to co-authors.

The corresponding author responds to editorial queries in a timely way and stays available after publication to answer critiques of the work and to cooperate with requests for data or additional information. Editors, in turn, send copies of all correspondence to all listed authors.

For an independent author who writes alone, all of this falls on one person. The contact email on the title page should be one he or she will keep: correspondence about the paper can arrive months or years after it appears.

What does an independent author disclose about funding and interests?

The same as any author: sources of funding, ties to organizations with an interest in the results and any other circumstance that could call independence into question, or a plain statement that there are none.

An author without an employer still has interests: clients, a consulting business, a patent, a product. The editorial policy of IAE Review asks authors to state on the title page the sources of funding for the study, affiliations with organizations that have an interest in the results and any other circumstances that could call the authors' independence into question. When there are none, the policy asks for a clear statement: "The authors declare no conflict of interest."

For a self-funded study the funding statement says so. If the author sells services based on the method the paper studies, that is a circumstance of the kind the policy asks authors to disclose, and the disclosure puts it on the record before review begins.

How does IAE Review treat authors without an academic affiliation?

IAE Review accepts manuscripts from specialists, researchers and practitioners regardless of citizenship or place of employment. IAE membership is not required and does not affect editorial decisions, and no article-processing charge is imposed.

The editorial policy of IAE Review states that authors may be specialists, researchers and practitioners in the relevant fields, regardless of citizenship or place of employment, and that IAE membership is not required for publication. The journal is interdisciplinary, with eight sections, and accepts manuscripts in Russian or English in DOCX, PDF or LaTeX, with abstracts and 5-8 keywords in both languages.

The title page is a separate file with the authors' full names, affiliations, ORCID iD, the corresponding author's contact email, funding sources and conflict-of-interest information; the main text is anonymized for review. Research manuscripts go to at least two independent reviewers in double-anonymous review, so reviewers see neither the author's name nor the presence or absence of an affiliation.

The initial editorial decision takes up to 7 business days and the decision after review up to 60 calendar days from submission. Articles are published under CC BY 4.0, authors retain copyright, and each article has a permanent page and PDFs in English and Russian. The policy requires that every author meet four criteria of contribution, revision, approval and responsibility and prohibits guest, honorary and ghost authorship.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Journal

Want to publish in IAE Review?

Submit your manuscript in Russian or English as DOCX, PDF or LaTeX through the submission form. Initial decision within 7 business days.

Manuscript

Received

Initial decision within 7 business days

Article typeOriginal research
Reviewers2, double-anonymous
DOI10.68034 via Crossref