Journal

How do you check a journal before you submit a manuscript?

A journal can be checked before submission against a published standard: the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing, version 4, issued in September 2022 by COPE, DOAJ, OASPA and WAME. They list what the journal's website should state about its review, editors, fees, licence and ethics. In FTC v. OMICS a federal court in Nevada ordered a publisher that misdescribed its review and hid its fees to pay more than $50.1 million.

An author from behind compares a plain journal with a manuscript stack

What should the journal's website state before you submit?

Aims and scope, target readership, the types of manuscripts accepted, authorship criteria, the ISSNs, the publishing schedule and archiving, under the 2022 Principles. The name must not be easily confused with another journal's.

The Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing are a joint document of the Committee on Publication Ethics, the Directory of Open Access Journals, the Open Access Scholarly Publishing Association and the World Association of Medical Editors. Version 4 was published on September 15, 2022. It sets 16 principles, and an author can go through them on the journal's own site before sending anything.

The first two concern identity. The journal's name should be distinctive, should not be easily confused with another journal's and should not mislead about origin, scope or affiliations. The website should be well maintained, use HTTPS throughout, must not copy another journal's site or logo and must not mislead readers or authors. It should display the aims and scope, the target readership, the types of manuscripts accepted, the authorship criteria and separate ISSNs for print and electronic versions.

Two more concern continuity. The publishing frequency should be stated and kept unless exceptional circumstances arise, and the journal should say how its content is backed up and preserved in the long term in case it stops operating. A journal that publishes on a rolling basis without issues meets the first point by saying so.

How do you check the journal's peer review claim?

Read whether the site says who reviews, which review model is used and how decisions are made. The Principles also say acceptance should not be guaranteed and articles should show publication dates, preferably with submission and acceptance dates.

Under the peer review principle the website should state whether content is peer reviewed, who reviews it, the type of review, the policy on reviewers and on masking identities, how decisions are made and any exceptions. Acceptance should not be guaranteed. Authors should be told about delays and should be able to withdraw.

The review type has standard names. ANSI/NISO Z39.106-2023, the Standard Terminology for Peer Review approved on June 5, 2023, distinguishes single anonymized, double anonymized, triple anonymized and all identities visible, depending on who sees the author's and reviewers' names. A policy that uses these terms and explains who sees the title page can be checked; a promise of rigorous review without a procedure cannot.

Published articles give a second test. The Principles ask for publication dates and prefer that submission and acceptance dates be shown too. When article after article shows acceptance within days of submission in a journal that promises two independent reviews, the author can see the conflict between the dates and the promise without asking anyone.

Who are the editors, and how do you verify them?

The site should list the editorial board and editors by full name and affiliation, with the editorial office's full mailing address. Board members should be recognized experts listed with their consent, and the list should be kept current.

The Principles ask that editorial board or advisory body members be recognized experts in the journal's field, that their full names and affiliations be listed, that the list be kept current with the members' consent and that it be reviewed periodically so that it does not include people linked to predatory or deceptive journals. Editors and the editorial team are listed with full names and affiliations, and the full mailing address of the editorial office is on the website.

Consent is the point the FTC case turned on. In FTC v. OMICS Group the complaint alleged that people listed as editors of the publisher's journals had not agreed to be affiliated with them. A name on a board page proves nothing until the person's own institutional page or profile mentions the role.

The check takes minutes. Search the board member's university page for the journal's name, and look for the editor's address and the publisher's ownership on the journal site. The Principles add that ownership and management should be clearly indicated and that organization names should not mislead about who the owner is.

When should the journal tell you what it charges?

Early in the submission process. The Principles require all charges, such as article processing and submission fees, to be stated clearly, or the absence of fees to be stated, and fees must not influence editorial decisions.

The author fees principle covers every charge, including article processing charges and submission fees. They should be clearly stated before or early in the submission process, or the site should say that there are none. Eligibility for waivers and how to apply should be explained, and neither fees nor waiver status may influence editorial decisions.

Hidden fees were the second core allegation in the OMICS case. The FTC alleged that the defendants hid significant publishing fees from authors and did not allow authors to withdraw articles after submission. In its April 3, 2019 press release the FTC quoted Andrew Smith, then Director of the Bureau of Consumer Protection: "These publishing companies lied about their academic journals."

Other money matters too. The Principles ask journals to state their business model and revenue sources and to state whether they accept advertising, keeping advertisements separate from content. None of these sources may influence editorial decisions.

What does an ISSN prove about a journal?

That the publication has an identifier as a serial. The ISSN International Centre describes ISSN as an identifier for serials and other continuing resources; an identifier does not assess content, review or standing.

An article of October 2017 on the site of the ISSN International Centre states that ISSN identifiers reliably identify serials and other ongoing resources worldwide. At that time the ISSN Register was fed by a network of 89 national centres and gave access to 1.9 million ISSN records. The identifier tells the author which publication is meant; it says nothing about how that publication reviews manuscripts.

Registration is not automatic proof that the data are true either. A 2016 article on the ISSN site states that since 2012 the ISSN network has received ISSN requests lacking correct and verifiable information, and that guidelines were developed for such requests.

The useful check is a match. The ISSN printed on the journal site should belong, in the ISSN Register, to a publication with the same title and publisher. The Principles ask journals to show separate ISSNs for print and electronic versions, so an online-only journal shows one.

How do you check a claim that the journal is indexed?

At the index itself, not on the journal's site. In the OMICS case the FTC alleged that the publisher claimed its journals were accepted by PubMed Central, which the National Institutes of Health had refused to index.

An indexing badge on a journal page is a statement by the journal. The Principles require that the website not mislead readers or authors, which covers claims about databases and metrics, but they cannot verify the claim for the author. Each index keeps its own searchable list of the titles it covers, and the title, ISSN and publisher there should match those on the journal site.

The FTC complaint against OMICS described the gap between claim and fact: the publisher said its journals were accepted by PubMed Central, while the NIH had refused to index them.

A journal that is new or not yet indexed can say so in plain words. The IAE Review policy, for example, states that external indexing will be announced only after it has actually been obtained.

What did the court decide in FTC v. OMICS?

In March 2019 the federal court in Nevada granted summary judgment to the FTC and ordered OMICS Group's owner and companies to pay more than $50.1 million for deceptive claims about their journals and inadequate fee disclosure.

The FTC filed the complaint on August 26, 2016 in the U.S. District Court for the District of Nevada, civil action 2:16-cv-02022. The defendants were OMICS Group Inc., a Nevada corporation also doing business as OMICS Publishing Group, iMEDPub LLC and Conference Series LLC, both Delaware corporations, and Srinubabu Gedela. The FTC alleged that they falsely advertised online scientific and medical journals and international conferences, claimed rigorous peer review and editorial boards of prominent academics, and hid steep publication fees.

On November 22, 2017 the court granted a preliminary injunction and denied the defendants' motion to dismiss. The FTC moved for summary judgment on May 1, 2018, and on March 29, 2019 the court granted it; the FTC announced the ruling on April 3, 2019. According to the FTC, the court ruled that the defendants violated the FTC Act through deceptive claims about their journals and conferences and through inadequate disclosure of publishing fees, and imposed a judgment of $50.1 million.

The defendants appealed to the Ninth Circuit, No. 19-15738. On September 11, 2020 the Ninth Circuit affirmed the summary judgment in an unpublished memorandum; Judge Hunsaker dissented in part, only on the amount of monetary relief.

Which ethics, copyright and licence terms should be public?

Policies on authorship, complaints and appeals, misconduct, conflicts of interest, data sharing, ethical oversight, intellectual property, post-publication discussion, corrections and retractions, plus copyright and licence terms on the site and in each article.

The publication ethics principle lists these policies by name and asks that they be publicly visible. A journal without a corrections and retractions policy leaves the author without a procedure if an error is found after publication; a journal without an appeals policy leaves him without one after a rejection.

Copyright terms should be stated on the website and in the articles, kept separate from the copyright of the website itself, and each article should name the copyright holder. Licensing information should be clear on the site and in each article; open access content must carry an open licence, and the journal should state its policy on posting versions in third-party repositories.

The last principle concerns the invitation that often starts the process. Direct marketing, including the solicitation of manuscripts, should be appropriate, well targeted, unobtrusive and truthful. An unsolicited email inviting a manuscript in a field unrelated to the author's work is not well targeted in the sense of this principle.

What can an author check about IAE Review before submitting?

Its editorial policy is public: double-anonymous review by at least two reviewers, decision timeframes, CC BY 4.0 licence with copyright kept by authors, no article-processing charge, appeals, corrections and retractions, conflict-of-interest rules.

IAE Review is the peer-reviewed open-access journal of the International Association of Experts, published online on a rolling basis without fixed issues; each article has a permanent page and PDFs in English and Russian. Its editorial policy sets out the scope, eight sections, six publication types with word limits and the review procedure for each type.

Research manuscripts go to at least two independent reviewers in anonymized form; the title page with names, affiliations, funding and conflict-of-interest information is a separate file. The initial editorial decision takes up to 7 business days and the decision after review up to 60 calendar days from submission. Reviewers who are co-authors, supervisors or subordinates of an author, work in the same organization or have a financial interest in the results must decline.

Authors retain copyright and grant IAE a non-exclusive licence; articles are published under CC BY 4.0, and authors may deposit the accepted manuscript or the published version in repositories and on personal sites. No article-processing charge is imposed, and IAE membership is not required and does not affect editorial decisions. The policy describes corrections, expressions of concern and retractions, and appeals within 30 days of a rejection.

The policy states that the journal follows COPE recommendations as professional guidance and is not a COPE member, and that external indexing will be announced only after it has been obtained. The journal page names the editor-in-chief and the members of the editorial board with their roles. Manuscripts are accepted in Russian or English in DOCX, PDF or LaTeX.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Journal

Want to publish in IAE Review?

Submit your manuscript in Russian or English as DOCX, PDF or LaTeX through the submission form. Initial decision within 7 business days.

Manuscript

Received

Initial decision within 7 business days

Article typeOriginal research
Reviewers2, double-anonymous
DOI10.68034 via Crossref