Expert opinion letters

Where to find an independent expert for an NIW or EB-1A letter?

Neither the EB-1A nor the NIW chapter of the USCIS Policy Manual defines an independent expert. The EB-1A chapter tells officers to consider the relationship or affiliation between the applicant and each writer, and the NIW chapter lists letters from experts in the applicant's field as evidence for the second prong. Authors with no tie to the applicant are found through the work: people who cite it, people funded to work on the same problem and outside product reviewers.

A professor reads a printed letter at a wooden desk in front of bookshelves

What counts as an independent expert for an NIW or EB-1A letter?

Neither Policy Manual chapter defines the term. The EB-1A chapter names the relationship or affiliation between the applicant and the writer as a factor in weighing a letter, and the NIW chapter asks for experts in the applicant's field.

Chapter 2 of Volume 6, Part F of the USCIS Policy Manual covers EB-1A. Its passage on letters of support says that the relationship or affiliation "between the beneficiary and the witness is also a factor the officer should consider." The next sentence gives the reason: it is "generally expected" that a person whose accomplishments have garnered sustained national or international acclaim would be recognized "well beyond the circle of their personal and professional acquaintances."

Chapter 5 (Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 5) covers the national interest waiver. For the second prong, whether the person is well positioned to advance the endeavor, it lists "letters from experts in the person's field, describing the person's past achievements and providing specific examples of how the person is well positioned to advance the person's endeavor." The same list "is not meant to be a checklist." Neither chapter calls a letter writer independent or sets a test for it.

The National Science Foundation sets a period for such ties in its grant review. It asks each senior person on a proposal to list collaborators, and its instructions say that "all co-authors in the last 48 months should be listed" and that the co-author and collaborator conflicts "are both 48 months in duration." For optional "last active" dates, the page explains that "this will help NSF staff easily determine which information remains relevant for reviewer selection." The two Policy Manual chapters set no such period, and the 48 months come from NSF grant review.

How officers weigh a letter from a collaborator against a letter from an outside author is set out in the IAE guide Independent expert or collaborator: whose letter carries more weight?

Where do you find experts who already know your work?

Among the researchers who cite it. In a Google Scholar profile, the "Cited by" number for an article opens the list of citations to it, and each citing work names its authors.

An applicant with a Google Scholar profile can "check who is citing your articles," in the words of the Google Scholar Profiles help page. To see the list of citations to one article, the page says to click the "Cited by" number for that article. Each citing work on the list carries the names of its authors.

For original contributions of major significance, criterion 5 of EB-1A, chapter 2 mentions "detailed letters from experts in the field explaining the nature and significance of the person's contribution." It adds that a letter "should also set forth the basis of the writer's knowledge and expertise." An author who cited the paper has a basis an officer can check: the citing article, its date and the passage where the applicant's work is used.

Sort the citing works by what they did with the paper. An author who built a method on it, reproduced its results or compared new results with it can describe the contribution in detail. An author who listed it among many references in an introduction has less to say about it.

Before writing to anyone, look through the citing author's publication list for any paper published together with the applicant. An author with a joint paper writes as a collaborator.

Can grant databases point you to experts in your field?

Yes. NIH RePORTER and NSF Award Search list funded projects with the names of their investigators, so you can find people funded to work on the same problem and check whether you share an award.

The National Institute of General Medical Sciences describes NIH RePORTER as "a searchable database of NIH-funded research projects, investigators, publications, and patents." Its results "show you lists of projects and names of funded researchers," and a search can be narrowed by institute, year or activity code.

NSF Award Search covers awards "since 1989." The simple search looks through the "title, abstract, names, institutions, programs and other information associated with an award." The advanced search filters by "principal investigator name, organization and location," by program and program officer, and by keywords, award dates and award numbers.

A search on the problem named in an NIW proposed endeavor returns the investigators whom NIH or NSF funded to work on it. Their award records give the project title and the institution, and a writer can name such an award when the letter sets forth the basis of the writer's knowledge, as chapter 2 asks.

The same database is the place to check for a conflict. If the applicant appears on one of the candidate's awards as a co-investigator or senior personnel, the two worked together on that project, and the candidate writes as a collaborator.

Who can write if the applicant works in industry or runs a company?

The NIW chapter names letters from government entities, outside investors and established business associations, and from third-party reviewers such as prospective investors, retailers or other industry experts.

Section D.4 of chapter 5, on entrepreneurs, has a subsection headed "Letters and Other Statements from Third Parties." Letters may come from "relevant government entities, outside investors, or established business associations" with knowledge of the research, products or services the applicant developed, or of the applicant's knowledge, skills or experience that would advance the proposed endeavor.

In the same passage USCIS writes that entrepreneurs "typically do not undergo the same type of peer review common in academia," but high-tech industries "have their own industry or technology experts that provide various forms of peer review," and a business plan, product or technology may be reviewed by "prospective investors, retailers, or other industry experts." Letters from such reviewers "may have probative value" for the substantial merit and national importance of the endeavor and for the person's position to advance it.

Section D.3 of the chapter covers interested government agencies and quasi-governmental entities in the United States. Their letters are "not required" but "can be helpful evidence" and, depending on their contents, "can be relevant to all three prongs."

An outside investor has money in the applicant's company, and a customer has a contract with it. The writer of such a letter can state that tie and give the agreement or the amount. In an EB-1A petition, chapter 2 makes the relationship or affiliation between the applicant and the letter writer a factor the officer should consider.

Can you write to a professor directly and ask for a letter?

Yes. The Policy Manual chapters on EB-1A and NIW say nothing about how a writer is approached. The request names the paper that connects the author to your work and the criterion or prong the letter would address.

A first message to an author who cited your work gives three facts: which of the author's papers cites which of yours, what petition you are filing and which criterion or prong the letter would cover. Attach your CV and the cited paper. The full record goes to the author after the author agrees.

Chapter 2 says the writers' statements "should be corroborated by documentary evidence in the record" and that letters "should explain in specific terms" why the witnesses hold their view of the applicant. The author therefore needs the exhibits: publications, citation records with the database and the date, evidence that others use the work, grant or contract documents and, for an NIW, the statement of the proposed endeavor.

Footnote 77 of chapter 5 says that petitioners "may submit evidence related to the credentials of experts who support a petition for officers to consider when assigning weight to the letter." Ask the author for a current CV together with the letter, so that it goes into the record next to it.

Should an independent expert be paid for the letter?

The EB-1A chapter of the Policy Manual does not address payment to letter writers. The factor it names is the relationship with the applicant, and a fee tied to the result would give the author a stake in it.

In chapter 2 the words "paid" and "compensation" appear in two criteria. In the criterion on published material, "paid" concerns content that the person or the employer paid for. In the criterion on high remuneration, both words concern pay for work in the field: the person's own and that of others. None of these passages deals with letter writers.

IAE pays its authors under the IAE Impartiality Policy (IAE-GOV-002), adopted by the IAE Board of Directors on October 29, 2026. The author "is paid a flat fee that does not depend on the content of the letter or on the outcome of the petition," and "the author is not informed of the price paid by the client." Under the same policy, a conflict of interest exists when the author "has a stake in the outcome of the matter."

A fee paid only on approval, or a bonus for a favorable conclusion, would create that stake. A fixed fee agreed in writing before the author reads the record does not depend on what the author concludes.

How do you check that the expert has no ties to you?

Compare both CVs and publication lists, search the grant databases for shared awards, and ask the author to confirm in writing that there is no personal, financial or professional relationship with you, your employer or your attorney.

Run the check before the author starts writing. A tie found at that stage means choosing another author. An officer who later finds a joint paper in the exhibits sees a tie that the letter does not name.

  • Search the author's publication list for any paper that carries your name, and note the year of the latest one.
  • Compare employers and institutions in both CVs for the same years, including visiting positions and postdoctoral appointments.
  • Check whether either of you supervised the other's thesis, postdoctoral work or job.
  • Search NIH RePORTER and NSF Award Search for awards that name both of you.
  • Ask whether the author has a financial interest in your company or your work, such as an investment, a consulting contract or a license.
  • Get a written confirmation from the author before work starts and keep it in the file.

How does IAE find an independent expert for an NIW or EB-1A letter?

IAE proposes an expert from its public registry in the applicant's field. You approve the expert and the CV before work starts, and the expert confirms in writing that there is no relationship with the applicant.

Send the applicant's CV and the petition category through the expert opinion letters page. Within one business day the Secretariat confirms the expert, the cost and the timeline. The cost depends on the category and the volume of materials. The expert's CV and registry record come before payment, and the expert's status can be checked in the public IAE registry by QR code and Member ID.

Before the order is assigned, the expert confirms in writing that he or she has no personal, financial or professional relationship with the applicant, the client's attorney or the client's employer, and signs a declaration of independence attached to the letter. If a relationship exists, the Secretariat assigns another expert. One expert signs one letter for one petition, and a package of several letters is signed by experts from different organizations.

The Secretariat prepares the draft from the applicant's documents. The expert checks every statement, corrects or removes anything the expert does not consider supported, and signs only a text that states the expert's own professional opinion. The draft goes to the applicant and the attorney before signing, with one round of factual edits included. Every letter is checked for overlap with letters issued earlier, and a draft with more than 10 percent of matching sentences goes back to the author.

The letter runs up to 15 pages, with analysis under the criteria of the category. The standard term is 10 business days and the rush term 5, counted from payment and receipt of all materials. IAE is not a law firm, and USCIS decides the petition.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert opinion letters

Ready to strengthen your petition with an expert opinion letter?

Send the applicant's CV and the petition category: the expert, cost and timeline within one business day.

Quote request

Received

Expert, cost and timeline within one business day

CategoryEB‑1A
ExpertIn the applicant's field
Timeline10 business days