Evidence

Independent expert or collaborator: whose letter carries more weight?

The USCIS Policy Manual tells officers to consider the relationship or affiliation between the applicant and the author of a letter when they weigh it. A collaborator can confirm what the applicant did inside a joint project. An independent expert can confirm that the work is known outside the applicant's circle. In a 2019 decision the USCIS Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) wrote that even letters from independent experts carry less weight than preexisting, independent evidence.

Two researchers at a long table compare two signed letters, one by a lab colleague and one by a professor at another university

What does the Policy Manual say about the author's relationship with the applicant?

Officers should consider the relationship or affiliation between the applicant and the writer when they weigh the statements. Under the Manual, a person with sustained acclaim is expected to be recognized well beyond personal and professional acquaintances.

The EB-1A chapter of the USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2 has a passage on letters of support. One sentence concerns the author: the relationship or affiliation "between the beneficiary and the witness" is a factor the officer should consider "when evaluating the significance of witnesses' statements."

The reason is stated in the next sentence. A person whose accomplishments have gained sustained national or international acclaim is generally expected to be recognized "well beyond the circle" of personal and professional acquaintances. Under the same passage, the writers' statements "should be corroborated by documentary evidence in the record," and letters that at most present the person as "a competent, respected figure" in the field do not necessarily establish extraordinary ability.

Under 8 CFR 214.2(o)(3)(iv), cited in the O-1 chapter of the Manual (Volume 2, Part M, Chapter 4), an O-1B petition in the arts may rely on recognition by organizations, critics, government agencies or other recognized experts. Such testimonials must clearly indicate "the author's authority, expertise, and knowledge of the beneficiary's achievements."

Whose letters were in Kazarian's file?

Letters from people who knew him through work: a California Institute of Technology professor from the same research group, professors at Yerevan State University and colleagues at Glendale Community College. The AAO found his contributions not major.

Kazarian, a theoretical physicist with a Ph.D. from Yerevan State University, filed an EB-1A petition, which USCIS denied. The Ninth Circuit ruled on March 4, 2010 (Kazarian v. USCIS, 596 F.3d 1115 (9th Cir. 2010)).

Kip S. Thorne, the Feynman Professor of Theoretical Physics at the California Institute of Technology, "worked in the same research group as Kazarian" and wrote that the research was "of the caliber that one would expect from a young professor." Professors at Yerevan State University wrote of his "great ability and considerable potency in science." Three colleagues at Glendale Community College praised his hard work.

On original contributions of major significance, the AAO found that "his contributions were not major," and the court upheld the finding. With two criteria instead of three, the denial stood.

Neither the court nor the AAO wrote that a letter lost weight because its author had worked with Kazarian. The letters praised his ability, and the AAO did not find in them contributions of major significance.

What did the AAO say about letters from mentors and collaborators?

In Matter of N-K-S-, decided on November 7, 2019, the AAO wrote that the content of the letters and how their authors learned of the petitioner's reputation are important considerations, and dismissed the appeal.

The petitioner in Matter of N-K-S-, ID# 5236251 (AAO Nov. 7, 2019), a non-precedent decision, was a cancer researcher whose petition the Director of the Nebraska Service Center denied. On appeal he claimed original contributions of major significance and relied on "letters from mentors and collaborators."

Citing Matter of Caron International, the AAO wrote that reference letters are not presumptive evidence of eligibility and that the content of the statements and "how they became aware of the Petitioner's reputation" are important considerations.

One author had never worked with the petitioner but was "very familiar with his published research." She wrote that his work would likely have a positive impact on cancer treatment. The AAO found that the letters attest to "the still-unrealized potential" of the research and that none of them gave an example of the work already affecting cancer treatment.

The AAO added that even letters by independent experts, when solicited for a petition, weigh less than "preexisting, independent evidence" of major significance. The appeal was dismissed.

Does an independent author make a letter decisive?

No. Under Matter of Caron International, USCIS may use a letter as an advisory opinion and makes the final determination. Under the Policy Manual, documents created at the time of an achievement may outweigh letters prepared for the petition.

In Matter of Caron International, Inc., 19 I&N Dec. 791 (Comm'r 1988), decided October 28, 1988, counsel filed letters from three universities and the American Yarn Spinners Association. The Commissioner of the Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) held that INS may use such statements as advisory opinions and may decline an opinion, or give it less weight, where it is not in accord with other information or is "in any way questionable."

In the NIW precedent Matter of Dhanasar, 26 I&N Dec. 884 (AAO 2016), the AAO wrote that it considers the quantity of the evidence and its quality, "including relevance, probative value, and credibility." A writer with no tie to the applicant addresses credibility. Relevance and probative value come from what the letter says and which exhibits it cites.

In the chapter on advanced degree and exceptional ability (Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 5), formal recognition created at the time of the claimed achievements "may have more weight than letters prepared for the petition."

When is a collaborator the right author?

When the fact is known from inside: years of experience, a leading or critical role, the applicant's part in joint work. The regulation requires employer letters for experience, and the Policy Manual values first-hand knowledge of a role.

Under 8 CFR 204.5(g)(1), evidence of qualifying experience or training "shall be in the form of letter(s) from current or former employer(s)" or trainers, with the writer's name, address and title and a description of the duties. For EB-2 exceptional ability, 8 CFR 204.5(k)(3)(ii)(B) names employer letters showing at least ten years of full-time experience. An independent expert cannot write either.

For a leading or critical role, the Policy Manual says that letters from persons with "personal knowledge of the significance" of the role can be particularly helpful, so long as they contain "detailed and probative information." That knowledge belongs to a supervisor or board member. In joint work, a co-author or the head of the lab can state who did what and point to the project report or the commit history.

For NIW, the factors of the second Dhanasar prong include "the interest of potential customers, users, investors, or other relevant entities or individuals." A licensee or an investor is an interested party by definition, and its letter answers that factor when it names the agreement or the payment.

What can an independent expert confirm that a collaborator cannot?

Recognition outside the applicant's circle. An author who learned of the work through its publications or its use at other organizations speaks to the recognition beyond acquaintances that the Policy Manual describes for sustained acclaim.

A colleague's praise comes from inside the circle of acquaintances. A professor at another university who builds on the applicant's paper, or an engineer at another company who adopted the method, confirms that the work reached people outside it.

For original contributions of major significance, the Policy Manual says that detailed expert letters may give context "particularly when the record includes documentation corroborating the claimed significance," and that they should set forth "the basis of the writer's knowledge and expertise." For an independent author, the basis is the papers read and the places where the work is in use.

In N-K-S- the independent author did not change the result, because she wrote about future effects. An independent letter has more to stand on when it names effects that already exist, such as a method in use at named organizations or a dated citation count from a named database.

How do you split the list of authors?

Begin with the criteria. Give each internal fact to the person who saw it first-hand, give each claim of significance to an author outside the applicant's circle, and ask every author to state the relationship.

The list is built on the criteria, with one row for each fact a letter will confirm.

  • Write down each criterion or Dhanasar prong you claim and the facts the officer has to accept for it.
  • Mark each fact as internal, such as a role or a share of joint work, or external, such as use of the work by others.
  • Give internal facts to supervisors, co-authors and employers, and ask each to name the document behind every statement.
  • Give external facts to authors who know the work through its publications or its use, and ask each to write how and when they learned of it.
  • Check every author for ties with the applicant, such as a joint paper, a shared grant or a financial interest. An author with such a tie writes as a collaborator and says so.

Should a letter state the relationship?

A joint paper or a shared employer is usually visible in the CV and the exhibits. A letter that calls its author independent while the exhibits list a joint publication is not in accord with other information in the file, and under Caron the officer may give it less weight. A sentence on how the author knows the work, with dates, answers the question that the AAO asked in N-K-S-.

What if you are not sure which criteria the record supports?

The IAE profile audit answers that in writing. A registry expert checks the record against the criteria of one category and marks each criterion as met, partly met or not met, with the documents behind each mark and a collection plan. The audit costs $350 per category, and the report comes within 5 business days of receiving the materials and payment.

How does IAE confirm that its expert is independent?

Before the order is assigned, the expert confirms in writing that he or she has no personal, financial or professional relationship with the applicant, the attorney or the employer, and signs a declaration of independence attached to the letter.

The rule is in the IAE Impartiality Policy (IAE-GOV-002), adopted by the IAE Board on October 29, 2026. If a relationship exists, the Secretariat assigns another expert. One expert signs one letter for one petition, and several letters in one package are signed by experts from different organizations. The author is paid a flat fee that does not depend on the content of the letter or the outcome of the petition.

For an IAE expert opinion letter, the Secretariat prepares the draft from the applicant's documents, and the expert checks every statement, removes what the expert does not consider supported and signs. The expert's CV and the declaration of independence are attached, and the expert's status is checked in the public IAE registry by QR code. The draft goes to the applicant and the attorney before signing. The standard term is 10 business days, 5 in rush mode.

Letters from collaborators that are already written can go through an IAE expert letter review: a registry member in the field checks the letter page by page and gives one of three verdicts, file, revise or redo.

IAE is not a law firm. The letter is one piece of evidence: USCIS weighs it with the rest of the record and decides the petition.

Sources

All guides

Guides

Case assessment in 1 business day

Tell us the petition category, field and deadline. The Secretariat replies within one business day: which letters make sense, who checks and signs them and what they cost.

Are you an expert thinking about IAE membership? One-minute eligibility check

Case for assessment

Sent

Secretariat reply within one business day

CategoryEB-1A
Letters neededIn the reply
AssessmentFree