Expert witnesses
Insurance bad faith expert witness: claims handling under Florida law
An insurance bad faith expert witness reads the claim file and tells the jury how the insurer handled the claim against the standards and practices of the insurance industry: what the insurer knew, when it knew it, and what it did next. In Florida the claim rests on section 624.155 of the Florida Statutes or on common law, and the Florida Supreme Court judges bad faith under the totality of the circumstances.

What does an insurance bad faith expert witness testify about?
About the standards and practices of the insurance industry and whether the insurer complied with them. In Primeaux a federal court in Florida barred the expert from saying that the insurer acted in bad faith and from explaining the law.
In Primeaux v. Progressive American Insurance Co., No. 2:20-cv-941-JLB-NPM (M.D. Fla. Aug. 8, 2022), Judge John L. Badalamenti ruled on the plaintiff's expert, attorney Kelly Gray. The order states: "Ms. Gray may, however, provide testimony about the standards and practices of the insurance industry" and about whether Progressive complied with those standards. The limits came in the same order: "Ms. Gray thus cannot express an opinion that Progressive acted in bad faith," she cannot offer any opinion on the legal standards of the case, and "the court must be the jury's only source of law." For the limit on legal conclusions the court cited the Eleventh Circuit in Montgomery v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co., 898 F.2d 1537, 1541 (11th Cir. 1990).
In Harvey v. GEICO General Insurance Co., the Florida Supreme Court recounted the trial testimony of two experts. Daniel Doucette, described as "an expert in bad faith," testified that a serious claim of that kind called for "a sense of urgency" from the insurer and that it would have been in the insured's best interests for the adjuster to tell the claimant's attorney that the insured had retained counsel. GEICO's expert, John Atkinson, testified "that Domnick needed that information to properly advise the estate regarding settlement." Domnick was the attorney for the estate that sued GEICO's insured.
Attorneys also testify as bad faith experts. Gray in Primeaux was one. In Hayas v. GEICO General Insurance Co., No. 8:13-cv-1432-T-33AEP (M.D. Fla. Oct. 22, 2014), the insured's expert was Dale Swope, whom the order describes as "the attorney from the underlying action," the claim that Ryan's estate brought against Hayas. The court denied GEICO's motion to strike the late disclosure, but warned that at trial it would bar "impermissible legal conclusions, testimony of which he is not qualified to opine" and "testimony based on speculation as to the parties' intent."
Which Florida law governs a bad faith claim against an insurer?
Section 624.155 of the Florida Statutes and common-law bad faith. Under subsection (11), a plaintiff may obtain a judgment under one or the other, not both, and damages may exceed the policy limits.
Section 624.155 gives a civil action to any person damaged by an insurer's violation of listed provisions of the insurance code, including section 626.9541(1)(i), (o) or (x) and section 626.9551. Subsection (1)(b) adds three acts of the insurer. The first is "Not attempting in good faith to settle claims when, under all the circumstances," it could and should have done so had it acted fairly and honestly toward its insured and with due regard for the insured's interests. The second is paying claims without a statement identifying the coverage under which payment is made. The third, "Except as to liability coverages, failing to promptly settle claims," covers delay under one part of the policy, once the obligation is reasonably clear, to influence settlement under another part.
Subsection (11) keeps other statutory and common-law remedies, but a person may obtain a judgment under common-law bad faith or under the statute, not both. Damages include those that are a reasonably foreseeable result of the violation and "may include an award or judgment in an amount that exceeds the policy limits." On an adverse adjudication the insurer also pays court costs and the plaintiff's reasonable attorney's fees under subsection (7).
Punitive damages are harder to reach. Under subsection (8) they require acts that occur "with such frequency as to indicate a general business practice" and that are willful, wanton and malicious or in reckless disregard of the insured's rights, and the claimant must post the costs of discovery in advance. Subsection (9) bars class actions against an authorized insurer under the section. The text quoted here is the 2025 edition of the Florida Statutes; its history line ends with section 4 of chapter 2023-15, Laws of Florida, and the 2026 table tracing session laws to the statutes lists no 2026 amendment to section 624.155.
What duties does a Florida liability insurer owe its insured?
To advise the insured of settlement opportunities, the probable outcome and the risk of an excess judgment, to investigate, to give fair consideration to a settlement offer and to settle where a reasonably prudent person would.
The Florida Supreme Court restated the duties from Boston Old Colony Insurance Co. v. Gutierrez, 386 So. 2d 783 (Fla. 1980), in Harvey: "This good faith duty obligates the insurer to advise the insured of settlement opportunities, to advise as to the probable outcome of the litigation, to warn of the possibility of an excess judgment, and to advise the insured of any steps he might take to avoid same." The insurer "must investigate the facts, give fair consideration to a settlement offer" and must settle, if possible, where a reasonably prudent person would do so.
Whether the insurer met those duties "is determined under the 'totality of the circumstances' standard." The court added: "Because the duty of good faith involves diligence and care in the investigation and evaluation of the claim against the insured, negligence is relevant to the question of good faith." It also wrote that "the focus in a bad faith case is not on the actions of the claimant but rather on those of the insurer."
The facts were these. On August 8, 2006, Harvey was in a collision with John Potts, who died and left a wife and three children. Harvey had a $100,000 liability policy with GEICO. On August 14 the estate's paralegal asked for a statement from Harvey about the extent of his assets. The adjuster, Fran Korkus, refused the request while acknowledging that such statements were standard practice, and did not tell Harvey of it for about two weeks. GEICO sent the $100,000 on August 17. The estate sued; the jury found Harvey 100% at fault and awarded $8.47 million, and in the later bad faith suit the trial court entered judgment for Harvey for $9.2 million.
The Fourth District reversed (208 So. 3d 810). On September 20, 2018, the Florida Supreme Court, in an opinion by Justice Quince decided 4 to 3, quashed that decision and directed that the verdict and judgment be reinstated. Chief Justice Canady dissented: "In Florida law, mere negligence has now become bad faith."
How do the 90-day tender rule and the claimant's duties change the expert's timeline?
No bad faith action lies if the insurer tendered the lesser of the limits or the demand within 90 days after actual notice of a claim with sufficient evidence. The jury may also weigh the claimant's own bad faith.
Subsection (4)(a) of section 624.155 provides that a bad faith action, statutory or common-law, "shall not lie if the insurer tenders the lesser of the policy limits or the amount demanded by the claimant" within 90 days after receiving actual notice of a claim accompanied by sufficient evidence to support the amount of the claim. If the insurer does not tender within that window, subsection (4)(b) makes inadmissible, in any action seeking to establish bad faith, the existence of the 90-day period and the fact that no bad faith action could have been brought had the insurer tendered, and subsection (4)(c) extends any applicable limitations period by 90 days.
Subsection (5)(a) states: "Mere negligence alone is insufficient to constitute bad faith." Under subsection (5)(b), the insured, the claimant and their representatives have a duty to act in good faith in furnishing information about the claim, making demands, setting deadlines and attempting to settle. That duty creates no separate cause of action, but the trier of fact may consider their failure to act in good faith and "may reasonably reduce the amount of damages awarded against the insurer."
These subsections set the questions for the expert's chronology. On what date did the insurer receive actual notice of the claim? Which documents supported the amount demanded, and when did each arrive? What deadline did the claimant set, and was it reasonable? Did the claimant's representative supply the information the insurer asked for? Harvey was decided in 2018. The current text was last amended in 2023, and the expert applies the version of the statute that governs the claim at issue.
What does the expert look at when several claimants compete for one policy limit?
Whether the insurer used one of the two routes in section 624.155(6) within 90 days, interpleader or binding arbitration, and how it treated each claimant under the adjuster code of ethics.
Subsection (6) addresses competing third-party claims from one occurrence that together may exceed the policy limits. The insurer is not liable beyond the limits for failing to pay all or part of a claim if, within 90 days after notice of the competing claims, it either files an interpleader action under the Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, with the claimants receiving prorated shares set by the trier of fact, or makes the full limits available through binding arbitration agreed to by the insurer and the claimants. In arbitration the insurer pays the arbitrator, the arbitrator sets the shares by comparative fault and the likely trial outcome, and each claimant paid through arbitration gives the insured a general release. The duty to defend continues.
Primeaux involved "multiple competing claims" and $10,000 in bodily injury limits. Progressive "pursued a global settlement conference with all claimants" instead of offering the $10,000 to Primeaux. Gray relied on the adjuster code of ethics, which she read as requiring the insurer to treat all claimants equally. Judge Badalamenti allowed her opinion that the global settlement approach did not comport with industry standards on the facts of the case, but ruled that "she cannot testify that noncompliance with the Adjuster Code of Ethics is 'indicative of bad faith.'"
What does the Florida adjuster code of ethics require?
Rule 69B-220.201 of the Florida Administrative Code requires every adjuster to treat all claimants equally, adjust claims strictly under the policy, report facts truthfully after a complete investigation and act with dispatch and due diligence.
Rule 69B-220.201, "Ethical Requirements for All Adjusters and Public Adjuster Apprentices," applies to "all types and classes of insurance adjusters, (company employee, independent, and public)." Paragraph (3)(b) states: "An adjuster shall treat all claimants equally," and (3)(b)1 adds that the adjuster "shall not provide favored treatment to any claimant." Under (3)(b)2, the adjuster "shall adjust all claims strictly in accordance with the insurance contract."
Paragraph (3)(d) requires "truthful and unbiased reports of the facts after making a complete investigation." Paragraph (3)(e) requires honesty and integrity in every adjustment and settlement. Paragraph (3)(f) requires the adjuster to "act with dispatch and due diligence in achieving a proper disposition of the claim." Under (3)(h), an adjuster "shall not advise a claimant to refrain from seeking legal advice." The current version took effect on April 21, 2025.
The code gives the expert a written standard to measure claim notes against, but Primeaux also cites Kuhlman v. Crawford & Co. (S.D. Fla. 2002) for the point that the code creates no independent cause of action. The expert compares conduct with the code; the court instructs the jury on bad faith.
Which deadlines does the expert check in a Florida property claim?
Section 627.70131: acknowledge communications within 7 calendar days, begin the investigation within 7 days after proof of loss, inspect within 30 days, and pay or deny within 60 days after notice, with a written explanation.
Under section 627.70131 of the 2026 Florida Statutes, an insurer that receives a communication about a claim "shall, within 7 calendar days, review and acknowledge receipt of such communication." The investigation follows: "within 7 days after an insurer receives proof-of-loss statements, the insurer shall begin such investigation," and "An insurer must conduct any such physical inspection within 30 days after its receipt of the proof-of-loss statements." The assigned adjuster gives the policyholder his or her name and state adjuster license number, and later communications about the claim must include them.
Subsection (7)(a) sets the payment deadline: "Within 60 days after an insurer receives notice of an initial, reopened, or supplemental property insurance claim," the insurer pays or denies the claim or a portion of it, unless factors beyond its control reasonably prevent that. A payment made after the deadline "bears interest at the rate set forth in s. 55.03" from the date the insurer received notice. The insurer "shall provide a reasonable explanation in writing to the policyholder of the basis in the insurance policy" for any payment, denial or partial denial.
In a first-party claim these dates go into the expert's timeline next to section 624.155(1)(b)3. For residential property claims, section 624.155(3)(f) also bars filing the civil remedy notice within 60 days after any party invokes appraisal.
What must happen before a statutory bad faith suit is filed?
The claimant gives the Department and the insurer 60 days' written notice on the Department's form. If the insurer pays the damages or corrects the violation within those 60 days, no action lies.
Under section 624.155(3)(a), "As a condition precedent to bringing an action under this section," the Department and the authorized insurer must receive 60 days' written notice of the violation. The notice is on the Department's form and states the statutory provision the insurer allegedly violated, the facts and circumstances, the names of any individuals involved, and the policy language relevant to the violation, if any. A third-party claimant need not cite policy language that the insurer did not provide after a written request. The notice also states that it is given to perfect the right to pursue the civil remedy.
Subsection (3)(c) is the cure provision: "No action shall lie if, within 60 days after the insurer receives notice," the damages are paid or the circumstances giving rise to the violation are corrected. The insurer reports to the Department how it resolved the alleged violation, and the limitations period is tolled for 60 days after the insurer receives the notice.
For the expert, the notice fixes the frame of the case. The statutory provisions it names and the facts it describes are the conduct the plaintiff has to prove, and the insurer's response during the 60 days becomes part of the claim file the expert reviews.
What will the court check before a bad faith expert testifies?
In federal court, Rule 702 as amended on December 1, 2023. In Florida state court, section 90.702. Both require a qualified witness, sufficient facts or data, reliable methods and their reliable application to the case.
Under Federal Rule of Evidence 702, a witness "qualified as an expert by knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education" may testify if the proponent establishes to the court "that it is more likely than not" that the expert's specialized knowledge will help the trier of fact, that the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data, that it is the product of reliable principles and methods, and that the opinion applies them reliably to the facts of the case. The Supreme Court's order of April 24, 2023 states that the amendments "shall take effect on December 1, 2023."
In state court, section 90.702 of the Florida Evidence Code applies "If scientific, technical, or other specialized knowledge will assist the trier of fact in understanding the evidence" and sets the same three conditions on facts or data, principles and methods, and their application. Its history line ends with chapter 2013-107. Section 90.703 provides that an otherwise admissible opinion is not objectionable because it includes an ultimate issue. The federal court in Primeaux still barred Gray from saying that Progressive acted in bad faith: an expert may not "merely tell the jury what result to reach."
Exclusion is not the default. Hayas quotes the Advisory Committee note to the 2000 amendment of Rule 702: "the rejection of expert testimony is the exception rather than the rule." Primeaux cites Quiet Technology DC-8, Inc. v. Hurel-Dubois UK Ltd., 326 F.3d 1333, 1345 (11th Cir. 2003), for the point that an objection that an opinion rests on inaccurate data or an inadequate study goes to weight, and cross-examination is the remedy. The committee note to the 2023 amendment of Rule 702 states that rulings treating the sufficiency of an expert's basis and the application of the method as questions of weight "are an incorrect application of Rules 702 and 104(a)." In federal court a retained expert also signs a report under Rule 26(a)(2)(B) with every opinion and its basis.
Which records does a bad faith expert need?
The policy, the full claim file with adjuster notes, every demand and deadline, the insurer's letters to the insured and the claimant, the tender, the civil remedy notice and the underlying judgment or verdict.
Each record answers a question that the statute, the rule or the case law above asks. The usual set for a Florida bad faith case:
- Get the policy and the declarations page to confirm the limits and the coverage under which each payment was made.
- Get the full claim file with the adjuster's dated notes, which fix the date of actual notice and the date the insurer had sufficient evidence of the amount.
- Collect every settlement demand from the claimant with its deadline and the documents attached to it.
- Collect the insurer's letters and emails to its insured about settlement opportunities, the probable outcome and the risk of an excess judgment.
- Add the tender letter and proof of payment, or the interpleader or arbitration papers if several claimants competed for the limits.
- In a property claim, add the acknowledgment, the inspection report, the payment or denial letter and the written explanation required by section 627.70131.
- Add the civil remedy notice, the insurer's response and its report to the Department.
- Add the verdict or judgment in the underlying case and the amount over the limits.
How does IAE find an insurance bad faith expert witness?
In the IAE request, choose the case type Commercial dispute and name the field, for example insurance claims handling under Florida law. Within 5 business days IAE sends 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and testimony lists.
The commercial litigation expert witness page lists claims against insurers among the case types and insurance claims handling among the specialties. The request asks for the field of expertise, the case type, the state and court, your side, the expert disclosure deadline, and the parties and their counsel for the conflict check. In a bad faith case that list includes the insurer, its insured, the claimant and the counsel in the underlying case. Please leave out privileged or sealed information.
Within 1 business day IAE replies whether it can search in that field by your deadline. Each candidate confirms in writing that he or she has no ties to the parties or their counsel. The candidates come with CVs, hourly rates, testimony from the last 4 years and publications from the last 10 years.
The search costs $2,000 per case, paid in advance, and candidate names and CVs come after payment. If no candidate fits, the second search is free; if IAE finds no candidates, it refunds the fee. The expert's hourly rate never depends on the outcome of the case or on the content of testimony. Under the optional agency arrangement, for hours at the expert's rate plus $100 per hour, for fixed fees, minimum charges and surcharges plus 40%, and for expenses at cost, the expert bills through IAE with one invoice, monthly billing and the search fee credited to the first invoice. IAE is not a law firm. Case strategy and the decision to retain an expert stay with the attorney.
Sources
- Florida Statutes (2025), section 624.155, Civil remedy (Florida Senate)
- Florida Legislature, Table Tracing Session Laws to Florida Statutes (2026)
- Florida Statutes (2026), section 627.70131 (Florida Senate)
- Florida Statutes (2026), chapter 90, Evidence Code, sections 90.702 and 90.703 (Florida Senate)
- Fla. Admin. Code R. 69B-220.201, Ethical Requirements for All Adjusters and Public Adjuster Apprentices (LII)
- Harvey v. GEICO General Insurance Co., No. SC17-85 (Fla. Sept. 20, 2018) (Justia)
- Primeaux v. Progressive American Insurance Co., No. 2:20-cv-941, Doc. 71 (M.D. Fla. Aug. 8, 2022) (Justia)
- Hayas v. GEICO General Insurance Co., No. 8:13-cv-1432, Doc. 106 (M.D. Fla. Oct. 22, 2014) (Justia)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702 (LII)
- Supreme Court of the United States, order amending the Federal Rules of Evidence (April 24, 2023)
Read also
All articles
Banking expert witness in a wire transfer fraud case: what makes a security procedure commercially reasonable under UCC 4A-202?
When a fraudster moves money out of a business account by wire, UCC Article 4A decides who absorbs the loss: the bank or its customer. The bank keeps
Custom and practice expert witness in a contract dispute: what may an industry expert say about trade usage, and where does the court draw the line?
In a contract dispute, an industry expert can tell the court how a term is used in the trade and how businesses in that trade ordinarily perform
Purchase price adjustment dispute: who decides working capital, the independent accountant or the court?
A purchase price adjustment trues up the price for changes in working capital between signing and closing, and the agreement sends disputes overExpert witnesses
Need an expert witness for your case?
Describe the question, the case type and the court. Within 5 business days you receive 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

