For attorneys

L-1B specialized knowledge: what must an expert letter prove, and why did the letters fail in G.D USA v. USCIS?

An L-1B petition has to show that the worker's knowledge of the company's product or processes is special or advanced compared with others in the company and the industry. In 2021 a federal court in Virginia upheld an L-1B denial because the letters did not describe this worker's training and knowledge in detail. In the Fogo de Chao cases, two courts faulted the USCIS Appeals Office for disregarding an affidavit, a CV, a nutritionist's letter and two expert reports.

Hands slide a blurred process sketch into an open petition folder beside a closed passport

What does an L-1B petition have to prove about specialized knowledge?

That the worker has special knowledge of the company's product and its application in international markets, or an advanced level of knowledge of its processes and procedures. The petitioner proves it by a preponderance of the evidence.

The definition comes from the Immigration and Nationality Act. Under 8 U.S.C. 1184(c)(2)(B), a worker has specialized knowledge if the worker has "a special knowledge of the company product and its application in international markets" or "an advanced level of knowledge of processes and procedures of the company." The regulation at 8 CFR 214.2(l)(1)(ii)(D) keeps the two branches. It speaks of "special knowledge possessed by an individual of the petitioning organization's product, service, research, equipment, techniques, management, or other interests and its application in international markets", and of "an advanced level of knowledge or expertise in the organization's processes and procedures."

Both texts are quoted in G.D USA, Inc. v. United States Citizenship and Immigration Services, a memorandum opinion issued on March 31, 2021 by District Judge M. Hannah Lauck of the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia in Civil Action No. 3:19cv694. The court also repeated the burden that applies to every L-1B petition: "The petitioner bears the burden of establishing the L-1B elements by a preponderance of the evidence."

Paragraph (l)(3)(iii) of the same regulation also requires "at least one continuous year of full-time employment abroad", and the court cited that requirement as well. The dispute in G.D USA concerned the knowledge itself, and so does this article.

Which factors does the 2015 L-1B memo list?

As the court in G.D USA quoted it, Policy Memorandum PM-602-0111 defines special and advanced knowledge by comparison with the industry and gives a non-exhaustive list of factors, among them knowledge that cannot be easily transferred without significant economic cost.

USCIS decided the G.D USA petition under Policy Memorandum PM-602-0111, which the court called the 2015 Policy Memo. The memo is quoted here as the court quoted it. Special knowledge is knowledge "distinct or uncommon in comparison to that generally found in the particular industry", and advanced knowledge is "greatly developed or further along in progress, complexity and understanding". For both, the petitioner ordinarily has to show that the worker's knowledge is "not commonly held throughout the particular industry." A statement that the worker's knowledge is "somehow different from others" is not enough on its own.

The memo sets out a non-exhaustive list of factors that USCIS may consider, and the court quoted six of them. The fifth factor settles whether the knowledge has to belong to the company alone: it may be sophisticated, complex or highly technical "although not necessarily unique to the petitioning organization". Under the definition above, it has to be uncommon in the industry.

  • The worker "possesses knowledge of foreign operating conditions that is of significant value" to the organization's U.S. operations.
  • The worker held assignments abroad that "have significantly enhanced the employer's . . . productivity, competitiveness, image, or financial position".
  • The claimed knowledge is "normally gained only through prior experience with the petitioning organization".
  • The worker knows a product or process that "cannot be easily transferred or taught to another individual without significant economic cost or inconvenience".
  • The knowledge concerns a process or a product that "either is sophisticated or complex, or of a highly technical nature".
  • The worker "possesses knowledge that is particularly beneficial to the petitioning organization's competitiveness in the marketplace".

What happened in G.D USA v. USCIS?

G.D USA, a supplier of cigarette making and packing machinery, petitioned for a technician from its Turkish affiliate. USCIS issued an RFE eight days after filing and denied the petition in August 2019, and the court upheld the denial.

G.D USA, Inc. supplies machinery for cigarette making and packing and is a subsidiary of the Coesia Group. According to the opinion, it has 165 employees at a 130,000 square-foot facility and lost nine mechanical technicians in the past 5 years. It sought an L-1B visa for Ahmet U., who had worked for its affiliate G.D Turkey since 2009 as a Mechanical Technician, to fill the position of Senior Assembly Technician. The company said it was "unable to find anyone in the U.S." with knowledge as close to his.

The petition on Form I-129 was filed on May 1, 2019. On May 9, 2019, USCIS issued a Request for Evidence. It asked for evidence of the worker's prior education, training and employment, for "A description of [Ahmet U.'s] knowledge or expertise and why it is specialized", for "A comparison of the beneficiary's knowledge to that of other employees and workers in the same field" and for curricula and training manuals for internal training courses.

On August 1, 2019, G.D USA answered with a letter and nine more exhibits. Among them were a second letter from its Service Manager dated July 31, 2019, a second letter from Country Manager Fauci dated July 30, 2019, a list of the worker's trainings since September 2005, a letter from Liggett Group LLC, a customer, dated July 26, 2019, and an anonymous sample diary of a technician's weekly tasks. USCIS denied the petition on August 13, 2019. The company sued under the Administrative Procedure Act.

Why did USCIS deny the petition?

USCIS found that the record did not describe the worker's special or advanced knowledge and did not show how he acquired it. It found support for one 10-day training, while the company claimed four years.

The company described "four years of intensive, in-house, and experiential training" and said that the worker had spent four years as a contractor training on G.D machines at the knowledge center in Bologna, Italy. USCIS read the record differently. It found "one training with a length of 10 days that was located in Bologna, Italy."

On the job itself USCIS wrote that "the duties themselves are broad and appear to be duties that are common to most repair or service technicians." It also noted that "[t]he record does not contain a comparison of skills, experience, or knowledge within the organization or industry." The comparison it had asked for in the RFE was missing.

The court accepted that reading of the training evidence. The list of trainings, it wrote, "gives almost no description about the nature of each training" beyond labels such as "Basic Mechanical Training". The worker received some trainings between 2005 and 2011, but G.D USA "does not specify what these trainings covered." In a footnote the court set out the finding of USCIS: the list showed that Ahmet U. "received 6 trainings for a Mechanical Technician" between 2005 and 2011, only one of them 10 days long and in Bologna, and that contradicted the Fauci letter about four years of training there.

Why did the court give the letters so little weight?

None of the letters described this worker's training and knowledge in detail. The customer had no personal knowledge of him, the affiliate kept no records of his one-on-one training, and the sample diary was not his.

The customer letter came from Liggett Group LLC. The court wrote that it "does not specifically address Ahmet U.'s relevant specialized knowledge or expertise" and "does not say that Ahmet U. ever assisted Liggett technicians." Nothing in it indicated "that Liggett has personal knowledge of or experience with Ahmet U." The letter also did not say that he had knowledge or training distinguishable from that of G.D USA's experienced technicians or of others in the industry.

The letters from Country Manager Fauci ran into a different problem. They stated that the affiliate does not maintain specific records of the worker's one-on-one experiential training. The court set these exhibits against the record in Fogo de Chao and wrote: "None of the exhibits provide the level of detail articulated in Fogo de Chao as to what the trainings specifically included."

The anonymous sample diary failed for a simpler reason. "The Sample Diary was not Ahmet U.'s," the court wrote, and it described Senior Assembly Technicians in general.

The court did not reject letters as a class. It weighed each one by whether it addressed this worker, his training and his knowledge compared with that of other technicians.

What did the courts say about the letters in the Fogo de Chao cases?

In 2014 the D.C. Circuit held that the USCIS Appeals Office had ignored an affidavit, a CV and a nutritionist's letter about the worker's training. In 2016 a district court held that it had disregarded reports by two industry experts.

The Fogo de Chao cases concerned an L-1B petition for Gasparetto, a gaucho chef, or churrasqueiro. The Appeals Office found insufficient evidence that he had completed the company's training program. In its opinion of October 21, 2014 in No. 13-5301, reported as 769 F.3d 1127, the D.C. Circuit pointed to three documents: a sworn affidavit by Fogo de Chao's Chief Executive Officer that Gasparetto had "completed the training program in Brazil", his curriculum vitae stating that he "graduated and specialized as waiter churrasqueiro", and a letter from a Brazilian nutritionist.

The nutritionist reviewed Gasparetto's curriculum vitae and information on the churrasqueiro position, interviewed him and concluded that he had "the cultural background and restaurant skills necessary to fill that position." The court noted: "None of that additional evidence is referenced in the Appeals Office opinion." It held: "We agree that this conclusion is not supported by substantial evidence." The D.C. Circuit reversed the district court's grant of summary judgment to the government and remanded.

On September 26, 2016, Judge Reggie B. Walton of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia decided a second Fogo de Chao case about the same worker, Civil Action No. 15-1272 (RBW), which the G.D USA opinion cites as 211 F. Supp. 3d 31. The record included reports by Gerald A. Hornbeck, "a restaurant-industry consultant", and Gregory P. Fatigati, "an associate dean for culinary arts at the Culinary Institute of America". The court wrote that the Appeals Office's decision "focuses entirely on Fogo's written training materials" and disregards the on-the-job part of the training, which Hornbeck put at "nearly 100% of the total training effort".

Judge Walton found that the Appeals Office's assessment of the facts about the gaucho churrasqueiro position "improperly disregarded substantial evidence" and vacated its finding that the position does not involve specialized knowledge. He affirmed the Appeals Office's findings regarding Gasparetto's training and qualifications.

The difference from G.D USA lies in the subject of the evidence. In Fogo de Chao the affidavit, the CV and the nutritionist spoke about this worker's training, and the two experts described the position and the training program. In G.D USA the letters spoke about the company, a customer or an anonymous technician.

How closely does a federal court review an L-1B denial?

Under the Administrative Procedure Act the court asks whether the denial was arbitrary or capricious and whether substantial evidence in the record supports it. It does not reweigh the evidence that USCIS had.

G.D USA sued under 5 U.S.C. 706(2)(A), which lets a court set aside agency action found to be "arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with law." The court called that review "highly deferential, with a presumption in favor of finding the agency action valid." Under 5 U.S.C. 706(2)(E) it also asked whether the denial was supported by substantial evidence, which the opinion defined as "such relevant evidence as a reasonable mind might accept as adequate to support a conclusion." The court's task "is not to reweigh the evidence and determine which of the competing views is more compelling."

The company argued that USCIS had applied a heightened standard of proof. The court disagreed. USCIS had named preponderance of the evidence as the standard and had found that the company did not show how the worker's knowledge differed from that of similar technicians. The court declined to give the agency's interpretation Chevron deference and gave it Skidmore weight, the "power to persuade." It granted summary judgment to USCIS and denied the company's motion.

The opinion cites each exhibit by its page in the administrative record, for example the RFE at R. 2-9 and the customer letter at R. 504-06, and measures the denial against that record. The court concluded that "USCIS weighed the evidence, applied the 2015 Policy Memo, and did not contradict long-standing agency precedent."

What can an expert opinion letter add to an L-1B petition?

The comparison with the industry. USCIS asked G.D USA to compare the worker's knowledge with that of other workers in the same field, and an independent expert in that field can describe what knowledge is common there.

As the court in G.D USA quoted it, the memo defines special knowledge by reference to what is "generally found in the particular industry". The employer knows its own staff and its own training. Which knowledge is common among technicians, engineers or analysts across the industry is a question about the field, and an expert who has worked in that field for years can answer it from experience. In the Fogo de Chao cases the courts weighed both kinds of evidence: an affidavit, a CV and a nutritionist's letter about the worker's own training, and reports by a restaurant-industry consultant and a culinary dean about the position.

USCIS wrote in G.D USA that the record lacked "a comparison of skills, experience, or knowledge within the organization or industry". An expert letter addresses the industry half of that sentence. The employer's records and letters address the organization half: who else in the company does the same work, how they were trained and what the worker knows that they do not.

The opinion also marks the limits of an outside letter. The court discounted the customer letter because it showed no "personal knowledge of or experience with Ahmet U." The nutritionist in Fogo de Chao reviewed the worker's CV and information on the position and interviewed him. An expert who writes for an L-1B petition therefore needs the worker's documents: training records with their content, the projects, the systems used and the duties abroad and in the United States.

What should the firm collect before the expert writes?

What USCIS requested in G.D USA: proof of education, training and employment, a description of the knowledge and why it is specialized, a comparison with others in the field, and internal curricula and training manuals.

The RFE in G.D USA lists what the officer asked for, and the court noted that it recommended the submission of training curricula and records. The list below follows that RFE and the gaps the court found in the response.

  • Collect a record of each training with its dates, length and content, since the court faulted a list that gave almost no description of each course.
  • Describe the worker's knowledge and why it is special or advanced, with the names of the products, machines or processes involved.
  • Compare the worker with other employees in the same role at the company, with numbers where the company has them.
  • Attach the curricula and training manuals for internal courses that the RFE named.
  • Obtain letters from people who worked with the worker directly and say so, since the court discounted a customer letter for lack of personal knowledge.
  • Order the expert letter on what knowledge is generally found in the industry after the expert has reviewed these documents.

How does IAE prepare an expert letter for an L-1B petition?

An expert from the IAE registry in the worker's field signs the letter with a declaration of independence. The free case assessment comes within one business day, and the letter within 10 business days after payment.

L-1B is one of the petition types listed on the page for attorneys, together with EB-1A, EB-1B, EB-2 NIW, O-1 and H-1B. The attorney sends the petition category, the beneficiary's field, the filing or RFE deadline, the beneficiary's CV and the draft petition or the RFE. Within one business day the Secretariat replies which letters make sense for the case, who the expert from the IAE registry in the beneficiary's field is, the cost and the deadline. The assessment is free and carries no obligation.

Before the invoice the attorney receives the expert's CV, degree, memberships and publications and a link to the registry record, and may decline the candidate. The invoice carries the case number and goes to the firm or to the client. The deadline runs from payment and receipt of the full file: 10 business days for a letter, 5 in rush mode, and 5 business days for an RFE or NOID response, 3 in rush mode.

The Secretariat prepares the draft from the beneficiary's documents, and the expert checks it, makes changes and signs. The draft goes to the attorney and the beneficiary, one round of factual edits is included, and the conclusions remain the expert's own. Before delivery, facts, dates and quotations are checked against the beneficiary's documents, and text from earlier letters is not reused, except section headings.

In every letter the expert confirms no personal, financial or professional connection to the beneficiary, and an expert with such a connection declines the order. One expert does not sign two letters for the same petition. IAE is not a law firm: the attorney is responsible for the case strategy, and USCIS weighs the letter together with the other evidence.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Request

Send your first case

The beneficiary's CV, the petition category and the deadline. The expert, the CV, the cost and the deadline within one business day.

Case for assessment

Received

Expert, cost and deadline within one business day

CategoryEB‑2 NIW
Beneficiary's fieldGeotechnics
RFE response duein 30 days