Expert witnesses
Medical billing expert witness: how is the reasonable value of medical bills proved and tested?
The amount on a medical bill is not, by itself, proof of what the treatment was worth. The Iowa Court of Appeals said so in 2007 and required expert testimony. In an unpublished 2016 opinion, a California appellate panel vacated a medical damages award because the plaintiff's expert never tied billed charges to market value. A medical billing expert compares charges with what providers are paid and explains the coding, and courts test that work under the evidence rules.

Why is a medical bill not enough to prove reasonable value?
Because the amount charged, standing alone, is not evidence of the reasonable value of the services. Courts require additional proof, usually expert testimony, that the charges match what such services are worth.
The Iowa Court of Appeals put the rule in plain terms in The C.B.E. Group, Inc. v. Bubeck, No. 7-874 / 07-0868, decided December 12, 2007. Relying on its earlier decision in Pexa, the court wrote: "The amount charged, standing alone, is not evidence of the reasonable and fair value of the services rendered." It added: "Expert testimony is required." The party claiming the charges must prove both that the services were medically necessary and that the charges were reasonable.
Bubeck was a suit over an unpaid hospital bill, and the court affirmed a judgment of $9,027.25 plus interest and costs against the patient. The rule it applied is the same one that governs medical expense damages in an injury case: the bill shows what the provider asked for, and a separate witness has to explain why that amount is a fair price.
A California appellate panel reached the same point by a different route, in an opinion that is not precedent. In Frisk v. Cowan, decided July 26, 2016 and not certified for publication, the Court of Appeal for the Third Appellate District held that for an uninsured plaintiff the billed amounts are relevant to the amount incurred and to reasonable value but are not sufficient on their own. The plaintiff needs additional evidence, typically expert testimony, that ties the billed amount to the market value of the service.
Who can testify about the reasonableness of medical charges?
A witness who knows how charges are set and how they compare with other charges. Bubeck accepted a hospital's director of patient financial services; Collins v. Benton accepted a medical bill auditor with over 30 years in billing.
In Bubeck the hospital called Kim Klavitter, Mercy's director of patient financial services for 17 years. He explained the billing process, testified that the charges were fair and consistent with other charges in Mercy's system, and noted that Mercy had never been penalized for excessive charges. The court of appeals held that he was qualified to testify about reasonableness, citing among other authority Mercy Hospital v. Hansen.
The court also addressed disclosure. Under Iowa Rule of Civil Procedure 1.508(1), parties disclose experts retained for litigation. Klavitter acquired his knowledge before the litigation, in his daily work, so he did not have to be disclosed as an expert, and his testimony was properly admitted. The patient offered no evidence that any charge was unreasonable, and the studies he cited were not in the record.
Federal courts reach the question through Rule 702. In Collins v. Benton, Civil Action No. 18-7465 in the Eastern District of Louisiana, Chief Judge Nannette Jolivette Brown found the defense witness Nancy Michalski qualified as a medical bill auditor: she had more than 30 years in healthcare billing and pricing, had run the medical billing department of an outpatient surgical unit between 1984 and 2001, and had testified as a medical bill auditor 89 times in court and 430 times in depositions.
What does California require for past medical expenses?
Under Howell v. Hamilton Meats, as the unpublished Frisk opinion applied it, recovery is limited to the lesser of the amount incurred or paid and the reasonable value of the services; an uninsured plaintiff's billed amounts need support.
Frisk v. Cowan applied the rule of Howell v. Hamilton Meats: a plaintiff's recovery of medical expenses is limited to the lesser of the amount incurred or paid and the reasonable value of the services. For an insured plaintiff, what the insurer and the plaintiff paid is relevant to reasonable value, and, in the words the court took from Howell, "evidence of the amount billed is not relevant to prove the reasonable value of services already provided."
The plaintiff in Frisk had received treatment under lien agreements. Her expert testified that the billed charges were "usual, customary, and reasonable" but did not link them to reasonable value and called the amounts providers were paid irrelevant. The court held that admitting that testimony was error. It also held that excluding the defense expert's evidence of the average amounts paid by insurers and government programs was error, because such evidence can bear on market value, although a nexus to reasonable value may be required.
The court stated that "a plaintiff, whether insured or uninsured, bears the burden of proving her medical damages." It vacated the awards of past and future medical expenses, remanded for a retrial limited to those damages, and affirmed the judgment in all other respects, including liability, noneconomic damages and punitive damages. The opinion is not certified for publication, and under rule 8.1115 of the California Rules of Court it cannot be cited or relied on as precedent.
How does a defense billing expert build an opinion?
By comparing each charge with benchmark prices for the same service in the same area. In Collins v. Benton the auditor used the 75th percentile of the Physicians Fee Reference and more than 20 other sources, adjusted for New Orleans.
The plaintiffs in Collins moved in limine, and under Daubert, to exclude or limit Michalski's testimony on the reasonable value of their medical services. Chief Judge Brown denied the motion in an order entered as Record Document 223 in July 2020.
The court described the method. Michalski used the 75th percentile of the Physicians Fee Reference and more than 20 other sources, applied a geographic modifier for New Orleans, and had her methodology peer-reviewed by Gerard Anderson, Ph.D. The court found that the method passed the flexible reliability inquiry under Rule 702 and that the plaintiffs' attacks on her data sources went to weight, to be tested on cross-examination, rather than to admissibility.
The structure is the usual one for such opinions. The expert lists each billed service with its code, assigns a benchmark price from named databases, adjusts for geography, and compares the billed amount with the benchmark. The plaintiff's billing expert, where there is one, uses the same steps with different sources or explains why the provider's charges fall within the market range.
Can a billing expert's testimony reduce the damages?
That depends on state law. In Collins the court held that under Louisiana law the auditor could not be used to call the bills unreasonable without evidence of bad faith, but could be used to impeach the treating physicians.
Louisiana courts have held that a tortfeasor must generally pay for the victim's medical treatment, even if it was excessive, unless the victim incurred it in bad faith. In Collins the court relied on Gunn v. Robertson, Yee v. Imperial Fire & Casualty, Revel v. Snow and Antippas v. Nola Hotel Group. The plaintiffs quoted Antippas: "in the absence of bad faith, it is error for the trier of fact to fail to award the full amount of medical expenses."
Applying that line of cases, the court held that Michalski's testimony could not be used to argue that the bills were unreasonable unless the defense presented evidence of bad faith. Unless such evidence came in at trial, the jury would be instructed that her testimony could not reduce the recoverable medical expenses.
The testimony stayed in the case for another purpose. The court allowed it to impeach the credibility of the treating physicians, pointing to a possible financial incentive created by the sale of the bills to a medical funding company, Medport, which could give the physicians a stake in the outcome. The same expert evidence can therefore be barred on the amount of damages and admitted on the weight of a physician's testimony.
What changes when treatment is paid through a lien or a funding company?
The paper trail changes. Courts look at what the lien holder or funding company paid for the receivable and at the providers' interest in the case: in Frisk as evidence of value, in Collins as grounds for impeachment.
In lien-based treatment the provider treats now and is paid from the recovery. Some providers sell the receivable to a funding company at a discount. Frisk noted California decisions, Katiuzhinsky and Uspenskaya, holding that amounts paid by third parties to buy liens may be relevant to reasonable value, while excluding them without a nexus to reasonable value is not error. The court found substantial evidence that the plaintiff was liable for the full billed amount under her lien agreements, even though the signed documents were not introduced.
In Collins the sale of bills to a medical funding company came in as a reason to question the treating physicians. A physician whose bills were sold, and whose payment may depend on the outcome, has a financial interest that the jury can consider.
A billing expert in a lien case therefore asks for documents beyond the bills: the lien agreements, any assignment or sale of the receivable, the price paid, and any agreement between the provider and the plaintiff's counsel. The expert explains what each document shows about the amount incurred and about the market price of the services.
What does a medical billing expert need from the file?
Itemized bills with procedure and diagnosis codes, records of payments, adjustments and write-offs, insurance explanations of benefits, lien agreements and any sale of the receivable, and the treatment records that show which service was provided on which date.
Totals are not enough. The expert works line by line, so the bills must be itemized, with the date of service, the provider, the procedure code, the diagnosis code and the charge for each line. Where the bill bundles services, the expert asks the provider for the breakdown.
Payment records come next. For an insured plaintiff, the payments by the insurer and the plaintiff, the contractual adjustments and the write-offs show the amount paid, which Frisk, following Howell, treats as relevant to reasonable value. For an uninsured plaintiff, the expert looks for any payments at all, lien terms and any sale of the account.
The treatment records tie the charges to the injury. The billing expert does not decide whether a service was medically necessary, but checks that each billed service appears in the records on the date billed and that duplicate or unrelated charges are identified.
How is a billing expert's method tested under Rule 702?
The proponent must establish that the expert's knowledge will help the jury, that the opinion rests on sufficient facts or data, and that reliable methods were reliably applied. In Collins, disputes about data sources went to weight.
Federal Rule of Evidence 702 requires the proponent to show the court that it is more likely than not that the expert's specialized knowledge will help the trier of fact, that the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data, that it is the product of reliable principles and methods, and that the opinion applies those methods reliably to the facts of the case.
Collins shows how a court applies those conditions to a billing auditor. Qualification rested on decades of billing and pricing work. Reliability rested on named databases, a stated percentile, a geographic adjustment and peer review of the methodology. The court treated disagreements about which databases were better as matters for cross-examination. Relevance and fit were where the testimony was limited, because Louisiana law restricted what the jury could do with it.
The committee note to the 2023 amendment of Rule 702 says that some challenges go to weight rather than admissibility, and that once the court finds the rule's requirements met, attacks go only to weight. Counsel preparing to challenge a billing expert separates the two: missing data or an unexplained method for a motion, competing databases for cross-examination.
Does a billing expert replace the treating physician?
No. The physician addresses whether the treatment was necessary and caused by the injury. The billing expert addresses what the services were worth. Bubeck requires proof of both necessity and reasonable charges.
Bubeck lists two elements for medical charges: the services were medically necessary, and the charges were reasonable. A billing expert speaks to the second. Whether a surgery was needed, whether physical therapy ran longer than the injury required, and whether a condition was caused by the crash are medical questions for a physician.
The two kinds of testimony meet at the point where a charge is questioned. If a billing expert finds a service billed with no matching treatment record, the physician explains or the charge drops. If a physician recommends future care, a billing expert or a life care planner prices it.
Collins adds a third point of contact. The court admitted the billing auditor's evidence on the credibility of the treating physicians, given the sale of their bills, while barring its use on the price of the services absent evidence of bad faith.
How does IAE find a medical billing expert for a personal injury case?
In the request choose the case type Personal injury and name medical billing and reasonable value of medical expenses in the field. Within 5 business days IAE sends 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.
The IAE personal injury expert witness page covers car and truck crashes, falls, workplace injuries and wrongful death and lists eight personal injury specialties. Its groups name accident mechanics, medicine, and damages and falls, including economists on lost earnings and vocational assessment.
The request form asks for the field of expertise, the case type, the state and court, the firm's side, the expert disclosure deadline, the parties and their counsel for the conflict check, and a short description of the case. For a billing dispute the description can say whether the plaintiff was insured, whether treatment was provided under a lien and whether the bills were sold. The form asks not to include privileged or sealed information.
Within 1 business day IAE replies whether it can search by the deadline. Each candidate confirms in writing that he or she has no ties to the parties or their counsel. Within 5 business days the firm receives 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates, testimony in the last 4 years and publications in the last 10 years. The search costs $2,000 per case, paid in advance, and candidate names and CVs come after payment. If no candidate fits, the second search is free; if IAE finds no candidates, it refunds the fee.
The expert bills the firm directly or through IAE under the agency option at +$100 per hour. IAE is not a law firm, and case strategy and the decision to retain an expert stay with the attorney.
Sources
- The C.B.E. Group, Inc. v. Bubeck, No. 7-874 / 07-0868 (Iowa Ct. App. Dec. 12, 2007) (Justia)
- Collins v. Benton, No. 18-7465, Rec. Doc. 223 (E.D. La. 2020), order on motion to exclude medical bill auditor (Justia)
- Frisk v. Cowan, No. C077975 (Cal. Ct. App., 3d Dist., July 26, 2016, unpublished)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702, with committee notes (LII, Cornell Law School)
Read also
All articles
Dram shop expert witness: what can a toxicologist prove about visible intoxication, and what do courts require of the opinion?
A dram shop claim asks a court to hold a bar or restaurant liable for what an intoxicated patron did after leaving. The crash is usually undisputed
Construction accident expert witness: which safety rules does the expert apply, and when do they decide the case?
A fall from a scaffold, a collapsed trench or a ladder that kicked out ends up in court as a question about safety rules. The construction safety
Traumatic brain injury expert witness: what can a neuropsychologist and brain imaging prove in court?
A mild traumatic brain injury often leaves nothing a standard scan can show, so the case turns on experts: the treating physiciansExpert witnesses
Need an expert witness for your case?
Describe the question, the case type and the court. Within 5 business days you receive 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

