Expert witnesses
Certificate of merit in medical malpractice: what Maryland requires of the attesting expert
In Maryland the certificate of merit in a medical malpractice claim is the certificate of a qualified expert. A health care provider attests that the defendant departed from the standards of care and that the departure was the proximate cause of the injury, and attaches a report. The deadline is 90 days. In Breslin v. Powell (2011) the state's highest court held that an unqualified attesting expert means dismissal without prejudice.

What is a certificate of merit in a Maryland malpractice claim?
Maryland calls it the certificate of a qualified expert. A health care provider who is not a party attests that the defendant departed from the standards of care and that the departure proximately caused the injury, and attaches a report.
The rules sit in the Health Care Malpractice Claims Act, Courts and Judicial Proceedings Article, title 3, subtitle 2A. The Court of Appeals of Maryland traced their history in Breslin v. Powell, No. 134, September Term 2010, decided on August 16, 2011. The Act was passed in 1976. It created mandatory arbitration of claims over $5,000 before the Health Claims Arbitration Office, and the arbitration scheme took effect in 1978 after constitutional challenges ended. Awards were not binding.
The certificate came ten years later. Senate Bill 559, chapter 640 of the Acts of 1986, added it after a 1984 proposal failed and a task force reported in December 1985. The court described the purpose in words it took from an earlier case: "The purpose of the statute is to weed out non-meritorious claims." A task force report quoted in the opinion states that under the requirement a health care provider who is not a party has reviewed the claim.
Arbitration is no longer the only route. A 1995 law, chapter 582, codified at section 3-2A-06B, permitted "waiver by either party of the entire arbitration process." Breslin calls the office the Health Care Alternative Dispute Resolution Office (HCADRO). After a waiver the case moves to circuit court, but the certificate requirement stays. The court held that "filing of a proper certificate is a condition precedent to filing an action in circuit court."
When must the certificate of a qualified expert be filed?
With the Director of HCADRO, within 90 days from the date of the complaint. Without it the claim is dismissed without prejudice, unless the panel chairman or the court grants an extension under the statute.
Section 3-2A-04(b)(1)(i), as quoted in Breslin, provides that "[a] claim or action filed after July 1, 1986, shall be dismissed, without prejudice, if the claimant or plaintiff fails to file a certificate of a qualified expert" with the Director "within 90 days from the date of the complaint." The certificate attests "to departure from standards of care, and that the departure from standards of care is the proximate cause" of the alleged injury.
The current text of section 3-2A-04 sets the conditions in paragraph (b)(1)(ii): "In lieu of dismissing the claim or action, the panel chairman or the court shall grant an extension of no more than 90 days for filing the certificate" if the limitations period applicable to the claim has expired and the failure to file "was neither willful nor the result of gross negligence." Paragraph (b)(5) adds that an extension of the time for filing a certificate of a qualified expert "shall be granted for good cause shown."
In Breslin the claim was filed with the arbitration office on July 30, 2004, and a certificate was filed with it. When the claimant later added a defendant by an amended statement of claim on August 5, 2005, a new certificate went in with the amendment.
What must the certificate and the report state?
The departure from the standards of care and that it was the proximate cause of the injury, with the expert's report attached. Earlier Maryland cases dismissed claims where the certificate did not name each defendant or the report was missing.
Section 3-2A-04(b)(3)(i) requires the attorney for each party, or a party proceeding pro se, to "file the appropriate certificate with a report of the attesting expert attached." The statute speaks of the departure from standards of care and of proximate cause. Footnote 25 of Breslin collects earlier decisions in which a deficient certificate led to dismissal without prejudice. In D'Angelo the plaintiff failed to name each person alleged to have violated the standard of care. In Carroll the certificate did not state proximate cause with specificity. In Kearney and in Walzer the expert report was not attached.
The certificate does not have to list the expert's credentials. The court wrote: "There is no express requirement that the expert's qualifications be stated in the certificate." Discovery fills the gap. Section 3-2A-04(b)(3)(ii) provides that "[d]iscovery is available as to the basis of the [Certificate]." In Breslin the defendant learned what the attesting expert did and did not practice from his deposition.
The same deposition can end the claim against a defendant. A certificate that attests to a departure by a surgeon, signed by a physician who testifies that he does not practice surgery, exposes the claimant to the motion that Dr. Breslin filed.
Who may sign the certificate in Maryland?
A health care provider who, within 5 years of the act or omission, practiced, consulted or taught in the defendant's specialty, a related field or the field in which the defendant treated the plaintiff, and meets the board certification test.
Section 3-2A-02(c)(2)(ii) applies to a health care provider "who attests in a certificate of a qualified expert or testifies in relation to a proceeding before a panel or court concerning a defendant's compliance with or departure from standards of care." Such a provider "[s]hall have had clinical experience, provided consultation relating to clinical practice, or taught medicine in the defendant's specialty or a related field of health care, or in the field of health care in which the defendant provided care or treatment to the plaintiff, within 5 years of the date of the alleged act or omission giving rise to the cause of action."
The same paragraph sets a second test. If the defendant is board certified in a specialty, the attesting expert "shall be board certified in the same or a related specialty as the defendant." That test does not apply if the defendant was providing care or treatment to the plaintiff unrelated to the area in which the defendant is board certified, or if the expert taught medicine in the defendant's specialty or a related field of health care.
The General Assembly added this paragraph in 2004, in chapter 5 of the Acts of the 2004 First Special Session. It "applies to a claim or action filed on or after January 1, 2005." The words "in addition to any other qualifications" led the court to read sections 3-2A-02 and 3-2A-04 together: the qualifications in one section are part of what makes a certificate "of a qualified expert" in the other.
The 5 years count back from the date of the alleged act or omission, not from the date the certificate is signed. The test runs to each defendant: in Breslin the certificate against a vascular surgeon came from an anesthesiologist, and the parties agreed that he was not a qualified expert on the surgeon's standard of care. Section 3-2A-04(b)(7) adds who may not sign at all. For any claim or action filed on or after July 1, 1989, a party may not serve as a party's expert, and the certificate may not be signed by a party, an employee or partner of a party, or an employee or stockholder of any professional corporation of which the party is a stockholder.
What is Maryland's 25 percent rule for attesting experts?
An attesting or testifying expert may not have devoted more than 25 percent of his or her professional activities to testimony in personal injury claims during the 12 months before the claim was first filed.
Section 3-2A-04(b)(4)(ii) covers a health care provider who attests in a certificate of a qualified expert "or who testifies in relation to a proceeding before an arbitration panel or a court concerning compliance with or departure from standards of care." Such a provider "may not have devoted more than 25% of the expert's professional activities to activities that directly involve testimony in personal injury claims during the 12 months immediately before the date when the claim was first filed." Under (b)(4)(i), the term "professional activities" covers all activities that arise out of the health care profession or relate to it.
The rule has changed since Breslin. The 2011 opinion quotes the earlier text, under which an attesting expert could not "devote annually more than 20 percent" of professional activities to such testimony. The current text fixes the period, the 12 months before the claim was first filed, and raises the ceiling to 25 percent. Under (b)(4)(iii), once a health care provider meets that requirement, the provider "shall be deemed to be a qualified expert" as to it "during the pendency of the claim."
The rule counts testimony in every kind of personal injury claim, medical malpractice among them, so testimony in automobile or workplace injury cases counts too. Because "[d]iscovery is available as to the basis of the certificate," the defense can ask the attesting expert how his or her professional activities divided in those 12 months. The expert's list of prior testimony, which a retained expert discloses in federal court for the previous 4 years under Rule 26(a)(2)(B), is one starting point for that question.
What happened in Breslin v. Powell?
An anesthesiologist signed the certificate against a vascular surgeon. Both sides agreed he was not qualified on the surgeon's standard of care. The trial court entered summary judgment; the appellate courts ordered dismissal without prejudice instead.
Jackie D. Powell, a dialysis patient, was admitted to Good Samaritan Hospital on October 31, 2002 for a hepatorenal arterial bypass. Dr. Monford Wolf, a board-certified anesthesiologist, gave the epidural anesthesia, and Dr. Jeffery Breslin, a board-certified vascular surgeon, performed the procedure. Mr. Powell suffered an ischemic spinal cord injury from an epidural hematoma and was paralyzed from the waist down. He died on March 8, 2004. The claim against Dr. Breslin alleged that he failed to recognize and respond in time to post-operative complaints of leg pain and numbness.
Ronald L. Powell, as personal representative, filed the claim with the arbitration office on July 30, 2004, with a certificate signed by Dr. Henry Rosenberg, a board-certified anesthesiologist. After waiving arbitration, he sued in the Circuit Court for Baltimore City. On August 5, 2005 he added Dr. Breslin and his professional association by an amended statement of claim, with a new certificate signed by Dr. Ronald Burt, also a board-certified anesthesiologist. Dr. Burt certified experience "in the field of Anesthesiology and/or the related field of general surgery."
At his deposition on September 6, 2006, Dr. Burt testified that he does not hold himself out as an expert in vascular surgery or general surgery. Asked whether anesthesiology was his only field, he answered: "Exactly." He said he would defer to a vascular surgeon on training and on diagnosing epidural hematomas. The parties later agreed that he was not a qualified expert on the standard of care for a vascular surgeon.
Powell answered with three points: the claim began in July 2004, before the 2005 qualification rule; the two specialties overlap, and Dr. Breslin's own expert, Dr. Gary Ruben, testified that both can diagnose spinal hematomas; and Powell had a general surgeon ready to testify who had also signed a certificate. The circuit court granted summary judgment for Dr. Breslin and denied reconsideration.
What did the court decide about a certificate from an unqualified expert?
That it requires dismissal without prejudice, not summary judgment. The court held that a claimant who files the certificate of an unqualified expert has failed to file a certificate of a qualified expert.
The Court of Special Appeals reversed in Powell v. Breslin, 195 Md. App. 340 (2010), holding that the sanction for any noncompliant certificate is dismissal without prejudice. The Court of Appeals affirmed in an opinion by Judge Harrell. The statute, it wrote, requires "dismissal without prejudice of the underlying claim for the filing of a non-compliant Certificate, regardless of the particular qualification or requirement the Certificate or its attestor fails to meet."
The reasoning runs in steps. A proper certificate is a condition precedent to suit. Quoting D'Angelo, the court wrote that "failure to file a proper certificate is tantamount to not having filed a certificate at all." It saw no basis to treat an unqualified attestor differently from a missing report: "To recognize such a distinction creates a dichotomy that is not included" in the statute. The Maryland Rules on summary judgment apply "[e]xcept as otherwise provided," so the Act's own remedy controls.
The court also placed the risk: "a claimant who retains an unqualified expert does so at his or her peril." Costs were assessed against Dr. Breslin as petitioner. The opinion lists Chief Judge Bell and Judges Harrell, Battaglia, Greene, Murphy, Adkins and Barbera on the panel.
Can the claim be filed again after a dismissal without prejudice?
Yes. Breslin allowed refiling within the limitations period. Section 3-2A-04(b)(4)(iv) now permits one refiling, absent bad faith, before the later of the limitations deadline or 120 days after a dismissal for an expert's noncompliance.
The opinion quotes Black's Law Dictionary: a dismissal without prejudice "does not bar the plaintiff from refiling the lawsuit within the applicable limitations period." Applying that to the certificate statute, the court wrote that the claimant has an opportunity to refile with the certificate of a qualified expert, "assuming the limitations period has not expired."
The statute now goes further. Under section 3-2A-04(b)(4)(iv), "[i]f a court dismisses a claim or action because a qualified expert failed to comply with the requirements of this subsection, unless there is a showing of bad faith, a party may refile the same claim or action before the later of" the expiration of the applicable period of limitation or "120 days after the date of the dismissal." Under (b)(4)(v), a claim or action may be refiled that way "only once."
In Breslin the treatment took place in October 2002, and the challenged certificate was filed in August 2005. Because the statutory refiling is available only once, the qualifications of the attesting expert are checked before the certificate is signed, not after the defense deposes him. Quoting the amicus brief of the Maryland Association for Justice, the Breslin court described one purpose of the Act as a balance between "the preservation of rights of those injured through malpractice" and the rights of those accused.
What should counsel confirm before the attesting expert signs?
Seven points from the statute and Breslin: the expert's field and recent work, board certification, each defendant's specialty, the 25 percent rule, who may sign, each defendant named, and the attestation with the report.
Each point below comes from the current text of sections 3-2A-02 and 3-2A-04 or from the earlier cases that Breslin cites. The 90-day period runs from the date of the complaint, and the 25 percent rule looks at the 12 months before the claim was first filed, so the review starts before filing.
- Within 5 years of the date of the alleged act or omission, the expert had clinical experience, provided consultation relating to clinical practice, or taught medicine in the defendant's specialty, a related field of health care, or the field in which the defendant treated the plaintiff.
- If the defendant is board certified, the expert is board certified in the same or a related specialty, unless one of the two statutory exceptions applies.
- Where the defendants practice different specialties, the expert meets the test for each of them, or a separate certificate is signed by an expert from each specialty.
- In the 12 months before the claim was first filed, the expert devoted no more than 25 percent of his or her professional activities to activities that directly involve testimony in personal injury claims.
- The expert is not a party, an employee or partner of a party, or an employee or stockholder of a professional corporation of which the party is a stockholder.
- The certificate names each health care provider alleged to have departed from the standards of care. In D'Angelo the omission led to dismissal.
- The certificate states the departure from standards of care and that the departure is the proximate cause of the alleged injury, the expert report is attached, and the certificate is filed with the Director within 90 days from the date of the complaint.
How does IAE find an attesting expert for a Maryland malpractice claim?
In the request choose the case type Medical malpractice, write Maryland in the State and court field and name the defendant's specialty. Within 5 business days IAE sends 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and testimony lists.
The medical malpractice expert witness page lists six medical malpractice specialties: surgeons, obstetricians, anesthesiologists, emergency physicians, nurses and geriatricians. IAE matches the expert to the defendant's specialty and the state's requirements. The page notes that specialty rules and the deadline for the first expert opinion differ by state. The request form asks for the field of expertise, the case type, the state and court, the firm's side, the expert disclosure deadline, the parties and their counsel for the conflict check, and a short description of the case.
For a Maryland claim the short description can give the date of the act or omission, the specialty of each defendant and whether the claim is already filed with HCADRO. Within 1 business day IAE replies whether it can search in that specialty by the deadline. Each candidate confirms in writing that he or she has no ties to the parties or their counsel. Within 5 business days the firm receives 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates, testimony in the last 4 years and publications in the last 10 years.
The search costs $2,000 per case, paid in advance, and candidate names and CVs come after payment. If no candidate fits, the second search is free; if IAE finds no candidates, it refunds the fee. The expert bills the firm directly or through IAE under the agency option at +$100 per hour. The expert's hourly rate never depends on the outcome of the case or on the content of testimony. IAE is not a law firm. Case strategy and the decision to retain an expert stay with the attorney.
Sources
- Breslin v. Powell, No. 134, September Term 2010 (Md. Aug. 16, 2011), slip opinion (Maryland Judiciary)
- Maryland Code, Courts and Judicial Proceedings, section 3-2A-04 (Maryland General Assembly, 2026 statute text)
- Maryland Code, Courts and Judicial Proceedings, section 3-2A-02 (FindLaw Codes, current as of January 1, 2025)
Read also
All articles
New Jersey affidavit of merit in medical malpractice: who may sign it, and what happens when the 120 days run out?
In New Jersey a malpractice plaintiff has 60 days after each defendant's answer to serve an affidavit of an appropriate licensed person
Pennsylvania certificate of merit in medical malpractice: what must the expert's written statement say?
In Pennsylvania a malpractice claim against a physician needs a certificate of merit within 60 days after the complaint is filed. The certificate
New York medical malpractice expert: what do the certificate of merit and CPLR 3101(d) require?
A New York medical malpractice complaint is filed with a certificate in which the plaintiff's attorney declares that he or she consulted at least oneExpert witnesses
Need an expert witness for your case?
Describe the question, the case type and the court. Within 5 business days you receive 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

