RFE responses
An NIW RFE on all three Dhanasar prongs: what evidence answers each?
An RFE in an EB-2 national interest waiver case can question all three Dhanasar prongs in one notice. The petitioner answers in a single package by the deadline the RFE sets, which may not exceed 12 weeks and cannot be extended. In several 2024 appeals the AAO decided the case on the first prong alone and made no finding on the other two.

Why does an NIW RFE question all three prongs at once?
The petitioner must prove each prong, and the second and third are measured against the endeavor described under the first. When that description stays general, the officer can find all three unproven in one notice.
In a decision of November 21, 2024, the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) restated the test of Matter of Dhanasar, 26 I&N Dec. 884, 889 (AAO 2016). The waiver may be granted when "1) the proposed endeavor has both substantial merit and national importance; 2) the individual is well positioned to advance their proposed endeavor; and 3) on balance, waiving the job offer requirement would benefit the United States." The USCIS Policy Manual adds: "Claims lacking corroborating evidence are not sufficient to meet the petitioner's burden of proof."
The second and third prongs refer back to the first. The second asks whether the person is well positioned to advance the proposed endeavor. The third weighs the person's contributions to that endeavor against the job offer and labor certification. The Policy Manual states that "The term 'endeavor' is more specific than the general occupation" and asks the petitioner to describe "what types of work the person proposes to undertake specifically within that occupation." A petition that names only an occupation gives the officer no specific endeavor to measure under any of the three prongs.
In one file the RFE reached every element of the case. In an NIW petition for a project manager in IT and telecommunications, the Director issued an RFE on August 24, 2022, stating that the petitioner had not established her eligibility as an advanced degree professional "or any of the three prongs of the Dhanasar framework." Before she answered, an Acting Director issued a second RFE dated January 5, 2023. It accepted the advanced degree, requested evidence on the first and third prongs and "includes no discussion on the second prong."
On February 8, 2024 the AAO found that the contradictory statements on the second prong "limited her ability to address any deficiencies in the evidence in the record." It withdrew the denial and remanded the case. A footnote records that she later filed another immigrant petition, and that petition was approved.
An RFE on the prongs can also question EB-2 eligibility, which comes before the waiver. In a case with an RFE dated May 2, 2022, the Director found that a computer systems analyst met none of the three prongs and only two of the three required criteria for exceptional ability. On appeal he repeated his RFE response on those criteria word for word. On September 11, 2023 the AAO adopted the Director's decision on the criteria, dismissed the appeal and did not reach the waiver.
How long do you have to answer, and how is the response filed?
The RFE states its own deadline, which under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8)(iv) may not exceed 12 weeks, and no extension is granted. All requested materials go to USCIS together, with the original RFE.
Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8)(iv), the notice "will specify the type of evidence required" and "will indicate the deadline for response, but in no case shall the maximum response period provided in a request for evidence exceed twelve weeks." The same paragraph adds: "Additional time to respond to a request for evidence or notice of intent to deny may not be granted."
Paragraph (b)(11) gives three options within that period: a complete response, a partial response with a request for a decision on the record, or withdrawal. "All requested materials must be submitted together at one time, along with the original USCIS request for evidence or notice of intent to deny." A package that answers two prongs and leaves the third for a later mailing falls under the next sentence: "Submission of only some of the requested evidence will be considered a request for a decision on the record."
Paragraph (b)(12) sets the date the evidence must prove. "A benefit request shall be denied where evidence submitted in response to a request for evidence does not establish filing eligibility at the time the benefit request was filed." Every new document in the response therefore carries a date, and the attorney checks it against the filing date on the receipt notice.
The differences between an RFE and a notice of intent to deny, and the effect of an RFE on premium processing, are covered in the guide RFE or NOID: what is the difference and how do you answer each?
Which prong should the response answer first?
The first. In 2024 the AAO dismissed NIW appeals in which the first prong failed and reserved the second and third prongs, citing the rule that agencies need not decide issues unnecessary to the result.
On November 21, 2024 the AAO dismissed the appeal of an entrepreneur and martial arts instructor. The Director had found substantial merit but not national importance. The AAO wrote: "Because the Petitioner has not established eligibility under the first prong of the Dhanasar test, we need not address his eligibility under the remaining prongs, and we hereby reserve them." A footnote cites INS v. Bagamasbad, 429 U.S. 24, 25 (1976): "courts and agencies are not required to make findings on issues the decision of which is unnecessary to the results they reach."
On March 7, 2024 the AAO dismissed the appeal of an IT consultant. The Director had found that he met none of the three prongs. The AAO affirmed the first-prong analysis and reserved the second and third. It noted that his 24 years of experience belonged to the analysis of whether he was well positioned, which it did not reach.
On July 15, 2024 the AAO dismissed the appeal of a petitioner who planned a consulting business in Texas for business intelligence and the modernization of accounting systems. It adopted the Director's finding on national importance and wrote: "As this issue is dispositive of the Petitioner's appeal, we decline to reach and hereby reserve our determination of her eligibility under the second and third prongs of the Dhanasar framework."
What evidence answers the first prong?
Evidence of what the petitioner will do and of the endeavor's potential impact beyond the petitioner's own clients and employees. A shortage in the occupation, the size of the industry and the petitioner's credentials do not establish national importance.
The Policy Manual sets the focus: "In determining national importance, the officer's analysis should focus on what the beneficiary will be doing rather than the specific occupational classification." It gives a negative example: "Endeavors such as classroom teaching, for example, without broader implications for a field or region, generally do not rise to the level of having national importance for the purpose of establishing eligibility for a national interest waiver."
Money is one route among several. Under the Policy Manual, "the potential to create a significant economic impact may be favorable but is not required," and "endeavors related to research, pure science, and the furtherance of human knowledge may qualify, whether or not the potential accomplishments in those fields are likely to translate into economic benefits for the United States."
The AAO decision of November 21, 2024 lists evidence that did not meet the prong. The national shortage of business professionals "is not, in and of itself, sufficient to establish the national importance of the Petitioner's endeavor." His credentials and experience in martial arts did not establish it either. The record did not "establish that the impact of the endeavor would extend beyond the Petitioner's clients and employees." The business plan placed the company in a HUBZone, yet "the Petitioner did not provide any evidence to establish that his business would operate in a HUBZone area or that it would be eligible to do so."
In the decision of March 7, 2024, the business plan projected eight jobs for U.S. workers. The AAO found that this "does not rise to the level" of significant potential to employ U.S. workers and that the record did not show "national or even global implications" within information technology. The AAO wrote that the question was the impact of the specific endeavor, and the importance of the IT industry did not answer it.
Letters from U.S. government bodies can count here. Under the Policy Manual, such letters "could prove favorable for purposes of the first prong if, for example, they establish that the agency or entity has expertise in the proposed endeavor and that the proposed STEM endeavor promises to advance a critical and emerging technology or is otherwise important for purposes of maintaining the United States' technological prominence."
What evidence answers the second prong?
Evidence about the person: degrees, a record of success, a plan, progress toward the endeavor and interest from customers, investors or agencies. Under the Policy Manual a degree in itself does not make a person well positioned.
The second prong concerns the person rather than the endeavor. The Policy Manual gives a list of evidence that "includes, but is not limited to" items such as these.
- The person holds degrees, certificates or licenses in the field.
- The person developed patents, trademarks or copyrights.
- Experts in the person's field write letters describing the person's past achievements.
- Published articles or media reports cover the person's achievements or current work.
- The person's work has a strong citation history or has influenced the field of endeavor.
- A plan describes how the person intends to continue the proposed work in the United States, and a detailed business plan comes with supporting evidence when appropriate.
- Prospective employers, clients or customers have written to the person.
- Documents show feasible plans for financial support, investment from U.S. investors, or awards and grants.
- Contracts, agreements or licenses show the potential impact of the proposed endeavor.
- Letters from U.S. government agencies or quasi-governmental entities speak to the person's position to advance the endeavor.
How much weight do a Ph.D. and government letters carry on the second prong?
A Ph.D. in a STEM field tied to the endeavor is an especially positive factor, though a degree alone is not enough. Detailed letters from interested government bodies are called valuable for this prong.
The Policy Manual says: "USCIS considers an advanced degree, particularly a Doctor of Philosophy (Ph.D.), in a STEM field tied to the proposed endeavor and related to work furthering a critical and emerging technology or other STEM area important to U.S. competitiveness or national security, an especially positive factor to be considered along with other evidence for purposes of the assessment under the second prong." The next sentence limits it: "A degree in and of itself, however, is not a basis to determine that a person is well positioned to advance the proposed endeavor."
On letters, the same chapter says that "Detailed letters of government or quasi-governmental interest that provide relevant information about how well-positioned the person is to advance the endeavor are valuable for purposes of assessing the second prong." For entrepreneurs it names other authors: "relevant government entities, outside investors, or established business associations" with knowledge of the research, products or services developed by the petitioner or the petitioner's entity, or of the petitioner's knowledge, skills or experience.
Evidence filed for the second prong does not repair the first. In a case about a planned Brazilian bakery in Florida, the petitioner filed a recommendation letter, a tax return and social media information with a combined motion. On April 22, 2024 the AAO noted the petitioner's own statement that this evidence related to the second prong, found that it did not support national importance under the first prong and dismissed both motions.
What evidence answers the third prong?
Facts showing that, on balance, waiving the job offer and labor certification benefits the United States: labor certification is impractical, the country benefits even if U.S. workers are available, or the work is urgent.
The Policy Manual lists the factors USCIS may weigh. The first three are the factors outlined in Matter of Dhanasar, and the next four are listed as more specific considerations.
- A labor certification application is impractical for the person or the employer.
- The United States benefits from the person's contributions even if other U.S. workers are available.
- The national interest in the person's contributions is sufficiently urgent.
- Urgency, such as public health or safety, warrants forgoing the labor certification process.
- The labor certification process may prevent an employer from hiring a person with unique knowledge or skills exceeding the minimum requirements for the occupation.
- The endeavor has the potential to generate considerable revenue, for example through economic revitalization.
- The endeavor may lead to potential job creation.
What counts as a strong positive factor on the third prong?
A combination of three facts in the record: an advanced STEM degree, particularly a Ph.D., work furthering a critical and emerging technology or another STEM area important to U.S. competitiveness, and a person well positioned to advance that endeavor.
The Policy Manual calls that combination "a strong positive factor" when the officer weighs whether the United States may benefit from the person's entry regardless of whether other U.S. workers are available. The three facts are linked: the third depends on the second prong, and the second depends on the endeavor described under the first.
Government bodies can also speak to this prong. The Policy Manual states that an interested government agency or quasi-governmental entity "can help explain how granting the waiver may outweigh the benefits of the job offer and labor certification requirement by explaining a particular urgency or detailing how the United States would benefit from the prospective alien's contributions, even if other U.S. workers are available."
The burden stays with the petitioner: "it is the petitioner's burden to establish that factors in favor of granting the waiver outweigh those that support the requirement of a job offer and thus a labor certification."
What should letters in the response say about each prong?
Each letter names the proposed endeavor in the words of the petition and states facts the author knows under the prong it supports. In a 2024 case, letters without information about the endeavor did not establish national importance.
In the November 21, 2024 case, the Director found that "the letters did not include information about the proposed endeavor or explain how it is nationally important." The AAO adopted and affirmed the Director's decision.
A letter filed with the response follows the order of the prongs. Under the first, the author describes the endeavor as the petition describes it and states facts about its reach beyond one employer or one client base, with a source for each figure. Under the second, the author writes about the petitioner's record, plan and progress, with dates, and points to the exhibit behind each fact. Under the third, the author states only what he or she can confirm, such as funding history or the urgency of the work. The author does not write that a prong is met, because the officer decides that.
The Policy Manual sets the limit for every letter: "unsubstantiated or implausible claims would not meet the petitioner's burden of proof." The point-by-point method for an expert letter in an RFE response is described in the guide Answering an RFE with an expert letter, point by point, and the evidence for each prong at filing in the guide Matter of Dhanasar: the three NIW prongs and the evidence for each.
Can the response describe a different endeavor?
No. Evidence in the response must establish eligibility as of the filing date, and a material change to the endeavor calls for a new petition. The response may clarify the original endeavor or make it more specific.
Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(1), the petitioner "must establish that he or she is eligible for the requested benefit at the time of filing the benefit request and must continue to be eligible through adjudication." Paragraph (b)(12) applies the same rule to RFE responses.
The AAO decision of April 6, 2023 concerned an NIW petitioner who first described the endeavor as work "as a Finance Director for U.S. companies, engaged in the Energy Industry, specifically Oil & Gas." The business plan filed with the RFE response described a plan "to create a company that will be specialized in offering Finance and Accounting Consulting Services." The AAO quoted Matter of Izummi, 22 I&N Dec. 169, 176 (Assoc. Comm'r 1998): "A petitioner may not make material changes to a petition in an effort to make a deficient petition conform to USCIS requirements." If significant, material changes are made, "a petitioner must file a new petition."
The AAO withdrew the decision and remanded it. The Director had to decide whether the evidence in the RFE response "1) clarified or provided more specificity to the proposed endeavor as initially described, or 2) presented a new set of facts regarding the proposed endeavor, which is material to eligibility for a national interest waiver," under Matter of Michelin Tire Corp., 17 I&N Dec. 248 (Reg'l Comm'r 1978).
An RFE that calls the endeavor vague is answered with more detail about the same endeavor: the projects, the users or clients, the region and the dates already set out in the petition.
What if the denial does not explain how the evidence was weighed?
The AAO can withdraw it. In 2024 it remanded two NIW denials that did not explain how the evidence led to the findings on the prongs. On remand the Director may issue a new RFE or NOID.
In the February 8, 2024 case, the Acting Director's decision "does not apply any factors to the Petitioner's evidence or explain why the evidence was insufficient." The AAO wrote that the Acting Director "did not adequately explain how the evidence in the record led to the determination," and added: "If appropriate, on remand the Director may issue a Request for Evidence or Notice of Intent to Deny."
On November 22, 2024 the AAO remanded the case of a nutrition researcher. The Director had accepted substantial merit and found national importance, the second prong and the third prong unproven. On the first prong the Director wrote that there was "no significant potential to employ U.S. workers," and the AAO found that the decision "provides no analysis explaining how the Director reached this determination." Exhibits 8 through 29 were not in the appellate record, so the AAO could not review them for the second prong, and it did not review the third prong at that stage.
The Policy Manual requires that a denial on the national interest "must include information about appeal rights and the opportunity to file a motion to reopen or reconsider." The choice between an appeal, a motion and a new petition is the subject of the article NIW denied after an RFE: appeal, motion or a new petition?
How does IAE answer an RFE on the Dhanasar prongs?
IAE prepares an expert opinion letter built on the text of the RFE, with a separate section for each finding in the expert's field. The standard turnaround is 5 business days, and the rush option takes 3.
The request on the RFE and NOID response page includes the text of the RFE or NOID, the petition and the supporting file. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day and checks the turnaround against the response deadline. Within one business day IAE confirms the fee, the turnaround and the expert in writing. The fee depends on the visa category and the volume of materials.
For EB-2 NIW the service page names the contested Dhanasar prong as the point the letter strengthens: merit and importance, the applicant's position, or the balance of interests. The letter runs up to 15 pages, with one section per finding and references to the evidence in the case file. Legal findings stay with the attorney. When the findings call for different specializations, a second expert joins at the assessment stage.
The secretariat prepares the draft from the client's documents. The expert checks it, makes changes and signs it, and revisions before signing are included. The draft goes to the attorney before signing. RFE and NOID orders go into a priority queue, and the 3-day rush term counts from payment and receipt of all materials.
The client receives a signed PDF with the expert's CV and a declaration of independence. The expert's record can be checked by Member ID or QR code on the status check page. IAE is not a law firm. The attorney prepares the response, the letter is one piece of evidence in it, and USCIS decides the petition.
Sources
- 8 CFR 103.2, Submission and adjudication of benefit requests (eCFR)
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 5, Advanced Degree or Exceptional Ability
- AAO non-precedent decision, I-140 national interest waiver, November 21, 2024
- AAO non-precedent decision, I-140 national interest waiver, November 22, 2024
- AAO non-precedent decision, I-140 national interest waiver, July 15, 2024
- AAO non-precedent decision, I-140 national interest waiver, April 22, 2024
- AAO non-precedent decision, I-140 national interest waiver, March 7, 2024
- AAO non-precedent decision, I-140 national interest waiver, February 8, 2024
- AAO non-precedent decision, I-140 exceptional ability and national interest waiver, September 11, 2023
- AAO non-precedent decision, I-140 national interest waiver, April 6, 2023
Read also
All articles
A second RFE after you responded: why does USCIS ask again, and how do you answer?
USCIS can send a second request for evidence on the same petition. Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8) it may deny, request more evidence or give notice of its
An H-1B RFE on a Level I wage: why does the wage level put the specialty occupation in question, and what evidence answers it?
A Level I wage on the labor condition application tells USCIS that the employer is paying an entry-level worker who performs routine tasks under
An EB-1A RFE on commercial success in the performing arts: what evidence answers it?
The tenth EB-1A criterion counts commercial successes in the performing arts, shown by box office receipts or record, cassette, compact disk or videoRFE and NOID responses
Received an RFE? We count the days with you.
The fee depends on the visa category and the volume of materials. We confirm the fee, the turnaround and the expert within one business day and check the turnaround against the response deadline.

