Examinations
Overlapping property lines: how does a surveyor map an overlap between two deeds, and which deed controls?
An overlap exists when two deeds describe the same strip of land. A surveyor finds it by plotting both descriptions on one map and computing the area each claims. Courts in Arkansas and Tennessee gave the strip to the older deed, a Maryland court restated the same rule, and an Arkansas court looked at notice when the older deed was recorded later. The surveyor maps the overlap; the court decides who owns it.

What is an overlap between property descriptions?
Two deeds or plats that both take in the same strip of land. The opposite case, land that neither description covers, is a gap. Both are found by plotting the descriptions of neighboring parcels together.
In Citizens Tri-County Bank v. Goodman, No. M2018-00958-COA-R3-CV, decided by the Court of Appeals of Tennessee on April 17, 2019, the court wrote that "The area in conflict is wooded and consists of approximately 17 acres" and that "the land taken in by the respective deeds of the parties creates a true overlap." Both chains of title ran back more than a century. Each side's surveyor located the client's deed lines, and the trial court found that both could "locate with good precision" the boundaries of their clients. Both surveyors measured with precision, and the deeds themselves took in the same land.
The 2021 Minimum Standard Detail Requirements for ALTA/NSPS Land Title Surveys, effective February 23, 2021, use the same terms. Section 6.B.vii requires the plat to show "The relationship of the boundaries of the surveyed property to its adjoiners (e.g., contiguity, gaps, overlaps)" where this can be determined from the record documents or from field evidence gathered during the fieldwork.
The overlaps in the cases discussed here differ in size. One was a 15-foot strip at the north end of two lake lots in Arkansas. Another was a narrow triangle 12.22 feet wide at its base between two lots carved out of a cotton field. Two Tennessee cases concerned about 17 acres each.
Why do two deeds end up describing the same land?
A grantor sold parcels out of one tract with descriptions that did not fit the ground, or a later surveyor stretched a description so that it would close. Reported Arkansas and Tennessee cases record both causes.
In Hughes v. Yates, 228 Ark. 860, 311 S.W.2d 179, decided by the Supreme Court of Arkansas on March 10, 1958, Ed Rogers owned an 800 by 400 foot cotton field east of Highway 61 near Blytheville. In 1948 he divided it into eight lots and sold them by metes and bounds, without recording a plat. He assumed the field was a perfect rectangle, but the government section line on the north ran about one degree south of due east, and a neighbor's fence stood on that line.
The Hughes deed, executed July 16, 1948 and recorded July 27, began by running "East along the South line of lot owned by Ada Tharpe Morgan." The Yates deed, executed August 6, 1948, described an exact rectangle running due east. The two descriptions overlapped in a narrow triangle between the lots.
In Slack v. Antwine, No. W2000-00961-COA-R3-CV, decided by the Court of Appeals of Tennessee on November 27, 2000, the overlap came from a survey. A surveyor working on the Lyons tract in 1992 found that its deed calls would not close and made them "fit" as best he could. His description enlarged the tract, which had been about 97 acres, to 115.62 acres and took about 17 acres off the neighboring Williams tract. The surveyors for the Williams family closed the Williams deed by tying its calls to old hedgerows and fences on three sides.
Section 3.E.ii of the ALTA/NSPS standards lists four sources of uncertainty in a retraced boundary: the availability, condition, history and integrity of reference or controlling monuments; ambiguities in the record descriptions or plats of the surveyed property or its adjoiners; occupation or possession lines that differ from the written title lines; and relative positional precision.
How does a surveyor map an overlap?
The surveyor collects the deeds and plats of both parcels, finds the monuments on the ground, plots each description on one map and computes the area that both descriptions claim, along with any gap.
Record research comes first. Under section 4.C.i of the ALTA/NSPS standards the surveyor is to be provided with the current record descriptions of adjoiners, except where the adjoiners are lots in platted, recorded subdivisions. Each chain of title is traced back to the common grantor, if there is one, because the order of the conveyances decides the legal question that follows.
Field work follows. The surveyor searches for the monuments called for in each deed, measures them and compares measured bearings and distances with the calls. Section 5.C.i of the standards requires evidence of possession or occupation along the perimeter to be located, "both by the occupants of the surveyed property and by adjoiners." Section 5.C.ii covers walls, buildings, fences and other improvements within five feet of each boundary line.
Each description is then plotted. If both close and still take in the same strip, the deeds overlap. If a description does not close, the surveyor records the misclosure and the calls that cause it. Section 6.B.iii requires the record dimension to be shown next to any measured or calculated dimension that differs significantly, and section 6.B.viii requires notes that explain significant differences or a fundamental boundary decision that the plat does not make clear.
Where the surveyed property is made up of several parcels, section 6.B.vii requires the extent of any gaps or overlaps between them to be identified. It adds: "Where gaps or overlaps are identified, the surveyor must, prior to or upon delivery of the final plat or map, disclose this to the insurer and client."
Which deed controls when two descriptions overlap?
Usually the older one. Courts in Arkansas and Tennessee gave the overlap to the prior deed, and a Maryland court restated that a prior deed takes precedence and that the first grantee does not contribute to the shortage.
In Hughes v. Yates the Supreme Court of Arkansas, in an opinion by Justice George Rose Smith, held that the Hughes deed, executed and recorded first, controlled: "its description is controlling if the two descriptions overlap." It read the first Hughes call as following the neighbor's fence, because "courses must yield to natural or artificial monuments," reversed the chancellor and remanded for a decree confirming the Hughes title to the triangle. Justice McFaddin dissented and would have split the 12.22-foot shortage between the lots, two-thirds to Hughes and one-third to Yates.
The Court of Special Appeals of Maryland took up the same rule in Millar v. Bowie, No. 1454, September Term 1996, filed June 2, 1997. The owner of Evergreen Farm deeded the eastern parcel to Jean Koehn in January 1961 and sold the remainder, excepting that parcel, by a deed dated January 31, 1962. The court restated that "a prior deed takes precedence over a subsequent deed in a dispute arising as to the boundary lines between adjoining tracts" and that "the one claiming under the common grantor's first deed is not required to contribute to the shortage." It construed only the 1961 deed and affirmed the straight-line boundary that the Bowies, who held under the 1962 deed, had advocated.
In Slack v. Antwine the Court of Appeals of Tennessee wrote: "Where there is a conflict, an older grant or deed will prevail over a younger grant or deed." The chancellor had found the Williams deed senior by more than 40 years and the encroachment about 17.34 acres, and the appellate court affirmed. In Citizens Tri-County Bank v. Goodman the same court relied on that rule in 2019 and affirmed a judgment for the owners whose chain of title went back farther and whose boundary description had been "so tight over all these many years."
When does the older deed not take the whole overlap?
When the older deed was recorded later and the junior buyer took without notice of it, or when lots were sold by reference to an erroneous plat. Arkansas courts discussed both limits.
In Rice v. Welch Motor Co., 95 Ark. App. 100, 234 S.W.3d 327, decided by the Court of Appeals of Arkansas on April 19, 2006, two 1930s conveyances from the same grantor "overlap by fifteen feet on their northern ends," in a valley running down to a lake cove. The older Glover deed, a duplicate of a 1934 deed, was recorded in 1939. The younger Rhodes deed had been recorded in 1936. The court stated the general rule that an unrecorded instrument is not valid against a later purchaser without actual notice, and that a purchaser with actual notice of a prior unrecorded deed takes subject to it.
The notice came from the junior deed itself. Its call ran "110 feet to center of the valley to the D.D. Glover lot corner." The court concluded that "Rhodes was thus notified that the property adjacent to his had been conveyed to Glover" and upheld the ruling that "the Glover deed, although recorded later, took priority." Whether a buyer had notice is a question of fact.
Hughes v. Yates limited apportionment of a shortage among lots. Quoting an earlier case, the court said the apportionment rule "is only to be availed of when the land is conveyed by reference to a plan." Rogers had recorded no plat, so the older Hughes deed took the whole triangle.
Adverse possession is a separate claim that can move the line. In Rice the claimants had to show possession for more than seven years that was visible, notorious, distinct, exclusive, hostile and intended to hold against the true owner. The court noted evidence that their use may have been permissive rather than adverse and deferred to the trial judge's finding that adverse possession was not proven. The chancellor in Hughes rejected an adverse possession claim, the chancellor in Slack found that none had been raised or proven, and neither side in Citizens Tri-County Bank pursued one.
Does the surveyor decide who owns the overlap?
No. The surveyor locates and measures, and the court decides title. The ALTA/NSPS standards locate potential encroachments without a legal opinion on ownership, and an Arkansas court called a surveyor's credibility a question for the fact-finder.
Section 5.C.iii of the 2021 standards opens with the words "Without expressing a legal opinion as to the ownership or nature of the potential encroachment" and then requires the surveyor to locate the evidence, location and extent of potentially encroaching appurtenances and projections by or onto adjoining property. Section 5.B.v uses the same approach for driveways, alleys and other access from adjoining properties.
In Rice the trial judge heard more than a dozen witnesses, viewed more than twenty exhibits, visited the property and quieted title to the strip according to one side's survey. The Court of Appeals of Arkansas held that "The credibility of a surveyor is a question for the fact-finder" and accepted the finding that the surveyor made "a studied and commendable effort at establishing the parties' true boundaries." The court also held that a quiet title judgment must describe the boundary specifically.
A later survey cannot redraw an older deed. In Millar v. Bowie the court cited an earlier Maryland decision for the point that one surveyor's interpretation producing "a tidier or neater package" "does not suffice, of itself, to override the intent of the original surveyor." Slack v. Antwine cited Woodfolk v. Cornwell for the rule that "A party may not, by an ex parte survey and marking of lines," fix a boundary other than the one the deed calls for.
Which calls in a deed control when they conflict?
Natural objects first, then artificial monuments, then adjoining owners' lines, and courses and distances last, in the order a Tennessee court applied. Acreage matters mainly where the boundary is in doubt.
In Slack v. Antwine the court quoted Thornburg v. Chase: "resort is to be had first to natural objects or landmarks." Artificial monuments come next, then the lines of adjoining landowners, and courses and distances last. The court added that the calls with the least probability of mistake prevail, and that boundaries "are not usually delineated by the quantity or acreage," although "where boundaries are in doubt, the quantity may become an important factor."
In Hughes v. Yates the neighbor's fence was the monument that bent the Hughes call off due east. In Rice the junior deed's call ended at the senior owner's lot corner, and that call gave the junior buyer notice. In Millar v. Bowie the court read a particular call ahead of a general one: the deed ran "in a straight line" along a driveway and hedgerow and then "continuing in the same straight line and with an old fence line" to Island Creek, and the court treated the fence reference as a general description of the area.
Calls can be run backward to test a description. Millar quoted the rule that "the calls may be reversed and the lines run in the opposite direction," and then rejected a 1993 plat run in reverse from Island Creek because "the survey does not end at the point of beginning, i.e., it does not close correctly." An overlap report that states which call each line follows, and the closure of each run, gives the court the data to apply its own order of calls.
Which records and testimony prove an overlap in court?
In federal court, recorded deeds and plats come in under hearsay exceptions 803(14) and 803(15), community reputation about boundaries under 803(20), and the surveyor's opinions through a written report under Rule 26(a)(2)(B).
Rule 803(14) covers the record of a document that purports to establish or affect an interest in property, offered to prove the content of the original and its signing and delivery, if the record is kept in a public office and a statute authorizes recording documents of that kind there. Rule 803(15) covers a statement in such a document if it relates to the document's purpose, unless later dealings with the property are inconsistent with it. Rule 803(20) admits a reputation in a community, arising before the controversy, concerning boundaries of land in the community; the advisory committee note says "The reputation is required to antedate the controversy, though not to be ancient."
Under Rule 26(a)(2)(B) a retained surveyor's report states every opinion with its basis and reasons, the facts or data considered, the exhibits that will summarize or support the opinions, the surveyor's qualifications with publications from the previous 10 years, the cases in the previous 4 years in which the surveyor testified, and the compensation. A report that only contradicts or rebuts the other side's expert evidence on the same subject is due "within 30 days after the other party's disclosure" under Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii), absent a stipulation or court order.
Rule 34(a)(2) lets a party request entry onto designated land the other party possesses or controls to inspect, measure, survey, photograph, test or sample it. The request must specify a reasonable time, place and manner, and the written response is due within 30 days after service. Under Rule 34(c) a nonparty can be compelled to permit an inspection through a Rule 45 subpoena.
What does IAE prepare when two deeds overlap?
For boundary, quiet title and encroachment cases in US courts, IAE prepares an expert report on the client's questions and a review of the opposing surveyor's report, in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.
The surveyor collects deeds, recorded plats and original field notes for the parcel and its neighbors, searches for the original monuments, measures with GNSS and a total station, and compares measured bearings and distances with the calls in each deed. Both parties' descriptions are plotted on one map; the surveyor computes the area of each overlap or gap and locates fences, driveways and buildings relative to the line. Each question is answered from the record documents and the field survey, as agreed with the client.
The client sends the deeds, plats and any prior surveys with the request. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. For cases with tight deadlines there is a 48-hour rush.
The specialist is a member of the public IAE registry, can be verified by Member ID or QR code and confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. Materials go through the contact form or to info@iaexperts.com and are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. A report is evidence that the court weighs with the rest of the record. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy; which deed controls and whether to sue to quiet title are questions for the client's attorney.
Sources
- Hughes v. Yates, 228 Ark. 860, 311 S.W.2d 179 (Ark. 1958)
- Rice v. Welch Motor Co., 95 Ark. App. 100, 234 S.W.3d 327 (Ark. Ct. App. 2006)
- Millar v. Bowie, No. 1454, September Term 1996 (Md. Ct. Spec. App. June 2, 1997)
- Slack v. Antwine, No. W2000-00961-COA-R3-CV (Tenn. Ct. App. Nov. 27, 2000)
- Citizens Tri-County Bank v. Goodman, No. M2018-00958-COA-R3-CV (Tenn. Ct. App. Apr. 17, 2019)
- Minimum Standard Detail Requirements for ALTA/NSPS Land Title Surveys, effective February 23, 2021
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 803 (Cornell LII)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26, Duty to Disclose; General Provisions Governing Discovery (Cornell LII)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 34 (Cornell LII)
Read also
All articles
Neighbor removed the survey markers: is it illegal, who pays to reset them, and what does the surveyor document?
A survey is finished, the corners are pinned, and a week later the pins are gone. In Washington intentionally disturbing a survey monument is a gross
Tree on the property line: who owns it, and how does a surveyor show where the trunk stands?
In California ownership of a tree follows its trunk: a tree whose trunk stands wholly on one lot belongs to that owner, and a tree whose trunk stands
Road right of way and the property line: where does the public road end and my lot begin?
Where a lot meets a public road, the line is the edge of the right of way or a line the deed sets, not the edge of the pavement. In Florida a roadExpert examinations
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

