Examinations
Parental alienation claims: how does a custody evaluator test them?
When one parent says the other turned the child against them, the court can turn to a psychologist to sort out why the child refuses contact. The 2022 APA custody guidelines state that refusal "is not necessarily a byproduct" of a parent's malicious influence, "but this dynamic can occur." The evaluator tests several explanations, screens for family violence and reports which explanation the data support.

What does a parental alienation claim allege?
That one parent's words or conduct caused the child to resist or reject the other parent. The APA custody guidelines use the terms "alienating behaviors or parent-child contact problems" and call the concept complex and multifactorial.
The American Psychological Association adopted its Guidelines for Child Custody Evaluations in Family Law Proceedings in February 2022, and they are scheduled to expire 10 years later. Their terminology section lists the terms under which such problems may be subsumed: "resist-refusal dynamics, alienating behaviors, domestic violence and/or child abuse, restrictive gatekeeping, and parental alienation, among others." The guidelines themselves use "alienating behaviors or parent-child contact problems" and describe the concept as "a complex and multifactorial one."
A claim of this kind has three parts. The first is conduct of the favored parent: disparaging remarks, missed exchanges, withheld school or medical information. The second is a change in the child: refused visits, adult complaints repeated by a young child, contact cut off. The third is the remedy the parent asks for, such as more parenting time, a change of custody, therapy or an order restraining the other parent. The psychologist is asked about the link between the first part and the second.
Guideline 5 states the starting point. Resisting or rejecting contact with a parent "is not necessarily a byproduct of the malicious influence of a parent whom intends to undercut the parent-child relationship," the guideline says, "but this dynamic can occur." The evaluator therefore treats the refusal as a fact to be explained and alienation as one of the possible explanations.
Is parental alienation a recognized diagnosis?
Not in the 2022 APA custody guidelines, which speak of alienating behaviors and call the concept complex and multifactorial. In Zafran v. Zafran (2002) a New York court noted that parental alienation syndrome was not listed in the DSM-IV.
Zafran v. Zafran was decided by the Supreme Court of New York, Nassau County, on March 14, 2002. The defendant wanted to present expert testimony on parental alienation syndrome. Justice Robert A. Ross wrote that "no cases in New York have been found to permit admission of expert testimony concerning 'PAS'" and noted that the syndrome is not listed in the DSM-IV. He did not decide admissibility on the papers. He allowed the defendant to proceed with a Frye-type hearing before trial to establish whether the testimony was admissible.
Sixteen years later, in J.F. v. D.F. (2018), another New York court wrote that "there is no doubt that parental alienation exists." The sentence follows the court's account of misgivings expressed by other judges, among them a Maryland concurrence that warned against using "parental alienation" casually or as if it were an established diagnosis and called for a Frye-Reed hearing before such diagnoses are admitted. The court then set out a legal test made of elements that each had to be proved by evidence.
Reem Alsalem, the United Nations Special Rapporteur on violence against women and girls, went further. Her report to the Human Rights Council dated April 13, 2023 (A/HRC/53/36) recommended that states "legislate to prohibit the use of parental alienation or related pseudo-concepts in family law cases and the use of so-called experts in parental alienation and related pseudo-concepts." The report states that there is "no commonly accepted clinical or scientific definition" of parental alienation. It binds no court in the United States.
An evaluator who follows the APA terminology reports the specific behaviors of each parent, the child's reactions and the evidence for each of them. A court can test such findings against the record, and a label without them gives the court nothing to test.
How does a custody evaluator test an alienation claim?
By checking several explanations for the child's refusal against the data. APA Guideline 5 states that psychologists "strive to evaluate hypotheses when assessing a case of resistance-refusal" and lists causes that lie with each parent and with the child.
The commentary to Guideline 5 lists factors "found to influence the alignment of the child with one parent and showing a negative reaction against the other." They include "having been abused, neglected, or poorly parented by the rejected parent," "having witnessed domestic violence," "responding to the high-conflict custody litigation," "reacting to the custody evaluation" and "having a preexisting preference for one parent over the other, among other reasons." Influence by the favored parent is one entry on that list.
Each explanation predicts different data. If the rejected parent was harsh or neglectful, the child names specific events, and school, medical or police records may date them. If the child is reacting to the litigation, the refusal may begin with the filing or with the evaluation itself. If the favored parent shaped the child's view, the child's complaints may repeat that parent's wording, and the refusal may follow events in that parent's household. The report sets out which data support and which contradict each explanation.
Guideline 11 adds a check on the evaluator. It states that custody evaluators "may have overt or unacknowledged opinions about some topics such as alienation, gender, family dynamics, victim credibility or behavior, or high-conflict families," and that "cognitive, confirmatory, implicit, or other biases may compromise a custody evaluation."
California writes the same check into its court rules. Rule 5.220(j)(1) requires court-ordered evaluators to "maintain objectivity, provide and gather balanced information for both parties, and control for bias," and Rule 5.220(f)(1) requires the report to "present all relevant information, including information that does not support the conclusions reached."
Why does the evaluator screen for family violence before weighing alienation?
Because the same refusal can come from abuse. The APA guidelines note that alienating behaviors are sometimes alleged "in an attempt to deflect allegations of domestic violence and/or child abuse," and Guideline 15 calls for screening.
Guideline 15 reads: "Psychologists endeavor to conduct appropriate screening for family violence, child maltreatment, intimate partner violence, and resultant trauma." Its rationale states that "separation, custody disputes, and renewed parent-child contact may generate or increase risks of violence." Guideline 5 lists "child maltreatment including alienating behaviors" among the high-risk issues that call for specialized competence and refers to Guideline 15.
Guideline 5 also contains the sentence that sets the order of work: "Alienating behaviors are sometimes alleged by one party in an attempt to deflect allegations of domestic violence and/or child abuse made by another party." An evaluation that examines the alienation claim and leaves the abuse allegation unexamined has tested one of two competing accounts.
In California the screening is part of the court rules. Rule 5.220(e)(2)(C) has the evaluator interview the parents, jointly or separately "unless contraindicated in cases involving domestic violence," and assess, among other things, the "history of child abuse, domestic violence, substance abuse, and psychiatric illness." Rule 5.230 requires persons appointed as child custody investigators under Family Code section 3110 or Evidence Code section 730 to complete basic domestic violence training, then 16 hours of advanced training within a 12-month period, and 4 hours of update training each year after that.
What does federal law say about experts in custody cases with abuse allegations?
Since 2022, 34 U.S.C. 10446(k) gives a grant increase to states whose laws admit expert evidence on alleged abuse only from professionals whose clinical experience with victims is "not solely of a forensic nature."
Subsection (k) was added by section 1504 of Division W of Public Law 117-103, enacted on March 15, 2022; the findings for the provision are in section 1502 of title XV of the same division. A state qualifies when it has a law under which, in a custody proceeding where a parent is alleged to have committed domestic violence or child abuse, "expert evidence from a court-appointed or outside professional relating to the alleged abuse may be admitted only if" the professional has expertise and clinical experience in working with victims of domestic violence or child abuse, "not solely of a forensic nature." The same law must require the court to consider protection orders, arrests and convictions of the accused parent for domestic violence, sexual violence or child abuse.
Other conditions concern the court. A qualifying state's courts may not order reunification treatment "unless there is generally accepted and scientifically valid proof of the safety, effectiveness, and therapeutic value" of the treatment. Judges who hear custody cases and court personnel, among them custody evaluators, guardians ad litem and mediators, must receive "not less than 20 hours of initial training" and "not less than 15 hours of ongoing training every 5 years" on domestic and sexual violence and child abuse. The grant increase is up to 10 percent of the average of the state's three most recent awards, and Congress authorized $5,000,000 for each of fiscal years 2023 through 2027.
Congress stated its reasons in findings printed as a note to the section. Finding 6 says that in cases "in which an allegedly abusive parent claimed the mother 'alienated' the child, courts believed only 1 out of 51 claims of sexual molestation by a father." Finding 9 says that "many experts who testify against abuse allegations lack expertise in the relevant type of alleged abuse, relying instead on unsound and unproven theories." The statute does not ban alienation evidence. It ties federal money to state rules on who may give expert evidence about alleged abuse.
What data does the evaluator collect in an alienation case?
Interviews with each parent and the child, observation of the child with each parent, tests, records and corroborating information. APA Guideline 18 asks for observation of parent-child interactions, and Guideline 19 for data sufficient to support the conclusions.
California's Rule 5.220(e)(2) requires data collection that lets the evaluator "observe and consider each party in comparable ways." The process may include reviewing pertinent documents, "including local police records"; observing parent-child interaction "unless contraindicated to protect the best interest of the child"; interviewing the parents; age-appropriate interviews and observation with the children; and "collecting relevant corroborating information or documents as permitted by law." APA Guideline 10 asks for an "evidence-based, multimethod, and multitrait assessment format," Guideline 18 for "an observation of parent-child interactions" and Guideline 19 for data sufficient "to address the scope of the evaluation."
In an alienation case the observation that answers the claim is the child with the rejected parent: whether the child engages, how the child responds when that parent approaches, and whether the behavior in the session matches what the child says in interview. A 2022 study by Farit Safuanov and nine co-authors, published in the Russian journal Psychology and Law, tested such joint-task sessions with 66 children aged 4 to 15 examined in comprehensive forensic psychological and psychiatric evaluations in residence and contact disputes; 28 of them were assessed as influenced by a parent. In sessions with the separately living parent, the indicators correctly identified 23 of those 28 children (82.14 percent) at the 0.05 level, and one child (3.57 percent) was misclassified as not influenced. The authors wrote that the method has only relative value for showing that a child was not influenced, because a negative attitude toward a parent can have other causes, and that it still needs testing on an independent sample.
Records date the events on which each explanation depends: school attendance and teacher notes, pediatric and therapy records, messages between the parents, the log of scheduled and missed exchanges, police reports and protection orders. Under 34 U.S.C. 10446(k)(3)(A)(ii), a qualifying state's courts must consider past or current protection orders, arrests and convictions of the accused parent when they decide an abuse allegation.
How have courts weighed parental alienation testimony?
On the evidence behind each alleged behavior. In J.F. v. D.F. (2018) a New York court weighed the testimony of three experts for the father, none of whom had talked to the children, and found alienation not proved.
J.F. v. D.F., 2018 NY Slip Op 51829(U), was decided on December 6, 2018 by the Supreme Court of New York, Monroe County, Justice Dollinger. The parents had three daughters, aged 15, 13 and 7. Three experts testified for the father: Dr. Amy Baker, who listed 17 alleged alienating behaviors; social worker Linda Gottlieb; and Robert Evans, who found a "moderate level" of alienation. The mother called Dr. Peter Favaro, who criticized their methodology. The court recorded that "none of the proffered experts ever interviewed or talked to any of the three daughters."
The court defined alienation by analogy with the tort of intentional infliction of emotional distress, in four elements: "(i) extreme and outrageous conduct; (ii) intent to cause, or disregard of a substantial probability of causing" it, "(iii) a causal connection between the alienating conduct and the child's rejection of a parent" and "(iv) severe parental alienation." It then took the alleged behaviors one at a time. Some conduct was proved, among it violations of the joint custody terms, withholding medical information and discussing the father's girlfriend and the court proceedings. The court found that none of it established alienation, mainly because the father did not show that it caused the daughters to reject him.
The court wrote that it "substantially credits Dr. Favaro's insights regarding the methodology of the father's experts" and that their testimony "fails to prove by the preponderance of the credible evidence that alienation exists." It dismissed the father's claim for a change of custody based on alienation and kept joint custody. It found that the breakdown in the parents' communication was a change in circumstances, but declined to modify the schedule in the parents' agreement.
The decision lists what the court looked for in the expert evidence: contact with the children, a specific behavior behind each allegation, and a causal link between that behavior and the children's views.
Can a court order reunification treatment after an alienation finding?
That depends on the state. California Family Code 3193, added in 2023, bars court-ordered reunification programs that require a no-contact order, a custody transfer, multiday or out-of-state stays, or forced transport of the child.
Senate Bill 331, Chapter 865 of the Statutes of 2023, was approved by the Governor on October 13, 2023 and added section 3193 to the Family Code. Under it a court "shall not order family reunification treatments, programs, or services, including, but not limited to, camps, workshops, therapeutic vacations, or educational programs that, as a condition of enrollment or participation, require or result in" any of five conditions: a no-contact order; an overnight, out-of-state or multiday stay; a transfer of physical or legal custody of the child; private youth transporters who use force, threat of force or physical obstruction; or threats of force, undue coercion, verbal abuse or isolation of the child from family and community.
Section 2 of the bill refers to programs used "to address, repair, or remediate the relationship with the other parent whom the child is rejecting or resisting." The same bill amended Government Code section 68555, which covers training for judicial officers, referees and commissioners and, if employed by the court, guardians ad litem, custody evaluators, mediators and child custody recommending counselors; the listed topics include child sexual abuse, coercive control and implicit and explicit bias related to parties in domestic violence cases.
The federal conditions in 34 U.S.C. 10446(k)(3)(B) point the same way. A qualifying state's courts may not, "solely in order to improve a deficient relationship with the other parent," remove a child from a parent who is competent, protective and not physically or sexually abusive and to whom the child is bonded or attached. Before an order requires the other parent to act, any order to remediate a child's resistance to a violent or abusive parent must primarily address "the behavior of that parent or the contributions of that parent to the resistance of the child." A recommendation on remedies therefore starts from the evaluator's finding on abuse.
Can each parent bring a psychologist on the alienation question?
Parents do: in J.F. v. D.F. the father called three experts and the mother one. California Rule 5.220(j)(3) bars a court-ordered evaluator from recommendations about a party not evaluated directly or in consultation with another qualified neutral professional.
A psychologist retained by one parent in an alienation dispute can do two kinds of work. One is an evaluation of the client and, where the court permits, of the child. The other is an analysis of the court-appointed evaluator's file and report: which explanations were tested, whether family violence was screened, whether the child was observed with the rejected parent, and whether each conclusion is tied to data.
Limits on opinions without examination apply to both kinds of work. Rule 5.220(j)(3) says a court-ordered evaluator must not "offer any recommendations about a party unless that party has been evaluated directly or in consultation with another qualified neutral professional," and Rule 5.220(f)(3) says to "only make a custody or visitation recommendation for a party who has been evaluated." In J.F. v. D.F. the father's experts testified about the daughters without having talked to them, and the court credited the mother's expert on their method.
The court weighs both psychologists' reports with the rest of the record. In J.F. v. D.F. the court did not exclude alienation testimony as a category. It held that the testimony offered did not prove the elements on that record.
What does IAE do in a custody case with an alienation claim?
A psychologist from the IAE registry writes an expert report on the client's questions in a child custody or parenting time dispute. Delivery takes up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.
IAE's forensic psychological service covers child custody and parenting time, decision-making capacity in contract and will disputes, and emotional distress claims in civil cases. A psychologist from the IAE registry writes an expert report on the client's questions or a review of the opposing psychologist's evaluation. IAE frames the questions from the pleadings, the records and the opposing evaluator's report and confirms them with the client before work starts.
The client sends the materials and describes the task. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, with a 48-hour rush for cases with tight deadlines.
Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry. The Member ID in the document or the QR code opens the specialist's category, specialization, attestation date and record status. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case, and materials are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. The court weighs the report with the rest of the evidence. Neither IAE nor the psychologist guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.
Sources
- American Psychological Association. Guidelines for Child Custody Evaluations in Family Law Proceedings, adopted as association policy in February 2022
- 34 U.S.C. 10446, subsection (k), added by Pub. L. 117-103, div. W, sec. 1504 (March 15, 2022), with findings note (sec. 1502)
- California Senate Bill 331 (2023), Chapter 865, Statutes of 2023: Family Code section 3193, Government Code sections 68555 and 68555.5
- California Rules of Court, rule 5.220, Uniform standards of practice for court-ordered child custody evaluations
- California Rules of Court, rule 5.230, Domestic violence training standards for court-appointed child custody investigators and evaluators
- J.F. v. D.F., 2018 NY Slip Op 51829(U), Supreme Court, Monroe County, December 6, 2018
- Zafran v. Zafran, Supreme Court of New York, Nassau County, March 14, 2002
- Report of the Special Rapporteur on violence against women and girls, its causes and consequences, Reem Alsalem: Custody, violence against women and violence against children, A/HRC/53/36, April 13, 2023
- Safuanov F.S., Savina O.F., Morozova M.V. et al. Child-parent interaction: forensic psychological expert assessments. Psychology and Law, 2022, vol. 12, no. 1, pp. 115-132. DOI 10.17759/psylaw.2022120110 (in Russian)
Read also
All articles
Undue influence expert witness: what can a psychologist assess in a will, trust or contract dispute?
In California a will, or a part of one, is ineffective to the extent undue influence procured it, and that claim is separate from a claim that
Capacity evaluation for guardianship: who examines the person, and what must the report contain?
Before a court appoints a guardian for an adult, professionals examine the person and report on which rights he or she can still exercise. Florida
Supervised visitation: when does a court order it, and what does a psychologist assess?
A court orders supervised visitation when contact with a parent is in the child's interest but carries a risk that a neutral third person can manageExpert examinations
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

