Examinations

How do you prepare for a custody evaluation?

A parent prepares for a custody evaluation by reading the evaluator's consent document, collecting the records the evaluator will ask for, naming people who have seen the parent with the child, and keeping the child out of the dispute. The 2022 APA guidelines for child custody evaluations set what a psychologist explains and collects. A brochure of the Association of Family and Conciliation Courts and an ABA Family Advocate article describe the parent's side.

A parent from behind waits with a blank clipboard and a child's coat on the next chair

What will the evaluator explain before the first appointment?

The procedures, timelines, fees, release of records, who receives the report and the limits of confidentiality. APA Guideline 7 asks psychologists to have every capable adult taking part sign an informed consent form.

The American Psychological Association adopted its Guidelines for Child Custody Evaluations in Family Law Proceedings as association policy in February 2022. The document contains 23 guidelines and is scheduled to expire 10 years from February 2022. Guideline 7 reads: "Psychologists strive to obtain informed consent when this is both feasible and appropriate." The commentary asks psychologists to have all capable adults participating in the evaluation sign an informed consent form. When a court orders the evaluation, consent may not be required, and the guideline then encourages psychologists to seek the parties' assent.

The consent discussion covers "expectations regarding parent-child communications about interviews, timelines, interpretive sessions, fees," the release of records, who "owns" the report and "with whom information may be shared." The same guideline tells parents what not to expect: "There is likely no privileged information or communication in a child custody evaluation." Written and oral communications relevant to the evaluation go to the court and to each party's counsel.

Philip Stahl and Rebecca Stahl describe the same step in "Preparing Your Client for a Custody Evaluation" in the ABA's Family Advocate. The evaluator gives "a written document, often referred to as an informed consent document or statement of understanding," explains the procedures for gathering collateral documents and explains "who will have access to the report if one is written."

The parent reads this document before the first interview and brings questions about it. The AFCC brochure for parents puts it as a task: "Make notes of the questions you want to ask."

Which records should a parent gather?

Records about the child and the parent's care: school, medical and mental health treatment records, and documents from the court file. Evaluators may ask for written consent to obtain records straight from the school, doctor or agency.

APA Guideline 8 reads: "Psychologists aspire to identify, request, and review relevant records." The commentary names "Information from children's medical, educational, mental health treatment, and other relevant records" and mentions "particularly sensitive information, such as child protective service documentation." Psychologists "strive to identify in a timely manner which records should be reviewed."

The Association of Family and Conciliation Courts published "Preparing for your Custody Evaluation" for parents. AFCC members Phil Bushard and Dorothy Howard prepared it in 1992, and it was revised in 2003. It tells parents: "Organize school and health records, and other information that the evaluator asks to review." It also warns that the evaluator "may request your written consent to obtain school and health records, social service and police information."

Stahl and Stahl list "school records, therapy information" and "a list of collateral witnesses" among the things parents gather, and add "supporting documents and records from the court file or elsewhere." Report cards, attendance records, summaries of pediatric visits, the names of the child's doctors and therapists, prior court orders and any protective orders belong in that set. A parent who keeps them in one folder can sign releases at the first meeting and answer questions about dates.

Whom should a parent name as collateral sources?

People who have seen the parent and child together: teachers, pediatricians, extended family members, childcare providers. APA asks evaluators to focus on what each source observed directly and on the factual basis of any opinion.

APA Guideline 13 says psychologists "seek to identify and interview collateral sources who can best help them understand the child's needs." Such sources "may include teachers, pediatricians, extended family members, childcare providers." In the interview the psychologist focuses on "the collateral source's direct observations and the factual basis for any opinions expressed."

Under that test a friend who has heard only the parent's account adds little. A teacher who sees which parent brings the child to school and attends conferences, or a pediatrician who knows who comes to appointments, reports what he or she saw. The parent gives the evaluator names, roles, phone numbers and the period during which each person saw the family.

The AFCC brochure says the evaluator "may interview other people in the children's lives, including stepparents or domestic partners." A new partner who lives with the child falls within that description.

APA Guideline 11 links fairness to equal treatment: evaluators "utilize the same assessment techniques for all parties when both feasible and reasonable." The commentary applies this to the pursuit of collateral sources, so both parents' lists are expected to be followed up in comparable ways.

How should a parent answer the evaluator's questions?

With specific examples and the reason each one worries the parent. Evaluators ask each parent about the other parent's allegations, and APA asks them to watch for impression management in parent interviews.

APA Guideline 14 reads: "Psychologists strive to interview the parents to assess functional parenting strengths, weaknesses, skills." The commentary says psychologists "try to be aware of parental impression management during interviews."

Stahl and Stahl describe follow-up interviews: "Evaluators often ask each parent about the statements and allegations made by the other parent." They add: "These are not meant to be gotcha moments, and they do not indicate the evaluator believes one parent over another." Their advice is to give "Specific examples with an explanation about why the situation worries the client" and to "avoid defensiveness, stay focused on the needs of the children."

The AFCC brochure tells parents: "Separate your marriage problems from your parenting concerns." It also says: "Plan to be open and honest with the evaluator." It says parents should "expect to talk to the evaluator alone and with the other parent," and lists "Conferences with both parents, when determined by the evaluator to be appropriate."

If the parents settle during the evaluation, the same brochure says: "Inform the evaluator immediately if you and the other parent reach an agreement."

Can a parent prepare for psychological testing?

Not by rehearsing the tests. Stahl and Stahl write that going over the potential tests with the parent would most likely be considered unethical and that the parent should answer truthfully without trying to fake the results.

The AFCC brochure says testing may be required when information about each parent's emotional and mental status is helpful to the judge, and that the psychologist "may administer several paper and pencil tests." APA Guideline 9 adds that "psychological tests are typically not used in isolation, but are part of a comprehensive assessment."

Stahl and Stahl write that testing "should only be used to generate hypotheses about the persons involved." On preparation they are direct: "going over the potential tests with the litigant parent would most likely be considered unethical." Counsel should "simply encourage your client to answer items in the testing truthfully and to avoid trying to fake the testing."

APA Guideline 17 asks psychologists to "be aware of normative data for divorced parents" and to "delegate testing only to those persons who can competently perform these services." Under Guideline 11 the same techniques are used for both parties when feasible and reasonable, so each parent takes a comparable set of measures.

Children are tested less often. Under Guideline 13 testing of a child "may not be necessary or appropriate if such testing does not help elucidate the best interests of the child."

What should a parent tell the child about the evaluation?

What the evaluator's instructions allow. APA Guideline 1 asks psychologists to instruct caregivers at the start about parent-child communications on interviews, and AFCC tells parents not to ask children to choose between them.

APA Guideline 1 says psychologists "strive to provide instructions to caregivers at the beginning of the evaluation" "as to appropriate parent-child communications about interviews." The commentary explains the reason: parents in an evaluation may draw children into their conflicts, and a child's expressed preference can be shaped by "manipulation and/or undue influence by a parent."

Under Guideline 7 the psychologist also explains the evaluation to the child: "Psychologists aspire to give children an age-appropriate explanation of the purpose of the evaluation." A parent who gives the child a second, different explanation, or asks afterwards what the child said, works against those instructions.

The AFCC brochure describes what the child will meet. "Custody evaluators regularly interview and observe children" and "may have the children participate in structured play, draw pictures or tell stories." It states that "the evaluator will not ask children to choose between parents" and gives parents the matching rule: "Don't ask your children to choose between you and the other parent."

The child's own therapist stays a therapist. APA Guideline 12 lists "Conducting child custody evaluations with one's current or prior psychotherapy clients/patients" as a multiple relationship, and Guideline 19 says treating psychologists refrain from custody or parenting time recommendations.

What happens during a home visit or office observation?

The evaluator watches the parent and the child together, at home or in the office. APA Guideline 18 asks psychologists to include an observation of parent-child interactions in every custody evaluation they can.

Guideline 18 reads: "Psychologists strive to include an observation of parent-child interactions when conducting child custody evaluations." The commentary says "Observing parent-child interactions often provides highly relevant information" and that "Observations may occur in a variety of settings, such as the home or clinical office." It also says such an observation is not an attachment evaluation, which requires special training and settings.

The AFCC brochure gives the parent's view: "This may take place in the evaluator's office or it may occur in your home." The observation "will allow the evaluator to observe the relationships between family members."

Under Guideline 11 the length and scope of observations are kept comparable for both parties when feasible. Each parent is seen with the child in a similar setting and for a similar time.

Can a parent record the sessions or bring a lawyer?

Not secretly. APA Guideline 17 treats explicit discouragement of surreptitious recording as part of informed consent and notes that recording or observers may alter responses. The AFCC brochure tells parents to consult their attorney throughout the evaluation.

The application section of APA Guideline 17 discusses recording devices and third-party observers. It says they may increase transparency, and that they may also "alter the evaluatees' responses, reducing reliability and validity of the evaluation." It notes that recording may be governed by law and describes "the explicit discouragement of surreptitious recording by examinees, counsel, and others" as a useful part of the informed consent process.

The AFCC brochure advises: "Consult with your attorney as needed throughout the evaluation process." Counsel prepares the parent, reviews the consent document and raises any objection to the procedure with the evaluator or the court.

Conditions of a court-ordered examination are set in the order. In federal civil cases, where a party's mental condition is in controversy, Rule 35(a)(2)(B) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure requires the order to "specify the time, place, manner, conditions, and scope of the examination," as well as the person who will perform it. Custody cases are heard in state courts under state rules, so a parent who wants an observer or a recording asks counsel to raise it before the evaluation starts.

What if there is a history of family violence or substance use?

Tell the evaluator and bring the records. APA Guideline 15 asks psychologists to screen for family violence, child maltreatment, intimate partner violence and resultant trauma, and Guideline 16 asks them to screen examinees for substance use.

Guideline 15 reads: "Psychologists endeavor to conduct appropriate screening for family violence, child maltreatment," "intimate partner violence, and resultant trauma." The screening is meant to "identify potential physical or sexual abuse, child abuse including alienating behaviors, intimate partner abuse," together with power imbalance and coercive control. Psychologists "utilize these findings, as appropriate, in their assessment processes and recommendations" and "inform the appropriate authorities of newly uncovered incidents."

Guideline 16 reads: "Psychologists endeavor to screen examinees for substance use." The screening covers both parents.

Safety can change the procedure. Under Guideline 18 "Psychologists may postpone or opt against observing parent-child interactions to protect the child's safety." A parent who fears an observation session tells the evaluator before it is scheduled and gives the reason.

The records that support such an account are the ones Guideline 8 and the AFCC brochure name, child protective service documentation, police information and medical records, together with the court file records that Stahl and Stahl mention, including protective orders with their dates.

Should a parent hire a separate psychologist?

Not to evaluate the child on the side. AFCC tells parents to be cautious of taking the children to their own separate evaluator; a consulting psychologist can prepare the parent's questions and later check the report.

The AFCC brochure says: "Be cautious of taking the children to your own separate evaluator." It also states that "An evaluator should not make a recommendation unless both parents have been interviewed." A report on the child obtained by one parent alone does not meet that condition.

A consultant works with the parent and counsel, not with the child. Before the evaluation the consultant can explain the APA guidelines and the likely procedures. After the report, Stahl and Stahl write, "you might want to engage the services of a consultant or expert witness to help you raise these issues with the court." They also advise parents to be open to the recommendations when the evaluator used a thorough process.

Access to the report depends on the court. The AFCC brochure says: "Court rules vary as to who has access to the report." It "may be available to both parents or it may be restricted to the judge and attorneys," and "In most jurisdictions the report is considered a confidential document and can be ordered sealed by the court." If the case goes to trial, the brochure says, the judge or the lawyers may ask the evaluator to be present to explain the report and its findings.

What does IAE do for a parent facing a custody evaluation?

A psychologist from the IAE registry writes an expert report on the client's questions or a review of the opposing psychologist's evaluation. Delivery takes up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.

The IAE page on forensic psychological evaluation covers child custody and parenting time, decision-making capacity in contract and will disputes, and emotional distress claims in civil cases. For custody it cites the 2022 APA guidelines: multimethod assessment, standardized measures and observation of parent-child interaction (Guidelines 10, 17 and 18). Questions are framed from the pleadings, the records and the opposing evaluator's report and are confirmed with the client before work starts.

The client sends the materials and describes the task. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day and, within one business day, confirms the format, cost, deadline and the specialist from the registry; the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. For tight deadlines there is a 48-hour rush.

The specialist is listed in the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome, and materials are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. IAE is not a law firm, and neither IAE nor the psychologist guarantees the court's decision.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert examinations

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member