Examinations
Manufacturing defect or misuse: how does an expert tell them apart in a goods dispute?
In two combine fire cases the manufacturer blamed maintenance or an oil change, and the buyers blamed the machine. The Eighth Circuit, applying Nebraska law, upheld a verdict where the evidence ruled out misuse without naming a specific defect. Kansas requires circumstantial evidence that tends to negate other reasonable causes, or an expert opinion. Maryland's highest court rejected a claim that left those causes open. The expert addresses each alternative explanation.

Who has to prove that the failure was not caused by misuse?
The buyer carries the burden of establishing the breach under UCC 2-607(4). Under Nebraska law, as applied by the Eighth Circuit, a buyer need not name the specific defect if the evidence lets a jury rule out misuse.
Section 2-607(4) reads: "The burden is on the buyer to establish any breach with respect to the goods accepted." When the seller answers with misuse, the buyer's evidence has to deal with it.
In C-Line Farms v. CNH America, decided August 21, 2007, a 2003 Case IH 2388 combine caught fire after the number six piston disengaged from the crankshaft and punched holes in the engine block and oil pan. The manufacturer's expert said the oil filter had been installed improperly at an oil change on October 9, 2004, oil leaked out and the engine ran dry. The plaintiffs' experts ruled out oil starvation, noting that only the number six piston and cylinder were damaged.
The Eighth Circuit applied Genetti v. Caterpillar, a Nebraska decision: a plaintiff need not identify a specific defect if the evidence lets the jury find no user misuse or abuse and that the event would not normally occur without a defect. The court quoted the Genetti reasoning that "if the breakdown was not due to improper use" then it was due to a defect. It rejected the manufacturer's argument that the plaintiffs had to prove the absence of misuse as a matter of law before the jury could draw the inference, and upheld the verdict for the plaintiffs on express warranty.
How do courts weigh misuse and other possible causes?
They ask whether the evidence makes a defect probable or only possible. Kansas requires circumstantial evidence negating other reasonable causes or an expert opinion; Maryland rejected a claim where repairs, an accident and irregular oil changes stayed unexplained.
In Dieker v. Case Corp., opinion filed July 25, 2003, the Supreme Court of Kansas dealt with another Case IH 2388 combine. The buyers bought it new in late September 1998, and on October 24, 1998, after about 12 days of use and 120 engine hours, it caught fire during the soybean harvest. The manufacturer argued that lack of maintenance caused the fire and that dry chaff and field trash around a solenoid valve ignited. The buyers' engineer testified that a loose fitting with an improperly sealed O-ring leaked hydraulic fluid onto the valve area, where debris built up and was ignited by heat from the valve body and solenoids.
The syllabus states the standard. Because liability cannot rest on speculation, guess or conjecture, "the circumstances shown must justify an inference of probability as distinguished from mere possibility." Circumstantial evidence "must tend to negate other reasonable cause, or there must be an expert opinion that the product was defective." The court reversed the Court of Appeals and affirmed the district court.
In Crickenberger v. Hyundai Motor America, decided March 21, 2008, the Court of Appeals of Maryland affirmed summary judgment for the manufacturer in a dispute over a used car that malfunctioned. The record showed varied repairs over years and thousands of miles, an accident and irregular oil changes, and the majority held that without expert testimony the buyer's defect allegations were mere speculation. The concurring opinion described the evidence that can reach a jury without an expert: proof that the car was properly maintained, not abnormally used or modified, and not involved in an event that could explain the malfunction.
What does the expert examine to separate a defect from misuse?
The failed part itself, its fracture surfaces, wear and repair marks, the maintenance and repair records, the conditions of use, and the instructions and labels. Each finding is set against the alternative cause the other side proposes.
The physical evidence comes first. A fracture surface, the pattern of wear and marks left by earlier repairs or disassembly can point to a flaw present at manufacture or to load, heat or handling after delivery. In C-Line Farms, the location of the damage in a single cylinder was the experts' ground for ruling out oil starvation, which the manufacturer said had made the engine run dry.
The documents come next. The Maryland court in Crickenberger looked at the repair history, the accident and the oil change record, and the concurrence listed maintenance, abnormal use, modification and intervening events as the facts with which a plaintiff can reach a jury without an expert. An expert who did not read the maintenance file cannot address the first of them.
The standard of use comes from the warranty itself. Under UCC 2-314(2)(c) merchantable goods are fit for "the ordinary purposes for which such goods are used," and under 2-314(2)(f) they conform to affirmations of fact on the container or label. The expert compares the actual use with that ordinary purpose and with the stated ratings and instructions. Use outside them supports the misuse defense; use within them supports the defect claim.
Must the expert test the failed part?
Not always. In C-Line Farms the Eighth Circuit admitted opinions based on observation and inspection without tests, holding that observations coupled with expertise generally may form the basis of an admissible expert opinion.
Neither of the plaintiffs' experts in C-Line Farms tested the damaged parts, and the court noted that the manufacturer's expert also relied on observations rather than tests. The manufacturer cited Fireman's Fund Insurance Co. v. Canon. The court answered that Fireman's Fund "does not stand for a bright line rule" requiring testing for every fire causation opinion; in that case the plaintiffs' own fire tests had failed to meet NFPA 921 and did not support their opinions. The court read Fireman's Fund as holding that testing, if performed, "must be appropriate in the circumstances and must actually prove what the experts claim it proves."
When a test would change the part, ASTM E860-22 applies. The standard covers examination and testing of evidence items when the work "is likely to change the nature, state, or condition of the evidence," and describes specific actions required for destructive testing.
How does Rule 702 treat alternative explanations?
The committee note to the 2000 amendment lists as a reliability factor whether the expert has adequately accounted for obvious alternative explanations. Since 2023 the proponent must establish each Rule 702 condition by a preponderance.
Since December 1, 2023, Rule 702 requires the proponent to establish to the court that it is more likely than not that the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data, is the product of reliable principles and methods, and applies them reliably to the facts of the case. A defect opinion that never mentions the maintenance record or the conditions of use leaves out facts that bear directly on the cause, and the sufficiency condition in Rule 702(b) is where the objection lands.
Among the factors listed in the note to the 2000 amendment is "whether the expert has adequately accounted for obvious alternative explanations." In a misuse dispute the obvious alternatives are named by the other side: improper installation, lack of maintenance, overload, modification. The report takes each one, states the evidence for and against it and explains why it is or is not the cause.
In General Electric Co. v. Joiner (1997) the Supreme Court held that a court may find "too great an analytical gap between the data and the opinion proffered." A misuse opinion that rests on the bare fact of failure, with no physical sign of misuse, and a defect opinion that rests on the bare fact of failure, with no ruling out of misuse, show the same gap.
Can the expert examine a failed part held by the other side?
Yes, on request. Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 34(a)(1) a party may inspect, test or sample tangible things in the other party's possession, custody or control. The written response is due within 30 days.
The request must specify a reasonable time, place and manner for the inspection and the related acts. Rule 34(a)(2) adds entry onto land or other property the responding party possesses or controls, for inspection, measurement, testing or sampling, which covers machinery installed at a plant or a farm.
When the part is with a repair shop, a dealer or another company that is not a party, Rule 34(c) points to Rule 45: a nonparty may be compelled to produce tangible things or to permit an inspection. Each side's expert records the condition of the part on arrival, so that later disassembly or testing can be traced.
What does a review of the opposing defect or misuse report check?
Whether the report lists the facts and data considered, addresses each alternative cause, ties each conclusion to a physical finding or a document, and whether the tests the conclusions need were run.
Rule 26(a)(2)(B) requires the opposing report to state all opinions with their basis and reasons and the facts or data considered. The reviewer compares that list with the file: if the maintenance records, the repair invoices or the operating logs were produced in discovery and the report does not list them, the review says so.
The review then follows each conclusion back to its basis. A statement that the part failed from overload is checked against the fracture description and the photographs. A statement that the part was defective is checked against the measurements or the comparison with the specification. Where a conclusion needs a test that was not run, the review names the test.
The review ends with the alternatives. If the opposing expert proposes one cause and does not discuss the other side's explanation, the review states the omission and the evidence in the file that bears on it.
What does IAE do when the cause of a failure is disputed?
IAE prepares an expert report on whether the failure came from manufacturing or misuse, or a review of the opposing expert's report, for warranty and supply disputes in US courts. Up to 5 business days.
On the product defects page the cause of failure is one of three questions: the expert reads fracture surfaces, wear and repair marks and states whether the cause was a manufacturing flaw or misuse; testing likely to change the item follows ASTM E860-22. A review of the opposing report lists the tests the expert did not run and the conclusions the data do not support. IAE confirms the questions with the client before work starts.
The client sends the report or the case materials, including photographs of the item, maintenance and repair records, and describes the task. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days; cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.
Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and passed the council's attestation under the published Criteria Matrix. The Member ID in the document opens the specialist's category, specialization, attestation date and record status on the status check page or by QR code. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case.
Materials go through the contact form or to info@iaexperts.com and are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. The court decides the cause of the failure on all the evidence. Neither IAE nor the expert guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm.
Sources
- C-Line Farms, Inc. v. CNH America LLC, No. 06-4180 (8th Cir. Aug. 21, 2007)
- Dieker v. Case Corp., Supreme Court of Kansas, opinion filed July 25, 2003
- Crickenberger v. Hyundai Motor America, Court of Appeals of Maryland (March 21, 2008)
- UCC § 2-607, Effect of Acceptance; Notice of Breach; Burden of Establishing Breach (LII)
- UCC § 2-314, Implied Warranty: Merchantability; Usage of Trade (LII)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702, Testimony by Expert Witnesses, with Committee Notes (LII)
- Supreme Court of the United States, order of April 24, 2023 amending Federal Rules of Evidence 106, 615 and 702, effective December 1, 2023
- General Electric Co. v. Joiner, 522 U.S. 136 (1997)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26 (LII)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 34 (LII)
- ASTM E860-22, Standard Practice for Examining and Preparing Items That Are or May Become Involved in Criminal or Civil Litigation
Read also
All articles
Goods damaged in a warehouse: who is liable, and what does the goods expert establish?
Goods go into a warehouse sound and come out wet, crushed, spoiled or short. Under UCC 7-204 the warehouse answers for damage caused by its failure
How do you prove goods are counterfeit, and what does the product expert compare?
Under the Lanham Act a counterfeit is a spurious mark that is identical with, or substantially indistinguishable from, a registered mark. Whether
Goods damaged in shipping: who bears the loss, and what does the expert establish?
When goods arrive damaged, three questions decide who pays: when the risk of loss passed to the buyer under UCC 2-509, whether the goods were alreadyExpert examinations
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

