Expert report review

Reasonable degree of scientific certainty: does an expert opinion need the phrase, and what does a reviewer check behind it?

Federal Rule of Evidence 702 does not require an expert to state an opinion "to a reasonable degree of scientific certainty." The National Commission on Forensic Science found in 2016 that the phrase has no scientific meaning and recommended that courts stop requiring it. The 2023 committee note to Rule 702 tells forensic experts to avoid it when the method is subjective. A reviewer looks past the phrase to the data, the method and the stated uncertainty.

A hand rests on a blank report page beside a small brass microscope

What does "reasonable degree of scientific certainty" mean?

It has no agreed meaning. The National Commission on Forensic Science found the phrase is not formally defined in standard medical or scientific reference materials, and that no common threshold exists across or within disciplines.

The Reporting and Testimony Subcommittee of the National Commission on Forensic Science prepared a views document on testimony using the term. It states that the terminology "is not formally defined in standard medical or scientific reference materials" and that "there is no common definition across science or within disciplines as to what threshold establishes" reasonable certainty.

The Commission's final views add: "Outside of the courts, this phrasing is not routinely used in scientific disciplines." A physicist, a toxicologist and a handwriting examiner who each use the words may mean different levels of confidence, and none of them has to say which.

For a reviewer this is the first point. A conclusion stated "to a reasonable degree of scientific certainty" tells the reader that the expert is confident. It does not say how confident, on what basis, or with what chance of error.

Where did the phrase come from?

According to the Commission, from a lawyer's question in Herbst v. Levy, an Illinois appellate case of 1935. The National Institute of Justice notes that the phrase was first linked to admissibility in 1969.

The National Institute of Justice summarized the history in a sidebar to an article in NIJ Journal issue 279; the web version is dated January 17, 2018. Relying on the Commission, it wrote that "reasonable degree of certainty" was first used, and not as a legal requirement, in Herbst v. Levy in 1935. The plaintiffs' expert was asked whether he could determine "with reasonable scientific certainty the cause of the capsizing of the boat."

The same sidebar states: "It was not until 1969 that the terminology was linked to the admissibility determination," in Twin City Plaza, Inc. v. Central Surety. According to the sidebar, the Commission observed that this link was made "without legal or scientific analysis as to what the term meant" or why its use was required.

Does Rule 702 require the phrase?

No. Rule 702 asks the proponent to show the court that it is more likely than not that the testimony is useful to the trier of fact, rests on sufficient facts or data, uses reliable methods and applies them reliably.

As amended in 2023, Rule 702 admits expert testimony if the proponent establishes to the court that it is more likely than not that four conditions are met: (a) the expert's specialized knowledge will aid the trier of fact in understanding the evidence or determining a fact in issue; (b) "the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data"; (c) "the testimony is the product of reliable principles and methods"; and (d) the opinion applies those principles and methods reliably to the facts of the case. No certainty formula appears in the text.

The 2023 Committee Note goes further for forensic testimony. It states that forensic experts "should avoid assertions of absolute or one hundred percent certainty," or of a reasonable degree of scientific certainty, "if the methodology is subjective and thus potentially subject to error." The note ties the wording of the conclusion to the nature of the method behind it.

State courts follow their own rules. The Commission's approved views note that admissibility standards remain a matter for each jurisdiction. A reviewer working on a state case checks the state's rule and case law before treating the phrase as either required or improper.

What did the National Commission on Forensic Science recommend?

In views approved on March 22, 2016, it said legal professionals should not require the phrase as a condition of admitting forensic testimony, providers should not promote it, and the term has no place in the judicial process.

The views document approved by the Commission on March 22, 2016 recommends that "legal professionals should not require that forensic discipline testimony be admitted conditioned upon the expert" expressing it to a reasonable degree of certainty. It also states that forensic science service providers and forensic science medical providers "should not endorse or promote" the terminology.

The central sentence is short: "the term 'reasonable degree of scientific [or discipline] certainty' has no place in the judicial process." The final draft notes that it does not formally recommend government action, and the approved text leaves admissibility standards to each jurisdiction.

The recommendation is addressed to courts and lawyers as well as to experts. A party that insists on the phrase in a deposition question, or a judge who asks for it before admitting an opinion, is doing what the Commission advised against.

Why can the phrase mislead a jury?

The Commission wrote that jurors may equate it with the certainty demanded by the beyond-a-reasonable-doubt standard, and that the word "scientific" gives an opinion an appearance of rigor and reproducibility it may not have.

The Commission's final views state: "Such statements have no scientific meaning and may mislead factfinders." A juror, it wrote, "might equate it with certainty at the level demanded by the" standard of proof beyond a reasonable doubt. The views also state that "use of the term 'scientific' cloaks the opinion with the rigor, acceptance and reproducibility" associated with science, whether or not the method has those qualities.

The phrase also clashes with probabilistic reporting. The Commission wrote that the term "invites confusion when presented with testimony expressed in probabilistic terms." An expert who reports a likelihood ratio or an error rate and then adds that he is reasonably certain gives the jury two measures that do not match.

The subcommittee's document quotes a court that found the phrase "reasonable degree of ballistic certainty" would "seriously mislead the jury as to the nature of the expertise involved." The reviewer uses this as a reason to ask what the phrase replaces in the report: a number, a validation study, or nothing.

What should a report say instead?

A statement about the examination itself: what was done, the bases and limitations of the opinion, and the uncertainty in the measurement or data. The Commission called dropping the phrase only a first step.

The subcommittee's document states that "experts should make a statement about the examination itself," "including an expression of the uncertainty in the measurement or in the data." The final views describe abandoning the phrase as a first step and ask experts to describe their examination, its uncertainty, and the bases and limitations of their conclusions.

This fits what Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(i) already requires of a retained expert's report: "a complete statement of all opinions the witness will express and the basis and reasons for them." A report that states the reasons in full has less need for a certainty formula. When a report states the formula but not the reasons, the missing reasons are where the review starts.

What does a reviewer check behind a certainty phrase?

Whether the method is objective or subjective, whether an error rate or measurement uncertainty is reported, whether the data support the strength of the conclusion, and whether the report explains each step that leads to the wording.

The reviewer treats the certainty phrase as a claim and looks for its support in the rest of the report. The checks follow conditions (b) to (d) of Rule 702 and the 2023 note.

  • Identify the method and whether its result depends on the examiner's judgment, which the 2023 note calls subjective.
  • Find any reported error rate, validation study or measurement uncertainty, and check whether it applies to the conditions of this case.
  • Compare the strength of the wording with the data: number of comparison points, sample size, quality of the material.
  • Check whether the report gives the basis and reasons for each opinion, as Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(i) requires, or only the conclusion and the phrase.
  • Look for internal mismatch, such as a probability in one section and a statement of certainty in the summary.
  • Write deposition questions that ask the expert to define the phrase and to name the threshold he applied.

What questions expose an empty certainty phrase at deposition?

Questions that ask the expert to define the phrase, to state the threshold he used, to name any error rate for his method, and to say what result would have led him to a weaker conclusion.

Under Rule 26(b)(4)(A) a party may depose an expert whose opinions may be presented at trial, after the report is provided. The 2010 Committee Note to Rule 26 confirms that the expert may be questioned about the development, foundation and basis of the opinions. Questions on certainty fall within that scope.

  • What does "reasonable degree of scientific certainty" mean in your field, and where is that definition written?
  • What percentage or threshold of confidence did you apply when you used the phrase?
  • What is the known error rate of the method you used, and under what conditions was it measured?
  • Which observation, if it had come out differently, would have led you to a weaker conclusion?
  • Did anyone ask you to state your opinion in these words?

What does IAE do when an opposing report rests on a certainty phrase?

An IAE specialist checks whether the method, the data and the reasoning support the strength of the stated conclusion, and prepares deposition questions. Format, cost, deadline and specialist are confirmed within one business day.

The client sends the opposing report and the case materials and describes the task. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its public registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts.

Two of the six questions a review answers apply here directly: whether the method fits the object and the questions and was followed at each stage, and whether the conclusions follow from the examination with no contradictions or inadmissible assumptions. The review can be ordered with deposition questions for the opposing expert.

The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, with a 48-hour rush for tight deadlines. The specialist confirms that he has no interest in the outcome and can be verified in the IAE registry by Member ID or QR code. IAE is not a law firm, and a review is evidence that the court weighs with the rest of the record.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member