Expert report review
Will the court hear a reviewer who only critiques the handwriting examiner?
A rebuttal expert in a federal civil case may confine the testimony to criticism of the other side's expert, a federal court in New York wrote in 2022. Handwriting cases add a second question: who is qualified to criticize. The Third Circuit reversed the exclusion of a critic of handwriting analysis in 1995, and the Eleventh Circuit upheld the exclusion of the same critic in 1999.

Can a rebuttal expert only criticize the handwriting examiner?
Yes. In Medidata v. Veeva (S.D.N.Y. 2022) the court held that rebuttal experts may limit themselves to criticizing the methodology and opinions of other experts and have no burden to offer an analysis of their own.
In Medidata Solutions, Inc. v. Veeva Systems Inc., No. 17 Civ. 589 (LGS), Judge Lorna G. Schofield of the Southern District of New York ruled on February 24, 2022 that "rebuttal experts may limit themselves to criticizing the methodology and opinions of other experts." She quoted In re Aluminum Warehousing Antitrust Litigation, 336 F.R.D. 5, 29 (S.D.N.Y. 2020): "A rebuttal expert, by nature, criticizes the methodology and/or opinions of another. There is no requirement that a rebuttal expert himself offer a competing analysis." Rebuttal experts "have no burden to produce models or methods of their own; they need only attack those of plaintiffs' expert."
Applied to a signature dispute, a reviewer can testify that the opposing examiner used too few known signatures, worked from a copy without stating the limits, or skipped the review of alternative explanations required by section 6.7 of ANSI/ASB Standard 070. The reviewer does not have to say who signed.
Two limits remain. The critique must stay on the same subject matter as the opposing disclosure, because Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii) covers only evidence intended solely to contradict or rebut that evidence. And the reviewer is an expert witness like any other: the party calling the reviewer must meet Rule 702 for the critique itself.
What did the Third Circuit decide in United States v. Velasquez?
On August 31, 1995 the Third Circuit held that the trial court erred as a matter of law in excluding a defense critic of handwriting analysis, and vacated the conviction on the continuing criminal enterprise count.
In United States v. Velasquez, 64 F.3d 844 (3d Cir. 1995), No. 93-7236, the government's handwriting expert was Lynn Bonjour. The defense offered Mark Denbeaux, described in the opinion as "a Professor of Law at Seton Hall University," to help the jury understand the limitations of the government's handwriting testimony. The district court excluded him, relying on his lack of formal training and inadequate practical experience in performing handwriting analysis.
The court of appeals, in an opinion by Judge Roth, wrote that even though the district court had recognized handwriting analysis as a field of expertise, "the court erred as a matter of law in denying the defense the opportunity to criticize the standards employed in that field of expertise." It added: "The mere fact that the Professor is not an expert in conducting handwriting analysis to identify particular scriveners of specified documents does not mean that he is not qualified to offer expert testimony criticizing the standards in the field."
The court pointed to "the Professor's eight years of self-directed research on handwriting analysis and his co-authorship of a law review article on the subject," and concluded that "in light of the liberal standard of admissibility of Rule 702," his testimony should have been admitted. It could not find the error harmless and vacated the conviction on Count VIII, the continuing criminal enterprise count, with a remand for a new trial on that count.
Why was the same critic excluded in United States v. Paul?
The Eleventh Circuit, reviewing for abuse of discretion, held on May 13, 1999 that the district court could exclude Denbeaux because his background as a law professor did not qualify him as an expert in the field.
In United States v. Paul, No. 97-9302 (11th Cir. May 13, 1999), the government's examiner testified about an extortion note, and the defense again offered Denbeaux. The court described the record: "Denbeaux has a law degree and that he is a law professor who teaches evidence," he "was not a questioned documents examiner, had received no formal training in the field," "had never attended seminars on handwriting analysis, had never worked in a questioned documents laboratory" and "was not a member of any professional organizations in the field."
The court held that "Denbeaux's background did not qualify him as an expert, and his knowledge of the subject matter is so limited that it was not an abuse of discretion" to exclude him. "His skill, experience, training and education as a lawyer did not make him any more qualified." The opinion states the standard it applied: "As to expert testimony, however, we review for abuse of discretion."
Velasquez and Paul reached opposite results on the same witness, and both turned on qualifications. A reviewer who is a trained document examiner, and who criticizes the application of the method in the case rather than the field as a whole, meets the objection on which Paul rested.
Can the critique limit the examiner instead of excluding him?
Yes. In Hines (D. Mass. 1999) the court accepted Denbeaux's critique at the pretrial hearing and barred the FBI examiner from naming the writer, while allowing testimony on similarities and dissimilarities.
In United States v. Hines, 55 F. Supp. 2d 62 (D. Mass. 1999), decided June 11, 1999, Judge Gertner held a Daubert and Kumho hearing on the testimony of an FBI document examiner, Diana Harrison. Denbeaux testified at the hearing, and the court wrote: "I accept Denbeaux's testimony, and the article supporting it." It also wrote that "There are no meaningful, and accepted validity studies in the field."
The ruling limited the examiner. Harrison met Rule 702 "to the extent that she restricts her testimony to similarities or dissimilarities," but "she may not render an ultimate conclusion on who penned the unknown writing." The defense did not call Denbeaux at trial, and the government's motion to exclude him became moot.
Military courts have dealt with the same request. In United States v. Ruth, No. 96-0155, decided February 12, 1997, the Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces found no abuse of discretion in a military judge's preliminary ruling denying production of Denbeaux, because the judge "expressly kept the issue open for defense counsel to pursue after evidence had been heard" and the defense never renewed the request.
What qualifications does a handwriting reviewer need?
Rule 702 qualifies an expert by knowledge, skill, experience, training or education. For criticism of how Standard 070 was applied in the case, the reviewer is a document examiner trained in those procedures.
Rule 702 opens with "A witness who is qualified as an expert by knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education." Velasquez accepted research and publication as the basis for a critic of the field. Paul refused to treat legal training as a substitute for training in document examination.
Standard 070 section 4.1 says the procedures "shall be used by a forensic document examiner trained in the procedures" and in the instruments used. A reviewer who says the opposing examiner misapplied section 6.3.8 on simulation, or section 6.5 on comparability of known writing, speaks from the same training the standard requires of the examiner.
Credentials also go to weight once the reviewer is admitted. In United States v. Rutland, 372 F.3d 543 (3d Cir. 2004), a case in which the government's examiner testified that signatures were forged, the Third Circuit wrote that "Jurors may properly take an expert's impressive experience and credentials into account." The rebuttal report lists qualifications and publications from the previous 10 years under Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(iv).
What may a critique-only rebuttal report cover?
Only the subject matter of the opposing disclosure, within 30 days of it absent a stipulation or court order. An opinion that a named person signed or did not sign follows the affirmative deadline.
Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii) sets the rebuttal deadline for evidence "intended solely to contradict or rebut evidence on the same subject matter identified by another party," within 30 days after the other party's disclosure. Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(i) sets the general deadline: at least 90 days before the date set for trial or for the case to be ready for trial.
A critique-only report still contains the six items of Rule 26(a)(2)(B). The "complete statement of all opinions" is the list of criticisms, each with its basis and reasons: which known writing was missing, which step was not documented, which limitation the conclusion ignores. The facts or data considered include the opposing report, the file produced in discovery and any originals the reviewer inspected under Rule 34.
Where the reviewer examined the originals and reached a view on authorship, counsel decides whether to disclose that view as an affirmative opinion on time or to keep the rebuttal within criticism.
Is the critique a question of weight or of admissibility?
Both, at different stages. Before the ruling, the critique bears on whether the proponent meets Rule 702 by a preponderance. After the court admits the examiner, any attack goes only to weight.
Velasquez, decided in 1995, said that the reliability of evidence goes "more to the weight than to the admissibility of the evidence." The 2023 amendment to Rule 702 changed the emphasis. The committee note says the preponderance standard applies to the reliability requirements and that rulings treating "the critical questions of the sufficiency of an expert's basis, and the application of the expert's methodology" as questions of weight "are an incorrect application of Rules 702 and 104(a)."
Once the court has found the requirement met, the note says, "any attack by the opponent will go only to the weight of the evidence." The 2000 committee note names the tools for that stage: "Vigorous cross-examination, presentation of contrary evidence, and careful instruction on the burden of proof are the traditional and appropriate means of attacking shaky but admissible evidence." A critique-only rebuttal expert is contrary evidence.
The same note observed that "the rejection of expert testimony is the exception rather than the rule." Hines shows the middle ground: the examiner testified, limited to what the court found the method supported.
Can a defendant who cannot pay get a handwriting rebuttal expert?
Yes, through the Criminal Justice Act. Under 18 U.S.C. § 3006A(e)(1), counsel for a person financially unable to obtain expert services may apply ex parte, and the court authorizes the services if it finds them necessary.
Section 3006A(e)(1) reads that counsel for a person "who is financially unable to obtain investigative, expert, or other services necessary for adequate representation may request them in an ex parte application." Upon finding, after appropriate inquiry in an ex parte proceeding, that the services are necessary and that the person cannot pay, the court "shall authorize counsel to obtain the services."
The application explains why a reviewer is necessary in the specific case: the government's handwriting evidence supports an element of the charge, the examiner's file shows a gap, and cross-examination alone cannot put contrary evidence before the jury. Velasquez is an example of a reversal on a count where the excluded critic was the defense's answer to the government's examiner.
Ruth shows the procedural point for military practice: a preliminary denial left open for reconsideration has to be renewed at trial.
If the critique is excluded, what is left?
Cross-examination built on the review and the jury's own comparison under Rule 901(b)(3). Rule 705 lets counsel require the examiner to disclose the underlying facts or data on cross-examination.
Rule 901(b)(3) permits authentication by "A comparison with an authenticated specimen by an expert witness or the trier of fact." In Paul the court wrote: "The jury was free to conduct its own comparison and reach its own conclusion regarding the author of the extortion note." Under Rule 901(b)(2), a lay witness may give an opinion that handwriting is genuine based on familiarity "that was not acquired for the current litigation."
Rule 705 says an expert "may be required to disclose those facts or data on cross-examination." An excluded reviewer still writes the questions: how many known signatures, from which years and supplied by whom; which images were used; whether anyone verified the conclusion.
The 2021 NIST report on handwriting examination, NIST IR 8282r1, gives counsel two testimony standards to put to the examiner. Recommendation 3.5 says the examiner "must be prepared to describe the steps taken during the examination to reduce the risk of process, observational, and cognitive errors" and "must not state that errors are impossible."
What does IAE do when the other side's handwriting examiner needs a critique?
IAE prepares reviews of the opposing handwriting examiner's report for federal and state cases. The signed document is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, with a 48-hour rush.
The reviewer checks whether the report states each opinion with its basis and the facts or data considered, as Rule 26(a)(2)(B) requires, and whether the examiner followed Standard 070 on originals, comparability, distortion and alternative explanations. The review answers whether the method fits the questions and was followed at every stage, whether all materials were examined, whether the conclusions follow from the examination, whether the examiner's education and experience match the subject, whether formal and procedural requirements were met and whether the report can be relied on.
The client sends the opposing report and what is available of the questioned document and known writing. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day, and within one business day IAE confirms the format, cost, deadline and the specialist from its registry. The client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts, so counsel sees the reviewer's qualifications before the question in Paul can arise.
Specialists are members of the public IAE registry, verified by Member ID or QR code, and confirm in the document that they have no interest in the outcome. A review is evidence the court weighs with the other materials; neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.
Sources
- Medidata Solutions, Inc. v. Veeva Systems Inc., No. 17 Civ. 589 (LGS), Opinion and Order of February 24, 2022 (S.D.N.Y.) (Justia)
- United States v. Velasquez, 64 F.3d 844 (3d Cir. 1995) (OpenJurist)
- United States v. Paul, No. 97-9302 (11th Cir. May 13, 1999) (U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit)
- United States v. Hines, 55 F. Supp. 2d 62 (D. Mass. 1999) (Justia)
- United States v. Ruth, No. 96-0155 (C.A.A.F. Feb. 12, 1997) (U.S. Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces)
- United States v. Rutland, 372 F.3d 543 (3d Cir. 2004) (Justia)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702, Testimony by Expert Witnesses, with Committee Notes (LII)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 705, Disclosing the Facts or Data Underlying an Expert (LII)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 901, Authenticating or Identifying Evidence (LII)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26, Duty to Disclose; General Provisions Governing Discovery (LII)
- 18 U.S. Code § 3006A, Adequate representation of defendants (LII)
- ANSI/ASB Standard 070, Standard for Examination of Handwritten Items, First Edition, 2022 (AAFS Standards Board)
- NIST IR 8282r1, Forensic Handwriting Examination and Human Factors: Improving the Practice Through a Systems Approach (May 2021)
Read also
All articles
The handwriting examiner's opinion is inconclusive: what does that mean, and what does a reviewer check?
An inconclusive handwriting result is a defined conclusion. In the Department of Justice's uniform language it means that "no determination can be
Comparison charts in the opposing handwriting report: what does a reviewer check?
The part of a handwriting report that a judge or jury remembers is often the chart: questioned letters set beside matching letters from the known
The report says the signature was written under unusual conditions: what does that mean, and how is it reviewed?
A handwriting report may find that a questioned signature was written under unusual conditions: slowly, with tremor, poor line quality or an oddExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

