Expert report review
Tribunal-appointed expert in arbitration: how does a party answer the report?
An arbitral tribunal may appoint its own expert unless the parties have agreed otherwise. Under Article 26 of the UNCITRAL Model Law and Article 6 of the IBA Rules on the Taking of Evidence, the parties are consulted on the appointment, may object to the expert's independence, receive the report, answer it in writing or through their own experts and question the expert at a hearing. The tribunal then weighs the report with all the circumstances of the case.

What is a tribunal-appointed expert?
An expert chosen by the arbitral tribunal, not by a party, to report on specific issues the tribunal identifies. Article 26 of the UNCITRAL Model Law permits the appointment unless the parties agreed otherwise.
Article 26(1) of the UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration: "Unless otherwise agreed by the parties, the arbitral tribunal (a) may appoint one or more experts to report to it on specific issues to be determined by the arbitral tribunal; (b) may require a party to give the expert any relevant information or to produce, or to provide access to, any relevant documents, goods or other property for his inspection."
The IBA Rules on the Taking of Evidence in International Arbitration, in the 2020 version, separate the two kinds of experts. Article 5(1): "A Party may rely on a Party-Appointed Expert as a means of evidence on specific issues." Article 6(1): "The Arbitral Tribunal, after consulting with the Parties, may appoint one or more independent Tribunal-Appointed Experts."
The difference is who chose the expert and to whom the expert reports. A party-appointed expert is a party's evidence. A tribunal-appointed expert reports to the tribunal, and the parties' work is to test that report.
Can the parties prevent the tribunal from appointing an expert?
Yes, by agreement. Article 26 of the Model Law and Article 29 of the Russian Law on Arbitration both apply "unless the parties agreed otherwise", so the parties can exclude or limit tribunal-appointed experts.
The default power is broad, and the parties can switch it off. The same opening words appear in Article 26(2) of the Model Law on the expert's participation in a hearing.
Russian Federal Law No. 382-FZ On Arbitration (Arbitral Proceedings) in the Russian Federation follows the same structure in Article 29: unless the parties agreed otherwise, the tribunal may appoint one or several experts to clarify matters that arise in the dispute and require special expertise, and may require a party to give the expert information or access to documents, goods or other property.
A party that wants every technical issue argued only through party-appointed experts writes that into the arbitration clause or the procedural agreements at the start of the case. Once the tribunal has appointed its expert, the room left is to shape the terms of reference and to answer the report.
How is the expert chosen, and can a party object?
The tribunal consults the parties and sets the terms of reference. Before accepting, the expert discloses qualifications and a statement of independence, and the parties may object within the time the tribunal sets.
Article 6(1) of the IBA Rules requires the tribunal to consult the parties on the appointment and on the terms of reference: "A copy of the final terms of reference shall be sent by the Arbitral Tribunal to the Parties." Under Article 29(2) of the Russian Law on Arbitration, unless the parties agreed otherwise, the tribunal defines the candidate and the questions for the expert taking into account the opinions of the parties.
Under Article 6(2) of the IBA Rules the expert must, before accepting, "submit to the Arbitral Tribunal and to the Parties a description of his or her qualifications" and a statement of independence. The parties may object within the time the tribunal fixes. After the appointment, objections are limited to grounds the party learned of after the appointment.
The UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules (2010) set the same sequence in Article 29(2): the expert presents qualifications and a statement of impartiality and independence, the parties raise objections within the time set by the tribunal, and the tribunal decides on them promptly.
The terms of reference are the first place a party can influence the report. Questions framed too broadly invite the expert to decide issues of law or liability. Narrow, exact questions keep the expert on the technical or financial issues the tribunal needs answered.
What can the expert require from the parties?
Relevant information and access to relevant documents, goods or other property. Under the IBA Rules the expert's authority to request them is the same as the tribunal's, and any dispute about a request goes to the tribunal.
Article 26(1)(b) of the Model Law lets the tribunal require a party to give the expert relevant information or access to documents, goods or other property for inspection. Article 6(3) of the IBA Rules lets the expert "request a Party to provide any information or to provide access to any Documents", subject to the objections in Articles 9.2 and 9.3, and sends disputes to the tribunal.
The UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules state the duty from the parties' side in Article 29(3): the parties give the expert any relevant information and produce for inspection any relevant documents or goods the expert may require, and the tribunal resolves disputes over such requests.
Each request and each answer becomes part of the record the report rests on. A party that hands documents to the tribunal's expert should keep an exact list, because later it will compare that list with what the report says the expert considered.
What must the report contain, and what may the parties see?
Under the IBA Rules the expert reports in writing with the facts relied on, the opinions, the methods and an affirmation of genuine belief. The parties receive the report and may examine the materials the expert reviewed.
Article 6(4) of the IBA Rules: "The Tribunal-Appointed Expert shall report in writing to the Arbitral Tribunal in an Expert Report." The article lists the contents, including the facts on which the expert relied, the opinions and conclusions, the methods, evidence and information used, and an affirmation of genuine belief in the opinions.
Under Article 6(5) the tribunal sends the report to the parties, who may examine the information, documents, goods and other material the expert reviewed. Article 29(4) of the UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules gives each party the right to inspect any document the expert relied on in the report.
Access to the materials is what makes an answer possible. A party that has only the conclusions can disagree with them. A party that has the data, the measurements and the documents can show where the reasoning departs from them.
How does a party answer the tribunal expert's report?
In writing, within the time the tribunal sets. Article 6(5) of the IBA Rules lets a party respond by its own submission, by a witness statement or by a report of a party-appointed expert.
The text of Article 6(5): "any Party shall have the opportunity to respond to the Expert Report in a submission by the Party". The response may also come through a witness statement or through the report of a party-appointed expert. Article 29(4) of the UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules gives the parties the opportunity to express their opinion on the report in writing.
An answer can have two layers. The first is the record: whether the expert considered all the materials provided, whether the facts in the report match the documents, whether the expert answered the questions in the terms of reference and only those. The second is the method: whether it fits the question, whether it was applied consistently and whether the conclusions follow from the data.
A review by an independent specialist serves the second layer. It can be filed as a party-appointed expert report or used by counsel to write the submission and the questions for the hearing.
Can a party question the tribunal's expert at the hearing?
Yes. Under Article 26(2) of the Model Law, if a party requests or the tribunal considers it necessary, the expert participates in a hearing where the parties may put questions and present their own expert witnesses.
Article 26(2) of the Model Law: "Unless otherwise agreed by the parties, if a party so requests or if the arbitral tribunal considers it necessary, the expert shall, after delivery of his written or oral report, participate in a hearing where the parties have the opportunity to put questions to him and to present expert witnesses in order to testify on the points at issue." Article 29(3) of the Russian Law on Arbitration is narrower: unless the parties agreed otherwise, the expert, if a party so requests or the tribunal considers it necessary, must take part in a hearing at which the parties may put questions to the expert about the examination and the report. It does not mention the parties' own expert witnesses.
Article 6(6) of the IBA Rules provides that "the Tribunal-Appointed Expert shall be present at an Evidentiary Hearing" at the request of a party or the tribunal. The tribunal may question the expert, and so may the parties and their party-appointed experts. Under Article 29(5) of the UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules, any party may present expert witnesses at that hearing to testify on the points at issue.
The request is the party's to make. A party that does not ask for the hearing, when the rules give it that right, has given up the chance to test the report in front of the tribunal.
Is the tribunal bound by its own expert's conclusions?
No. Article 6(7) of the IBA Rules requires the tribunal to assess the report and its conclusions with due regard to all circumstances of the case. The tribunal also decides the admissibility, relevance and weight of evidence.
The IBA Rules state that the tribunal assesses the report "with due regard to all circumstances of the case". Article 27(4) of the UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules provides that the tribunal determines the admissibility, relevance, materiality and weight of the evidence. Under Article 19(2) of the Russian Law on Arbitration, failing an agreement of the parties, the tribunal may conduct the arbitration in the manner it considers appropriate, including determining the admissibility, relevance and weight of any evidence.
The parties' answers are among those circumstances. A written response, a party expert's report and the questions at the hearing give the tribunal reasons to depart from its expert's conclusion on a point, or to accept it.
Who pays for the tribunal-appointed expert?
The parties, as the tribunal decides. Under Article 6(8) of the IBA Rules the fees and expenses of a tribunal-appointed expert are funded as the tribunal determines and form part of the costs of the arbitration.
Article 6(8): "The fees and expenses of a Tribunal-Appointed Expert" are funded in the manner the tribunal determines and "shall form part of the costs of the arbitration." The final allocation follows the tribunal's decision on costs.
The cost of answering the report is a separate item. A party-appointed expert or a reviewer is paid by the party that retains them, and whether that cost is shifted depends on the tribunal's costs decision.
What if a party was not given a chance to answer the report?
It can raise the point when the award is challenged, if it objected in time. The Russian Supreme Court lists a party's inability to present its explanations as a ground for setting aside, where the violation was material.
In Resolution No. 53 of December 10, 2019 on the courts' assistance and control functions in arbitration, the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation addressed a party's inability to present its explanations to the tribunal (item 48). Item 49 states that a violation of the procedure is a ground for setting aside or refusing enforcement only when it substantially violated the party's rights and the party objected in time. Item 51 treats improper notice of the hearing that prevented a party from presenting explanations as an independent ground.
For the tribunal's expert this means timing. A party that was denied the report, the materials or the hearing should object at once, in writing, in the arbitration. An objection raised for the first time in the setting-aside court comes late.
What does a reviewer check in a tribunal expert's report?
Whether the expert answered the questions in the terms of reference, considered all materials the parties provided, used a method suited to the question and applied it consistently, and whether the conclusions follow from the data.
The reviewer starts with the terms of reference and the list of materials. A report that answers a question the tribunal did not ask, or ignores a document a party supplied, has a gap the response can point to. The second step is the method: whether it is recognized in the field, whether it fits the object and the question, and whether each stage is described.
The third step is the reasoning. A conclusion that rests on an assumption the expert did not test, or that states more certainty than the data allow, is a point for the written response and a question for the hearing.
What does IAE do when a tribunal has appointed its own expert?
IAE reviews the tribunal expert's report on six questions, including method, completeness and soundness of conclusions, and prepares questions for the hearing on request. The signed PDF follows in up to 5 business days.
The review answers six questions about the report: whether the method fits the object and the questions and was followed at every stage; whether all objects, materials and questions were examined, with no substituted questions or gaps; whether the conclusions follow from the examination, with no contradictions or inadmissible assumptions; whether the expert's education, specialty and experience match the subject; whether the report meets the formal requirements and procedure of the proceedings; and whether it can be relied on.
The client sends the report, the terms of reference and the materials the expert considered and describes the task: a review, questions for the hearing, or both. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day, and within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry. The client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days, and a 48-hour rush is available for tight deadlines.
Every reviewer is a member of the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code, and confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy; how to answer the tribunal's expert is a decision for the party's counsel. The tribunal weighs the review with the other evidence, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome.
Sources
- IBA Rules on the Taking of Evidence in International Arbitration (2020), Articles 5 and 6 (copy published by BAHR)
- UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration (1985, as amended in 2006), Article 26 (LexMea)
- UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules (as revised in 2010, with new article 1, paragraph 4, as adopted in 2013), Russian text, Articles 27 and 29 (UNCITRAL)
- Federal Law No. 382-FZ of December 29, 2015 On Arbitration (Arbitral Proceedings) in the Russian Federation, as amended on August 8, 2024, Russian text, Articles 18, 19 and 29 (rulaws.ru)
- Federal Law No. 382-FZ, table of contents, version of August 8, 2024 (ConsultantPlus)
- Resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation No. 53 of December 10, 2019 on the courts' assistance and control functions in arbitration (vsrf.ru)
Read also
All articles
The opposing expert used AI to prepare the report: what does a reviewer check, and when do courts exclude the opinion?
In the decisions discussed below, no court barred experts from using generative AI. The courts excluded or refused to credit work the expert did not
Must a rebuttal expert offer an alternative opinion, or is a critique of the other report enough?
A rebuttal expert does not have to build a competing model. In Medidata v. Veeva (S.D.N.Y. 2022) the court repeated that "there is no requirement
Can the opposing expert change deposition testimony on an errata sheet?
A deponent who asks for review before the deposition ends has 30 days to sign a statement listing changes "in form or substance" with the reasonsExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

