Examinations

Rejection of nonconforming goods: what must the buyer prove, and how fast?

A buyer may reject goods that fail to conform to the contract, but only within a reasonable time after delivery, and the rejection is ineffective unless the seller is notified in time. In 1988 a federal judge in New York upheld the rejection of 1,973 microprocessors after laboratory tests of a sample. The court weighed the agreed test temperature, the failure rates in the sample and the date of each letter.

Gloved hands lift a metal chassis from a wooden crate beside a matching sample

What makes goods nonconforming?

Failure to meet the contract: its specifications, its quality limit, its quantity or a sample that formed part of the bargain. Slow sales are not a nonconformity, a federal court in the Virgin Islands held in 1983.

Integrated Circuits Unlimited, Inc. v. E. F. Johnson Co. was decided in the Eastern District of New York on August 10, 1988. Johnson, a Minnesota maker of two-way taxi radios, bought microprocessors in March 1984 from ICU, a New York distributor of electronic components. The parts had to work at an agreed standard temperature. In its rejection letter of April 24, 1984, Johnson told ICU that its acceptable quality level was 1 percent. Judge Weinstein started from the general rule: "A buyer is entitled under the U.C.C. to reject goods which fail to conform to the contract."

The standard comes from the contract, and the buyer cannot change it after delivery. In T-Shirt World, Inc. v. Artland, Inc., decided by the District Court of the Virgin Islands on March 28, 1983, a store that bought T-shirts from a supplier ended their arrangement in early April 1980 and tried to return its whole stock of about 22,000 shirts. The court found that at most 1,000 of them were nonconforming. The court wrote: "Appellant had no right to reject or revoke acceptance of conforming goods." It added: "Because some styles or sizes were slow-moving did not make them nonconforming."

A sample can also set the standard. Section 2-313(1)(c), as the same opinion quotes it, provides that "Any sample or model which is made part of the basis of the bargain creates an express warranty". Artland argued that shelf signs showing the shirt designs were such samples. The court held that the signs were there for retail customers and were not part of the bargain between the supplier and the store, so they created no warranty between them.

Can a buyer reject a whole shipment when only a few units fail?

Yes, if an unacceptable share of the units fails under the agreed conditions. In Integrated Circuits failure rates of 4.6 and 2.6 percent at the agreed temperature led the court to hold the entire shipments nonconforming.

Under order WO4746, Johnson tested 130 of the 1,709 units delivered, and 6 failed: 4.6 percent. Under order WO4750, 115 units were tested. At the agreed standard temperature 3 of them failed, or 2.6 percent. The opinion reports separately that 113 failed when exposed to temperatures higher than the maximum required by commercial standards and by Johnson's own procurement specifications.

ICU's expert testified that the acceptable defect rate for electronic parts in the microprocessor industry is five percent. The court first credited that testimony and concluded preliminarily that Johnson's rejection of 1,973 parts was wrongful. On reconsideration it declined to credit it and noted that the witness's conclusion was "counterintuitive" and his presentation "confusing".

The court's own reasoning was arithmetic. A radio built from many components "could not produce a reliable product if each of those parts had a five percent chance of being defective". Even a radio with only five such parts, the opinion says, would have roughly a one-in-four chance of containing an inadequate component. The opinion adds that "the industry requires a failure rate much lower than one percent." The court found that the defects rendered the shipments containing defective parts nonconforming in their entirety, and it upheld the rejection.

Does the buyer have to test every unit before rejecting?

No. The court accepted tests of 130 out of 1,709 microprocessors, about 8 percent, as a basis for rejecting the whole order. The sample was not randomized, but the court found that the units were chosen for testing without bias.

Judge Weinstein wrote: "While the sampling was not scientifically randomized, selection for testing was made without bias." He found that the sample sufficed as a basis for commercial rejection and that it was reasonable to infer that the untested units shared the defect. For that conclusion the opinion cites the work of professors Kaye and Cohen and that of James.

"All tests were conducted by an independent laboratory," the opinion says. The judge also said that Johnson's employees "impressed the court as sound and honest technicians even though they did not have industry-wide experience." ICU ran its own test after the dispute began, and one of 19 devices failed at commercial tolerances.

In T-Shirt World the count was made on what remained in the store. Artland had sold 9,000 of the shirts at a discount. At trial about 4,000 shirts were left, and roughly 1,000 of them were defective.

How long may the buyer test the goods before rejecting them?

A reasonable time after delivery, judged by the goods. Laboratory testing of electronic parts, with rejection letters 11 days after the last shipment, was reasonable in Integrated Circuits. For shirts, a one-week period was upheld on appeal.

Section 2-602(1) requires rejection "within a reasonable time after their delivery or tender" and adds: "It is ineffective unless the buyer seasonably notifies the seller." ICU delivered 1,709 microprocessors under order WO4746 in four shipments between March 21 and April 13, 1984. Johnson sent rejection letters on April 24 and 25 and an itemized list of the 1,973 rejected parts on May 8.

The court held the rejection effective. "Time to test complex electronic parts must be afforded," the opinion says. The judge described the testing by the independent laboratory Johnson retained as prompt and thorough, and the May 8 list named the parts Johnson wished to return on the basis of those tests.

Shirts gave the buyer much less time. Artland's store officers initialed receipts on delivery, it had 30 days to pay and it rarely inspected the goods. The trial court treated one week as the reasonable period for rejecting defective shirts. On appeal the District Court wrote: "Although we might have determined that a longer period would be within reason, it was a question for the fact-finder." Artland did not show that the defective shirts came in the last week of deliveries, so its rejection was late.

What must the rejection notice tell the seller?

That the goods are rejected and what is wrong with them, in enough detail for the seller to cure. The court held that Johnson's May 8 list of the rejected parts met the particularity requirement of section 2-605.

The court read section 2-605 as requiring the buyer to state the defect with enough particularity to let the seller cure it. Johnson gave notice in two steps: the letters of April 24 and 25, 1984, and then the itemized list. The opinion found that the May 8 letter identified the defects with sufficient detail.

Public buyers write the same steps into their procedures. Section 20-5 of the California State Contracting Manual tells the person who rejects goods to report the problem and the rejection to the buyer immediately through the purchasing system. The buyer notifies the supplier within the time set in the General Provisions and sends a notice of rejection letter. That letter describes the defects, the delivery and inspection criteria, and how the delivery fails to conform. The manual cites UCC 2602 for this step.

Does using or paying for the goods during testing count as acceptance?

Not by itself. In Integrated Circuits temporary use of some units during testing and payments on some invoices did not amount to acceptance. A buyer who keeps using goods after learning that the defect remains has accepted them.

Under section 2-606(1)(b), a buyer who fails to make an effective rejection accepts the goods, but that acceptance "does not occur until the buyer has had a reasonable opportunity to inspect them." Johnson had used some of the microprocessors while it tested them. The court answered: "Those actions were taken during the time required to complete the tests." On May 21 Johnson sent ICU a check for $70,465 as payment in full for 829 parts received on April 11, after the rejection letters. The court held that paying did not waive Johnson's rights: "The payments represented an effort on the part of Johnson to resolve the dispute amicably."

The North Carolina Court of Appeals reached the opposite result on different facts in Williams v. Hyatt Chrysler-Plymouth, Inc., decided August 19, 1980. The buyer of a 1976 Dodge Ramcharger knew within a day that the vibration was still there and kept driving the vehicle. The court treated the vehicle as accepted, so the remedy became the difference in value under G.S. 25-2-714. "The buyer bears the burden of proving that difference in value," the court wrote.

Conduct at delivery counts as well. The supplier's prices were shown on delivery receipts that Artland's officers signed, and the District Court found that Artland had acquiesced in the price increases.

Can the buyer keep part of a delivery and reject the rest?

Yes. California's State Contracting Manual, citing UCC 2601, lets a state buyer accept some units and reject the rest, for example keep the 50 monitors ordered and return the 25 extra monitors the supplier shipped.

The manual gives two examples. A 50-monitor order arrives as 75 monitors. A 50-case paper order arrives as 150 cases. In each case the buyer may reject the whole shipment, or accept the quantity ordered and return the excess.

When the goods are not interchangeable, each rejected item has to be tied to its delivery. The shirts in T-Shirt World varied in size, color, price, composition and popularity. "Hence they were not fungible within the meaning of the Code," the court wrote, and the delivery date of each shirt decided whether its rejection came within the one-week period.

What happens to the goods after rejection?

The buyer holds them with reasonable care until the seller takes them back. If the supplier does not collect them, California's manual lets the state ship them back at the supplier's expense or store them and charge storage.

Under section 20-5 the buyer arranges protected storage for the rejected goods and takes reasonable care of them until the supplier retrieves them, citing UCC 2602. If the supplier does not remove them within a reasonable time or within the period stated, the buyer may return them at the supplier's expense or keep them in storage and require the supplier to reimburse the cost. Departments outside FI$Cal prepare a Returned Stock Report, STD. 108, and departments in FI$Cal process a Return to Vendor transaction. Before shipping anything back, the department checks whether the supplier requires a return authorization.

In Integrated Circuits the goods went back and forth. On August 15, 1984, Johnson told ICU it was returning the rejected parts "no matter what", shipped them, debited ICU's account $170,450.00 and withheld payment of $160,725 on two invoices. ICU refused delivery, the parts came back to Johnson, and Johnson held them on ICU's account.

What can the seller recover if the rejection was wrongful?

Usually not the contract price. Judge Weinstein wrote that even a wrongful but effective rejection bars an action for the price under section 2-709, which leaves the seller with the market-price measure of section 2-708.

Johnson had rejected the parts effectively, so ICU could not maintain an action for the price under section 2-709, even if the rejection had been wrongful. ICU had sued for $160,725, the unpaid balance on its invoices, and relied on that section.

The court described the section 2-708 measure as the difference between the contract price and the market price at the time of delivery, plus incidental damages. Johnson's contract price matched the market at delivery, so on that measure ICU "would receive no damages". The final judgment ordered Johnson to pay ICU $4,638.73 with interest from August 15, 1984. The published opinion omits the detailed damages calculation.

What does a goods expert examine in a rejection dispute?

The contract specification, the test method, the sample, the failure count and the conditions of each test. In Integrated Circuits the result changed when the court reconsidered which technical testimony on these points to credit.

Two kinds of technical evidence met in that case. ICU's expert offered an industry-wide defect rate of five percent. Johnson's technicians and the independent laboratory offered failure counts at the agreed temperature, sample sizes and separate results at higher temperatures. The court first accepted the industry figure and then, on further consideration of the testimony, declined to credit it and wrote that the industry requires a failure rate much lower than one percent.

The findings that decided the case were factual: the agreed test temperature, the 1 percent quality level stated in Johnson's letter of April 24, 130 units tested out of 1,709, 6 failures, 3 failures out of 115 under order WO4750, the dates of delivery and the dates of each letter.

T-Shirt World turned on timing more than on testing. The count of about 1,000 defective shirts did not help the store, because it could not show when those shirts had been delivered.

What does IAE do when a buyer rejects goods or the seller disputes the rejection?

An IAE expert reports whether the goods were defective when delivered, whether a failure came from manufacturing or misuse and what the goods were worth as accepted, or reviews the opposing expert's report, in up to 5 business days.

For warranty and supply disputes in US courts, IAE prepares an expert report on the client's questions or a review of the opposing expert's report. The expert tests the item against the merchantability rule of UCC 2-314 and the contract description, reads fracture surfaces, wear and repair marks to tell a manufacturing flaw from misuse, and documents the condition of the item before any test likely to change it, under ASTM E860-22. When the goods are in the other party's possession, Rule 34(a)(1)(B) lets a party inspect, test or sample them on request, with a written response due in 30 days.

The client describes the task through the Request a quote button on the service page and names the goods, the defect, the delivery and rejection dates and what is attached: the contract or purchase order, delivery papers, rejection letters, test data and any report by the other side's expert. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. Cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush. A report that only rebuts the opposing expert is due within 30 days after the other party's disclosure, unless the parties stipulate or the court orders otherwise.

Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome, and materials are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. The court weighs the report with the rest of the record. Neither IAE nor the expert guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert examinations

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member