Letter review

Russian or Ukrainian specialist diploma: does USCIS treat it as a master's degree?

A Russian specialist diploma takes five to six years of full-time study, and Russian law places it at the same level of higher education as a master's degree. U.S. evaluators describe it in different terms: WES equates the five-year diploma with a bachelor's and a master's degree, and the public EDGE entry for the Ukrainian specialist diploma compares that diploma to a master's. USCIS treats every evaluation as an advisory opinion, and the AAO checks evaluations against EDGE.

Hands compare a dark red diploma booklet with a thin evaluation letter turned away

What is a Russian specialist diploma?

A higher education diploma awarded after five, five and a half or six years of full-time study that begins after secondary school. Russian law puts it on the same level as the master's degree, above the bachelor's.

Part 5 of Article 10 of Russian Federal Law No. 273-FZ on education lists the levels of professional education. Higher education has three of them: the bachelor's level; the level of the specialist degree and the master's degree, named together; and the training of highly qualified personnel. A bachelor's program sits one level below a specialist program.

The public country page of EDGE, the database of the American Association of Collegiate Registrars and Admissions Officers, describes the Russian Specialist Diploma as a program of 5, 5.5 or 6 years of full-time study. It notes that the word "specialist" does not appear on the documents. It also says that "both the Specialist and Bachelor programs have the same admission requirements but differ in the purpose of the education and credential," and that "The Specialist Diploma functions as a professional credential that yields a specific qualification for employment." The bachelor's program takes 4 years, and the master's program takes 2 years after a bachelor's.

The same page says that admission to the Candidate of Sciences, a research degree, requires a Specialist or Master diploma. In the Russian system the two diplomas open the same door to doctoral study.

Ukraine had two kinds of specialist diploma. The public EDGE entry for the Dyplom Spetsialista says that until 2016 it "was awarded after 5 to 6 years of study, depending on the type of institution and field of study," while "Post-Bakalavra Specialist Diplomas were awarded after 1-2 years of study." An evaluation has to say which of the two it is describing.

Why does the equivalency matter for an immigration petition?

Because EB-2 requires an advanced degree: a U.S. degree above the bachelor's or a foreign equivalent degree. A specialist diploma counted as a master's qualifies by itself; counted as a bachelor's, it needs five years of progressive experience on top.

The regulation at 8 C.F.R. 204.5(k)(2) defines an advanced degree as "any United States academic or professional degree or a foreign equivalent degree above that of baccalaureate." The next sentence adds: "A United States baccalaureate degree or a foreign equivalent degree followed by at least five years of progressive experience in the specialty shall be considered the equivalent of a master's degree." And if a doctoral degree is customarily required by the specialty, "the alien must have a United States doctorate or a foreign equivalent degree."

The evidence follows the definition. Under 8 C.F.R. 204.5(k)(3)(i)(A) the petition includes "An official academic record showing that the alien has a United States advanced degree or a foreign equivalent degree." Under (k)(3)(i)(B) the alternative is an official academic record of a U.S. baccalaureate or a foreign equivalent degree plus letters from current or former employers showing at least five years of progressive post-baccalaureate experience in the specialty. If the evaluation puts the specialist diploma at the bachelor's level only, the petition moves to the second route and needs the experience letters.

The H-1B master's cap is a separate question with a fixed answer. Under 8 U.S.C. 1184(g)(5)(C) the H-1B numerical limit does not apply, until 20,000 such exemptions have been used in a year, to a worker who "has earned a master's or higher degree from a United States institution of higher education." A specialist diploma from a Russian or Ukrainian university does not qualify for that exemption under any evaluation, because the school is not a U.S. institution.

What do WES and EDGE say about the specialist diploma?

WES equates the five-year specialist diploma with a U.S. bachelor's and master's degree, and a one- to two-year post-bachelor specialist diploma with a master's. The public EDGE entry for Ukraine compares the Dyplom Spetsialista to a master's degree.

World Education Services describes its Russian equivalencies on its own website. For the five-year diploma it writes: "WES equates this degree that has a five-year program length with bachelor's and master's degrees in the U.S. and Canada." For the shorter program: "WES equates this degree that has a one- to two-year program length with a master's degree in the U.S. and Canada." The Bakalavr is a bachelor's degree of four years, and the Magistr is a master's degree across all academic disciplines.

The public EDGE entry for Ukraine states: "The Dyplom Spetsialista represents attainment of a level of education comparable to a master's degree in the United States." An earlier version of the same entry, dated May 18, 2020, used almost the same words: "The Specialist Diploma represents attainment of a level of education comparable to a masters degree in the United States."

For Russia the public EDGE country page describes the structure of higher education and gives no U.S. comparability for the Specialist Diploma; parts of the page are marked as content for EDGE subscribers. From that page a petition for a Russian graduate can cite the description of the program, but not a comparability statement of the kind the Ukrainian entry contains. The AAO, for its part, cites EDGE in its decisions on foreign degrees, as the cases below show.

How does USCIS weigh a credential evaluation?

As an advisory opinion. The AAO has written that it may reject or give less weight to evaluations that conflict with the record or are in any way questionable, and it calls EDGE a reliable source on foreign credential equivalencies.

In a non-precedent decision of November 9, 2022, the AAO wrote: "Evaluations of educational credentials by evaluation services and individual evaluators are utilized by USCIS as advisory opinions only." The next sentence: "We may reject or give less evidentiary weight to expert opinions that conflict with evidence in the record or are 'in any way questionable.'" It cited Matter of Caron International, Inc., 19 I&N Dec. 791, 795 (Comm'r 1988), and Matter of Sea, Inc., 19 I&N Dec. 817 (Comm'r 1988).

In a footnote to the same decision the AAO stated: "We consider EDGE to be a reliable source of information about foreign credential equivalencies." The officer therefore reads the evaluation next to EDGE. When the two agree, the evaluation adds detail. When they disagree, the evaluation has to explain why.

An evaluation has to carry its own reasoning. In the 2022 decision the AAO faulted the report because it did "not include detailed analysis of the Beneficiary's coursework" and did not provide a substantive basis for its assertion that it could not differentiate between undergraduate and postgraduate credit hours.

Does a five-year degree count as a master's because of its length?

Not in two AAO decisions on comparable five-year degrees from Chile and Spain. In both, evaluations that called the degree a master's equivalent lost to EDGE, which compared the degree to a U.S. bachelor's.

The 2022 decision concerned a Chilean Título Profesional de Psicólogo. The beneficiary completed five years of coursework, 1997 through 2001, and received the title in 2002. A World Education Services report said the degree was equivalent to a U.S. bachelor's and master's degree from a regionally accredited institution. EDGE states that the Título Profesional is awarded "upon completion of up to ten semesters of study" and that it "represents attainment of an education comparable to bachelor's degree" in the United States.

The AAO found that the WES report "fails to overcome concerns raised by other evidence in the record, such as its inconsistency with EDGE." The position required a U.S. master's or foreign equivalent degree in counseling, social work or a related field, and the appeal was dismissed.

The decision of February 5, 2019, Matter of S- Inc., concerned a Spanish degree in industrial engineering. The AAO wrote that, according to EDGE, the Spanish engineering title stands for five years of post-secondary studies, "equating to only a U.S. bachelor's degree." It held that the evaluations "are unreliable because they conflict with the Petitioner's assertions and evidence" and that "the evaluations don't explain the bases of their findings." The motion to reconsider was denied.

The formula WES uses for the five-year Russian specialist diploma, a bachelor's and a master's degree, is the same formula its report gave the Chilean degree in 2022. An evaluation of a Russian diploma that rests on that formula alone, without an analysis of the courses and hours, faces the same question from the officer.

What happened with a Ukrainian specialist diploma at the AAO?

On September 14, 2021, the AAO rejected an evaluation of a one-year Ukrainian specialist degree in law that did not explain the courses or the credit conversion, and withdrew the finding that the petitioner held an advanced degree.

The petitioner listed a "Specialist Degree in Law" earned in the 2007-2008 academic year. Her evaluation described a "One-year graduate program in jurisprudence, 31 credits of graduate study in Ukrainian law resulting in a Specialist Degree." The AAO found that the evaluation did not explain the content of the courses, how academic hours were converted to credits or how the program compares to U.S. education, and wrote: "we question the credibility of the evaluation."

The decision also compared the program with Ukrainian rules. A specialist diploma there required 60 to 90 ECTS credits, and the petitioner had completed 52. The AAO concluded that the record was "currently insufficient to persuasively establish that her education is the equivalent to a particular degree or level of education in the United States."

The consequences went beyond the degree. The AAO withdrew the Director's finding that the petitioner was a member of the professions holding an advanced degree, found that she did not qualify as an individual of exceptional ability, and dismissed the appeal without reaching the national interest waiver. For a post-bachelor specialist diploma, the credit count and the course list carry the equivalency.

Is a Candidate of Sciences degree treated as a PhD?

WES equates the Kandidat Nauk with a U.S. doctorate. EDGE describes it as a research degree of about three years that requires a specialist or master's diploma and includes a thesis defense, awarded by the Supreme Certifying Council.

WES states that the program "takes a minimum of three years to complete" and that "The U.S. and Canadian WES equivalency for this program is a doctorate (in any academic discipline)." The public EDGE page for Russia describes the Candidate of Sciences as a research degree awarded by the Supreme Certifying Council (VAK), with a Specialist or Master diploma required for admission and a three-year program that includes qualification examinations after the first year and the preparation and defense of a thesis. The Doctor of Sciences requires a further dissertation beyond the Candidate level.

For an EB-2 petition a doctorate is a degree above the baccalaureate, so an evaluation that equates the Kandidat Nauk with a doctorate also establishes an advanced degree under 8 C.F.R. 204.5(k)(2). Because admission to the Candidate program requires a specialist or master's diploma, the evaluation of the Candidate degree and the evaluation of the earlier diploma go into the petition together, and they should not contradict each other.

What should a review check in an evaluation of a specialist diploma?

Which kind of specialist diploma it is, the years and credits, the stated basis for the equivalency, its agreement with EDGE, and whether the equivalency is the one the petition needs: a master's for EB-2 or a bachelor's for H-1B.

The kind of diploma comes first. A five-year program after secondary school and a one- or two-year program after a bachelor's carry different equivalencies at WES and have separate descriptions in EDGE for Ukraine. Since the Russian diploma does not print the word "specialist," the evaluation has to identify the program from the diploma and the transcript.

Next come the years and the credits. The AAO counted ECTS credits in the 2021 Ukrainian decision and looked for an analysis of the coursework and of the split between undergraduate and postgraduate hours in the 2022 decision. Evaluations without that analysis meet the objection of the 2019 decision, in which the AAO wrote that "the evaluations don't explain the bases of their findings."

Then the comparison with EDGE. Where the public EDGE entry for Ukraine compares the Dyplom Spetsialista to a master's, an evaluation that says the same agrees with it. For a Russian diploma the evaluation should state the basis of its equivalency in its own text, because the public EDGE country page for Russia gives no comparability for the Specialist Diploma.

Last, the fit with the petition. For EB-2, a master's equivalency supports the advanced degree on its own; a bachelor's equivalency needs letters showing five years of progressive post-baccalaureate experience in the specialty. For an H-1B, a bachelor's equivalency is enough for the degree requirement, while the master's cap stays closed to a foreign degree under 8 U.S.C. 1184(g)(5)(C).

What does IAE check in an evaluation of a specialist diploma?

An IAE reviewer checks the evaluation's methodology, the evaluator's authority and its weak points, and gives one of three verdicts: file, revise or redo. The standard turnaround is 3 business days, and the rush option takes 1 business day.

The client sends the evaluation and a short description of the petition. The secretariat confirms the fee, the turnaround and the reviewer within one business day. The reviewer is an IAE registry member in the field of the document and is independent of the provider of the document under review, and confirms this in writing.

The review is page by page: every section is checked against the criteria of the visa category and the expectations of USCIS, and for a credential evaluation the reviewer examines the methodology, the evaluator's authority and the weak points of the degree or experience evaluation. The result is a signed review of 3-5 pages with a list of weak points, a recommendation for each and one of three verdicts with reasoning: file, revise or redo. The deadline runs from payment and receipt of all materials.

IAE is not a law firm; strategy questions in the case are for a licensed immigration attorney. The decision on the petition is made by USCIS, and neither IAE nor the reviewer influences it.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert letter review

Check the letter before the officer does

The standard turnaround is 3 business days, the rush option 1 business day. The fee depends on the visa category and the volume of materials; we confirm the fee, the turnaround and the reviewer within one business day.

Review

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

DocumentExpert letter
Timeline3 business days, rush 1
VerdictFile or revise